Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
|
#1
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
I need to come up with a reasonable way to record our Church services and
distribute the recordings to members who are sick, etc. Our current system is simply cassette tapes, but this format is getting on a bit. Output of the mixer is analogue. My current thoughts are a minidisc recorder such as Sony's HiMD range or otherwise an iRiver H320 or similar, which can be taken home and plugged into a PC (preferably digitally so that its faster than realtime). The resulting MP3 can then be saved onto a CD for playback in a discman style CD player with MP3 capability, car stereo, or home stereo. It would also be possible then to save the MP3 onto other playback formats. The copying would be done by a volunteer who is not necesarily highly computyer literate so it needs to be a relatively simple process. Since church services are generally slightly longer than the length of a CD, normal CD recording is not an option. I have thought about DVD (audio only) but figured portable DVD players are not quite ready for the average church member (too expensive, not enough options). Thanks for any responses Eric |
#2
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
Since your programs are longer than 80 minutes CD's, I buy a used desktop
computer for $100, put a good sound card in it and record to hard disk. Burn your MP3 CD from there and skip the MD. A computer with a single application installed will be reliable enough. |
#3
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
Hi Carey,
Thanks for your reply, I would like the copying to be done at home after the service, since that suits our situation better. The volunteer can then organise the copies during the week and distributes them as required. Hence a requirement for some form of portable method which is easy to take home. However a laptop may possibly do it, although a smaller format is preferable. Eric "Carey Carlan" wrote in message . 191... Since your programs are longer than 80 minutes CD's, I buy a used desktop computer for $100, put a good sound card in it and record to hard disk. Burn your MP3 CD from there and skip the MD. A computer with a single application installed will be reliable enough. |
#4
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
Eric wrote:
I would like the copying to be done at home after the service, since that suits our situation better. The volunteer can then organise the copies during the week and distributes them as required. Hence a requirement for some form of portable method which is easy to take home. If you compress the wav file losslessly using freebie software such as WavPack, AudioZip, Monkey, RKAU and FLAC as described in more detail at: http://www.firstpr.com.au/audiocomp/lossless/ It will then easily fit on a CD-R or CD-RW for the trip home. You can also load the .wav file onto a USB flash drive, which are now well under $100 for up to 1 GB. Or, you can burn the oversided file onto a DVD-R or DVD-RW - the burners and media is pretty cheap, now. I've reused a DVD-RW over 90 times with no apparent loss of data integrity, so this has to be another very cost-effective solution for moving data around. If your services go only slightly over 80 minutes there's usually enough dead air, or other useless stuff that you can easily edit out, so that your final product is under 80 minutes. |
#5
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
Eric wrote:
Since church services are generally slightly longer than the length of a CD, normal CD recording is not an option. I have thought about DVD (audio only) but figured portable DVD players are not quite ready for the average church member (too expensive, not enough options). How much longer than 80 minutes are your services? Is there anything you can edit out to make it fit on the CD? I would think it would be well worth it if you could cut out a 5 minute hymn in order to get the entire service on one disc. I think you will have problems with burning MP3 files to disc. I would be willing to bet that many of those who will be receiving the discs won't have a CD player capable of playing MP3 files. I know I don't. -- Eric Practice Your Mixing Skills www.Raw-Tracks.com www.Mad-Host.com |
#6
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
"EricK" wrote in message
... How much longer than 80 minutes are your services? Is there anything you can edit out to make it fit on the CD? I would think it would be well worth it if you could cut out a 5 minute hymn in order to get the entire service on one disc. I don't believe you can include hymns that are copyrighted without paying a few so cutting them out will probably solve the size problem (but obviously aggravate those who enjoy the songs). |
#7
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
Ricky Hunt wrote:
I don't believe you can include hymns that are copyrighted without paying a few so cutting them out will probably solve the size problem (but obviously aggravate those who enjoy the songs). You could be right, but it depends on the hymns. If they are traditional, their copyright could well be expired. When I was a kid I used to run copies of the service for my church. We always included the hymns. -- Eric Practice Your Mixing Skills www.Raw-Tracks.com www.Mad-Host.com |
#8
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
Just read further down the thread, looks like the copyright discussion
is already taking place. -- Eric Practice Your Mixing Skills www.Raw-Tracks.com www.Mad-Host.com |
#9
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
"Eric" wrote [from au]...
