Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
#1
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
From an interview with Edgarhorn engineer Dr. Bruce Edgar:
Bruce: Yes, though there were some people at the show who didn't like the direct radiator subwoofer. I don't blame them, but they just totally turned off. I've had a number of people listen to the system and tell me, "I have been through four or five different speaker systems," and start listing the expensive speaker systems they've had. With each one, they finally just had to give up and sell it, and go on to the next. Then they heard one of my horn systems and said, "This is the only system that I can listen to." Another interesting thing that I hear from customers is that when they get my speaker system installed, they have to go back and listen to their whole CD or record collection because all their favorite source material now doesn't sound very good, and the material that was unlistenable before now sounds pretty good. My explanation is that the unlistenable records had a wide dynamic range, and the original speaker system couldn't handle it. Now that you have all the dynamic range that you 'd want, suddenly the record that was breaking up your older speaker system sounds live, and the records that you liked before sound very compressed. I have to go through many CDs and records to find good material to play on my system, because if the material is compressed it will sound lifeless. One of the other interesting experiences is to hear various pieces of electronic gear through the horn system. Before the single-ended amplifier revolution I was using solid state gear-Bill Chater's MOSFET amplifier. When Joe Roberts started publishing Sound Practices and advocating single-ended amplifiers, I asked him if he knew anybody that had single-ended amplifiers in California. Well, he gave me a couple of names, and I had one guy bring over his home-built amplifier. At first it sounded pretty good, but then I started hearing a certain amount of muddiness. I thought something was wrong with my speakers, so I finally dragged out my old MOSFET amplifier, plugged it in, and everything sounded good again. My experience is that horns are a double-edged sword. They are very, very sensitive, and it doesn't take a whole lot of amplifier power to get good sound out of them, but that watt or so of energy needs to be extremely clean because if there's any distortion in your electronics chain, it will show up. I think one of the reasons that horn speakers have gotten a bad rap is that the electronics associated with them were not all that great. Sure, they had problems with response peaks, but I think the electronics were also part of it. As the single-ended amplifiers have improved, my horns have sounded better. Dave: How did you connect with Electra-Print? Bruce: I've had a very good working relationship with Cy Brenneman and Jack Elliano at Electra-Print. One day about two years ago, they called me and said, "We've heard all about your horn system and we've got an amplifier we want to try." It was a mono push-pull amplifier. It sounded very good on the horns. When the opportunity came up for the '95 CES, I asked them to supply an amplifier for my horn system. Since the Vaic people were sponsoring a room, they modified their newly developed 300B amplifier for the Vaic tube, and it sounded pretty good. We worked between the '95 CES and the '95 Stereophile show to correct the problems that had shown up at the January show. Everything came right together right before the show, and we were all positively amazed at how much better the amps and speakers sounded. People at the show said, "It sounds great, it must be those horns," and I said, "No, it's the horns and the tube amplifiers." The Vaic tube is one of the cleanest tubes I've ever heard, better than any 300B. I am at the point now where I can pick out the distortion in a 300B amplifier because I've heard the difference. Dave: And in fact, we're sitting here now looking at a prototype of an Electra-Print preamp, which I would guess we'll be seeing at that show? Bruce: Yes. One of the nice things about the cooperation between us is that for every improvement that the amplifier people do, it shows up immediately on my speakers, and that allows me also to listen more closely to my speakers and identify things that I can improve. It's a very synergistic relationship. |