Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Eric Johnson Signature Guitar?
Hello everyone,
I'm thinking about purchasing the new Eric Johnson Signature Stratocaster that Fender is selling by special order. What do you experienced guitarists think are the pros and cons in such a purchase. It's selling for $1,600 on the web, however the Guitar Center said they can sell it for $1,500. Although I love the Eric Johnson tones, will I still be able to get the Stevie Ray Van tone out of this guitar? I hope I can sound like both! And what is a V Neck? Come to think of it, what is a C Neck? Thanks for your help. ROCK AN ROLL!!!! |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
Hey, I'm not one to talk anybody out of buying anything, but it's a
strat and it's going to sound like every other strat. Some sound great, others ok. The difference in tone between the SRV, Malmsteen, Beck and most other SIgnature strats are very, very similar. It's the feel that's going to be different. later, m |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
Hi!
Please don't order a guitar without playing it... you have to feel the instrument, take it in your hands and make it sing. From my experience as a guitarist, an amateur electric guitar maker and as a recordist, although the specs are really important, I am quite sure that SRV would still sound like SRV with Eric's guitar and Eric would still sound like Eric with SRV's guitar. In terms of specs? then I would say that the fact that this guitar does not have a rosewod fingerboard, does not have Dunlop 6100 bass-style frets, does not have specially wound pickups, does not have the lacquer stripped off and worn out, and does not have monster 013s strings gives you an idea about whether it would give you a SRV sound. Visit a shop and try 'her' out. Best of Luck, Evangelos % Evangelos Himonides IoE, University of London tel: +44 2076126599 fax: +44 2076126741 "Allas to those who never sing but die with all their music in them..." Oliver Wendell Holmes % |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
-- Somewhere in Texas, a village is missing its idiot. wrote in message ps.com... Hey, I'm not one to talk anybody out of buying anything, but it's a strat and it's going to sound like every other strat. Some sound great, others ok. The difference in tone between the SRV, Malmsteen, Beck and most other SIgnature strats are very, very similar. It's the feel that's going to be different. later, m This isn't at all true. There is a significant difference in various Strat models, has been for years. There are variations in electronics (ie pickups, tone controls, active vs. passive), hardware (bridge etc), neck design.... That said, I wouldn't buy it online. Two of the same model can differ quite a bit. Get it somewhere that you can play a bunch of them and get the one that speaks to you. |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
On 13 Feb 2005, song writer wrote in
: Thanks for your help. ROCK AN ROLL!!!! So you think that multi-posting this to EVERY music newsgroup is going to get you an answer? Here, I'll help you by forwarding it to every porn newsgroup for you. Hope that helps. |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
In article ,
song writer wrote: Although I love the Eric Johnson tones, will I still be able to get the Stevie Ray Van tone out of this guitar? I hope I can sound like both! And what is a V Neck? Come to think of it, what is a C Neck? I don't want to discourage you, but those are pretty fundamental questions for someone willing to spend so much money on so specific a guitar. If you like both EJ and SRV, you might be better off trying a few standard "off the shelf" Strat models, to get a feel for the differences. Try the latest US and Japanese standard models, then try the vintage reissues. Find out whether you prefer maple or rosewood fretboards, vintage or modern profiles. The Eric Johnson and Stevie Ray Vaughan sounds are/were the result of far more than just a guitar. SRV's Strats had bass frets, heavy strings and high action, and he plugged into a multi-amp rig. EJ has a stacked humbucker (wound for single-coil use) in the bridge position of his Strat. But the most important link in the chain is the *person* playing the guitar. EJ is not SRV, and you are neither of them. Try the EJ signature model, buy it if it makes you happy, but when you don't sound exactly like Eric, don't blame the guitar. Adrian -- __________________________________________________ ______________ http://www.spaghetti-factory.co.uk --- http://www.sfocata.co.uk For offgroup communication: sfocata squiggle yahoo ptang com |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
|
#8
|
|||
|
|||
If possible I would play the individual guitars before buying one.