My current thoughts are a minidisc recorder such as Sony's HiMD range or otherwise an iRiver H320 or similar, which can be taken home and plugged into a PC (preferably digitally so that its faster than realtime). I would record directly to computer. No fooling around with intermediate media, conversion, etc. etc. If you can get a "waterfalled" old computer from a member next time they upgrade, it will be sufficient for this kind of recording. The resulting MP3 can then be saved onto a CD for playback in a discman style CD player with MP3 capability, car stereo, or home stereo. This sounds really dubious. Have you done a census of the "customers" to see what kind of playback facilities they have? Unless you have a very unusual population, the chances of your parishoners having MP3 on CD playback capability I'd wager is pretty unlikely. Since church services are generally slightly longer than the length of a CD, normal CD recording is not an option. Are you including music? Or is just the spoken part longer than 80 minutes? Are you paying license fees to distribute recordings of the music? I have thought about DVD (audio only) but figured portable DVD players are not quite ready for the average church member (too expensive, not enough options). I would think that MP3 on CD is no more likely than DVD. In fact DVD players (like those "throw-away" ones from China) are really cheap and frequently they play MP3 on CD. I'd consider some judicious editing. I've never seen a religious service that didn't have a bit of time that could be cut out without materially affecting the message, etc. |
#10
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]() "Richard Crowley" wrote in message ... Are you including music? Or is just the spoken part longer than 80 minutes? Are you paying license fees to distribute recordings of the music? License fees for church hymns??? I record our services all the time for the same reasons the OP is , I never thought about License fees. .! Ed |
#11
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
Edward Bridge wrote:
"Richard Crowley" wrote in message ... Are you including music? Or is just the spoken part longer than 80 minutes? Are you paying license fees to distribute recordings of the music? License fees for church hymns??? I record our services all the time for the same reasons the OP is , I never thought about License fees. .! Please see http://www.ccli.com/ This covers licensed materials in hymnals. I seem to recall that a standard CCLI license allows you to make and sell enough CDs to cover a reasonable percentage of the service's attendance. |
#12
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
"Edward Bridge" wrote ...
"Richard Crowley" wrote ... Are you including music? Or is just the spoken part longer than 80 minutes? Are you paying license fees to distribute recordings of the music? License fees for church hymns??? I record our services all the time for the same reasons the OP is , I never thought about License fees. .! Check your hymnal for copyright notices. I've never seen a hymnal that didn't have at least 90% of the songs still under copyright protection. Distributing recordings requires separate licensing than live performance (which generally is exempt for churches and schools in the USA). Even projecting lyrics on a screen or distributing hard-copy requires separate licensing. You paid for the licenses for the hymnal copies as part of the hymnal purchase price. There is an organization for copyright clearances for churches: www.ccli.com You should certainly at least have a working knowledge of this in order to be legal (not to mention ethical). |
#13
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
Won't some church somewhere please challenge some of these provisions in
court. I find it insane that a church that has paid for copyright for the songs in their hymnbooks supposedly doesn't have the right to transmit the service in digital form to members who are absent due to sickness or frailty. Listen folks-- it would be a thing of beauty. Get the press involved. Select a frail, ill older member, and hold a press conference and explain how she is not entitled to hear the music at her church service because of the unreasonable claims of the copyright holder. Maybe an enlightened member of congress might even pause from stuffing his pockets with cash from lobbiests and Recording and Film organizations to take part. Announced that you are going to proceed to include the hymns on your recordings of the service and you invite the copyright owners to take action if they really want to. Please, somebody do it... Richard Crowley wrote: "Edward Bridge" wrote ... "Richard Crowley" wrote ... Are you including music? Or is just the spoken part longer than 80 minutes? Are you paying license fees to distribute recordings of the music? License fees for church hymns??? I record our services all the time for the same reasons the OP is , I never thought about License fees. .! Check your hymnal for copyright notices. I've never seen a hymnal that didn't have at least 90% of the songs still under copyright protection. Distributing recordings requires separate licensing than live performance (which generally is exempt for churches and schools in the USA). Even projecting lyrics on a screen or distributing hard-copy requires separate licensing. You paid for the licenses for the hymnal copies as part of the hymnal purchase price. There is an organization for copyright clearances for churches: www.ccli.com You should certainly at least have a working knowledge of this in order to be legal (not to mention ethical). |
#14
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
"Bill Van Dyk" wrote in ...
