Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #1   Report Post  
Luther Bell
 
Posts: n/a
Default MOTU Digital Performer 4 vs. other audio editors

I work at a concert hall that is thinking of upgrading it's digital audio
side of things. Mainly computers, DAWs and affiliated items. I'm trying to
decide which route to take. PC or MAC. We don't have enough money to run
out and buy ProTools, so I am opting for the M-Audio Quattro. A nice little
slightly cheap interface. All I really want is a decent balanced feed into
my computer for editing purposes. The part that I can't decide on is the
quality/user-friendliness of PC and MAC programs. I started a couple years
ago using Sound Forge, but then I moved onto Syntrillium's Cool Edit Pro
(now Adobe Audition). I like the simplicity and various options of CEP.
What I don't know anything about are Mac audio editing programs. I have
come across MOTU's DP4 and BIAS's Peak 4.1. My question is:

"How do these two programs compare to their Windows counterparts?"

I am mainly looking for an audio editing program. Multitrack capability is
also a factor. Those are pretty much my only two stipulations. If the
program has extra features, so be it. So, could you please enlighten me on
other Mac audio editing software out there...Thanks
-Luther


  #2   Report Post  
Raymond
 
Posts: n/a
Default


I work at a concert hall that is thinking of upgrading it's digital audio
side of things. Mainly computers, DAWs and affiliated items. I'm trying to
decide which route to take. PC or MAC. We don't have enough money to run
out and buy ProTools, so I am opting for the M-Audio Quattro. A nice little
slightly cheap interface. All I really want is a decent balanced feed into
my computer for editing purposes. The part that I can't decide on is the
quality/user-friendliness of PC and MAC programs. I started a couple years
ago using Sound Forge, but then I moved onto Syntrillium's Cool Edit Pro
(now Adobe Audition). I like the simplicity and various options of CEP.
What I don't know anything about are Mac audio editing programs. I have
come across MOTU's DP4 and BIAS's Peak 4.1. My question is:

"How do these two programs compare to their Windows counterparts?"

I am mainly looking for an audio editing program. Multitrack capability is
also a factor. Those are pretty much my only two stipulations. If the
program has extra features, so be it. So, could you please enlighten me on
other Mac audio editing software out there...Thanks
-Luther


If you don't know Mac or don't have anyone that does your going to have some
conflict with its user interface. I use a Mac (400Mhz 1999 G4 with MOTU 24i and
DP3) and I think that Mac is all around a better system then PC but many have
there own ideas about PC so you may just stir up a hornet's nest with it.
You say you need milti track? How many do you need? I can tell you that Peak
will not run on a PC (atlest not at this time) DP runs best on a Mac with MOTU
hardware, DP4 needs OSX and it better be a very good (hopped up) CPU.

What's wrong with or what do you not like about what you have now? One of my
favorite sayings is, "if it ant broke, don't try and fix it"
  #3   Report Post  
Raymond
 
Posts: n/a
Default


I work at a concert hall that is thinking of upgrading it's digital audio
side of things. Mainly computers, DAWs and affiliated items. I'm trying to
decide which route to take. PC or MAC. We don't have enough money to run
out and buy ProTools, so I am opting for the M-Audio Quattro. A nice little
slightly cheap interface. All I really want is a decent balanced feed into
my computer for editing purposes. The part that I can't decide on is the
quality/user-friendliness of PC and MAC programs. I started a couple years
ago using Sound Forge, but then I moved onto Syntrillium's Cool Edit Pro
(now Adobe Audition). I like the simplicity and various options of CEP.
What I don't know anything about are Mac audio editing programs. I have
come across MOTU's DP4 and BIAS's Peak 4.1. My question is:

"How do these two programs compare to their Windows counterparts?"

I am mainly looking for an audio editing program. Multitrack capability is
also a factor. Those are pretty much my only two stipulations. If the
program has extra features, so be it. So, could you please enlighten me on
other Mac audio editing software out there...Thanks
-Luther


If you don't know Mac or don't have anyone that does your going to have some
conflict with its user interface. I use a Mac (400Mhz 1999 G4 with MOTU 24i and
DP3) and I think that Mac is all around a better system then PC but many have
there own ideas about PC so you may just stir up a hornet's nest with it.
You say you need milti track? How many do you need? I can tell you that Peak
will not run on a PC (atlest not at this time) DP runs best on a Mac with MOTU
hardware, DP4 needs OSX and it better be a very good (hopped up) CPU.

