Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
#1
![]()
Posted to rec.audio.pro,rec.audio.opinion
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
I'm using Cubase LE on XP. I find the following:
1. It requires running as admin privilige, at least to modify audio output parameters, such as latency. If I try to do so as a regular user, Cubase either hangs, or leaves the latency at 50 ms. If I use a copy of a project created as administrator that has latency set to, say, 2ms, when I run the copy as a regular user, it resets to 50 ms. 2. If the computer hibernates and is restored from hibernated state, the midi in connection breaks. I thought this was a problem with my midiman usb converter, so I switched to a Creative Audigy ZS game port. However, the same happens. Processor is an Athlon 64 3200. Frequently, "LE" products are not as well maintained as full versions. Does anyone have any additional experience with these limitations? |
#2
![]()
Posted to rec.audio.pro,rec.audio.opinion
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
"Robert Morein" said:
I'm using Cubase LE on XP. I find the following: 1. It requires running as admin privilige, at least to modify audio output parameters, such as latency. If I try to do so as a regular user, Cubase either hangs, or leaves the latency at 50 ms. If I use a copy of a project created as administrator that has latency set to, say, 2ms, when I run the copy as a regular user, it resets to 50 ms. Run regedit and copy/paste the appropriate reg file from "user" to "local machine". 2. If the computer hibernates and is restored from hibernated state, the midi in connection breaks. I thought this was a problem with my midiman usb converter, so I switched to a Creative Audigy ZS game port. However, the same happens. Simple, really, turn the hibernate function off. If you need to put something in stand by, go to your energy settings and just let the monitor swith off after a while. -- "Audio as a serious hobby is going down the tubes." - Howard Ferstler, 25/4/2005 |
#3
![]()
Posted to rec.audio.pro,rec.audio.opinion
|
|||
|
|||
![]() "Sander deWaal" wrote in message news ![]() "Robert Morein" said: I'm using Cubase LE on XP. I find the following: 1. It requires running as admin privilige, at least to modify audio output parameters, such as latency. If I try to do so as a regular user, Cubase either hangs, or leaves the latency at 50 ms. If I use a copy of a project created as administrator that has latency set to, say, 2ms, when I run the copy as a regular user, it resets to 50 ms. Run regedit and copy/paste the appropriate reg file from "user" to "local machine". Do you mean, "key", as opposed to "file"? How would I know the name of the key? 2. If the computer hibernates and is restored from hibernated state, the midi in connection breaks. I thought this was a problem with my midiman usb converter, so I switched to a Creative Audigy ZS game port. However, the same happens. Simple, really, turn the hibernate function off. If you need to put something in stand by, go to your energy settings and just let the monitor swith off after a while. I would like to use hibernate, because the difference in power consumption is quite substantial. For example, my 2.6g P4 draws 110 watts operating, 70 watts standby, and 0 watts hibernating. |
#4
![]()
Posted to rec.audio.pro,rec.audio.opinion
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
I've been strongly warned off using Hibernation in general. My own
experience is that an awkward awakening one time really screwed up my windows virus. I won' t use it anymore. |
#5
![]()
Posted to rec.audio.pro,rec.audio.opinion
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
Leave hibernating to bears. I understand that the hibernate function is
a bit of a crap shoot between the windows virus and the random hardware abstraction layer. |
#6
![]()
Posted to rec.audio.pro,rec.audio.opinion
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
"Robert Morein" wrote in message
2. If the computer hibernates and is restored from hibernated state, the midi in connection breaks. I thought this was a problem with my midiman usb converter, so I switched to a Creative Audigy ZS game port. However, the same happens. Simple, really, turn the hibernate function off. If you need to put something in stand by, go to your energy settings and just let the monitor swith off after a while. I would like to use hibernate, because the difference in power consumption is quite substantial. For example, my 2.6g P4 draws 110 watts operating, 70 watts standby, and 0 watts hibernating. You do understand that when a machine hibernates, it pretty well breaks all connections with outside I/O devices, right? |
#7
![]()
Posted to rec.audio.pro,rec.audio.opinion
|
|||
|
|||
![]() "Arny Krueger" wrote in message ... "Robert Morein" wrote in message 2. If the computer hibernates and is restored from hibernated state, the midi in connection breaks. I thought this was a problem with my midiman usb converter, so I switched to a Creative Audigy ZS game port. However, the same happens. Simple, really, turn the hibernate function off. If you need to put something in stand by, go to your energy settings and just let the monitor swith off after a while. I would like to use hibernate, because the difference in power consumption is quite substantial. For example, my 2.6g P4 draws 110 watts operating, 70 watts standby, and 0 watts hibernating. You do understand that when a machine hibernates, it pretty well breaks all connections with outside I/O devices, right? You do understand that this depends upon how the driver is written, right? |
#8
![]()
Posted to rec.audio.pro,rec.audio.opinion
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
"Robert Morein" said:
You do understand that when a machine hibernates, it pretty well breaks all connections with outside I/O devices, right? You do understand that this depends upon how the driver is written, right? I'm afraid that Arny is right, I've never seen a WinXP machine that keeps its connections when going into hibernating status. And I meant reg keys instead of files, of course. Look in the registry in "software" for something like Steinberg or Cubase (or whatever company it is now). -- "Audio as a serious hobby is going down the tubes." - Howard Ferstler, 25/4/2005 |
#9
![]()
Posted to rec.audio.pro, rec.audio.opinion
|
|||
|
|||
![]() "Robert Morein" wrote in message : "Arny Krueger" wrote in message ... "Robert Morein" wrote in message You do understand that when a machine hibernates, it pretty well breaks all connections with outside I/O devices, right? You do understand that this depends upon how the driver is written, right? You do understand that this doesn't invalidate the general truth of the previous statement, right? |
