Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
#1
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
I desparately,want to be an Audio Engineer......Period. I heard from many
people, including Graduates that Full Sail(http://www.fullsail.com)is not worth the time and money. What is ther best way to become and Audio engineer??? |
#2
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
What is ther best way to become and Audio engineer???
Buy yourself a job. John A. Chiara SOS Recording Studio Live Sound Inc. Albany, NY www.sosrecording.net 518-449-1637 |
#3
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
(PHILLYSTRES) wrote
I desparately,want to be an Audio Engineer......Period. This will get you no where. I heard from many people, including Graduates that Full Sail(http://www.fullsail.com)is not worth the time and money. You only thing you get from something is what you put into it. What is ther best way to become and Audio engineer??? What ever you feel is the best way to do it, but you best do a lot of research first, posting here is a good start, going by what you head via the grape vine is a bad start. Yes, I sat beside a lot of kids who should have never enrolled at Full Sail but I got quite a bit out of the school. No matter what school or subject your talking about, college is only something to get you started. And if your the type of person who believes everything you hear from everyone...oh man your going to have it very hard in recording! |
#4
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]() Buy yourself a job. HUH?? |
#5
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
the bigger issue ISN'T that Full Sail is or is not a waste of money (I've
pontificated on this before...) - it's whether or not engineering schools are even RELEVANT in today's musical climate where everybody and their uncle has a fully stocked studio in their PC. I get calls several times a month from recent FS grads who want jobs in my studio - but have no idea what the real studio climate (I'm talking the business of studios here) is. If you think going to school will automatically put you at the head of the line for a gig in a studio - you are sadly mistaken. As one other poster pointed out, you get out of Full Sail what you put into it (I didn't do so badly - I make a full time living at music AND met my most excellent wife while going to FS!!). If you want to be an engineer, do your homework and see if it even makes sense to go to school for it, or if you'd be better off spending your $$$$ on the equipment and figuring it out yourself, at which point you'd be just like everyone else with their home studio... -- John Marsden Little-Big Sound audio for video, film & digital media; graphics & software solutions www.lbsound.com "PHILLYSTRES" wrote in message ... I desparately,want to be an Audio Engineer......Period. I heard from many people, including Graduates that Full Sail(http://www.fullsail.com)is not worth the time and money. What is ther best way to become and Audio engineer??? |
#7
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
In article ,
uperman (PHILLYSTRES) wrote: I desparately,want to be an Audio Engineer......Period. I heard from many people, including Graduates that Full Sail(http://www.fullsail.com)is not worth the time and money. What is ther best way to become and Audio engineer??? There are many good sources of information about audio recording and sound reinforcement: books. Read some. Get as much practical experience as you can: volunteer to help a band you know doing live sound and making live or demo recordings. Buy some gear and start using it. If you have a passion for audio this will all make sense and keep you interested and occupied and one day you will wake up and realize that you ARE an audio engineer. Schools can streamline the process some and help organize the learning, but you hold the key to your own success: just keep doing what you love and it will happen regardless of the path you take. -Jay -- x------- Jay Kadis ------- x---- Jay's Attic Studio ------x x Lecturer, Audio Engineer x Dexter Records x x CCRMA, Stanford University x http://www.offbeats.com/ x x-------- http://ccrma-www.stanford.edu/~jay/ ----------x |
#8
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
uperman (PHILLYSTRES) wrote in message ...
