Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
#1
Posted to rec.audio.high-end
|
|||
|
|||
Turntable bearing oil ?
I just bought a new table and it came with 5ml of RED oil. I put the bearing
assy together and realized that the hole drilled through the base wasn't straight and I needed to take the bearing apart again. My Question is.. Is there a good reason why anyone should spend 15 to 25 bucks on a very SMALL amount of this oil? Isn't it available some other way? Who knows what it is exactly? Thanks |
#2
Posted to rec.audio.high-end
|
|||
|
|||
Turntable bearing oil ?
Stevie Vaughan wrote:
I just bought a new table and it came with 5ml of RED oil. I put the bearing assy together and realized that the hole drilled through the base wasn't straight and I needed to take the bearing apart again. My Question is.. Is there a good reason why anyone should spend 15 to 25 bucks on a very SMALL amount of this oil? Isn't it available some other way? Who knows what it is exactly? Thanks It's hard to say exactly what it is, but some time ago, there was a manufacturer who was selling "super" lubricating oil for some ungodly amount of money. It, to was red. On a hunch, I went to my local auto parts store and picked up a can of Marvel Mystery Oil. In every single property I and a chemist friend were able to evaluate, the magic high priced oil WAS Marvel Mystery Oil. When the manufacturer's US agent was queried, he of course, denied this and flat out stated that the warranty was void unless their special high-priced oil was used. Not long thereafter, an employee of the company confirmed that, in fcat, the very expeinsive special oil WAS Marvel Mystery Oil, simply poured out of the can. If you included $1 for the little glass vial, profit margin to the distributor was in the realm of 96%. |
#3
Posted to rec.audio.high-end
|
|||
|
|||
Turntable bearing oil ?
Stevie Vaughan wrote:
I just bought a new table and it came with 5ml of RED oil. I put the bearing assy together and realized that the hole drilled through the base wasn't straight and I needed to take the bearing apart again. My Question is.. Is there a good reason why anyone should spend 15 to 25 bucks on a very SMALL amount of this oil? Isn't it available some other way? Who knows what it is exactly? Thanks Since I use Mobil 1 in my auto.. I use it with the VPI I have. |
#4
Posted to rec.audio.high-end
|
|||
|
|||
Turntable bearing oil ?
"Stevie Vaughan" wrote in message
... I just bought a new table and it came with 5ml of RED oil. I put the bearing assy together and realized that the hole drilled through the base wasn't straight and I needed to take the bearing apart again. My Question is.. Is there a good reason why anyone should spend 15 to 25 bucks on a very SMALL amount of this oil? Isn't it available some other way? Who knows what it is exactly? Thanks I've been using cans labeled "3 in 1 Multi Purpose Oil" and "3 in 1 SAE 20 Motor Oil", probably the same item, for "a coons age" with no ill effect. |
#5
Posted to rec.audio.high-end
|
|||
|
|||
Turntable bearing oil ?
Is there a good reason why anyone should spend 15 to 25 bucks on a very
SMALL amount of this oil? Isn't it available some other way? Who knows what it is exactly? Most likely, it is a form of Marvel Mystery Oil, AKA "After-Run" oil repackaged at midnight by a new moon using only left-handed virgins all born at midnight of Walpurgis Night (May 1, of course) , and all aged 66.6 years old. About $3 for 4 ounces at your nearest automotive store. It has a distinctive smell, so you can narrow it down easily. I have found that most bearings of the nature you describe respond very well to PTFE-based oils found at your local hobby-shop. If the guy behind the counter boggles, just say "Teflon-Oil", he will hand you a small pin-point oiler for about $4. I have used it for years on everything from R/C submarines to clocks to tuning condenser bearings. Great stuff, doesn't get hard, doesn't gum... I also use the Marvel as after-run oil, about 1/4th the cost of the purpose-sold stuff, and I have hundreds of hours on the motor (.50CC 2-stroke) of my R/C hovercraft. But when you wrote "red" it triggered the connection. Peter Wieck Wyncote, PA |
#6
Posted to rec.audio.high-end
|
|||
|
|||
Turntable bearing oil ?
Sounds like "Snake oil"
"Stevie Vaughan" wrote in message ... I just bought a new table and it came with 5ml of RED oil. I put the bearing assy together and realized that the hole drilled through the base wasn't straight and I needed to take the bearing apart again. My Question is.. Is there a good reason why anyone should spend 15 to 25 bucks on a very SMALL amount of this oil? Isn't it available some other way? Who knows what it is exactly? Thanks |
#7
Posted to rec.audio.high-end
|
|||
|
|||
Turntable bearing oil ?