#10
![]()
Posted to rec.audio.pro,rec.audio.opinion
|
|||
|
|||
![]() Arny Krueger wrote: "Robert Morein" wrote in message 2. If the computer hibernates and is restored from hibernated state, the midi in connection breaks. I thought this was a problem with my midiman usb converter, so I switched to a Creative Audigy ZS game port. However, the same happens. Simple, really, turn the hibernate function off. If you need to put something in stand by, go to your energy settings and just let the monitor swith off after a while. I would like to use hibernate, because the difference in power consumption is quite substantial. For example, my 2.6g P4 draws 110 watts operating, 70 watts standby, and 0 watts hibernating. You do understand that when a machine hibernates, it pretty well breaks all connections with outside I/O devices, right? Anything that needs a 'sync' is going to lose it for sure. Graham |
#11
![]()
Posted to rec.audio.pro,rec.audio.opinion
|
|||
|
|||
![]() "Pooh Bear" wrote in message ... Arny Krueger wrote: "Robert Morein" wrote in message 2. If the computer hibernates and is restored from hibernated state, the midi in connection breaks. I thought this was a problem with my midiman usb converter, so I switched to a Creative Audigy ZS game port. However, the same happens. Simple, really, turn the hibernate function off. If you need to put something in stand by, go to your energy settings and just let the monitor swith off after a while. I would like to use hibernate, because the difference in power consumption is quite substantial. For example, my 2.6g P4 draws 110 watts operating, 70 watts standby, and 0 watts hibernating. You do understand that when a machine hibernates, it pretty well breaks all connections with outside I/O devices, right? Anything that needs a 'sync' is going to lose it for sure. Graham Not inevitably. IME, firewire connections to external sound devices do break. OTOH, usb connections to external hard drives generally restore when the machine wakes up. So do HIDs (human interface devices, as defined by Microsoft, to include typing keyboards and pointing devices. When the Midiman 1x1 stopped working after a hibernate cycle, I did suspect a problem of this nature. So I switched to the MIDI interface on the Creative sound card. This is a simple, asynchronous interface similar in nature to a serial port. The only device on it is a Fatar SL880 keyboard, which is an output-only device. If the Creative sound card driver is as well written as a typical serial port driver, it should survive a hibernate sequence. OTOH, the problem may be in the Cubase program itself. Perhaps it needs to get a new port handle on wakeup, and fails to do so. |
#12
![]()
Posted to rec.audio.pro,rec.audio.opinion
|
|||
|
|||
![]() "Greg Pasquariello" wrote in message . .. "Robert Morein" wrote in message : "Arny Krueger" wrote in message ... "Robert Morein" wrote in message You do understand that when a machine hibernates, it pretty well breaks all connections with outside I/O devices, right? You do understand that this depends upon how the driver is written, right? You do understand that this doesn't invalidate the general truth of the previous statement, right? You do understand it's not generally true, don't you? -- that it depends on the specific driver interface? You do understand this, don't you? |
#13
![]()
Posted to rec.audio.pro, rec.audio.opinion
|
|||
|
|||
![]() "Robert Morein" wrote in message : You do understand that this doesn't invalidate the general truth of the previous statement, right? You do understand it's not generally true, don't you? -- that it depends on the specific driver interface? You do understand this, don't you? Yup. And I'm willing to put money on the fact that there are substantially more drivers that will not behave as you seem to hope during hibernation. Assuming that's the case, then it DOES make the statement generally true. You understand this, don't you? |
#14
![]()
Posted to rec.audio.pro,rec.audio.opinion
|
|||
|
|||
![]() "Greg Pasquariello" wrote in message ... "Robert Morein" wrote in message : You do understand that this doesn't invalidate the general truth of the previous statement, right? You do understand it's not generally true, don't you? -- that it depends on the specific driver interface? You do understand this, don't you? Yup. And I'm willing to put money on the fact that there are substantially more drivers that will not behave as you seem to hope during hibernation. Assuming that's the case, then it DOES make the statement generally true. You understand this, don't you? The statement is not "generally true." It is different for every driver. You understand this, don't you? |
#15
![]()
Posted to rec.audio.pro,rec.audio.opinion
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
"Robert Morein" wrote in message
"Arny Krueger" wrote in message ... "Robert Morein" wrote in message 2. If the computer hibernates and is restored from hibernated state, the midi in connection breaks. I thought this was a problem with my midiman usb converter, so I switched to a Creative Audigy ZS game port. However, the same happens. Simple, really, turn the hibernate function off. If you need to put something in stand by, go to your energy settings and just let the monitor swith off after a while. I would like to use hibernate, because the difference in power consumption is quite substantial. For example, my 2.6g P4 draws 110 watts operating, 70 watts standby, and 0 watts hibernating. You do understand that when a machine hibernates, it pretty well breaks all connections with outside I/O devices, right? You do understand that this depends upon how the driver is written, right? No, the specs for hibernation always involve a complete power shutdown of the computer. http://www.microsoft.com/windowsxp/u...hibernate.mspx "Hibernate saves an image of your desktop with all open files and documents, and then it powers down your computer. When you turn on power, your files and documents are open on your desktop exactly as you left them." If a laptop computer is hibernating, then you can remove the batteries and it will still recover from hibernation the next time you power it up. If a desktop computer is hibernating, you can pull the power cord and remove all other sources of power. It will then be electrically inert except for the CMOS battery which is irrelevant to powering external I/O devices. It will then recover from hibernation the next time you apply power. If the computer is not powered down, it isn't hibernating, according to Microsoft. |
#16
![]()
Posted to rec.audio.pro,rec.audio.opinion
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