I desparately,want to be an Audio Engineer......Period. I heard from many people, including Graduates that Full Sail(http://www.fullsail.com)is not worth the time and money. What is ther best way to become and Audio engineer??? I'd take the same approach to getting into the industry as writing music. Listen very carefully to what everyone says you have to do. Do the opposite. Paul |
#9
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]() I desparately,want to be an Audio Engineer......Period. I heard from many people, including Graduates that Full Sail(http://www.fullsail.com)is not worth the time and money. What is ther best way to become and Audio engineer??? Everybody likes to think you don't need either the school or the experience. It's no fun to think that you'll actually have to work at something to become proficient. It doesn't help that a lot of schools are not very good and just tell the students what they want to hear: "You can go work with famous people after this relatively short program and you'll already know everything and it's all loads of glamorous fun!" This is an advertisement, not an education. The wrong school is indeed a waste of time, just as the wrong apprenticeship will be. It also doesn't help that some ignorant people essentially win the lottery and get a hit record by chance and then spread their misconceptions as gospel. "They have a hit, they must know everything!" Following them is the blind leading the blind. It also becomes confusing because after you master the "rules", the exceptions to them and the unexpected inspirations are indeed what often separate the men from the boys. But too many people try to skip the first part of that equation. There are plenty of idiots in this business and I'd rather not encourage aspiring engineers to join their ranks. That means don't skip school, but don't choose a poor school or think you can learn everything in your first year. Also, don't think that you won't need plenty of apprenticeship time after school. You need both the education and the experience unless you want to be forever half-assed or just hoping to "win the lottery" in a very competitive and unhealthy business right now. Just look at this group. Look at all the erroneous pop knowledge, technical misconceptions, and fiercely held positions based on pseudo-scientific nonsense. If we were doctors, 80% of our patients would probably die. Thank gooness it's only audio. For the future health of our business and quality of our craft, I think we should stress the importance of both quality education and effective apprenticeship. Both are often lacking, but both are vitally important. -- Jay Frigoletto Mastersuite Los Angeles promastering.com |
#10
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
First I'd suggest learning to communicatre before you spend money on a
recording school. tHe correct phrase would be "becoming an engineer" and not "becoming and engineer." BRBR Is this some kind of a joke? You misspell two words to his one and omit a comma before the quote. Then, after a few more typos you ramble the following: I hope once you've made up your mind that your resume presents you in a better light than your choice of a subject line for your posted article. This isn't a sentence. It isn't even a lucid thought. I have worse spelling than most and I don't always check for typos when I post here. This forum is about the exchange of ideas, it's not a freaking spelling bee... although if it was, you would lose. Joe Egan EMP Colchester, VT www.eganmedia.com |
#11
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]() "Jay - atldigi" wrote in message ... Just look at this group. Look at all the erroneous pop knowledge, technical misconceptions, and fiercely held positions based on pseudo-scientific nonsense. If we were doctors, 80% of our patients would probably die. Thank gooness it's only audio. For the future health of our business and quality of our craft, I think we should stress the importance of both quality education and effective apprenticeship. Both are often lacking, but both are vitally important. These are wise words IMO. One thing though: Because it's only audio, it doesn't necessarily mean that you're half-assed if you don't know all the components of all your equipment inside out and on top of that know all about acoustics, electricity, psychoacoustics, music theory, etc. It's good to know the basics of them all, but how "deep" would you really wanna get with understanding how sound waves travel, for example? That's the reason we have acousticians, musicians, engineers, producers, all as different human beings. g Yes, let's admit it: one man cannot know the whole universe even if he studied it for 75 years. Personally I'm interested in all things related to audio and music, but at the same I know that I have a limited amount of time on this planet, so I try to concentrate more on art than science, since it is my main interest; I don't really care if someone knows how electricity travels through my equalizer better than me. What matters more to me is how will the end result of my recording sound when compared to the other guy's track. |