Mail order guitars can be a crap shoot, so if you go that route make sure you can return it if you want to. V and C necks refer to the shape of the back of the neck, or the neck profile. The EJ guitar is basically just a nice vintage style strat. You could buy a second hand custom shop strat off of ebay for $1200, or even one of the older Japanese Tokais or Fernandes guitars. Or, put one together from parts for much cheaper than $1600... I put together strats and teles often, switching the parts around until I get the magic combination of wood and pickups. People are making excellent guitar parts nowadays and if you know what you are doing you can put together a guitar that's just as good as an old Fender. It's a bit of a hassle to do it but I've ended up with a couple of really great guitars that cost me less than $700. I sold all my vintage stuff over the last 10 years in favour of doing this and I don't regret it. Al On Sun, 13 Feb 2005 14:28:02 GMT, song writer wrote: Hello everyone, I'm thinking about purchasing the new Eric Johnson Signature Stratocaster that Fender is selling by special order. What do you experienced guitarists think are the pros and cons in such a purchase. It's selling for $1,600 on the web, however the Guitar Center said they can sell it for $1,500. Although I love the Eric Johnson tones, will I still be able to get the Stevie Ray Van tone out of this guitar? I hope I can sound like both! And what is a V Neck? Come to think of it, what is a C Neck? Thanks for your help. ROCK AN ROLL!!!! |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
song writer wrote:
And what is a V Neck? Come to think of it, what is a C Neck? Until you've figured that out just get yourself the Behringer V-Tone guitar and amp package and stand in front of the mirror while you play. With practice you could get to be half as good as Joe Cocker. -- ha |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
Mike Rivers wrote:
A C neck is optimized for playing in the key of C. A V neck is optimized for playing in the key of V. Close, Mike; the C neck has the built-in capo, and the V neck is virtual. Thanks for playing. -- ha |
#11
|
|||
|
|||
Only Eric Johnson will get Eric Johnson tones
You will get your own tones.The guitar is just set up to his preferences and with his choice of electronicsAs you know tones are produced by different combinations of equipment,but the one main place where tone is created is in the fingers of the artist.I would pick a strat off the wall of the music store and chose it that way,not because it has someones name on it.Eric is an incredible player and it has nothing to do with his choice of guitar.He would sound good on a peice of crap set up because he has "it" song writer wrote in message ... Hello everyone, I'm thinking about purchasing the new Eric Johnson Signature Stratocaster that Fender is selling by special order. What do you experienced guitarists think are the pros and cons in such a purchase. It's selling for $1,600 on the web, however the Guitar Center said they can sell it for $1,500. Although I love the Eric Johnson tones, will I still be able to get the Stevie Ray Van tone out of this guitar? I hope I can sound like both! And what is a V Neck? Come to think of it, what is a C Neck? Thanks for your help. ROCK AN ROLL!!!! |
#12
|
|||
|
|||
song writer wrote: Hello everyone, I'm thinking about purchasing the new Eric Johnson Signature Stratocaster that Fender is selling by special order. What do you experienced guitarists think are the pros and cons in such a purchase. Caution and research is urged. It's selling for $1,600 on the web, Choose a guitar like you would a girlfriend or wife. Buying a guitar on the web is like a 'mail-order-bride' however the Guitar Center said they can sell it for $1,500. Although I love the Eric Johnson tones, will I still be able to get the Stevie Ray Van tone out of this guitar? I hope I can sound like both! If Stevie was alive to hear you say that he would roll over in his grave. ;-] Eric and Stevie are/were both Hendrix affectionados so there's some Start-essence in common but their styles and use of amp/effects are quite divergent. And what is a V Neck? It's a very distinct feel with the pronounced ridge or 'spine' running down the back of the neck. Common only on the mid `50's models with maple neck and the `50's reissues as well as some of the Custom models like the Clapton. It's a very distinct feel with the pronounced ridge or 'spine' running down the back of the neck. You REALLY need to try one to make sure you like it. You should be able to find a `57 reissue to get an idea. Come to think of it, what is a C Neck? The most common neck profile, very rounded. This does not relate to fret radius, only the back of the neck. Thanks for your help. ROCK AN ROLL!!!! good luck rd |
#13
|
|||
|
|||
If you can't answer the questions you have from playing any of the guitars
