[[email protected]]

Arny Krueger wrote:
"Harry Lavo" wrote in message

"Jenn" wrote in
message
...
An interesting little piece

http://www.nytimes.com/2006/12/31/ar...ic/31thom.html

Lots to think about here. Thanks, Jenn.

For one thing...it seems to challenge the idea often
promulgated here that there is poor long term auditory
memory.

This is only because yiou can't state the issue properly, Harry.

The proper statement of the issue is that there is poor long term memory for
certain subtle details.

Apparently Harry, you lack the experience or mental powers required to
compare and contrast the difference in sound quality related to the same
musician playing the same music on two different musical instruments
(relatively large), and the difference in sound quality related to the same
musician playing the same music on two different good amplifiers or two
different digital formats, given that the lesser format is 16/44 or above
(relatively subtle).



==================================

Krueger's discussion style:
' Apparently Harry, you lack the experience or mental powers required
.....
But thanks Harry for again providing more powerful evidence that we can use
to establish your lack of experience and ability to do critical thinking.

I hate imitating your atrocious manners but it seems nothing else will
penetrate
your thick skull..

Harry is n-times more open minded than you. He doesn't have
your idiotic little axes to grind. He loves music and tries to get the
best
reproduction of it he can..

Ditto for Jenn. She knows better what music is about than you will ever

grasp.

Reproduction of music is not about "accuracy" to the bunch of sound
engineers with your kind of feel for what music is all about or to the
foreman
at the pressing plant

It is about trying to be faithful to the composer and the performer.

I can just see you in a little chair in a little office, in not so
ditant time or country
seeing that the writers and composers do not depart from the "party
line".
You fit in to a T.

You have something to contribute on the technical side. Why don't you
stick to
that and leave art to those who understand it?
Ludovic Mirabel