#12
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
In article , "Tommi"
wrote: inside out and on top of that know all about acoustics, electricity, psychoacoustics, music theory, etc. You need to have a general base of knowledge in these areas, but you don't have to know everything about everything. Even doctors have specialties. -- Jay Frigoletto Mastersuite Los Angeles promastering.com |
#13
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]() "Jay - atldigi" wrote in message ... In article , "Tommi" wrote: inside out and on top of that know all about acoustics, electricity, psychoacoustics, music theory, etc. You need to have a general base of knowledge in these areas, but you don't have to know everything about everything. Even doctors have specialties. Of course. That was the whole point of my text, but even when speaking about "knowing the basics", it's hard at least for myself to define what are the basics of, say psychoacoustics for example, since the more you learn, the more interesting it gets. It essentially comes down to making a conscious decision about when to stop spending that 4 hours of your day reading about how the ear and your brain process a sound, and start moving to the control room. g |
#14
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
fwiw, i'll give you my (A) history into the biz, and then (B) offer a
suggestion as to how you may land an internship only from my experience: (A) i was supposed to go to school for computer programming, unfortunately, sitting at a desk for hours each day only gave my time to think about how much i wanted to be recording. got a job as a carpenter and literally spent every dime on used beat up gear. since i was pretty handy with an iron, i could get broken/incomplete stuff cheap and fix it. at first, i recorded my own stuff/band, never thought i'd record anyone else, but after i had a few $K in gear (tascam 38, m50 console, akg414, etc), i realized i had to do something more to justify the money i had invested. i started recording other bands for free in my apartment. then i started going to clubs and offering to record bands i liked for next to nothing. word started to spread and so on. carpentry paid off since it helped my build a good sounding room in a cool building in a cool south saint louis neighborhood, now i can offer experience, analog equipment (a very rare bird in this town that a lot of bands still prefer) a good room and competitive rates. i've also since worked out having a few other engineers work out of this room for a room rate -- i don't make a ton off of the deal, but the bills get paid while i'm out on the motorbike. . . all of that said, i often get resume's in the e/mail for internships. people telling me they'll sell their left nut to come in here and sweep the floors. as a college dropout i (nihilistically) don't care about formal education, although if you told me you had an audio degree from NYU or an EE degree from MIT, etc., i'd pay you just to let me ask you some questions. . . fullsail, not so much -- all that tells me you can run a protools rig . . . i do run into people that tell me personally that they want to intern here, and i'm down for it -- they're into cool music, they have some musical background, and they have some degree of style, but it never seems to work out, so here is the nugget of info (if any) this post may hold for you: (B) i don't mind the idea of an intern, but i get by fine without one. so why should i hassle to get someone in here? i shouldn't. to date, everyone has talked about wanting to come in, but hasn't gotten down to making it happen. the only thing i can say, is find a studio you think you'd like to work in, one whose asthetic jives with yours (don't fake this), and research as much as you can (website, bands that record there, perhaps talk to some people that have recorded there, visit to the studio), try to get a feel for how the place works, then figure out a way that you can HELP out. work up a deal, then approach the studio manager/owner with a plan that benefits both of you. because that's why any of us audio/music/entertainment biz assholes do anything, because it benefits US. anyway, best regards and best of luck. c deckard radiopenny saint louis moe. uperman (PHILLYSTRES) wrote in message ... I desparately,want to be an Audio Engineer......Period. I heard from many people, including Graduates that Full Sail(http://www.fullsail.com)is not worth the time and money. What is ther best way to become and Audio engineer??? |
#15
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
In article , "Tommi"
wrote: inside out and on top of that know all about acoustics, electricity, psychoacoustics, music theory, etc. You need to have a general base of knowledge in these areas, but you don't have to know everything about everything. Even doctors have specialties. Of course. That was the whole point of my text, but even when speaking I understood. I was just following the train of thought and clarifying a point. -- Jay Frigoletto Mastersuite Los Angeles promastering.com |
