Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
#121
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
From: "Roger W. Norman"
And I said this about 15 times on this thread. I found a good picture. But I'm glad to have you saying the same thing, Tom. Your electrical knowledge has been a real plus on this newsgroup. I'm a plumber. I only know enough about electricity to let the electricians do that work. Oh, and one other thing: "Always use a tester or VoM". --TP |
#122
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
Roger W. Norman wrote:
Yes there is. All water heaters have an active electrical connection because no water heater would heat water without it. Silly, that's what the gas line is for. Electricity is too expensive to waste heating water. --scott -- "C'est un Nagra. C'est suisse, et tres, tres precis." |
#123
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
Roger W. Norman wrote:
Yes there is. All water heaters have an active electrical connection because no water heater would heat water without it. Silly, that's what the gas line is for. Electricity is too expensive to waste heating water. --scott -- "C'est un Nagra. C'est suisse, et tres, tres precis." |
#124
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
Roger W. Norman wrote:
Yes there is. All water heaters have an active electrical connection because no water heater would heat water without it. I beg to differ based on experiences several years ago taking a hot shower in a pitch dark house that had been without electricity for 3 days. I developed a little ritual that involved using the flash light to get to the shower, then showering in total darkness, then turning on the flashlight again once I was done. - Logan |
#125
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
Roger W. Norman wrote:
Yes there is. All water heaters have an active electrical connection because no water heater would heat water without it. I beg to differ based on experiences several years ago taking a hot shower in a pitch dark house that had been without electricity for 3 days. I developed a little ritual that involved using the flash light to get to the shower, then showering in total darkness, then turning on the flashlight again once I was done. - Logan |
#126
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
Tom Paterson wrote:
From: Pooh Bear Over here ( UK ) the gas pipe to the heater will be copper ( as is the water too ). The gas entering my home starts off as a steel pipe though - and then is converted to copper inside the property. Never seen any examples over here of the 'orange discolouration'. Your copper gas lines must be different material from water lines (USA spec): Copper water tube is a seamless, almost pure copper material manufactured to the requirements of ASTM B 88 €“ Standard Specification for Seamless Copper Water Tube, of three basic wall thickness dimensions designated as types K, L, and M. Type K is the thickest and type M is the thinnest with type L being of intermediate thickness. All three types of tube are manufactured from copper alloy C12200 having a chemical composition of a minimum of 99.9% Copper (Cu) and Silver (Ag) combined and a maximum allowable range of Phosphorous (P) of 0.015 % - 0.040 %. This stuff, when used with flare fittings for gas connections to water heaters etc., does get orange especially where the copper was stressed to form the flare, though they might take some years to fail. Leaks in older plain soft copper connectors are "usual" (more than common); the flares are seen to be orange and/or black and crumbly upon disassembly ("hydrogen embrittlement"). Coated corrugated copper lines and all-stainless steel flexi lines (still flare ends on half union fittings) have replaced plain soft copper flare connectors, I believe at least since the 1984 Uniform Code. --TP Clearly very different to here. We use the same copper pipe for water and gas. Optionally, water may be run in plastic pipe. Don't use 'flared' joints either. Graham |
#127
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
Tom Paterson wrote:
From: Pooh Bear Over here ( UK ) the gas pipe to the heater will be copper ( as is the water too ). The gas entering my home starts off as a steel pipe though - and then is converted to copper inside the property. Never seen any examples over here of the 'orange discolouration'. Your copper gas lines must be different material from water lines (USA spec): Copper water tube is a seamless, almost pure copper material manufactured to the requirements of ASTM B 88 €“ Standard Specification for Seamless Copper Water Tube, of three basic wall thickness dimensions designated as types K, L, and M. Type K is the thickest and type M is the thinnest with type L being of intermediate thickness. All three types of tube are manufactured from copper alloy C12200 having a chemical composition of a minimum of 99.9% Copper (Cu) and Silver (Ag) combined and a maximum allowable range of Phosphorous (P) of 0.015 % - 0.040 %. This stuff, when used with flare fittings for gas connections to water heaters etc., does get orange especially where the copper was stressed to form the flare, though they might take some years to fail. Leaks in older plain soft copper connectors are "usual" (more than common); the flares are seen to be orange and/or black and crumbly upon disassembly ("hydrogen embrittlement"). Coated corrugated copper lines and all-stainless steel flexi lines (still flare ends on half union fittings) have replaced plain soft copper flare connectors, I believe at least since the 1984 Uniform Code. --TP Clearly very different to here. We use the same copper pipe for water and gas. Optionally, water may be run in plastic pipe. Don't use 'flared' joints either. Graham |