"Robert Morein" wrote in message
"Greg Pasquariello" wrote in message . .. "Robert Morein" wrote in message : "Arny Krueger" wrote in message ... "Robert Morein" wrote in message You do understand that when a machine hibernates, it pretty well breaks all connections with outside I/O devices, right? You do understand that this depends upon how the driver is written, right? You do understand that this doesn't invalidate the general truth of the previous statement, right? You do understand it's not generally true, don't you? -- that it depends on the specific driver interface? You do understand this, don't you? Morein, three people (and its not like Sander and I agree about much!) and a relevant Microsoft document say otherwise. I know that its against your religion to admit that you're wrong, but you should really give it up! |
#17
![]()
Posted to rec.audio.pro,rec.audio.opinion
|
|||
|
|||
![]() "Arny Krueger" wrote in message ... "Robert Morein" wrote in message "Arny Krueger" wrote in message ... "Robert Morein" wrote in message 2. If the computer hibernates and is restored from hibernated state, the midi in connection breaks. I thought this was a problem with my midiman usb converter, so I switched to a Creative Audigy ZS game port. However, the same happens. Simple, really, turn the hibernate function off. If you need to put something in stand by, go to your energy settings and just let the monitor swith off after a while. I would like to use hibernate, because the difference in power consumption is quite substantial. For example, my 2.6g P4 draws 110 watts operating, 70 watts standby, and 0 watts hibernating. You do understand that when a machine hibernates, it pretty well breaks all connections with outside I/O devices, right? You do understand that this depends upon how the driver is written, right? No, the specs for hibernation always involve a complete power shutdown of the computer. http://www.microsoft.com/windowsxp/u...hibernate.mspx "Hibernate saves an image of your desktop with all open files and documents, and then it powers down your computer. When you turn on power, your files and documents are open on your desktop exactly as you left them." If a laptop computer is hibernating, then you can remove the batteries and it will still recover from hibernation the next time you power it up. If a desktop computer is hibernating, you can pull the power cord and remove all other sources of power. It will then be electrically inert except for the CMOS battery which is irrelevant to powering external I/O devices. It will then recover from hibernation the next time you apply power. If the computer is not powered down, it isn't hibernating, according to Microsoft. True, but utterly irrelevant to the question. When a computer restores from hibernation, all standard USB HID devices work: keyboard and mouse. So does an external USB drive. Obviously, there are some devices that work, and some that don't. Some respondents on this thread have asserted "Generally___". This is not new information; it is not responsive to the question. |
#18
![]()
Posted to rec.audio.pro,rec.audio.opinion
|
|||
|
|||
![]() "Arny Krueger" wrote in message ... "Robert Morein" wrote in message "Greg Pasquariello" wrote in message . .. "Robert Morein" wrote in message : "Arny Krueger" wrote in message ... "Robert Morein" wrote in message You do understand that when a machine hibernates, it pretty well breaks all connections with outside I/O devices, right? You do understand that this depends upon how the driver is written, right? You do understand that this doesn't invalidate the general truth of the previous statement, right? You do understand it's not generally true, don't you? -- that it depends on the specific driver interface? You do understand this, don't you? Morein, three people (and its not like Sander and I agree about much!) and a relevant Microsoft document say otherwise. I know that its against your religion to admit that you're wrong, but you should really give it up! True, but utterly irrelevant to the question. When a computer restores from hibernation, all standard USB HID devices work: keyboard and mouse. So does an external USB drive. Obviously, there are some devices that work, and some that don't. Some respondents on this thread have asserted "Generally___". This is not new information; it is not responsive to the question. |
#19
![]()
Posted to rec.audio.pro,rec.audio.opinion
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
"Pooh Bear" wrote
in message Arny Krueger wrote: "Robert Morein" wrote in message 2. If the computer hibernates and is restored from hibernated state, the midi in connection breaks. I thought this was a problem with my midiman usb converter, so I switched to a Creative Audigy ZS game port. However, the same happens. Simple, really, turn the hibernate function off. If you need to put something in stand by, go to your energy settings and just let the monitor swith off after a while. I would like to use hibernate, because the difference in power consumption is quite substantial. For example, my 2.6g P4 draws 110 watts operating, 70 watts standby, and 0 watts hibernating. You do understand that when a machine hibernates, it pretty well breaks all connections with outside I/O devices, right? Anything that needs a 'sync' is going to lose it for sure. Agreed. |
#20
![]()
Posted to rec.audio.pro, rec.audio.opinion
|
|||
|
|||
![]() "Robert Morein" wrote in message : The statement is not "generally true." It is different for every driver. You understand this, don't you? Are you a moron? If drivers generally do not behave well during hiberanation, then the statement "when a machine hibernates, it pretty well breaks all connections with outside I/O devices" IS generally true. But whatever. You're the one with the issue, not me, so knock yourself out arguing false semantics. |
#21
![]()
Posted to rec.audio.pro,rec.audio.opinion
|
|||
|
|||
![]() "Arny Krueger" wrote in message ... "Pooh Bear" wrote in message Arny Krueger wrote: "Robert Morein" wrote in message 2. If the computer hibernates and is restored from hibernated state, the midi in connection breaks. I thought this was a problem with my midiman usb converter, so I switched to a Creative Audigy ZS game port. However, the same happens. Simple, really, turn the hibernate function off. If you need to put something in stand by, go to your energy settings and just let the monitor swith off after a while. I would like to use hibernate, because the difference in power consumption is quite substantial. For example, my 2.6g P4 draws 110 watts operating, 70 watts standby, and 0 watts hibernating. You do understand that when a machine hibernates, it pretty well breaks all connections with outside I/O devices, right? Anything that needs a 'sync' is going to lose it for sure. Agreed. Agreed, but MIDI is an asynchronous interface, a unidirectional asynchronous bit stream at 31.25 Kbits/sec. with 10 bits transmitted per byte, with a single start bit, 8 data bits, and a singles stop bit. This is identical in format to an ANSI serial data stream. Since it has a built in sync signal in every byte, it does not require a continuous datastream. Each time a MIDI controller is actuated, it generates a fresh sync at the start, and every byte thereafter. There is nothing inherent in the protocol that would make it difficult to recover from a hibernate, or even a physical disconnection. One can unplug and plug a MIDI keyboard, with no ill effects. |
