[R. Stanton]

On Dec 8, 12:57 pm, Signal wrote:
Mr Stanton wrote:"Comments from this group, have shown that many people consider
the ABX test stressful and confusing. One person who used the ABX
test for a group evaluation wrote: "... several of us noted that we
had great difficulty remembering what A had sounded like by the time
we got through with X."

The conclusion here is that ABX is stressful and thus confusing.
However the very experienced ABX tester Thomas Nousaine, endorsed by
ABX spokesperson Arnold Krueger, has expressed the alternative view :
ABX is not stressful enough.

Nousaine:

Actually people perform their
BEST under stress. It is the human condition...when the lion growls we
attain maximal sensitivity! Nousaine:

Actually putting a gun to your head would ensure that IF real differences
were present you would be able to hear them.Nousaine again:

I'd say that if IF someone held a gun to a subjects head threatening to shoot
him when he failed to reliably report the presence of a given sound the
subject would be most likely to respond correctly when the sound was
actually a real phenomenonSo here's an outline of the new improved ABX+

First, select the two components to be tested. Lets call them "A" and
"B." Group tests are fallible - so tests should be performed on an
individual basis. Testees should therefore be kept in a waiting room
and called in one at a time. To prevent subjects from being influenced
by overhearing tests hearing should be masked with headphones or tape.

As each subject is called out they should also be blindfolded and
gagged to prevent bias and communication. To maximize sensitivity, gag
first, produce your firearm so they can see it, *then* blindfold them.
Now you can remove their headphones and whisper "if you answer any
question incorrectly I will shoot you in the head". Bind them to a
chair in the "sweet spot" using rope or chains and proceed with the
testing....

Play snippets or A and B in a random order, and ask them to identify
which one is X. Those who survive get to make a better informed
shopping choice.

--
S i g n a l @ l i n e o n e . n e t

Thank you very much for your joke. A little levity always livens up a
debate. You were joking weren't you? :-(

[George M. Middius]

StantonBorg clanked:

As each subject is called out they should also be blindfolded and
gagged to prevent bias and communication. To maximize sensitivity, gag
first, produce your firearm so they can see it, *then* blindfold them.
Now you can remove their headphones and whisper "if you answer any
question incorrectly I will shoot you in the head". Bind them to a
chair in the "sweet spot" using rope or chains and proceed with the
testing....

Play snippets or A and B in a random order, and ask them to identify
which one is X. Those who survive get to make a better informed
shopping choice.

Thank you very much for your joke. A little levity always livens up a
debate. You were joking weren't you? :-(

It's not for nothing that Nousiane (in)famously said "audio is a deadly
serious business".





--

Krooscience: The antidote to education, experience, and excellence.