Won't some church somewhere please challenge some of these provisions in court. I find it insane that a church that has paid for copyright for the songs in their hymnbooks supposedly doesn't have the right to transmit the service in digital form to members who are absent due to sickness or frailty. Listen folks-- it would be a thing of beauty. Get the press involved. Select a frail, ill older member, and hold a press conference and explain how she is not entitled to hear the music at her church service because of the unreasonable claims of the copyright holder. Maybe an enlightened member of congress might even pause from stuffing his pockets with cash from lobbiests and Recording and Film organizations to take part. Announced that you are going to proceed to include the hymns on your recordings of the service and you invite the copyright owners to take action if they really want to. Please, somebody do it... You don't even know any composers, do you? |
#15
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
Bill Van Dyk wrote:
Listen folks-- it would be a thing of beauty. Get the press involved. Select a frail, ill older member, and hold a press conference and explain how she is not entitled to hear the music at her church service because of the unreasonable claims of the copyright holder. If 7 cents a song is unreasonable, I'll chip in... and I'm a Buddhist! |
#16
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]() |
#17
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
In article . net,
Edward Bridge wrote: License fees for church hymns??? Well, there are traditional churches that play no music more recent that Thomas Tallis or J.S. Bach, and then there are churches that play contemporary music which is certainly in copyright. And even the first case can have issues, such as when you have performance royalties for specific orchestral and choral arrangements. Will ASCAP come after your church with litigation? If so, will your deity smite them? (That would get me to start going to church, you betcha.) |
#18
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
I worked as head engineer at a church for 8 years, in this type of
situation, license fees do not apply, we contacted the copyright holder and unless you are trying to make a profit, you don't have to pay fees. That is just what i know. And as for the recording process, if you are recording stereo, cd's are probably the best bet, just use one for praise&worship and one for the sermon. For editing on a budget, check out Sony's Sound Forge Audio Studio, with a price of $69 bucks its a good deal, and easy to use. i have been using sound forge since version 3.5 and am now on version 8. So for pc editing its one of you're best bets. You can than do cuts and edits of the 2 cd's down. I know it works, i did it for 8 years and have LOTS of master cd's. You can pick up a used tascam cd recorder pretty cheap, or new ones are getting cheaper by the day. Eric if you still want some sugestions feel free to email me at jonATwwaite.tv(just replace AT with @) hope this gives you some more help. Jon Waite JB Productions Edward Bridge wrote: "Richard Crowley" wrote in message ... Are you including music? Or is just the spoken part longer than 80 minutes? Are you paying license fees to distribute recordings of the music? License fees for church hymns??? I record our services all the time for the same reasons the OP is , I never thought about License fees. .! Ed |
#19
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
"Jon" wrote ...