#22
![]()
Posted to rec.audio.pro,rec.audio.opinion
|
|||
|
|||
![]() "Greg Pasquariello" wrote in message ... "Robert Morein" wrote in message : The statement is not "generally true." It is different for every driver. You understand this, don't you? Are you a moron? If drivers generally do not behave well during hiberanation, then the statement "when a machine hibernates, it pretty well breaks all connections with outside I/O devices" IS generally true. But whatever. You're the one with the issue, not me, so knock yourself out arguing false semantics. But drivers do not "generally" do this, or that. Knock yourself out. I posted with a specific question. If you don't have a contribution, you can either try to detour it to symantics, or remain silent. |
#23
![]()
Posted to rec.audio.pro,rec.audio.opinion
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
"Robert Morein" wrote in message
"Pooh Bear" wrote in message ... Arny Krueger wrote: "Robert Morein" wrote in message 2. If the computer hibernates and is restored from hibernated state, the midi in connection breaks. I thought this was a problem with my midiman usb converter, so I switched to a Creative Audigy ZS game port. However, the same happens. Simple, really, turn the hibernate function off. If you need to put something in stand by, go to your energy settings and just let the monitor swith off after a while. I would like to use hibernate, because the difference in power consumption is quite substantial. For example, my 2.6g P4 draws 110 watts operating, 70 watts standby, and 0 watts hibernating. You do understand that when a machine hibernates, it pretty well breaks all connections with outside I/O devices, right? Anything that needs a 'sync' is going to lose it for sure. Not inevitably. Yes, inevitably. No power, no synch. IME, firewire connections to external sound devices do break. This is a debating trade ploy. The discussion was about MIDI, and now discussion has switched to IEE1394. However, Morein's debating trade ploy just digs him in deeper, because he quickly makes false distinctions between USB and IEEE1394. OTOH, usb connections to external hard drives generally restore when the machine wakes up. So do IEE1394 connections. Both IEEE1394 and USB are hot-plug interfaces. Both can convey power to outside devices, which may confuse the unaware. So do HIDs (human interface devices, as defined by Microsoft, to include typing keyboards and pointing devices. This is yet another debating trade ploy. The discussion was about MIDI, IEEE1394 and USB and now discussion has switched to a class of I/O devices which are available commonly available with USB and yet another interface, the interface used for mini-DIN connectors such as found on legacy mice and keyboards. Morein has already demonstrated gross technical incompetence with his incorrect claims about MIDI. IEE1394, and USB which share in common the fact that they are by definition, hot-pluggable. The mini-DIN keyboard/mouse interface is commonly impmented either way. Typically hot-pluggable for keyboards, and mice on laptops, but not hot-pluggable on desktop computers. Why Morein would venture into an area with this greater complexity is unimaginable for a sane person, given how badly he's blown it with the simpler cases. When the Midiman 1x1 stopped working after a hibernate cycle, I did suspect a problem of this nature. Pretty simple really, you powered everything off, except perhaps the source MIDI device the SL880 keyboard. So I switched to the MIDI interface on the Creative sound card. This is a simple, asynchronous interface similar in nature to a serial port. That's MIDI, no matter what hardware implements it. The only device on it is a Fatar SL880 keyboard, which is an output-only device. If the Creative sound card driver is as well written as a typical serial port driver, it should survive a hibernate sequence. That depends on the program that you are trying to control with the SL880 keyboard. OTOH, the problem may be in the Cubase program itself. Perhaps it needs to get a new port handle on wakeup, and fails to do so. How about that? ;-) |
#24
![]()
Posted to rec.audio.pro,rec.audio.opinion
|
|||
|
|||
![]() "Arny Krueger" wrote in message ... "Robert Morein" wrote in message "Pooh Bear" wrote in message ... Arny Krueger wrote: "Robert Morein" wrote in message 2. If the computer hibernates and is restored from hibernated state, the midi in connection breaks. I thought this was a problem with my midiman usb converter, so I switched to a Creative Audigy ZS game port. However, the same happens. Simple, really, turn the hibernate function off. If you need to put something in stand by, go to your energy settings and just let the monitor swith off after a while. I would like to use hibernate, because the difference in power consumption is quite substantial. For example, my 2.6g P4 draws 110 watts operating, 70 watts standby, and 0 watts hibernating. You do understand that when a machine hibernates, it pretty well breaks all connections with outside I/O devices, right? Anything that needs a 'sync' is going to lose it for sure. Not inevitably. Yes, inevitably. No power, no synch. IME, firewire connections to external sound devices do break. This is a debating trade ploy. The discussion was about MIDI, and now discussion has switched to IEE1394. However, Morein's debating trade ploy just digs him in deeper, because he quickly makes false distinctions between USB and IEEE1394. OTOH, usb connections to external hard drives generally restore when the machine wakes up. So do IEE1394 connections. Both IEEE1394 and USB are hot-plug interfaces. Both can convey power to outside devices, which may confuse the unaware. So do HIDs (human interface devices, as defined by Microsoft, to include typing keyboards and pointing devices. This is yet another debating trade ploy. The discussion was about MIDI, IEEE1394 and USB and now discussion has switched to a class of I/O devices which are available commonly