What's wrong with or what do you not like about what you have now? One of my
favorite sayings is, "if it ant broke, don't try and fix it"
  #4   Report Post  
Luther Bell
 
Posts: n/a
Default

currently I'm using a bogged down 800Mhz Compaq and I am interfacing with
the board through the standard 1/8" jack in the stock sound card. We've
decided to upgrade and do it right and we figured, why not go the whole nine
yards and upgrade fully. I'm not looking for many multitrack channels.
Like I said, I feel that the M-Audio Quattro will do just fine. We don't do
much multitrack recording, but I have come into a few situations where it
would have been nice. I have used Mac in the past (my wife has a G4 iBook),
it's just that I've never done audio editing on them so I was kind of
clueless as for where to start looking for Mac software that is decent.
-Luther


"Raymond" wrote in message
...

I work at a concert hall that is thinking of upgrading it's digital audio
side of things. Mainly computers, DAWs and affiliated items. I'm trying

to
decide which route to take. PC or MAC. We don't have enough money to

run
out and buy ProTools, so I am opting for the M-Audio Quattro. A nice

little
slightly cheap interface. All I really want is a decent balanced feed

into
my computer for editing purposes. The part that I can't decide on is the
quality/user-friendliness of PC and MAC programs. I started a couple

years
ago using Sound Forge, but then I moved onto Syntrillium's Cool Edit Pro
(now Adobe Audition). I like the simplicity and various options of CEP.
What I don't know anything about are Mac audio editing programs. I have
come across MOTU's DP4 and BIAS's Peak 4.1. My question is:

"How do these two programs compare to their Windows counterparts?"

I am mainly looking for an audio editing program. Multitrack capability

is
also a factor. Those are pretty much my only two stipulations. If the
program has extra features, so be it. So, could you please enlighten me

on
other Mac audio editing software out there...Thanks
-Luther


If you don't know Mac or don't have anyone that does your going to have

some
conflict with its user interface. I use a Mac (400Mhz 1999 G4 with MOTU

24i and
DP3) and I think that Mac is all around a better system then PC but many

have
there own ideas about PC so you may just stir up a hornet's nest with it.
You say you need milti track? How many do you need? I can tell you that

Peak
will not run on a PC (atlest not at this time) DP runs best on a Mac with

MOTU
hardware, DP4 needs OSX and it better be a very good (hopped up) CPU.

What's wrong with or what do you not like about what you have now? One of

my
favorite sayings is, "if it ant broke, don't try and fix it"



  #5   Report Post  
Luther Bell
 
Posts: n/a
Default

currently I'm using a bogged down 800Mhz Compaq and I am interfacing with
the board through the standard 1/8" jack in the stock sound card. We've
decided to upgrade and do it right and we figured, why not go the whole nine
yards and upgrade fully. I'm not looking for many multitrack channels.
Like I said, I feel that the M-Audio Quattro will do just fine. We don't do
much multitrack recording, but I have come into a few situations where it
would have been nice. I have used Mac in the past (my wife has a G4 iBook),
it's just that I've never done audio editing on them so I was kind of
clueless as for where to start looking for Mac software that is decent.
-Luther


"Raymond" wrote in message
...

I work at a concert hall that is thinking of upgrading it's digital audio
side of things. Mainly computers, DAWs and affiliated items. I'm trying

to
decide which route to take. PC or MAC. We don't have enough money to

run
out and buy ProTools, so I am opting for the M-Audio Quattro. A nice

little
slightly cheap interface. All I really want is a decent balanced feed

into
my computer for editing purposes. The part that I can't decide on is the
quality/user-friendliness of PC and MAC programs. I started a couple

years
ago using Sound Forge, but then I moved onto Syntrillium's Cool Edit Pro
(now Adobe Audition). I like the simplicity and various options of CEP.
What I don't know anything about are Mac audio editing programs. I have
come across MOTU's DP4 and BIAS's Peak 4.1. My question is:

"How do these two programs compare to their Windows counterparts?"