#128
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
In article ,
"Arny Krueger" wrote: I live in Nashville. Been in this house for 14 year & 3 gas water heaters. Replaced the original a few years after we moved in. Home Depot, don't remember the brand. 5 year warranty. Kept the receipt in warranty folder. 4 years, 2 mos. later it fails. HD replaces it w/GE 40 gal. Replaced it once after 3 years & am getting ready to do so again. Do you have a dielectric coupling in the system? Copper back to water meter. The only thing between meter & heater are the 2 whole house filters I mentioned. The housings are PVC. One "paper" sediment filter & one carbon activated filter for chlorine. |
#129
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
In article ,
"Arny Krueger" wrote: I live in Nashville. Been in this house for 14 year & 3 gas water heaters. Replaced the original a few years after we moved in. Home Depot, don't remember the brand. 5 year warranty. Kept the receipt in warranty folder. 4 years, 2 mos. later it fails. HD replaces it w/GE 40 gal. Replaced it once after 3 years & am getting ready to do so again. Do you have a dielectric coupling in the system? Copper back to water meter. The only thing between meter & heater are the 2 whole house filters I mentioned. The housings are PVC. One "paper" sediment filter & one carbon activated filter for chlorine. |
#131
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]() |
#132
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
"murph" wrote in message
In article , "Arny Krueger" wrote: I live in Nashville. Been in this house for 14 year & 3 gas water heaters. Replaced the original a few years after we moved in. Home Depot, don't remember the brand. 5 year warranty. Kept the receipt in warranty folder. 4 years, 2 mos. later it fails. HD replaces it w/GE 40 gal. Replaced it once after 3 years & am getting ready to do so again. Do you have a dielectric coupling in the system? Copper back to water meter. The only thing between meter & heater are the 2 whole house filters I mentioned. The housings are PVC. One "paper" sediment filter & one carbon activated filter for chlorine. The filter bodies are good dielectric isolators, but they are supposed to be used only on the cold side of the water heater. You might want to put a dielectric isolator into the piping on the hot side of the heater. |
#133
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
"murph" wrote in message
In article , "Arny Krueger" wrote: I live in Nashville. Been in this house for 14 year & 3 gas water heaters. Replaced the original a few years after we moved in. Home Depot, don't remember the brand. 5 year warranty. Kept the receipt in warranty folder. 4 years, 2 mos. later it fails. HD replaces it w/GE 40 gal. Replaced it once after 3 years & am getting ready to do so again. Do you have a dielectric coupling in the system? Copper back to water meter. The only thing between meter & heater are the 2 whole house filters I mentioned. The housings are PVC. One "paper" sediment filter & one carbon activated filter for chlorine. The filter bodies are good dielectric isolators, but they are supposed to be used only on the cold side of the water heater. You might want to put a dielectric isolator into the piping on the hot side of the heater. |
#134
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
"Roger W. Norman" wrote in message
Yes there is. All water heaters have an active electrical connection because no water heater would heat water without it. You never heard of gas water heaters? |
#135
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
"Roger W. Norman" wrote in message
Yes there is. All water heaters have an active electrical connection because no water heater would heat water without it. You never heard of gas water heaters? |
#136
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]() |
#137
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]() |
#138
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
"Mike Rivers" wrote in message
news:znr1100735378k@trad In article writes: Yes there is. All water heaters have an active electrical connection because no water heater would heat water without it. My gas water heater has no electrical connection to the outside world. Any electricity involved with its operation is self-generated. There's a temperature sensor (it's call a thermocouple in the book, but I've never taken one apart) that holds the pilot valve open that I think may be electrical, or maybe it's just a heat pipe. I've taken them apart. They indeed are based on a bimetalic thermocouple or thermocouple stack (thermopile). They activate a sensitive solenoid that operates the gas valve. http://hearth.com/what/gas/howgasworks.html |
#139