#16
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]() "Jay - atldigi" wrote in message ... In article , "Tommi" wrote: inside out and on top of that know all about acoustics, electricity, psychoacoustics, music theory, etc. You need to have a general base of knowledge in these areas, but you don't have to know everything about everything. Even doctors have specialties. Of course. That was the whole point of my text, but even when speaking I understood. I was just following the train of thought and clarifying a point. I like your doctor analogy because it emphasizes the sometimes forgotten aspect of audio engineering, responsibility about your own work. |
#17
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
I'm actually interested in becoming a studio engineer myself. This is
my first visit to rec.audio.pro I'm currently a Computer Science junior at Cornell University (Ithaca, NY), and wonder if it will help me in any fashion. Any advice on this? My suspicion is that it won't help me at all, but I'm pretty far along in my degree, so leaving any ivy league education incomplete would be very unfortunate. I currently perform in Last Call, a Cornell all-male acappella group (2002 ICCA runner-ups). I started my collecting pieces to my own modest rig to record my group. Setup with a digidesign MBox, Rode NTK tube mic, Rode NT1a, and a Rode NT3 to record solos, backing vocals, and beat box respectively. I do the recording and editing, while the mixing is being done professionally by Bill Hare who specializes in acappella at Bill Hare Productions (www.dyz.com/studio). I currently have a couple tracks up, and am wondering if you had any suggestions on what to do/fix what we have done. http://www.people.cornell.edu/pages/...reeFalling.mp3 Any suggestions on how to break into the recording business? Are the venues to pursuing internships in the industry documented in any fashion, or is it simply a matter of contacting studios you are interested in by email and setting up an interview? Thanks, G (mr c deckard) wrote in message . com... fwiw, i'll give you my (A) history into the biz, and then (B) offer a suggestion as to how you may land an internship only from my experience: (A) i was supposed to go to school for computer programming, unfortunately, sitting at a desk for hours each day only gave my time to think about how much i wanted to be recording. got a job as a carpenter and literally spent every dime on used beat up gear. since i was pretty handy with an iron, i could get broken/incomplete stuff cheap and fix it. at first, i recorded my own stuff/band, never thought i'd record anyone else, but after i had a few $K in gear (tascam 38, m50 console, akg414, etc), i realized i had to do something more to justify the money i had invested. i started recording other bands for free in my apartment. then i started going to clubs and offering to record bands i liked for next to nothing. word started to spread and so on. carpentry paid off since it helped my build a good sounding room in a cool building in a cool south saint louis neighborhood, now i can offer experience, analog equipment (a very rare bird in this town that a lot of bands still prefer) a good room and competitive rates. i've also since worked out having a few other engineers work out of this room for a room rate -- i don't make a ton off of the deal, but the bills get paid while i'm out on the motorbike. . . all of that said, i often get resume's in the e/mail for internships. people telling me they'll sell their left nut to come in here and sweep the floors. as a college dropout i (nihilistically) don't care about formal education, although if you told me you had an audio degree from NYU or an EE degree from MIT, etc., i'd pay you just to let me ask you some questions. . . fullsail, not so much -- all that tells me you can run a protools rig . . . i do run into people that tell me personally that they want to intern here, and i'm down for it -- they're into cool music, they have some musical background, and they have some degree of style, but it never seems to work out, so here is the nugget of info (if any) this post may hold for you: (B) i don't mind the idea of an intern, but i get by fine without one. so why should i hassle to get someone in here? i shouldn't. to date, everyone has talked about wanting to come in, but hasn't gotten down to making it happen. the only thing i can say, is find a studio you think you'd like to work in, one whose asthetic jives with yours (don't fake this), and research as much as you can (website, bands that record there, perhaps talk to some people that have recorded there, visit to the studio), try to get a feel for how the place works, then figure out a way that you can HELP out. work up a deal, then approach the studio manager/owner with a plan that benefits both of you. because that's why any of us audio/music/entertainment biz assholes do anything, because it benefits US. anyway, best regards and best of luck. c deckard radiopenny saint louis moe. uperman (PHILLYSTRES) wrote in message ... I desparately,want to be an Audio Engineer......Period. I heard from many people, including Graduates that Full Sail(http://www.fullsail.com)is not worth the time and money. What is ther best way to become and Audio engineer??? |
