Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
#1
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
I've modified my Oktava ML52, including replacing the original
transformer with a Jensen JT-34K-DPC. Out of curiosity, I made some THD measurements of both transformers. The results should be considered preliminary or suspect, due to impedance mismatch problems with my test setup. My audio interface is an Echo Mona. I drove the transformer primaries directly from the the Mona line output (at reduced levels). I don't know what the Mona's output impedance is, but it's undoubtedly higher than the rated 31 Ohm impedance of the JT-34K's primary. I'm not sure what the effect of the mis-match might be on THD measurements. I drove the transformer inputs so that the outputs were at -35 dBu, 0.02V peak. Given the ML52's rated sensitivity of 1mV/Pa, that would correspond to 120 dB SPL with the original transformer--a high level, but well within it's operating range (max 135 dB SPL). I measured the THD at 20, 50, 100, 200, 500, 1K, 2K, 5K, 10K, and 20K Hz, using Purebits' Sample Champion software. Here are the results (which, as mentioned above, should be considered prelimary and/or suspect until I can improve the measurement system to match impedances). %THD %THD Freq Oktava JT-34K ----- ----- ------ 20 6.578 0.398 50 1.457 0.082 100 0.339 0.056 200 0.093 0.041 500 0.066 0.037 1000 0.069 0.037 2000 0.066 0.014 5000 0.057 0.012 10000 0.028 0.010 20000 0.024 0.018 The Jensen numbers are a little higher than the curves published in the spec sheet, probably due to shortcomings of my measurement setup. The relative distortion differences between transformers is probably worth noting, in spite of the measurement problems. The Jensen transformer is significantly better throughout the measured range, but particularly so in the low end (as might be expected). It is much larger physically than the original, with a correspondingly larger core. The frequency response of the Jensen was flat within 2 dB throughout the measured range, whereas the Oktava varied as much as 14 dB, rolling off on the low end, with a 2 dB rise between 5K and 10K Hz. However, this result is even more suspect (I think...) than the THD numbers due to the drive impedance problems. A few additional notes: I chose the JT-34-DPC because it has good performance (response, THD, phase) with a high turns ratio (1:37) and a low imput impedance. It also fits (barely) in the bottom cavity of the ML52. The JT-34-DPC is the same basic design as the JT-34K-DX, but the DX model is double shielded, making it larger, and not able to fit into the ML52. The DPC model has a pin interface for PCB mounting, and the DX has wire leads. The measurements were made with an RC damping network on the output of the JT-34K, as described in the Jensen spec sheet (test setups 1 and 2). This network damps high frequency ringing caused by capacitance between the secondary windings (forming a self-resonant LC circuit). One of the engineers at Jensen told me that this network should be used when the transformer is installed in the mic, as well. The JT-34K-DPC is available from Jensen for $78.51. Before I did something that necessitated a re-ribboning (oops) I did some test recordings, and compared them to recordings of the same material (drums and cymbals) made before the mods. The sound was enormously improved. I'm going to try buffering the output of the Mona with a low-noise, low output impedance amp (e.g., AD797), to better match the input impedance of the transformer. If it works, I'll make some more measurements and post them. I should also be able to measure the gain, frequency response, and phase shift. When I get the mic re-ribboned, I'll make some measurements of the its acoustic performance. I'll try to borrow an unmodified ML52 for comparison. By the way, the Sample Champion software seems like a good buy. It does MLS-based impulse response measurements (among many other things), and seems relatively well-written, at $199 for the pro version. There are some additional plug-ins, and you can get a bundle with everything for $299. See www.purebits.com Cheers, Da5id |
Reply |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
![]() |
||||
Thread | Forum | |||
Altec 15356a Line Transformer | Pro Audio | |||
Doppler Distortion - Fact or Fiction | Pro Audio | |||
Oktava ML-52-02 Resonance Analysis and Mod | Pro Audio | |||
Building a circuit with no power transformer ? | Pro Audio | |||
Hum from the transformer in power supply | Tech |