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
"Mike Rivers" wrote in message
news:znr1100735378k@trad In article writes: Yes there is. All water heaters have an active electrical connection because no water heater would heat water without it. My gas water heater has no electrical connection to the outside world. Any electricity involved with its operation is self-generated. There's a temperature sensor (it's call a thermocouple in the book, but I've never taken one apart) that holds the pilot valve open that I think may be electrical, or maybe it's just a heat pipe. I've taken them apart. They indeed are based on a bimetalic thermocouple or thermocouple stack (thermopile). They activate a sensitive solenoid that operates the gas valve. http://hearth.com/what/gas/howgasworks.html |
#140
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
Carlos Alden wrote:
Our hot water radiator heating system is actually gas-fired, but depends too much on electricity to make it run and respond to the thermostat. I was unable to bypass the system to light it. Chakaal's boiler uses electricity for control, but also to run two little quarter-horsepower circulating pumps. Which makes you think that it is just 400W or so until you realize how nasty a load the motors are. I suspect it will probably run off a 1KW inverter in a pinch although I haven't tried it. My gas furnace has a 1 HP blower motor, which is way too much to deal with on an inverter. And I donated my generator to a bunch of WWII re-enactors... --scott -- "C'est un Nagra. C'est suisse, et tres, tres precis." |
#141
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
Carlos Alden wrote:
Our hot water radiator heating system is actually gas-fired, but depends too much on electricity to make it run and respond to the thermostat. I was unable to bypass the system to light it. Chakaal's boiler uses electricity for control, but also to run two little quarter-horsepower circulating pumps. Which makes you think that it is just 400W or so until you realize how nasty a load the motors are. I suspect it will probably run off a 1KW inverter in a pinch although I haven't tried it. My gas furnace has a 1 HP blower motor, which is way too much to deal with on an inverter. And I donated my generator to a bunch of WWII re-enactors... --scott -- "C'est un Nagra. C'est suisse, et tres, tres precis." |
#142
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
Arny Krueger wrote:
"murph" wrote in message In article , "Arny Krueger" wrote: I live in Nashville. Been in this house for 14 year & 3 gas water heaters. Replaced the original a few years after we moved in. Home Depot, don't remember the brand. 5 year warranty. Kept the receipt in warranty folder. 4 years, 2 mos. later it fails. HD replaces it w/GE 40 gal. Replaced it once after 3 years & am getting ready to do so again. Do you have a dielectric coupling in the system? Copper back to water meter. The only thing between meter & heater are the 2 whole house filters I mentioned. The housings are PVC. One "paper" sediment filter & one carbon activated filter for chlorine. The filter bodies are good dielectric isolators, but they are supposed to be used only on the cold side of the water heater. You might want to put a dielectric isolator into the piping on the hot side of the heater. Heating water in the USA sounds *astonishingly* complicated ! Graham |
#143
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
Arny Krueger wrote:
"murph" wrote in message In article , "Arny Krueger" wrote: I live in Nashville. Been in this house for 14 year & 3 gas water heaters. Replaced the original a few years after we moved in. Home Depot, don't remember the brand. 5 year warranty. Kept the receipt in warranty folder. 4 years, 2 mos. later it fails. HD replaces it w/GE 40 gal. Replaced it once after 3 years & am getting ready to do so again. Do you have a dielectric coupling in the system? Copper back to water meter. The only thing between meter & heater are the 2 whole house filters I mentioned. The housings are PVC. One "paper" sediment filter & one carbon activated filter for chlorine. The filter bodies are good dielectric isolators, but they are supposed to be used only on the cold side of the water heater. You might want to put a dielectric isolator into the piping on the hot side of the heater. Heating water in the USA sounds *astonishingly* complicated ! Graham |
#144
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
Arny Krueger wrote:
"Mike Rivers" wrote in message news:znr1100735378k@trad In article writes: Yes there is. All water heaters have an active electrical connection because no water heater would heat water without it. My gas water heater has no electrical connection to the outside world. Any electricity involved with its operation is self-generated. There's a temperature sensor (it's call a thermocouple in the book, but I've never taken one apart) that holds the pilot valve open that I think may be electrical, or maybe it's just a heat pipe. I've taken them apart. They indeed are based on a bimetalic thermocouple or thermocouple stack (thermopile). They activate a sensitive solenoid that operates the gas valve. http://hearth.com/what/gas/howgasworks.html Now *that* actually sounds not dissimilar to my old gas water heater. It opens the main burners automatically on demand for hot water. Graham |