available with USB and yet another interface, the interface used for mini-DIN connectors such as found on legacy mice and keyboards. Morein has already demonstrated gross technical incompetence with his incorrect claims about MIDI. IEE1394, and USB which share in common the fact that they are by definition, hot-pluggable. The mini-DIN keyboard/mouse interface is commonly impmented either way. Typically hot-pluggable for keyboards, and mice on laptops, but not hot-pluggable on desktop computers. Why Morein would venture into an area with this greater complexity is unimaginable for a sane person, given how badly he's blown it with the simpler cases. When the Midiman 1x1 stopped working after a hibernate cycle, I did suspect a problem of this nature. Pretty simple really, you powered everything off, except perhaps the source MIDI device the SL880 keyboard. So I switched to the MIDI interface on the Creative sound card. This is a simple, asynchronous interface similar in nature to a serial port. That's MIDI, no matter what hardware implements it. The only device on it is a Fatar SL880 keyboard, which is an output-only device. If the Creative sound card driver is as well written as a typical serial port driver, it should survive a hibernate sequence. That depends on the program that you are trying to control with the SL880 keyboard. OTOH, the problem may be in the Cubase program itself. Perhaps it needs to get a new port handle on wakeup, and fails to do so. How about that? ;-) I'm looking for answers, not sarcasm. |
#25
![]()
Posted to rec.audio.pro,rec.audio.opinion
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
"Robert Morein" wrote in message
"Arny Krueger" wrote in message ... "Robert Morein" wrote in message "Greg Pasquariello" wrote in message . .. "Robert Morein" wrote in message : "Arny Krueger" wrote in message ... "Robert Morein" wrote in message You do understand that when a machine hibernates, it pretty well breaks all connections with outside I/O devices, right? You do understand that this depends upon how the driver is written, right? You do understand that this doesn't invalidate the general truth of the previous statement, right? You do understand it's not generally true, don't you? -- that it depends on the specific driver interface? You do understand this, don't you? Morein, three people (and its not like Sander and I agree about much!) and a relevant Microsoft document say otherwise. I know that its against your religion to admit that you're wrong, but you should really give it up! True, but utterly irrelevant to the question. Not at all. Morein, you made them relevent with your OP and your ongoing debating-trade inspired complexifying of the situation. When a computer restores from hibernation, all standard USB HID devices work: keyboard and mouse. True, but this happens for a complex series of reasons. One reason why this works is because the entities that you control with the keyboard and mouse are designed to be restartable. If this is a laptop both the keyboard and mouse are hot-pluggable. The ability to be hot-plugged extends all the way back into the bowels of the computer. A hot-pluggable interface does not necessarily make a hot-pluggable function. A hot-pluggable interface is a necessary, but not a sufficient condition. So does an external USB drive. That actually depends on the software that is accessing the USB drive. If you unplug a USB hard drive while a program is writing to it, the results can be pretty catastrophic to that program. Or not. Obviously, there are some devices that work, and some that don't. I think the real problem is Morien that you don't understand all of the things that must be lined up in a row for things to work as you wish. You finally got around to admitting that you're reading this keyboard with Cubase. Where is it written in stone that Cubase is written to be totally interuptable and capable of fully supporting hot-pluggable I/O gear? Some respondents on this thread have asserted "Generally___". This is not new information; it is not responsive to the question. Wrong again Morein. An intelligent person would see that Graham is helping you to exclude possible causes. You're criticizing him for helping him just as you've repeated bitten my hand with your many ludicrous "Arny is ia psychopath" and "Arny is a bad scientist" posts. There's a crazy man on this thread Robert, one who is no scientist at all, and he's you! :-( I think Robert this is because you don't understand how to troubleshoot even simple situations, let alone say the process of obtaining a PhD degree, or even just making a MIDI keyboard work with Cubase... Your trouble-shooting procedures generate smoke, not working systems. |
#26
![]()
Posted to rec.audio.pro,rec.audio.opinion
|
|||
|
|||
![]() "Arny Krueger" wrote in message ... "Robert Morein" wrote in message "Arny Krueger" wrote in message ... "Robert Morein" wrote in message "Greg Pasquariello" wrote in message . .. "Robert Morein" wrote in message : "Arny Krueger" wrote in message ... "Robert Morein" wrote in message You do understand that when a machine hibernates, it pretty well breaks all connections with outside I/O devices, right? You do understand that this depends upon how the driver is written, right? You do understand that this doesn't invalidate the general truth of the previous statement, right? You do understand it's not generally true, don't you? -- that it depends on the specific driver interface? You do understand this, don't you? Morein, three people (and its not like Sander and I agree about much!) and a relevant Microsoft document say otherwise. I know that its against your religion to admit that you're wrong, but you should really give it up! True, but utterly irrelevant to the question. Not at all. Morein, you made them relevent with your OP and your ongoing debating-trade inspired complexifying of the situation. When a computer restores from hibernation, all standard USB HID devices work: keyboard and mouse. True, but this happens for a complex series of reasons. One reason why this works is because the entities that you control with the keyboard and mouse are designed to be restartable. If this is a laptop both the keyboard and mouse are hot-pluggable. The ability to be hot-plugged extends all the way back into the bowels of the computer. A hot-pluggable interface does not necessarily make a hot-pluggable function. A hot-pluggable interface is a necessary, but not a sufficient condition. So does an external USB drive. That actually depends on the software that is accessing the USB drive. If you unplug a USB hard drive while a program is writing to it, the results can be pretty catastrophic to that program. Or not. Obviously, there are some devices that work, and some that don't. I think the real problem is Morien that you don't understand all of the things that must be lined up in a row for things to work as you wish. You finally got around to admitting that you're reading this keyboard with Cubase. Where is it written in stone that Cubase is written to be totally interuptable and capable of fully supporting hot-pluggable I/O gear? That is not an answer, Arny. You don't know the answer. Some respondents on this thread have asserted "Generally___". This is not new information; it is not responsive to the question. Wrong again Morein. An intelligent person would see that Graham is helping you to exclude possible causes. Wrong again. However, I credit Graham with good intent. Obviously, there is an answer: driver vs. app vs. Windows behavior. No one here appears to know. There is nothing wrong about not knowing. Now stop this nonsense, because you're adding nothing. |
