Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
#1
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
Howdy. I have a Fostex D2424LV that backs up (annoyingly) to an external,
scsi, DVD-Ram drive. My computer is on the other side of the house from my studio. If I get a scsi card, can I import the tracks into my computer? |
#2
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]() "Doc Gorpon" wrote in message ... Howdy. I have a Fostex D2424LV that backs up (annoyingly) to an external, scsi, DVD-Ram drive. My computer is on the other side of the house from my studio. If I get a scsi card, can I import the tracks into my computer? I'm pretty sure you can't do that. I think some of the confusion comes from the way certain rack mount samplers can do that. The sampler is setup to look like a SCSI device, the D2424LV and the computer SCSI card are controllers looking for SCSI devices. Besides, I don't think SCSI is going to work well all the way across a house, unless it's a really small house. You might want to look into getting the ethernet option for your D2424LV. It's the 8360 ethernet option card. List is $299, street is $249 ( according to http://www.bayviewproaudio.com/fostex_d2424lv.html ) I don't have this option myself. Best of luck Doc! John L Rice |
#3
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]() |
#4
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
I'm pretty sure you can't do that. I think some of the confusion comes from
the way certain rack mount samplers can do that. The sampler is setup to look like a SCSI device, the D2424LV and the computer SCSI card are controllers looking for SCSI devices. Besides, I don't think SCSI is going to work well all the way across a house, unless it's a really small house. Thanks for the answers guys. However, I wanted to clarify what I think is a misconception about my intention. I was hoping to get a scsi card, so that I could take the external dvd-ram drive (with the disc inside that has the fostex backup material) and hook THAT up to my computer. Somehow get the info from the backup source onto the computer that way. Not hook the fostex directly into the computer. I'm thinking the ethernet thing might be the way to go. But one more question: What if I get a dvd-ram drive, internal, on my pc? Will it be able to read the backup discs made from the external scsi drive? Is it possible to get a dvd-ram drive put into a pc these days? And this is all assuming that there is some sort of rip available so that my computer can read whatever proprietary fostex files the backup disc will be. |
#5
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
Just a thought,
I don't know anything about the dvd-ram backups or the newer software used for it but I used to track with a D80 which I backed up to dat tape. (yea..annoying!!) But, it transfered the audio to dat intact, ...each stereo pair (1-2/3-4 etc) was recorded(backed up) in sequence and in realtime to the dat tape with a short beep at the project start of each pair so all could be easily aligned once I recorded/transfered them into my daw. You might be able to do something similar with the files on the dvdram....(mabye??). Good luck, Mike "Doc Gorpon" wrote in message ... I'm pretty sure you can't do that. I think some of the confusion comes from the way certain rack mount samplers can do that. The sampler is setup to look like a SCSI device, the D2424LV and the computer SCSI card are controllers looking for SCSI devices. Besides, I don't think SCSI is going to work well all the way across a house, unless it's a really small house. Thanks for the answers guys. However, I wanted to clarify what I think is a misconception about my intention. I was hoping to get a scsi card, so that I could take the external dvd-ram drive (with the disc inside that has the fostex backup material) and hook THAT up to my computer. Somehow get the info from the backup source onto the computer that way. Not hook the fostex directly into the computer. I'm thinking the ethernet thing might be the way to go. But one more question: What if I get a dvd-ram drive, internal, on my pc? Will it be able to read the backup discs made from the external scsi drive? Is it possible to get a dvd-ram drive put into a pc these days? And this is all assuming that there is some sort of rip available so that my computer can read whatever proprietary fostex files the backup disc will be. |
#6
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
By the product literature it's a dual drive bay situation of which an
internal DVD-RAM drive could be used or an additional hard drive. Why not use a hard drive. I don't know about the export to .wav function, but John Rice owns one and probably will be able to give you better specifics on the product. He's laid down some drums on some of my stuff and shipped the .wav files out over the 'net without problems, or at least he didn't mention any. -- Roger W. Norman SirMusic Studio Purchase your copy of the Fifth of RAP CD set at www.recaudiopro.net. See how far $20 really goes. "Doc Gorpon" wrote in message ... Howdy. I have a Fostex D2424LV that backs up (annoyingly) to an external, scsi, DVD-Ram drive. My computer is on the other side of the house from my studio. If I get a scsi card, can I import the tracks into my computer? |
#7
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
You said it well enough to understand, but some synths allowed a scsi drive
to sit between a synth and a computer and still have access from both, because the synth looked like a scsi device. Yours has a controller, which is what John was talking about. Can have multiple devices on a controller, not multiple controllers on a device. However, since the unit HAS dual drive capability, why the hassle about the DVD-RAM? Why not just use another drive, assuming that the Fostex will output (export) the raw wave data to .wav on the second drive? Then you simply carry that drive in and slap it into your computer. And yes, you could probably do the same thing with DVD-RAM, and it would be easier, but DVD-RAM is SLOOOOWWWW in comparison to hard disk transfers. I just did some more backups of some shows I'd left on the hard drive, and the DVD-RAM transfer was about an hour each for 8 tracks of 24/44.1. Now I admit, I'm not all that knowledgable on the D2424LV, but I make the wild hair assumption that one cannot do backups during a session, so that means X amount of time for the export/transfer function, and then