#145
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
Arny Krueger wrote:
"Mike Rivers" wrote in message news:znr1100735378k@trad In article writes: Yes there is. All water heaters have an active electrical connection because no water heater would heat water without it. My gas water heater has no electrical connection to the outside world. Any electricity involved with its operation is self-generated. There's a temperature sensor (it's call a thermocouple in the book, but I've never taken one apart) that holds the pilot valve open that I think may be electrical, or maybe it's just a heat pipe. I've taken them apart. They indeed are based on a bimetalic thermocouple or thermocouple stack (thermopile). They activate a sensitive solenoid that operates the gas valve. http://hearth.com/what/gas/howgasworks.html Now *that* actually sounds not dissimilar to my old gas water heater. It opens the main burners automatically on demand for hot water. Graham |
#146
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
?? either you sent that one too quick or i'm missing something -- most
of the heaters here in st louis are nat gas. chris deckard saint louis mo "Roger W. Norman" wrote in message ... Yes there is. All water heaters have an active electrical connection because no water heater would heat water without it. -- |
#147
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
?? either you sent that one too quick or i'm missing something -- most
of the heaters here in st louis are nat gas. chris deckard saint louis mo "Roger W. Norman" wrote in message ... Yes there is. All water heaters have an active electrical connection because no water heater would heat water without it. -- |
#148
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
In article ,
"Arny Krueger" wrote: Copper back to water meter. The only thing between meter & heater are the 2 whole house filters I mentioned. The housings are PVC. One "paper" sediment filter & one carbon activated filter for chlorine. The filter bodies are good dielectric isolators, but they are supposed to be used only on the cold side of the water heater. You might want to put a dielectric isolator into the piping on the hot side of the heater. You might have misunderstood me. They are on the inlet side of the tank. In from street, hits 2 filters, then the heater. The reason I started using the whole house filters originally was the taste (heavy chlorine). So I decided to add the extra sediment filter before the carbon. I've wondered if the filters could somehow be compunding the problem, but I will never understand the science...Anyway, this has been a very interesting thread. |
#149
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
In article ,
"Arny Krueger" wrote: Copper back to water meter. The only thing between meter & heater are the 2 whole house filters I mentioned. The housings are PVC. One "paper" sediment filter & one carbon activated filter for chlorine. The filter bodies are good dielectric isolators, but they are supposed to be used only on the cold side of the water heater. You might want to put a dielectric isolator into the piping on the hot side of the heater. You might have misunderstood me. They are on the inlet side of the tank. In from street, hits 2 filters, then the heater. The reason I started using the whole house filters originally was the taste (heavy chlorine). So I decided to add the extra sediment filter before the carbon. I've wondered if the filters could somehow be compunding the problem, but I will never understand the science...Anyway, this has been a very interesting thread. |
#150
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]() Arny Krueger wrote: "Roger W. Norman" wrote in message Yes there is. All water heaters have an active electrical connection because no water heater would heat water without it. You never heard of gas water heaters? There are gas powered water heaters that use no external electricity. The tiny amount of power needed to operate the thermostat is provided by a thermocouple heated by the pilot light. Newer ones actually have a small generator in the water flow, and only turn on when the water is running. --Dale |
#151
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]() Arny Krueger wrote: "Roger W. Norman" wrote in message Yes there is. All water heaters have an active electrical connection because no water heater would heat water without it. You never heard of gas water heaters? There are gas powered water heaters that use no external electricity. The tiny amount of power needed to operate the thermostat is provided by a thermocouple heated by the pilot light. Newer ones actually have a small generator in the water flow, and only turn on when the water is running. --Dale |
#152
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
From: Pooh Bear