#18
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
Gei-Tai Lin wrote:
I'm currently a Computer Science junior at Cornell University (Ithaca, NY), and wonder if it will help me in any fashion. Any advice on this? My suspicion is that it won't help me at all, but I'm pretty far along in my degree, so leaving any ivy league education incomplete would be very unfortunate. Yes, it will help you a lot. Take a numerical analysis class. Take any classes you can get in scientific computing. There is a BIG demand for folks to do signal processing software for audio out there. If you can even install and maintain the stuff, let alone write it, there is a much better market for your skills than just someone who can mix and track well. Also, take a music theory class. I wish I had taken a music theory class when I was an undergrad. Go to the EE school there and at least take DC and AC circuit theory. Audit the audio electronics class. Try and get some background in electronics. Go work at the college radio station as an engineering intern. EVERY college station needs people with basic maintenance skills, and this is also a good place to learn about music as well, and to get contact with people in the local music scenes. Any suggestions on how to break into the recording business? Are the venues to pursuing internships in the industry documented in any fashion, or is it simply a matter of contacting studios you are interested in by email and setting up an interview? It's a matter of contact studios AND telling them what you can offer them. That latter part is the part that most folks seem to miss. Be aware that there are a LOT of people applying. I probably get five to ten resumes faxed to me a week, and I am a one-man operation and have no intention of ever taking on an intern. I'd hate to see what the big studios get. --scott -- "C'est un Nagra. C'est suisse, et tres, tres precis." |
#19
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]() |
#20
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
Scott Dorsey wrote:
Gei-Tai Lin wrote: I'm currently a Computer Science junior at Cornell University (Ithaca, NY), and wonder if it will help me in any fashion. Any advice on this? My suspicion is that it won't help me at all, but I'm pretty far along in my degree, so leaving any ivy league education incomplete would be very unfortunate. Yes, it will help you a lot. Take a numerical analysis class. Take any classes you can get in scientific computing. There is a BIG demand for folks to do signal processing software for audio out there. If you can even install and maintain the stuff, let alone write it, there is a much better market for your skills than just someone who can mix and track well. Are you serious? I don't see it. I suspect it's observer bias, though. There's a lot of demand for people doing DSP for digital radio systems and such, but that's a heck of a lot more involved than audio frequency signals processing. At least the rates are higher, and the value added is being able to inferentially analyze results wihtout having all the data in a dump. This is really strong masters level/PhD level work. I've no doubt that a talented person with a bachelors can do it, but the chance of getting the instruction really needed in those sort of transforms is not very likely at the bachelors level. I mean, it can't hurt to learn it, but as a marketable skill, it seems to get a big yawn out there. Applying discrete transform stuff in say, the VST toolkit is not at all a difficult thing, as those things go. Also, take a music theory class. I wish I had taken a music theory class when I was an undergrad. Go to the EE school there and at least take DC and AC circuit theory. Audit the audio electronics class. Try and get some background in electronics. If the physics department offers an instrumentation class, this is a Good Thing, especially if it's the Junior Physics Lab done electronically... Go work at the college radio station as an engineering intern. EVERY college station needs people with basic maintenance skills, and this is also a good place to learn about music as well, and to get contact with people in the local music scenes. Any suggestions on how to break into the recording business? Are the venues to pursuing internships in the industry documented in any fashion, or is it simply a matter of contacting studios you are interested in by email and setting up an interview? It's a matter of contact studios AND telling them what you can offer them. That latter part is the part that most folks seem to miss. Be aware that there are a LOT of people applying. I probably get five to ten resumes faxed to me a week, and I am a one-man operation and have no intention of ever taking on an intern. I'd hate to see what the big studios get. --scott -- "C'est un Nagra. C'est suisse, et tres, tres precis." -- Les Cargill |
