Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
#1
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
I spent this weekend listening to bookshelf speakers ($180-1400). Of
course, there were variations among the speakers. However, one speaker that sounded significantly better was a JM (or was it JL) /Focal floor standing model. OK, never mind that it retails for $1900. It had a lot of detail without being "sibilant". One test I was using was whether you could hear the horns specifically while the rest of the orchestra was playing loudly, and this speaker did the best on that. I figure that if you can hear lots of details while the speaker is otherwise playing loudly, then the speaker must be pretty linear. I wonder if it is because this speaker has 3 drivers, so that the audio load is more spread out among the drivers. Thus the drivers have less excursion and don't distort as much. I don't know how many problems you take on by having another crossover, though (phase and frequency response mismatch). I guess my question is that all other factors being equal (e.g. within a speaker model line from one company), will the 3 driver model sound better/more detailed/can play orchestral music better than the 2 driver version? Or maybe a better question is whether the jump in sound quality is bigger between the 3 driver and 2 driver model, vs a 2 driver model and a slightly smaller 2 driver model. In particular, I'm thinking of Paradigm speakers, in the Monitor line. They have a mini-monitor (small bookshelf), Monitor 3 (medium bookshelf with 2 drivers) and monitor 5 (3 drivers). Will the difference in "goodness" between the Monitor 5 vs 3 be bigger than the difference btw the 3 and Mini? I have a subwoofer, so I don't care that much about how low the bass goes. I also wonder if it is often the case that a cheaper 3 driver speaker can beat a more expensive 2 driver. (e.g. paradigm monitor 5 vs Studio 20) |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
![]() |
||||
Thread | Forum | |||
Question on the Type of Wood Used in Speaker Construction and Effect on Sound | Tech | |||
Weird speaker cabling question | High End Audio | |||
Baffle step and wall speaker question | Tech | |||
Newbie Question Stereo watts per channel vs. speaker input power | Pro Audio | |||
amp speaker question | Car Audio |