Stevie Vaughan wrote:
I just bought a new table and it came with 5ml of RED oil. I put the bearing assy together and realized that the hole drilled through the base wasn't straight and I needed to take the bearing apart again. My Question is.. Is there a good reason why anyone should spend 15 to 25 bucks on a very SMALL amount of this oil? Isn't it available some other way? Who knows what it is exactly? Thanks An earlier response was eaten by my lovely Mozilla browser... arrgh! Specialty industrial and scientific oils are sold in 55 gal drums and in the smallest batches I've ever seen, 5 gal pails... so any mfr who selects a specialty oil has to fork over some bucks up front for way too much. (For example there are special bearing oils for high speed spindles...) I'd want to know what type of bearing it is, that would give a clue as to what sort of oil and vicosity it really needs. Of course, some mfrs may have merely guessed. If the viscosity range fits, the the synthetic oils will be superior - they're available up to 160 as automotive gear oil. BTW, 3-In-1 should NOT be used as a bearing oil because of the additives, it's not a straight oil, afaik. _-_-bear |
#8
Posted to rec.audio.high-end
|
|||
|
|||
Turntable bearing oil ?
BTW, 3-In-1 should NOT be used as a bearing oil because of the
additives, it's not a straight oil, afaik. Actually, it should not be used excepting "Oilite" bearings due to the _lack_ of additives, not the presence of same. 3-in-1 was pretty much designed to be a household oil, or a *motor bearing* oil for fractional HP motors in such things as fans, blowers, bench-grinders and the like, applications where the oil is expended over a realtively short time and must be constantly renewed. For a semi-permanent single application, non-gumming, anti-oxidation additives are required (or synthetics with sufficiently long-chain molecules to resist gumming and oxidation). In the application noted (Turntable spindles), the pressures and temperatures are relatively minor, so the major consideration would be film-strength, lubrication properties and resistance to oxidation. At the most basic level, anything above 10W or so should be fine, and anything at the 'grease' range might be too thick. If the oil that came with the unit was liquid at room temperature, and had flow to it, the PTFE-based hobby-oil will be excellent, as it is about 60W, synthetic, and contains suspended Teflon to prevent metal-to-metal contact. If the OEM stuff does not flow, but needs to be 'extruded', I would suggest searching for a molybdenum-disulphide-based bearing grease as the closest thing to a light-weight high-pressure bearing grease commonly available. Try to stay away from *gear* oils, as their primary characteristic is high film strength (to protect the gear faces under extreme pressures and at often very high temperatures), not lubrication (help things slip more easily), so they may considerably increase the load on the turntable motor. Despite rumors to the contrary, it ain't nohow rocket science. This is not a turbine, doesn't spin at 30,000rpm, and does not undergo huge pressures. Peter Wieck Wyncote, PA |
#9
Posted to rec.audio.high-end
|
|||
|
|||
Turntable bearing oil ?
I've heard you can use sewing machine oil in bearings because it is nice and
light. I did this with my old table and never noticed any problems. |
#10
Posted to rec.audio.high-end
|
|||
|
|||
Turntable bearing oil ?
What type of table would have a bearing hole misdrilled and then have
you assemble the bearing and buy oil for it? The oil is likely either transmission fluid or MMO (basically transmission fluid!) as mentioned earlier. -Bill www.uptownaudio.com Roanoke VA (540) 343-1250 PS: I thought you were dead... "Stevie Vaughan" wrote in message ... I just bought a new table and it came with 5ml of RED oil. I put the bearing assy together and realized that the hole drilled through the base wasn't straight and I needed to take the bearing apart again. My Question is.. Is there a good reason why anyone should spend 15 to 25 bucks on a very SMALL amount of this oil? Isn't it available some other way? Who knows what it is exactly? Thanks |
#11
Posted to rec.audio.high-end
|
|||
|
|||
Turntable bearing oil ?
sounds like transmission fluid (oil) which I use on heater blower motors and
it makes them run so smooth. "Uptown Audio" wrote in message ... What type of table would have a bearing hole misdrilled and then have you assemble the bearing and buy oil for it? The oil is likely either transmission fluid or MMO (basically transmission fluid!) as mentioned earlier. -Bill www.uptownaudio.com Roanoke VA (540) 343-1250 PS: I thought you were dead... "Stevie Vaughan" wrote in message ... I just bought a new table and it came with 5ml of RED oil. I put the bearing assy together and realized that the hole drilled through the base wasn't straight and I needed to take the bearing apart again. My Question is.. Is there a good reason why anyone should spend 15 to 25 bucks on a very SMALL amount of this oil? Isn't it available some other way? Who knows what it is exactly? Thanks |
Reply |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
More Direct Drive Turntable Myths | Audio Opinions | |||
TURNTABLE anyone? | Marketplace | |||
Need a working TURNTABLE? | Marketplace | |||
*** ANNUAL TURNTABLE EVENT *** | Marketplace | |||
>>>>> TURNTABLE BONAZA <<<<< | Marketplace |