I am mainly looking for an audio editing program. Multitrack capability

is
also a factor. Those are pretty much my only two stipulations. If the
program has extra features, so be it. So, could you please enlighten me

on
other Mac audio editing software out there...Thanks
-Luther


If you don't know Mac or don't have anyone that does your going to have

some
conflict with its user interface. I use a Mac (400Mhz 1999 G4 with MOTU

24i and
DP3) and I think that Mac is all around a better system then PC but many

have
there own ideas about PC so you may just stir up a hornet's nest with it.
You say you need milti track? How many do you need? I can tell you that

Peak
will not run on a PC (atlest not at this time) DP runs best on a Mac with

MOTU
hardware, DP4 needs OSX and it better be a very good (hopped up) CPU.

What's wrong with or what do you not like about what you have now? One of

my
favorite sayings is, "if it ant broke, don't try and fix it"





  #6   Report Post  
S O'Neill
 
Posts: n/a
Default

Luther Bell wrote:

I work at a concert hall that is thinking of upgrading it's digital audio
side of things. Mainly computers, DAWs and affiliated items. I'm trying to
decide which route to take. PC or MAC. We don't have enough money to run
out and buy ProTools, so I am opting for the M-Audio Quattro. A nice little
slightly cheap interface. All I really want is a decent balanced feed into
my computer for editing purposes. The part that I can't decide on is the
quality/user-friendliness of PC and MAC programs. I started a couple years
ago using Sound Forge, but then I moved onto Syntrillium's Cool Edit Pro
(now Adobe Audition). I like the simplicity and various options of CEP.
What I don't know anything about are Mac audio editing programs. I have
come across MOTU's DP4 and BIAS's Peak 4.1. My question is:

"How do these two programs compare to their Windows counterparts?"

I am mainly looking for an audio editing program. Multitrack capability is
also a factor. Those are pretty much my only two stipulations. If the
program has extra features, so be it. So, could you please enlighten me on
other Mac audio editing software out there...Thanks
-Luther


Peak is a simple two-track editor with rock-solid operation whose UI is
sometimes a little quirky. That is, it does things like not remember that you
like the main window lower on your desktop, and plugin editors show up almost
under another window. And that kind of stuff is all nit-pick: the way the
program works and sounds, and the way the work flows using it is like any
well-made tool, really excellent. A very powerful waveform editor.

DP4 is a multitrack audio and MIDI sequencer and editor with every feature you
can imagine, and then some. Its waveform editing features are limited, but you
can have it use Peak for more demanding tasks, it integrates seamlessly (it
hands the section to Peak, and when you close Peak, it hands it back).

You can start a war asking anything about Mac/PC differences. I used Cool Edit
2000 for years, but it was lots more stable than the OS (NT4) under it. For
that reason I switched to Mac for audio, and never looked back.


  #7   Report Post  
S O'Neill
 
Posts: n/a
Default

Luther Bell wrote:

I work at a concert hall that is thinking of upgrading it's digital audio
side of things. Mainly computers, DAWs and affiliated items. I'm trying to
decide which route to take. PC or MAC. We don't have enough money to run
out and buy ProTools, so I am opting for the M-Audio Quattro. A nice little
slightly cheap interface. All I really want is a decent balanced feed into
my computer for editing purposes. The part that I can't decide on is the
quality/user-friendliness of PC and MAC programs. I started a couple years
ago using Sound Forge, but then I moved onto Syntrillium's Cool Edit Pro
(now Adobe Audition). I like the simplicity and various options of CEP.
What I don't know anything about are Mac audio editing programs. I have
come across MOTU's DP4 and BIAS's Peak 4.1. My question is:

"How do these two programs compare to their Windows counterparts?"

I am mainly looking for an audio editing program. Multitrack capability is
also a factor. Those are pretty much my only two stipulations. If the
program has extra features, so be it. So, could you please enlighten me on
other Mac audio editing software out there...Thanks
-Luther


Peak is a simple two-track editor with rock-solid operation whose UI is
sometimes a little quirky. That is, it does things like not remember that you
like the main window lower on your desktop, and plugin editors show up almost
under another window. And that kind of stuff is all nit-pick: the way the
program works and sounds, and the way the work flows using it is like any
well-made tool, really excellent. A very powerful waveform editor.

DP4 is a multitrack audio and MIDI sequencer and editor with every feature you
can imagine, and then some. Its waveform editing features are limited, but you
can have it use Peak for more demanding tasks, it integrates seamlessly (it
hands the section to Peak, and when you close Peak, it hands it back).

You can start a war asking anything about Mac/PC differences. I used Cool Edit
2000 for years, but it was lots more stable than the OS (NT4) under it. For
that reason I switched to Mac for audio, and never looked back.