#21
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
Les Cargill wrote:
There's a lot of demand for people doing DSP for digital radio systems and such, but that's a heck of a lot more involved than audio frequency signals processing. At least the rates are higher, and the value added is being able to inferentially analyze results wihtout having all the data in a dump. This is really strong masters level/PhD level work. I've no doubt that a talented person with a bachelors can do it, but the chance of getting the instruction really needed in those sort of transforms is not very likely at the bachelors level. Yes. Same with the stuff like filter design for digital audio and the NR systems design. Right now a lot of that is proprietary and right now most of is is going to require MS-level stuff minimum, but in five or ten years that's not going to be the case. And now is the time to learn how that stuff works inside. When I got an "information and computer science" degree, I got a whole lot of information theory stuff and a lot of continuous math, but I suspect that this isn't the case any longer. But knowing basic differential equations, Fourier theory, and Laplace transforms will take you a long way in terms of developing audio software. I mean, it can't hurt to learn it, but as a marketable skill, it seems to get a big yawn out there. Applying discrete transform stuff in say, the VST toolkit is not at all a difficult thing, as those things go. Right, and it's getting easier. But it's still important to know what is going on inside those black boxes. Also, take a music theory class. I wish I had taken a music theory class when I was an undergrad. Go to the EE school there and at least take DC and AC circuit theory. Audit the audio electronics class. Try and get some background in electronics. If the physics department offers an instrumentation class, this is a Good Thing, especially if it's the Junior Physics Lab done electronically... Absolutely! Just the week or so of discussion on grounding is probably worth auditing. I never got that until it was too late. --scott -- "C'est un Nagra. C'est suisse, et tres, tres precis." |
#22
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
As everyone else has said a Full Sail is what you make of it. I know
some people who have gone and know enuff to cause a major catastrophe. Of course that has been my only experience with students from there, but this but one man's opinion. I got my start at Age 11 and was doing Radio by 14 and held a full time Job as a an engineer (FOH) by 20. I went into the studio side of things at 24 and was blessed to have apprenticed under a great engineer. personally I believe, because that is how I learned, that is the best way to go. Even after completing Full Sail I'd recomend an apprenticeship. I started going to school and was bored aceing all the exams. Trust me though, the Theory you learn is very important and if you dont have the wherewithall to learn it on your own, reading studying, etc... then a school is a good idea. I loved reading and learning and studying in my own spare time. (hence me aceing tests on all the theory and a lot of practical) I eventually dropped out because the one thing I wanted to learn they could not teach me. HOW TO MIX. My Apprenticeship taught me that and the only thing I think I might have missed in school was learning protocol. I had to learn that the hard way. Getting cussed out often. LOL But I made it and life is good. Just my .02 On 2004-03-04 00:57:04 -0500, uperman (PHILLYSTRES) said: I desparately,want to be an Audio Engineer......Period. I heard from many people, including Graduates that Full Sail(http://www.fullsail.com)is not worth the time and money. What is ther best way to become and Audio engineer??? |
#23
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
Lines: 31
Message-ID: X-Trace: ldjgbllpbapjglppdbdpiflmbcekedmfhojhikkbagflhcbobl dgkncfnnhciipjecjobkgamippnjnhdajlkhijjcnclficalpn flbapfokdkpedpmadndknodlchpnbhoekkejclhobbemfacicp nbjpiogfmi NNTP-Posting-Date: Thu, 04 Mar 2004 10:16:48 EST Date: Thu, 04 Mar 2004 15:16:48 GMT Xref: intern1.nntp.aus1.giganews.com rec.audio.pro:1047214 For the original poster: First I'd suggest learning to communicatre before you spend money on a recording school. tHe correct phrase would be "becoming an engineer" and not "becoming and engineer." IT matters not whether you're planning on recording or something else as a career. LEarning to communicate in both written adn spoken ENglish is important here in this country. IT matters not if you can drive an SSL if you can't communicate effectively. I hope once you've made up your mind that your resume presents you in a better light than your choice of a subject line for your posted article. Richard Webb Electric Spider Productions REplace anything before the @ symbol with elspider for real email -- Braille: support true literacy for the blind! |