On Wed, 24 Nov 2004 01:55:39 GMT, "GeoSynch"
wrote:

dave weil wrote:

"God save the queen we mean it man
"There is no future in england's dreaming..."

I'd certainly rank that song in the top 20, if not the top 10.

But not the top 5?

No, not for me. At least during most weeks. It would have to crowd out
Joe Le Taxi, and we can't have *that*.

dave weil wrote:

"God save the queen we mean it man
"There is no future in england's dreaming..."

I'd certainly rank that song in the top 20, if not the top 10.

But not the top 5?

No, not for me. At least during most weeks. It would have to crowd out
Joe Le Taxi, and we can't have *that*.

So, what constitutes the top 5 in Dave's world?


GeoSynch

On Wed, 24 Nov 2004 23:24:32 GMT, "GeoSynch"
wrote:

dave weil wrote:

"God save the queen we mean it man
"There is no future in england's dreaming..."

I'd certainly rank that song in the top 20, if not the top 10.

But not the top 5?

No, not for me. At least during most weeks. It would have to crowd out
Joe Le Taxi, and we can't have *that*.

So, what constitutes the top 5 in Dave's world?


GeoSynch

There's no way that I could make a top 5 "greatest songs of all time"
list. The minimum size list that I could make is a top 20, and it
would have to be understood that the order wasn't fixed in stone. Even
then, a top 20 is difficult. The problems are several-fold. Someone
else has already outlined the perils of such listing (was it Norm?)
The main problem is trying to fold in the ideas of "personal favorite"
and "important". Having said that, I'll simmer on this and see if I
can't come up with something.