#27
![]()
Posted to rec.audio.pro,rec.audio.opinion
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
"Robert Morein" wrote in message
"Arny Krueger" wrote in message ... "Robert Morein" wrote in message "Pooh Bear" wrote in message ... Arny Krueger wrote: "Robert Morein" wrote in message 2. If the computer hibernates and is restored from hibernated state, the midi in connection breaks. I thought this was a problem with my midiman usb converter, so I switched to a Creative Audigy ZS game port. However, the same happens. Simple, really, turn the hibernate function off. If you need to put something in stand by, go to your energy settings and just let the monitor swith off after a while. I would like to use hibernate, because the difference in power consumption is quite substantial. For example, my 2.6g P4 draws 110 watts operating, 70 watts standby, and 0 watts hibernating. You do understand that when a machine hibernates, it pretty well breaks all connections with outside I/O devices, right? Anything that needs a 'sync' is going to lose it for sure. Not inevitably. Yes, inevitably. No power, no synch. IME, firewire connections to external sound devices do break. This is a debating trade ploy. The discussion was about MIDI, and now discussion has switched to IEE1394. However, Morein's debating trade ploy just digs him in deeper, because he quickly makes false distinctions between USB and IEEE1394. OTOH, usb connections to external hard drives generally restore when the machine wakes up. So do IEE1394 connections. Both IEEE1394 and USB are hot-plug interfaces. Both can convey power to outside devices, which may confuse the unaware. So do HIDs (human interface devices, as defined by Microsoft, to include typing keyboards and pointing devices. This is yet another debating trade ploy. The discussion was about MIDI, IEEE1394 and USB and now discussion has switched to a class of I/O devices which are available commonly available with USB and yet another interface, the interface used for mini-DIN connectors such as found on legacy mice and keyboards. Morein has already demonstrated gross technical incompetence with his incorrect claims about MIDI. IEE1394, and USB which share in common the fact that they are by definition, hot-pluggable. The mini-DIN keyboard/mouse interface is commonly impmented either way. Typically hot-pluggable for keyboards, and mice on laptops, but not hot-pluggable on desktop computers. Why Morein would venture into an area with this greater complexity is unimaginable for a sane person, given how badly he's blown it with the simpler cases. When the Midiman 1x1 stopped working after a hibernate cycle, I did suspect a problem of this nature. Pretty simple really, you powered everything off, except perhaps the source MIDI device the SL880 keyboard. So I switched to the MIDI interface on the Creative sound card. This is a simple, asynchronous interface similar in nature to a serial port. That's MIDI, no matter what hardware implements it. The only device on it is a Fatar SL880 keyboard, which is an output-only device. If the Creative sound card driver is as well written as a typical serial port driver, it should survive a hibernate sequence. That depends on the program that you are trying to control with the SL880 keyboard. OTOH, the problem may be in the Cubase program itself. Perhaps it needs to get a new port handle on wakeup, and fails to do so. How about that? ;-) I'm looking for answers, not sarcasm. You're getting answers, Morein. Trouble is they are given in a language that you have problems properly comprehending - American English. |
#28
![]()
Posted to rec.audio.pro,rec.audio.opinion
|
|||
|
|||
![]() "Arny Krueger" wrote in message ... "Robert Morein" wrote in message "Arny Krueger" wrote in message ... "Robert Morein" wrote in message "Pooh Bear" wrote in message ... Arny Krueger wrote: "Robert Morein" wrote in message 2. If the computer hibernates and is restored from hibernated state, the midi in connection breaks. I thought this was a problem with my midiman usb converter, so I switched to a Creative Audigy ZS game port. However, the same happens. Simple, really, turn the hibernate function off. If you need to put something in stand by, go to your energy settings and just let the monitor swith off after a while. I would like to use hibernate, because the difference in power consumption is quite substantial. For example, my 2.6g P4 draws 110 watts operating, 70 watts standby, and 0 watts hibernating. You do understand that when a machine hibernates, it pretty well breaks all connections with outside I/O devices, right? Anything that needs a 'sync' is going to lose it for sure. Not inevitably. Yes, inevitably. No power, no synch. IME, firewire connections to external sound devices do break. This is a debating trade ploy. The discussion was about MIDI, and now discussion has switched to IEE1394. However, Morein's debating trade ploy just digs him in deeper, because he quickly makes false distinctions between USB and IEEE1394. OTOH, usb connections to external hard drives generally restore when the machine wakes up. So do IEE1394 connections. Both IEEE1394 and USB are hot-plug interfaces. Both can convey power to outside devices, which may confuse the unaware. So do HIDs (human interface devices, as defined by Microsoft, to include typing keyboards and pointing devices. This is yet another debating trade ploy. The discussion was about MIDI, IEEE1394 and USB and now discussion has switched to a class of I/O devices which are available commonly available with USB and yet another interface, the interface used for mini-DIN connectors such as found on legacy mice and keyboards. Morein has already demonstrated gross technical incompetence with his incorrect claims about MIDI. IEE1394, and USB which share in