[thermocouples, gas WH] Now *that* actually sounds not dissimilar to my old gas water heater. It opens the main burners automatically on demand for hot water. The thermostat has a sensor in the tank. When the water temp falls below the setting, the "main" valve opens, allowing gas to flow to the burner. The pilot flame lights the burner, which runs until the set temp is reached again. The pilot flame thermocouple "safety loop" is there so that the burner lights off instead of an unlit pilot allowing the passing unburned nat. gas into the room (ka-boom). There's an "ECO" cutoff in the probe, too, which will shut off the gas if it gets too hot. Along with the T&P valve, the object is to prevent "runaway" (stuck on) burners from running the temp up until the tank ruptures. Steam explosion, no good. Water heaters flying like rocketships, I've seen it in "plumber training films". --TP |
#153
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
From: Pooh Bear
[thermocouples, gas WH] Now *that* actually sounds not dissimilar to my old gas water heater. It opens the main burners automatically on demand for hot water. The thermostat has a sensor in the tank. When the water temp falls below the setting, the "main" valve opens, allowing gas to flow to the burner. The pilot flame lights the burner, which runs until the set temp is reached again. The pilot flame thermocouple "safety loop" is there so that the burner lights off instead of an unlit pilot allowing the passing unburned nat. gas into the room (ka-boom). There's an "ECO" cutoff in the probe, too, which will shut off the gas if it gets too hot. Along with the T&P valve, the object is to prevent "runaway" (stuck on) burners from running the temp up until the tank ruptures. Steam explosion, no good. Water heaters flying like rocketships, I've seen it in "plumber training films". --TP |
#154
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
"murph" wrote in message
In article , "Arny Krueger" wrote: Copper back to water meter. The only thing between meter & heater are the 2 whole house filters I mentioned. The housings are PVC. One "paper" sediment filter & one carbon activated filter for chlorine. The filter bodies are good dielectric isolators, but they are supposed to be used only on the cold side of the water heater. You might want to put a dielectric isolator into the piping on the hot side of the heater. You might have misunderstood me. They are on the inlet side of the tank. In from street, hits 2 filters, then the heater. I've got that. The reason I started using the whole house filters originally was the taste (heavy chlorine). So I decided to add the extra sediment filter before the carbon. I've wondered if the filters could somehow be compunding the problem, but I will never understand the science... Your use of filters is just fine. However, there still might be a benefit to adding a dielectric coupling on the output side of the hot water heater. Anyway, this has been a very interesting thread. |
#155
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
"murph" wrote in message
In article , "Arny Krueger" wrote: Copper back to water meter. The only thing between meter & heater are the 2 whole house filters I mentioned. The housings are PVC. One "paper" sediment filter & one carbon activated filter for chlorine. The filter bodies are good dielectric isolators, but they are supposed to be used only on the cold side of the water heater. You might want to put a dielectric isolator into the piping on the hot side of the heater. You might have misunderstood me. They are on the inlet side of the tank. In from street, hits 2 filters, then the heater. I've got that. The reason I started using the whole house filters originally was the taste (heavy chlorine). So I decided to add the extra sediment filter before the carbon. I've wondered if the filters could somehow be compunding the problem, but I will never understand the science... Your use of filters is just fine. However, there still might be a benefit to adding a dielectric coupling on the output side of the hot water heater. Anyway, this has been a very interesting thread. |
#156
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
"Dale Farmer" wrote in message
Arny Krueger wrote: "Roger W. Norman" wrote in message Yes there is. All water heaters have an active electrical connection because no water heater would heat water without it. You never heard of gas water heaters? There are gas powered water heaters that use no external electricity. The tiny amount of power needed to operate the thermostat is provided by a thermocouple heated by the pilot light. Newer ones actually have a small generator in the water flow, and only turn on when the water is running. Agreed. |
#157
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
"Dale Farmer" wrote in message
Arny Krueger wrote: "Roger W. Norman" wrote in message Yes there is. All water heaters have an active electrical connection because no water heater would heat water without it. You never heard of gas water heaters? There are gas powered water heaters that use no external electricity. The tiny amount of power needed to operate the thermostat is provided by a thermocouple heated by the pilot light. Newer ones actually have a small generator in the water flow, and only turn on when the water is running. Agreed. |
#158
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]() |
#159
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]() |
#160
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]() |
Reply |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|