I worked as head engineer at a church for 8 years, in this type of situation, license fees do not apply, In the USA, license/permission ALWAYS applies for mechanical (audio) and sync (video) rights to distribute copies. Makes no difference whether you are selling copies or giving them away. Also makes no difference whether the organization is for-profit or non-profit, government, school, religious institution, etc. we contacted the copyright holder and unless you are trying to make a profit, you don't have to pay fees. That was the decision of that particular copyright holder. And very charitable of them. They are free to charge whatever they wish including zero. Extrapolating that single data point to a blanket statement is incorrect and misleading. |
#20
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]() In article jon@waite writes: I worked as head engineer at a church for 8 years, in this type of situation, license fees do not apply, we contacted the copyright holder and unless you are trying to make a profit, you don't have to pay fees. That is just what i know. You know it for your hymnal's publisher. They're not all the same. In general, profit doesn't have anything to do with copyright, but the copyright owner can, if he chooses, give you a license at no cost for a non-profit project. -- I'm really Mike Rivers ) However, until the spam goes away or Hell freezes over, lots of IP addresses are blocked from this system. If you e-mail me and it bounces, use your secret decoder ring and reach me he double-m-eleven-double-zero at yahoo |
#21
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
In article znr1113613193k@trad, Mike Rivers wrote:
In article jon@waite writes: I worked as head engineer at a church for 8 years, in this type of situation, license fees do not apply, we contacted the copyright holder and unless you are trying to make a profit, you don't have to pay fees. That is just what i know. You know it for your hymnal's publisher. They're not all the same. In general, profit doesn't have anything to do with copyright, but the copyright owner can, if he chooses, give you a license at no cost for a non-profit project. Profit is not a necessary element for copyright infringement. If it were that simple, the barter system would create a defense, and the whole issue with file sharing would simply go away. |
#22
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
Eric wrote:
Since church services are generally slightly longer than the length of a CD, normal CD recording is not an option. I have thought about DVD (audio only) but figured portable DVD players are not quite ready for the average church member (too expensive, not enough options). You can't swap CDs during the offertory or something? If you record on CD-R, you can load the recording up into a workstation almost instantly, make a few quick cuts, and dump it to a distribution disk almost instantly. If you record on MD, you have to load it up in realtime. --scott -- "C'est un Nagra. C'est suisse, et tres, tres precis." |
#23
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
Thanks to Scott, Richard, EricK and Carey for your quick replies.
Youv'e given me a fair bit of food for thought, I'll take that away and have a good think about it all and get back to you all later if necessary. I'll probably do that in a new thread. However, if anyone wants to put in more thoughts feel free to add to this thread as I'll be monitoring it regularly anyway. Thanks again Eric "Scott Dorsey" wrote in message ... Eric wrote: Since church services are generally slightly longer than the length of a CD, normal CD recording is not an option. I have thought about DVD (audio only) but figured portable DVD players are not quite ready for the average church member (too expensive, not enough options). You can't swap CDs during the offertory or something? If you record on CD-R, you can load the recording up into a workstation almost instantly, make a few quick cuts, and dump it to a distribution disk almost instantly. If you record on MD, you have to load it up in realtime. --scott -- "C'est un Nagra. C'est suisse, et tres, tres precis." |
#24
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
I started doing this about 9 months ago for our Church, when we
received a request to have MP3 downloads available on the web site. We were already doing cassette tape recording/duplication. We record the services using a laptop computer using the Audacity software, which is a free download. The services are typically about 75-90 minutes long. I take the laptop home and use Audacity to copy the track and edit it down to 80 minutes (actually about 79:30) or less so that it can be burned to CD. I then copy the track again and edit it so only the spoken parts of the service remain, and create an MP3 file. The MP3 file is highly compressed so that it does not take too long to download. The only real problem with this is that the computer has to be there every Sunday to record the service, which means it does not happen if I am not there. We are looking at getting a digital recorder that uses Compact Flash media instead of the computer for recording. The editing would still be done on a computer. -Ewan |