common the fact that they are by definition, hot-pluggable. The mini-DIN keyboard/mouse interface is commonly impmented either way. Typically hot-pluggable for keyboards, and mice on laptops, but not hot-pluggable on desktop computers. Why Morein would venture into an area with this greater complexity is unimaginable for a sane person, given how badly he's blown it with the simpler cases. When the Midiman 1x1 stopped working after a hibernate cycle, I did suspect a problem of this nature. Pretty simple really, you powered everything off, except perhaps the source MIDI device the SL880 keyboard. So I switched to the MIDI interface on the Creative sound card. This is a simple, asynchronous interface similar in nature to a serial port. That's MIDI, no matter what hardware implements it. The only device on it is a Fatar SL880 keyboard, which is an output-only device. If the Creative sound card driver is as well written as a typical serial port driver, it should survive a hibernate sequence. That depends on the program that you are trying to control with the SL880 keyboard. OTOH, the problem may be in the Cubase program itself. Perhaps it needs to get a new port handle on wakeup, and fails to do so. How about that? ;-) I'm looking for answers, not sarcasm. You're getting answers, Morein. Trouble is they are given in a language that you have problems properly comprehending - American English. Arny, for the love of Christ, shut up. Nobody in this thread knows whether the cause is the driver, the OS, or the app. There is an answer. There is no shame on you, or me, or anybody else in not knowing the answer. So take your adhominem crap and shove it. |
#29
![]()
Posted to rec.audio.pro,rec.audio.opinion
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
"Robert Morein" wrote in message
Arny, for the love of Christ, shut up. Morien, since when did you become interested in Christianity, except to use your pathetic misapprehensions about it to try to abuse me in public? Nobody in this thread knows whether the cause is the driver, the OS, or the app. Given the operator, its probably an operator errror. There is an answer. Yes Robert, but your bull-headed abuse of people who try to help you, as I have tried to help you for years, as your PhD committed tried to help you for years, won't help you get your problem solved. There is no shame on you, or me, or anybody else in not knowing the answer. There is shame Robert in abusing people for your personal satisfaction, especially people who have tried to help you for years and years. So take your adhominem crap and shove it. Robert, if you had two working synapses to rub together, you'd learn from this experience instead of accusing the people who tried to help you. |
#30
![]()
Posted to rec.audio.pro,rec.audio.opinion
|
|||
|
|||
![]() "Arny Krueger" wrote in message . .. "Robert Morein" wrote in message Arny, for the love of Christ, shut up. Morien, since when did you become interested in Christianity, except to use your pathetic misapprehensions about it to try to abuse me in public? Nobody in this thread knows whether the cause is the driver, the OS, or the app. Given the operator, its probably an operator errror. There is an answer. Yes Robert, but your bull-headed abuse of people who try to help you, as I have tried to help you for years, as your PhD committed tried to help you for years, won't help you get your problem solved. There is no shame on you, or me, or anybody else in not knowing the answer. There is shame Robert in abusing people for your personal satisfaction, especially people who have tried to help you for years and years. So take your adhominem crap and shove it. Robert, if you had two working synapses to rub together, you'd learn from this experience instead of accusing the people who tried to help you. Arny, shut up. You don't know the answer. Fine. Nobody in this thread does. Just shove that adhominem crap up your ass. |
#31
![]()
Posted to rec.audio.pro,rec.audio.opinion
|
|||
|
|||
![]() "Arny Krueger" wrote in message ... You do understand that when a machine hibernates, it pretty well breaks all connections with outside I/O devices, right? You learned this on your last trip up at the mountains? The hibernating bears were not avaiable for outside I/O connections? -- Posted via NewsDemon.com - Premium Uncensored Newsgroup Service -------http://www.NewsDemon.com------ Unlimited Access, Anonymous Accounts, Uncensored Broadband Access |
#32
![]()
Posted to rec.audio.pro,rec.audio.opinion
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
Robert Morein wrote:
I'm using Cubase LE on XP. I find the following: 2. If the computer hibernates and is restored from hibernated state, the midi in connection breaks. I thought this was a problem with my midiman usb converter, so I switched to a Creative Audigy ZS game port. However, the same happens. Here's the answer to your 2nd question: http://www.google.com/search?num=100...net&lr=lang_en Now, do the due diligence. GeoSynch |
#33
![]()
Posted to rec.audio.pro,rec.audio.opinion
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
On Sun, 8 Jan 2006 19:50:22 -0500, "Robert Morein"
wrote: That is not an answer, Arny. You don't know the answer. He doesn't. But I do. When you come out of hibernate, the OS will gladly recognize external devices that it supports natively. External devices that require 3rd party drivers won't magikally re-appear. This hibernation return problem is inherent in XP as well as OSX. There is no fix. Developers can write the fanciest-shmanciest device drivers in all the world, and they still "unplug" during hibernate. You have options. You can use a MIDI device supported natively by your OS. (feh) You can re-load the device each damn time. You can turn off hibernate. I would recommend #3. If you are recording in the field and have absolutely no access to AC power, then get a better battery. If you are recording at home, in a studio or in the field with AC power, turn off hibernate. At some point you will have to decide whether or not your laptop is going to be your DAW. If so, turn off the sounds, bells and whistles, turn off unnecessary services, remove the ****e software, clean out your nonpresent devices, streamline your system performance and turn OFF the hibernate function. - TR |
#34
![]()
Posted to rec.audio.pro,rec.audio.opinion
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
Citizen Ted wrote:
At some point you will have to decide whether or not your laptop is going to be your DAW. If so, turn off the sounds, bells and whistles, turn off unnecessary services, remove the ****e software, clean out your nonpresent devices, streamline your system performance and turn OFF the hibernate function. Here's a nice roundup of the subject: "Optimizing Windows 2000 and Windows XP for Audio" http://www.digitalproducer.com/2002/...ze_pcaudio.htm GeoSynch |