  #8   Report Post  
Marc Wielage
 
Posts: n/a
Default

On Fri, 14 May 2004 00:08:33 -0700, Luther Bell wrote
(in article ):

I am mainly looking for an audio editing program. Multitrack capability is
also a factor. Those are pretty much my only two stipulations. If the
program has extra features, so be it. So, could you please enlighten me on
other Mac audio editing software out there...
--------------------------------snip----------------------------------


Nobody has recommended ProTools yet, so I'd put in a vote for that. I don't
think there's a better multitrack editing/mixing program for the Mac, period.

You also might investigate Deck (from Bias, Inc.) and Apple's own Logic.
Logic has the advantage over ProTools of being far less expensive, but I
would give the edge to ProTools, just on sheer usability, and having the
greatest number of users and plug-ins available.

--MFW

  #9   Report Post  
Marc Wielage
 
Posts: n/a
Default

On Fri, 14 May 2004 00:08:33 -0700, Luther Bell wrote
(in article ):

I am mainly looking for an audio editing program. Multitrack capability is
also a factor. Those are pretty much my only two stipulations. If the
program has extra features, so be it. So, could you please enlighten me on
other Mac audio editing software out there...
--------------------------------snip----------------------------------


Nobody has recommended ProTools yet, so I'd put in a vote for that. I don't
think there's a better multitrack editing/mixing program for the Mac, period.

You also might investigate Deck (from Bias, Inc.) and Apple's own Logic.
Logic has the advantage over ProTools of being far less expensive, but I
would give the edge to ProTools, just on sheer usability, and having the
greatest number of users and plug-ins available.

--MFW

  #10   Report Post  
Raymond
 
Posts: n/a
Default

Mark wrote
Nobody has recommended ProTools yet, so I'd put in a vote for that. I don't
think there's a better multitrack editing/mixing program for the Mac, period.


I believe the OP stated that they didn't want to spend that much cash but hands
down Pro Tools is the most popular and probably the best for Mac. I've used DP3
(and its earlier versions Digital Performer) as well as Pro Tools and I find
that they are very similar in many aspects. Pro Tools 24 hardware had better
converters than MOTU's and HD is edging out the new MOTU devices to. I think I
would stay with DP3 even if I had more cash to upgrade because of its ease of
use with MIDI and I've grown use to it to.
I would agree with Deck being something to look at but it would be much easier
to go with a MOTU interface as you'll get Audio Desk (audio software) with most
all of there units. I use Peak LE for gain make-up after I track and mix in
DP3, its an inexpensive two track editor and they work very well together so it
would be worth having both programs.


  #11   Report Post  
Raymond
 
Posts: n/a
Default

Mark wrote
Nobody has recommended ProTools yet, so I'd put in a vote for that. I don't
think there's a better multitrack editing/mixing program for the Mac, period.


I believe the OP stated that they didn't want to spend that much cash but hands
down Pro Tools is the most popular and probably the best for Mac. I've used DP3
(and its earlier versions Digital Performer) as well as Pro Tools and I find
that they are very similar in many aspects. Pro Tools 24 hardware had better
converters than MOTU's and HD is edging out the new MOTU devices to. I think I
would stay with DP3 even if I had more cash to upgrade because of its ease of
use with MIDI and I've grown use to it to.
I would agree with Deck being something to look at but it would be much easier
to go with a MOTU interface as you'll get Audio Desk (audio software) with most
all of there units. I use Peak LE for gain make-up after I track and mix in
DP3, its an inexpensive two track editor and they work very well together so it
would be worth having both programs.
  #12   Report Post  
j t
 
Posts: n/a
Default

In article , Luther Bell
wrote:

currently I'm using a bogged down 800Mhz Compaq and I am interfacing with
the board through the standard 1/8" jack in the stock sound card. We've
decided to upgrade and do it right and we figured, why not go the whole nine
yards and upgrade fully. I'm not looking for many multitrack channels.
Like I said, I feel that the M-Audio Quattro will do just fine. We don't do
much multitrack recording, but I have come into a few situations where it
would have been nice. I have used Mac in the past (my wife has a G4 iBook),
it's just that I've never done audio editing on them so I was kind of
clueless as for where to start looking for Mac software that is decent.



Peak is cheap and easy to use, but only 2-track.

Performer is excellent, and as a previous poster stated, it works best
with MOTU hardware.