you wish to consider for purchase, then don't buy any of the guitars. If you don't know from personal experience the touch and feel of a C neck vs a V neck, then whatever you buy has at least a 50/50 chance of being wrong (or of being right, but a $1500 WRONG purchase is a serious waste of time and money). If you don't know what the guitars play like, you'll never make any reasonable sounds out of them without considerable change in your approach to playing them. You will play a guitar you feel comfortable with far better than one you're not comfortable with, and that's just a fact. Getting someone else's sounds out of a guitar is about the stupidest reason to buy a guitar, particularly sight unseen. If you've got $1500 to play with, go to a reputable MI store and simply play guitars until one says quietly into your ear "Take me home, we were made for each other". Otherwise save your money because if you make purchasing decisions based on advertising or what looks pretty or might help you, you simply are going to need that money to fix some mistakes. -- Roger W. Norman SirMusic Studio "song writer" wrote in message ... Hello everyone, I'm thinking about purchasing the new Eric Johnson Signature Stratocaster that Fender is selling by special order. What do you experienced guitarists think are the pros and cons in such a purchase. It's selling for $1,600 on the web, however the Guitar Center said they can sell it for $1,500. Although I love the Eric Johnson tones, will I still be able to get the Stevie Ray Van tone out of this guitar? I hope I can sound like both! And what is a V Neck? Come to think of it, what is a C Neck? Thanks for your help. ROCK AN ROLL!!!! |
#14
|
|||
|
|||
Idiot....that's my point exactly. I realize that some, like the
Clapton have some active electronics, etc. But, basically, it's just a strat. Go to a music store that stocks a bunch and get the best playing one. You can always upgrade the pickups and put whatever you like in it. I've found a few of the Mex or Jap strats to be some of my favs as far as feel go. I've had 60s strats that felt like ass. Guys always think there's going to be some magic to a signature instrument. There's not. It's just the particular guitar that these guys got that feel/sounded right to them when they purchased it. For someone else to copy it and sell it to someone else....it's basically just a strat. That was my point. For $1600 I'd much rather look around for something that spoke to me. Later, m |
#15
|
|||
|
|||
One more thing Roger/Self proclaimed Strat expert.....
I was addressing the guy that was asking the question. If he doesn't know the difference between a neck shape, then I doubt seriously he's going to be able to tell the difference between a randomly selected group of strats....active, or passive. Those of us that have played for a while and owned many, many guitars the answer is very different. later, m |
#16
|
|||
|
|||
-- Somewhere in Texas, a village is missing its idiot. wrote in message oups.com... Idiot....that's my point exactly. I realize that some, like the Clapton have some active electronics, etc. But, basically, it's just a strat. Go to a music store that stocks a bunch and get the best playing one. You can always upgrade the pickups and put whatever you like in it. I've found a few of the Mex or Jap strats to be some of my favs as far as feel go. I've had 60s strats that felt like ass. Guys always think there's going to be some magic to a signature instrument. There's not. It's just the particular guitar that these guys got that feel/sounded right to them when they purchased it. For someone else to copy it and sell it to someone else....it's basically just a strat. That was my point. For $1600 I'd much rather look around for something that spoke to me. Later, m Idiot. Nice. I don't recall calling you names. Lets go to the tape. Quote: "it's a strat and it's going to sound like every other strat." My POINT, idiot, was that all strats DO NOT sound alike. A strat does not NECESSARILY sound like every other strat. Asspanda. Grow some social skills. |
#17
|
|||
|
|||
If you didn't I stand corrected. If you didn't, then who did type that
village idiot quote on both of your posts? Seriously Roger, do you really think the original poster is going to tell the difference between an american std that can be had for about $800 less? I'm not insulting his/her abilities, just the fact that I'm guessing they're an EJ fan and looking for tones similar. Give any decent player ANY strat with an effects rack that can mimic those sounds and he's there. Not to say that ANYONE is going to be able to get the same sound as EJ, just an approximation. But getting these tones is not dependant on the signature model. later, m |
#18
|
|||
|
|||
Not to just keep dragging this out, but I just bounced over to the