#26
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
In article ,
"Eric" wrote: I need to come up with a reasonable way to record our Church services and distribute the recordings to members who are sick, etc. Our current system is simply cassette tapes, but this format is getting on a bit. Snip Since church services are generally slightly longer than the length of a CD, normal CD recording is not an option. I have thought about DVD (audio only) but figured portable DVD players are not quite ready for the average church member (too expensive, not enough options). Get in line for an Edirol R1. With a cheap 512mb card or two at 320mb MP3 compression you can record for about 3 hours. Take the CF card into a PC or Mac, simple editing, throw some track ID's in, burn, distribute and archive. Note that the R1 is backordered to the moon - demand far outstrips supply. We are just now seeing December orders being filled-I got 20% of my order. Product dribbles in, no one has stock and everyone is backordered. I do have one here on my desk, however..... Here is a possible alternative: http://tinyurl.com/6dnsh They are also backordered but only into late April but it may be more machine than you need. We are dealers and you can get in our line if you'd like. -- Regards, Klay Anderson http://www.klay.com +801-942-8346 |
#27
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
In article ,
Klay Anderson wrote: We are dealers and you can get in our line if you'd like. I'm interested in this, but if I buy one, I'd have to have it by May 15 or else I'd have to back out. I take it you don't have sufficient assurance from the vendor to make committments like that? I was entertaining the idea of pre-ordering one of these through Zzounds ($440) but I hesitate for this reason. |
#28
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]() |
#29
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
I need to come up with a reasonable way to record our Church services
and distribute the recordings to members who are sick, etc. Our current system is simply cassette tapes, but this format is getting on a bit. Output of the mixer is analogue. Sounds like it's tailor made for Pro Tools Free and some church member's old computer. Phil Brown |
#30
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
Hi Eric,
I need to come up with a reasonable way to record our Church services and distribute the recordings to members who are sick, etc. Our current system is simply cassette tapes, but this format is getting on a bit. Output of the mixer is analogue. My current thoughts are a minidisc recorder such as Sony's HiMD range or otherwise an iRiver H320 or similar, you could use a Marantz Professional PMD660 (~650 EUR) (http://www.d-mpro.eu.com/users/folde...4&SubCatID=143) to record the service onto a regular Compact Flash card, read it into the computer through a normal CF-USB-interface (cheap) and - if needed - trim the recording so that it fits on a regular CD. Best regards, Dieter Michel |
#31
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
Eric,
Another possibility is the Core Sound PDAudio. This is a digital audio capture device which is hosted in a pocket pc. You can get a little AD converter from Radio Shack (under $20) which converts line level from your pa/mixer to the S/PDIF digital source required by PDAudio. It should be very suitable for your purpose but will limit the sampling to 44.1kHz and 16-bit. PDAudio is capable of 24-bit recording. In addition...here is what you would need. pocket pc (H2215 $349 or rx2750 $549) one that has both CF and SD slots PDAudio ($199) SD memory (1gb costs about $70) recording software ($50) Key points - this system is immediately available. !!! - recorded data is highly mobile. Take it home on SD and read with a card reader into your desktop or laptop system. - your recorder is also very lightweight and portable. - the software supports changing media while recording, but a 1gb SD will last 3 hours at 16/44.1 - you could probably fit 2 services on a single 1gb SD. That could be handy if you couldn't transfer it right away. - the system is upgradeable. Using a portable micpre/converter and some mics you could make some very nice 24-bit ambient recordings, choir, music programs, etc. For details see the Core Sound website. http://www.core-sound.com Gordon Gidluck http://www.gidluckmastering.com/live2496.html Eric wrote: I need to come up with a reasonable way to record our Church services and distribute the recordings to members who are sick, etc. Our current system is simply cassette tapes, but this format is getting on a bit. Output of the mixer is analogue. My current thoughts are a minidisc recorder