I am still running Performer 3.1 on a G3 with OS 9.2.1 via a MOTU 2408
and I get excellent results. When I got the system it was 'the latest
thing' and it is still more than useable 4 years later.

You can get a 2408 (Mk.I) used these days for like $300 or less.

Soon, I will upgrade to Performer 4, but I'll need a new computer to do
it properly. The G3 isn't fast enough for DP4. If you can get a G4 or
G5 with OSX and DP4 you'll be in bliss.

Cubase and Logic are also excellent programs with large user bases.

Logic is notoriously hard to use but once you conquer it, most users
say it is worth the trouble.

Cubase is probably the simplest of them all, but I think Performer is
better and not MUCH harder to learn for a newbie.

Overall, I would say DEFINITELY use a Mac for your audio productions.

The user interface of Mac OSX is actually easier, more flexible, and
more stable than Windows. Once you adapt to the new way of working,
you will be glad you made the effort.


JT
  #13   Report Post  
j t
 
Posts: n/a
Default

In article , Luther Bell
wrote:

currently I'm using a bogged down 800Mhz Compaq and I am interfacing with
the board through the standard 1/8" jack in the stock sound card. We've
decided to upgrade and do it right and we figured, why not go the whole nine
yards and upgrade fully. I'm not looking for many multitrack channels.
Like I said, I feel that the M-Audio Quattro will do just fine. We don't do
much multitrack recording, but I have come into a few situations where it
would have been nice. I have used Mac in the past (my wife has a G4 iBook),
it's just that I've never done audio editing on them so I was kind of
clueless as for where to start looking for Mac software that is decent.



Peak is cheap and easy to use, but only 2-track.

Performer is excellent, and as a previous poster stated, it works best
with MOTU hardware.

I am still running Performer 3.1 on a G3 with OS 9.2.1 via a MOTU 2408
and I get excellent results. When I got the system it was 'the latest
thing' and it is still more than useable 4 years later.

You can get a 2408 (Mk.I) used these days for like $300 or less.

Soon, I will upgrade to Performer 4, but I'll need a new computer to do
it properly. The G3 isn't fast enough for DP4. If you can get a G4 or
G5 with OSX and DP4 you'll be in bliss.

Cubase and Logic are also excellent programs with large user bases.

Logic is notoriously hard to use but once you conquer it, most users
say it is worth the trouble.

Cubase is probably the simplest of them all, but I think Performer is
better and not MUCH harder to learn for a newbie.

Overall, I would say DEFINITELY use a Mac for your audio productions.

The user interface of Mac OSX is actually easier, more flexible, and
more stable than Windows. Once you adapt to the new way of working,
you will be glad you made the effort.


JT
  #14   Report Post  
Catfish
 
Posts: n/a
Default

"How do these two programs compare to their Windows counterparts?"

I am mainly looking for an audio editing program. Multitrack capability is
also a factor. Those are pretty much my only two stipulations. If the
program has extra features, so be it. So, could you please enlighten me on
other Mac audio editing software out there...Thanks
-Luther



I used to be a long time PC guy. I've used Cakewalk, Sonar, Sound
Forge, and Samplitude. Then I decided to switch to Mac. I would never
go back. The Mac to me is a more user friendly set-up. I knew more
about Macs in 3 years then I did about PCs in 5 years.

OSX is great. It practically does everything for you. As for your
software, I've used Pro Tools for the last 3 years. It's great. If
you don't need a lot of inputs at the same time, get the digi 002. It
can be just as good as the full blown system, if you learn how to
"budget" your CPU and plug ins.

However, I'm doing a lot of MIDI (for film scoring). I checked out DP
and now I'm hooked. I think it is a superior program, but not as easy
as Pro Tools.

If you switch to Mac, there will be a learning curve, but also greater
stablity and control with either Pro Tools or Digital Performer.

Just as a reality check. My friend here in LA mixes major label albums
on Pro tools LE digi 001 with G4 1.2G with only 512RAM!!!!!!! He's a
genius with handling his plug ins.

In short:

Need more than 8 inputs at once, midi or transcriptions, go with DP
and like a 2408 or multiple 828mkII 's

If not, go with Pro Tools LE....even a used dig 001 and score some
free plug ins from a buddy

If you want to stay PC, Sonar gets my vote

Best
Catfish
  #15   Report Post  
Catfish
 
Posts: n/a
Default

"How do these two programs compare to their Windows counterparts?"