fender.com site and read the specs on this EJ sig model. It's basically a 50s model vintage reissue with a 12" radius neck. Nothing special. True it's modeled after one of EJ's main guitars...I suppose but is that worth $1600? And to Roger....how is this one going to sound much different from another 57V series? Look...I understand that EVERY guitar is different....you're talking to a guy with 40+ guitars....Les Pauls, Strats, Teles, Ricks....everything. I'm just saying that all my strats basically fall into the "strat" category. Tele's....ditto, etc. Heck, all the Fenders fall into a certain category that for most people, would probably suffice. Like, in a studio setting....."I think a single coil fender sound would be better here than a Gibson". I'm talking broad strokes....not finite details. Just trying to save the guy some money and point out that I don't think this EJ Sig guitar is really going to be $800 different than a regular american std on the wall. Maybe it will be. Maybe the one that he picks up will be magic in his hands.....the world will be in slow motion while he's strumming in the Guitar Center next to the 15 other guys blasting Metallica licks away while he's nailing that intro to Cliffs of Dover.....what am I to say....I'm the missing idiot from a village in Texas..... Why do I get baited into these things when all I'm trying to do is help a brother out..... later, m later, m |
#19
|
|||
|
|||
-- Somewhere in Texas, a village is missing its idiot. wrote in message ups.com... Not to just keep dragging this out, but I just bounced over to the fender.com site and read the specs on this EJ sig model. It's basically a 50s model vintage reissue with a 12" radius neck. Nothing special. True it's modeled after one of EJ's main guitars...I suppose but is that worth $1600? And to Roger....how is this one going to sound much different from another 57V series? Look...I understand that EVERY guitar is different....you're talking to a guy with 40+ guitars....Les Pauls, Strats, Teles, Ricks....everything. I'm just saying that all my strats basically fall into the "strat" category. Tele's....ditto, etc. Heck, all the Fenders fall into a certain category that for most people, would probably suffice. Like, in a studio setting....."I think a single coil fender sound would be better here than a Gibson". I'm talking broad strokes....not finite details. Just trying to save the guy some money and point out that I don't think this EJ Sig guitar is really going to be $800 different than a regular american std on the wall. Maybe it will be. Maybe the one that he picks up will be magic in his hands.....the world will be in slow motion while he's strumming in the Guitar Center next to the 15 other guys blasting Metallica licks away while he's nailing that intro to Cliffs of Dover.....what am I to say....I'm the missing idiot from a village in Texas..... Why do I get baited into these things when all I'm trying to do is help a brother out..... later, m later, m #1, the village idiot thing goes along with every post and wasn't aimed at you in particular, so I apologize if you took it that way. For my money, theres only one village idiot missing from Texas currently, and he's living in DC. #2 I don't know much about the EJ strat specifically. For my money, EJs tone is so effected and so processed, he could be playing an Ibanez. The only thing I was taking issue with was the specific line that every strat was going to sound like every other strat. And when I take issue with it, I'm not really thinking of the subtler variations from guitar to guitar, but differences in models. For example, I have an Ultra Plus, which has Lace Sensors. I love it to death, but its not at all the classic strat sound. It can do a nice strat -type- of sound, but its real tone falls somewhere between what one would consider a Fender sound and more Gibson type sound. Kind of like a much more nimble, less heavy handed Les Paul. I used to have a Clapton signature. It didn't sound -anything- like the Ultra, even though they both had Lace Sensors. The physical differences included different various of PUs, different bridge and nut hardware, different neck, active electronics tone boost. And /neither/ of those guitars sound anything like the vintage 60s strat I've been recording recently, which is reminiscent of the early solo Clapton sound. All that aside, you're undoubtedly correct that if the guy in question doesn't know about things like neck shapes, its probably going to matter far more that he just finds a strat he likes to play. And he probably would be better served financially to just get one of the nicer American std models. |
Reply |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
Guitar and panning | Pro Audio | |||
Help with home recording classical guitar! | Pro Audio | |||
Recording acoustic guitar and vocal | Pro Audio | |||
Another "Look-alike" Lawsuit | Pro Audio | |||
Mic Questions | Pro Audio |