#35
![]()
Posted to rec.audio.pro,rec.audio.opinion
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
Robert Morein wrote:
That is not an answer, Arny. You don't know the answer. Arny may well not know the answer, but he's got at least one leg up on you. His computer actually works (AFAWK). Your dumb ass is here asking for advice & when you get some pretty damn good advice (i.e. Don't ****ing run hibernate on an audio system), you not only ignore it, you ****ing argue with it. Fine! take your damn dodgy, hibernating-ass computer home & play all by ****ing yourself. If you're too ****ing smart to take good advice then nobody here really gives much of a rat's ass if your computer freezes. Have a nice ****ing day. |
#36
![]()
Posted to rec.audio.pro,rec.audio.opinion
|
|||
|
|||
![]() "Citizen Ted" wrote in message ... On Sun, 8 Jan 2006 19:50:22 -0500, "Robert Morein" wrote: That is not an answer, Arny. You don't know the answer. He doesn't. You're talking out of the back of your neck. You can't know what I do and don't know without reading my mind. Given the years and years of bad blood between Robert and I, I could have easily been giving him short shrift. I know from years and years of bad experience that Robert makes a habit out of biting any hand that tries to help him. In fact I gave him the short version of what you provide below, except I failed to make an error that you made by being overly general. But I do. It turns out you screwed up by being overly general. But that's not fatal - at least you gave it a try, and most of your advice is perfect. When you come out of hibernate, the OS will gladly recognize external devices that it supports natively. External devices that require 3rd party drivers won't magikally re-appear. This hibernation return problem is inherent in XP as well as OSX. There is no fix. Developers can write the fanciest-shmanciest device drivers in all the world, and they still "unplug" during hibernate. That's essentially what Graham and I told Robert, before he started arguing with us. Except that there are external devices that require 3rd party drivers that do re-appear without manual intervention. Just thinking about some that I *know* work, I come up with a whole class of external third-party devices that resume operation when the laptop comes out of hibernatiion - USB-connected wireless network adaptors. You have options. The easy, reliable one is the third one. You can use a MIDI device supported natively by your OS. (feh) You can re-load the device each damn time. You can turn off hibernate. I would recommend #3. If you are recording in the field and have absolutely no access to AC power, then get a better battery. If you are recording at home, in a studio or in the field with AC power, turn off hibernate. If you read the OP, turning off hibernate was eliminated as a possibility. At some point you will have to decide whether or not your laptop is going to be your DAW. If so, turn off the sounds, bells and whistles, turn off unnecessary services, remove the ****e software, clean out your nonpresent devices, streamline your system performance and turn OFF the hibernate function. That is exactly conventional wisdom, and of course very good advice. |
#37
![]()
Posted to rec.audio.pro,rec.audio.opinion
|
|||
|
|||
![]() "Citizen Ted" wrote in message ... On Sun, 8 Jan 2006 19:50:22 -0500, "Robert Morein" wrote: That is not an answer, Arny. You don't know the answer. He doesn't. But I do. When you come out of hibernate, the OS will gladly recognize external devices that it supports natively. External devices that require 3rd party drivers won't magikally re-appear. This hibernation return problem is inherent in XP as well as OSX. There is no fix. Developers can write the fanciest-shmanciest device drivers in all the world, and they still "unplug" during hibernate. You have options. You can use a MIDI device supported natively by your OS. (feh) You can re-load the device each damn time. You can turn off hibernate. Citizen Ted, You're a standup guy! Thanks for the answer! Regards, Bob Morein |
#38
![]()
Posted to rec.audio.pro,rec.audio.opinion
|
|||
|
|||
![]() "Arny Krueger" wrote in message ... "Citizen Ted" wrote in message ... On Sun, 8 Jan 2006 19:50:22 -0500, "Robert Morein" wrote: That is not an answer, Arny. You don't know the answer. He doesn't. You're talking out of the back of your neck. You can't know what I do and don't know without reading my mind. Given the years and years of bad blood between Robert and I, I could have easily been giving him short shrift. You don't know the answer, Arny. Thanks to Ted!!! |
#39
![]()
Posted to rec.audio.pro,rec.audio.opinion
|
|||
|
|||
![]() "GeoSynch" wrote in message ink.net... Robert Morein wrote: I'm using Cubase LE on XP. I find the following: 2. If the computer hibernates and is restored from hibernated state, the midi in connection breaks. I thought this was a problem with my midiman usb converter, so I switched to a Creative Audigy ZS game port. However, the same happens. Here's the answer to your 2nd question: http://www.google.com/search?num=100...net&lr=lang_en Now, do the due diligence. GeoSynch GeoSynch, "Citizen Ted" has answered the question. According to him, it is impossible to author a 3rd party driver that correctly reinitializes after awakening from hibernation. This means that it is not a QC issue with respect to 3rd party software or hardware, but an intrinic property of the XP kernel. At this point, I would like to thank all those who responded in this thread without adhomineum references. This was a technical question, and it has now been adequately answered. |
#40
![]()
Posted to rec.audio.pro,rec.audio.opinion
|
|||
|
|||
![]() Robert Morein said: Given the years and years of bad blood between Robert and I [sic], I could have easily been giving him short shrift. You don't know the answer, Arny. This might be another case of Mr. **** having intended to give the right answer only to be sidetracked by his filthy, christianity-addled brain. As Turdborg has asserted frequently in the past: "If I'd said what I should have said, I would have been 100's and 100's of %'s correct." |
Reply |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
![]() |
||||
Thread | Forum | |||
M-Audio Firewire 410 with Cubase Problem | Pro Audio | |||
Cubase synchronization (Midi Clock sync) problem | Pro Audio | |||
stay with cubase, or jump ship to protools? | Pro Audio | |||
Why are my RADAR Bwavs out of time in Cubase SX | Pro Audio | |||
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!sonar vs cubase: final verdict.. | Pro Audio |