I am mainly looking for an audio editing program. Multitrack capability is
also a factor. Those are pretty much my only two stipulations. If the
program has extra features, so be it. So, could you please enlighten me on
other Mac audio editing software out there...Thanks
-Luther



I used to be a long time PC guy. I've used Cakewalk, Sonar, Sound
Forge, and Samplitude. Then I decided to switch to Mac. I would never
go back. The Mac to me is a more user friendly set-up. I knew more
about Macs in 3 years then I did about PCs in 5 years.

OSX is great. It practically does everything for you. As for your
software, I've used Pro Tools for the last 3 years. It's great. If
you don't need a lot of inputs at the same time, get the digi 002. It
can be just as good as the full blown system, if you learn how to
"budget" your CPU and plug ins.

However, I'm doing a lot of MIDI (for film scoring). I checked out DP
and now I'm hooked. I think it is a superior program, but not as easy
as Pro Tools.

If you switch to Mac, there will be a learning curve, but also greater
stablity and control with either Pro Tools or Digital Performer.

Just as a reality check. My friend here in LA mixes major label albums
on Pro tools LE digi 001 with G4 1.2G with only 512RAM!!!!!!! He's a
genius with handling his plug ins.

In short:

Need more than 8 inputs at once, midi or transcriptions, go with DP
and like a 2408 or multiple 828mkII 's

If not, go with Pro Tools LE....even a used dig 001 and score some
free plug ins from a buddy

If you want to stay PC, Sonar gets my vote

Best
Catfish


  #16   Report Post  
Mike
 
Posts: n/a
Default

"Luther Bell" wrote in message ...
I work at a concert hall that is thinking of upgrading it's digital audio
side of things. Mainly computers, DAWs and affiliated items. I'm trying to
decide which route to take. PC or MAC. We don't have enough money to run
out and buy ProTools, so I am opting for the M-Audio Quattro. A nice little
slightly cheap interface. All I really want is a decent balanced feed into
my computer for editing purposes. The part that I can't decide on is the
quality/user-friendliness of PC and MAC programs. I started a couple years
ago using Sound Forge, but then I moved onto Syntrillium's Cool Edit Pro
(now Adobe Audition). I like the simplicity and various options of CEP.
What I don't know anything about are Mac audio editing programs. I have
come across MOTU's DP4 and BIAS's Peak 4.1. My question is:

"How do these two programs compare to their Windows counterparts?"

I am mainly looking for an audio editing program. Multitrack capability is
also a factor. Those are pretty much my only two stipulations. If the
program has extra features, so be it. So, could you please enlighten me on
other Mac audio editing software out there...Thanks
-Luther


Are you talking about buying two programs or one? DP4 is a multitrack
audio plus midi recording and editing product. Peak is just a 2 track
editing product.

Mike http://www.mmeproductions.com
  #17   Report Post  
Mike
 
Posts: n/a
Default

"Luther Bell" wrote in message ...
I work at a concert hall that is thinking of upgrading it's digital audio
side of things. Mainly computers, DAWs and affiliated items. I'm trying to
decide which route to take. PC or MAC. We don't have enough money to run
out and buy ProTools, so I am opting for the M-Audio Quattro. A nice little
slightly cheap interface. All I really want is a decent balanced feed into
my computer for editing purposes. The part that I can't decide on is the
quality/user-friendliness of PC and MAC programs. I started a couple years
ago using Sound Forge, but then I moved onto Syntrillium's Cool Edit Pro
(now Adobe Audition). I like the simplicity and various options of CEP.
What I don't know anything about are Mac audio editing programs. I have
come across MOTU's DP4 and BIAS's Peak 4.1. My question is:

"How do these two programs compare to their Windows counterparts?"

I am mainly looking for an audio editing program. Multitrack capability is
also a factor. Those are pretty much my only two stipulations. If the
program has extra features, so be it. So, could you please enlighten me on
other Mac audio editing software out there...Thanks
-Luther


Are you talking about buying two programs or one? DP4 is a multitrack
audio plus midi recording and editing product. Peak is just a 2 track
editing product.