such as Sony's HiMD range or otherwise an iRiver H320 or similar, which can be taken home and plugged into a PC (preferably digitally so that its faster than realtime). The resulting MP3 can then be saved onto a CD for playback in a discman style CD player with MP3 capability, car stereo, or home stereo. It would also be possible then to save the MP3 onto other playback formats. The copying would be done by a volunteer who is not necesarily highly computyer literate so it needs to be a relatively simple process. Since church services are generally slightly longer than the length of a CD, normal CD recording is not an option. I have thought about DVD (audio only) but figured portable DVD players are not quite ready for the average church member (too expensive, not enough options). Thanks for any responses Eric |
#32
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
"Gordon Gidluck" wrote in message
... - the software supports changing media while recording, but a 1gb SD will last 3 hours at 16/44.1 Only in mono. In stereo you get about 90 minutes per gigabyte at 16/44. Peace, Paul |
#33
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
Paul,
Thanks for catching that. Hands were not typing what head was thinking. ;-) Gordon Paul Stamler wrote: "Gordon Gidluck" wrote in message ... - the software supports changing media while recording, but a 1gb SD will last 3 hours at 16/44.1 Only in mono. In stereo you get about 90 minutes per gigabyte at 16/44. Peace, Paul |
#34
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
Another possibility is the Core Sound PDAudio. This is a
digital audio capture device which is hosted in a pocket pc. You can get a little AD converter from Radio Shack (under $20) which converts line level from your pa/mixer to the S/PDIF digital source required by PDAudio. It should be very suitable for your purpose but will limit the sampling to 44.1kHz and 16-bit. PDAudio is capable of 24-bit recording. In addition...here is what you would need. pocket pc (H2215 $349 or rx2750 $549) one that has both CF and SD slots PDAudio ($199) SD memory (1gb costs about $70) recording software ($50) For a total cost the better part of a kilobuck. Not to mention the vulnerability of such high-value pocketable stuff. Plus the cost of interface for the SD card at the other end. Remembering that this is a low-budget, FIXED application, the slowest hand-me-down computer running free software would capture (and edit) 16x44K WAV directly to HD. New CD-RW drives are down to $30 in my neighborhood shop if the compute doesn't have one already. Total cost : $50 and possibly zero. |
#35
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
Gordon Gidluck wrote:
You can get a little AD converter from Radio Shack (under $20) which converts line level from your pa/mixer to the S/PDIF digital source required by PDAudio. It should be very suitable for your purpose but will limit the sampling to 44.1kHz and 16-bit. PDAudio is capable of 24-bit recording. Can you provide a RS part number or URL on their web site for this product? |
#36
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
Arny,
It's 15-1242. They call it a signal converter. Typical use is audio and video. The price is right for a cheap digitizer. http://www.radioshack.com/product.as...t%5Fid=15-1242 Gordon Arny Krueger wrote: Gordon Gidluck wrote: You can get a little AD converter from Radio Shack (under $20) which converts line level from your pa/mixer to the S/PDIF digital source required by PDAudio. It should be very suitable for your purpose but will limit the sampling to 44.1kHz and 16-bit. PDAudio is capable of 24-bit recording. Can you provide a RS part number or URL on their web site for this product? |
#37
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
Gordon Gidluck wrote:
Arny, It's 15-1242. They call it a signal converter. Typical use is audio and video. The price is right for a cheap digitizer. http://www.radioshack.com/product.as...t%5Fid=15-1242 Hmmm, I'll have to take a closer look, on the test bench. |
#38
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]() |
#39
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
Arny,
It's 15-1242. They call it a signal converter. Typical use is audio and video. The price is right for a cheap digitizer. http://www.radioshack.com/product.as...t%5Fid=15-1242 Gordon Arny Krueger wrote: Gordon Gidluck wrote: You can get a little AD converter from Radio Shack (under $20) which converts line level from your pa/mixer to the S/PDIF digital source required by PDAudio. It should be very suitable for your purpose but will limit the sampling to 44.1kHz and 16-bit. PDAudio is capable of 24-bit recording. Can you provide a RS part number or URL on their web site for this product? |
Reply |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
![]() |
||||
Thread | Forum | |||
Some Recording Techniques | Pro Audio | |||
Linux is dead...It doesn't even have a pulse. | Pro Audio |