[Jenn]

In article om,
wrote:

Both sound like real "instruments" to me. However, by miking so closely
low frequency components are picked up that would normally not be heard
or recorded in an orchestral setting. Arny's triangle recording is not
al all how a triangle sounds a few feet or more away. It's similar to
the bass cancelation of dipolar speakers at normal distance due to the
front and back waves meeting. However if you put a microphone right
next to the speaker diaphragm of such a speaker the mike will pick up
the bass full strength. Sorry I'm not more eloquent in my description.

TB

Hi TB,

Respectfully, there's no way in hell that those are real acoustic
instruments. It is a synth. The triangle is real; a terrible
instrument, but real.

[Arny Krueger]

"Jenn" wrote in
message



Respectfully, there's no way in hell that those are real
acoustic instruments. It is a synth.

Please correct me if I'm wrong Jenn, but your hypothesis is that real
trumpet players can never ever play that closely to perfect pitch and hold a
note that steadily, that long.

[Jenn]

In article ,
"Arny Krueger" wrote:

"Jenn" wrote in
message



Respectfully, there's no way in hell that those are real
acoustic instruments. It is a synth.

Please correct me if I'm wrong Jenn, but your hypothesis is that real
trumpet players can never ever play that closely to perfect pitch and hold a
note that steadily, that long.

You're close to part of it. Acoustic trumpets or (French Horns in the
"French Horns" file) played by humans cannot play that well in tune.
The "Trumpets" file contains notes not playable by trumpets. There is
no shift in timbre when the range shifts, particularly at the overtone
breaks of the instruments. These are SOME of the clues.

[[email protected]]

Jenn wrote:
In article om,
wrote:

Both sound like real "instruments" to me. However, by miking so closely
[snip]

TB

Hi TB,

Respectfully, there's no way in hell that those are real acoustic
instruments. It is a synth. The triangle is real; a terrible
instrument, but real.

Note that in the above post I was refering only to the triangle and the
kitchen utensil, not the "trumpets" etc.

TB

[Jenn]

In article .com,
wrote:

Jenn wrote:
In article om,
wrote:

Both sound like real "instruments" to me. However, by miking so closely
[snip]

TB

Hi TB,

Respectfully, there's no way in hell that those are real acoustic
instruments. It is a synth. The triangle is real; a terrible
instrument, but real.

Note that in the above post I was refering only to the triangle and the
kitchen utensil, not the "trumpets" etc.

TB

I see; sorry about that.