Mike http://www.mmeproductions.com
  #18   Report Post  
Steve Carroll
 
Posts: n/a
Default

In article ,
(Mike) wrote:

"Luther Bell" wrote in message
...
I work at a concert hall that is thinking of upgrading it's digital audio
side of things. Mainly computers, DAWs and affiliated items. I'm trying
to
decide which route to take. PC or MAC. We don't have enough money to run
out and buy ProTools, so I am opting for the M-Audio Quattro. A nice
little
slightly cheap interface. All I really want is a decent balanced feed into
my computer for editing purposes. The part that I can't decide on is the
quality/user-friendliness of PC and MAC programs. I started a couple years
ago using Sound Forge, but then I moved onto Syntrillium's Cool Edit Pro
(now Adobe Audition). I like the simplicity and various options of CEP.
What I don't know anything about are Mac audio editing programs. I have
come across MOTU's DP4 and BIAS's Peak 4.1. My question is:

"How do these two programs compare to their Windows counterparts?"

I am mainly looking for an audio editing program. Multitrack capability is
also a factor. Those are pretty much my only two stipulations. If the
program has extra features, so be it. So, could you please enlighten me on
other Mac audio editing software out there...Thanks
-Luther


Are you talking about buying two programs or one? DP4 is a multitrack
audio plus midi recording and editing product. Peak is just a 2 track
editing product.

Mike
http://www.mmeproductions.com

If anyone is interested, the latest version of Peak does let you burn
CD's... can't do that in DP yet (that I know of). The OP wants more than
just 2 tracks so DP would be the way to go if the choice were between
Peak and DP. As to how they compare to their Windows counterparts, I
can't really say, but I do know DP is quite full featured and has WAY
more stuff than I'll probably ever use... the nice thing is that the
'stuff' isn't necessarily in your way if you don't need it. I really
like the interface, myself. The OP didn't really talk about any criteria
for the editing he plans to do. Doing so might help accomplish his task.
I'm using DP with Peak configured as the external editor... works great
for me.

Steve
  #19   Report Post  
Steve Carroll
 
Posts: n/a
Default

In article ,
(Mike) wrote:

"Luther Bell" wrote in message
...
I work at a concert hall that is thinking of upgrading it's digital audio
side of things. Mainly computers, DAWs and affiliated items. I'm trying
to
decide which route to take. PC or MAC. We don't have enough money to run
out and buy ProTools, so I am opting for the M-Audio Quattro. A nice
little
slightly cheap interface. All I really want is a decent balanced feed into
my computer for editing purposes. The part that I can't decide on is the
quality/user-friendliness of PC and MAC programs. I started a couple years
ago using Sound Forge, but then I moved onto Syntrillium's Cool Edit Pro
(now Adobe Audition). I like the simplicity and various options of CEP.
What I don't know anything about are Mac audio editing programs. I have
come across MOTU's DP4 and BIAS's Peak 4.1. My question is:

"How do these two programs compare to their Windows counterparts?"

I am mainly looking for an audio editing program. Multitrack capability is
also a factor. Those are pretty much my only two stipulations. If the
program has extra features, so be it. So, could you please enlighten me on
other Mac audio editing software out there...Thanks
-Luther


Are you talking about buying two programs or one? DP4 is a multitrack
audio plus midi recording and editing product. Peak is just a 2 track
editing product.

Mike
http://www.mmeproductions.com

If anyone is interested, the latest version of Peak does let you burn
CD's... can't do that in DP yet (that I know of). The OP wants more than
just 2 tracks so DP would be the way to go if the choice were between
Peak and DP. As to how they compare to their Windows counterparts, I
can't really say, but I do know DP is quite full featured and has WAY
more stuff than I'll probably ever use... the nice thing is that the
'stuff' isn't necessarily in your way if you don't need it. I really
like the interface, myself. The OP didn't really talk about any criteria
for the editing he plans to do. Doing so might help accomplish his task.
I'm using DP with Peak configured as the external editor... works great
for me.

Steve
Reply
Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules

Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off


Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
f.S. Tons of cheapgear Cheapgear1 Pro Audio 2 February 23rd 12 02:25 AM
F.S. tons of gear for sale, keys, modules, pro audio, etc Cheapgear1 Pro Audio 5 February 18th 12 11:29 PM
MOTU Digital Performer 4 vs. other audio editors Luther Bell Tech 0 May 14th 04 08:13 AM
"Digital Audio" brand 5.1 speakers Lightning General 1 September 18th 03 01:52 AM
digital audio shortage Clive Backham General 11 August 19th 03 03:49 AM


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 06:47 AM.

Powered by: vBulletin
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004-2025 AudioBanter.com.
The comments are property of their posters.
 

About Us

"It's about Audio and hi-fi"