about the same amount of time for the transfer to HD in the computer, of which both will significantly be slower than simply transferring digitally on playback. And as far as my computer system is concerned, I can load in the tracks of a DVD-RAM, but I can't play them back from that source without tons of stutter, so a transfer to hd is imperative. So my view would be, internal second hard drive, export tracks to that hard drive and put it in your computer, OR, digitally transfer the tracks on playback to the computer, OR DVD-RAM in that order, going from fastest to slowest respectively. -- Roger W. Norman SirMusic Studio Purchase your copy of the Fifth of RAP CD set at www.recaudiopro.net. See how far $20 really goes. "Doc Gorpon" wrote in message ... I'm pretty sure you can't do that. I think some of the confusion comes from the way certain rack mount samplers can do that. The sampler is setup to look like a SCSI device, the D2424LV and the computer SCSI card are controllers looking for SCSI devices. Besides, I don't think SCSI is going to work well all the way across a house, unless it's a really small house. Thanks for the answers guys. However, I wanted to clarify what I think is a misconception about my intention. I was hoping to get a scsi card, so that I could take the external dvd-ram drive (with the disc inside that has the fostex backup material) and hook THAT up to my computer. Somehow get the info from the backup source onto the computer that way. Not hook the fostex directly into the computer. I'm thinking the ethernet thing might be the way to go. But one more question: What if I get a dvd-ram drive, internal, on my pc? Will it be able to read the backup discs made from the external scsi drive? Is it possible to get a dvd-ram drive put into a pc these days? And this is all assuming that there is some sort of rip available so that my computer can read whatever proprietary fostex files the backup disc will be. |
#8
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]() |
#9
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
Doc,
Yes, you can do what you're talking about doing. In fact, I have a Panasonic DVD-RAM drive I'd sell you cheap if you like. But you should know that DVD-RAM as a format is pretty much dead and before too long you won't be able to buy the drives anymore. I don't know if typical DVD drives can read DVD-RAM discs or not. And I haven't been able to get my DVD-RAM drive to work with a Macintosh. But on W2K it works just fine. Not that I actually use it. ulysses Doc Gorpon wrote: I'm pretty sure you can't do that. I think some of the confusion comes from the way certain rack mount samplers can do that. The sampler is setup to look like a SCSI device, the D2424LV and the computer SCSI card are controllers looking for SCSI devices. Besides, I don't think SCSI is going to work well all the way across a house, unless it's a really small house. Thanks for the answers guys. However, I wanted to clarify what I think is a misconception about my intention. I was hoping to get a scsi card, so that I could take the external dvd-ram drive (with the disc inside that has the fostex backup material) and hook THAT up to my computer. Somehow get the info from the backup source onto the computer that way. Not hook the fostex directly into the computer. I'm thinking the ethernet thing might be the way to go. But one more question: What if I get a dvd-ram drive, internal, on my pc? Will it be able to read the backup discs made from the external scsi drive? Is it possible to get a dvd-ram drive put into a pc these days? And this is all assuming that there is some sort of rip available so that my computer can read whatever proprietary fostex files the backup disc will be. |
#10
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
Yes, you can do what you're talking about doing. In fact, I have a
Panasonic DVD-RAM drive I'd sell you cheap if you like. How cheap, Jack? |
#11
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
internal DVD-RAM drive could be used or an additional hard drive. Why not
use a hard drive. I already have the DVD drive hooked up. He's laid down some drums on some of my stuff and shipped the .wav files out over the 'net without problems, or at least he didn't mention any. How did you do that John? |
#12
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]() I was hoping to get a scsi card, so that I could take the external dvd-ram drive (with the disc inside that has the fostex backup material) and hook THAT up to my computer. edit First, though, I'd puzzle through the Fostex manual (I know how hard that is, I've seen some, though not that one) and maybe the buttons and menus to see if it's actually possible to export files in WAV format to a drive connected to the external SCSI port. I believe it is, but be sure that you can actually do what you need to do before you go off buying hardware. Yes, you are correct. Fostex D2424LV manual : Page 93 Save/load data using SCSI Page 99 Save/load data using onternal hard drive 2 or DVD Page 101 Save/load WAV data Notes about saving loading WAV files : You have to use an MS DOS FAT 16 formated drive The D2424LV can't format disks as MS DOS FAT 16. You'll have to format them first on your PC. Hard drives formatted FAT 16 are limited to one partition with a max size of 2 gigs. ( I'd assume that DVD's are also limited to 2 gigs until someone proves different ) If you expect to import WAV files back into the D2424LV a very strict file naming convention must be used. And this is all assuming that there is some sort of rip available so that my computer can read whatever proprietary fostex files the backup disc will be. Didn't John or somebody say that even though it stored files in its own format, that there was a button on there that exports in the WAV format? (see above) The Alesis HD24 works like that - it stores files the way it likes them, and converts them to WAV or AIFF on the fly as it spits them out the Ethernet port. Yup, that's the Fostex recommended way of doing it. There 'is' that third party beta experimental ripper that 'can' take Fostex proprietary FDMS-3 format files and convert them to WAV files but, it has little or no support so I wouldn't count on it working for any particular person. There have been a couple reports of it working pretty good though. I haven't tried it myself. John L Rice |
#13
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]() "Doc Gorpon" wrote in message ... internal DVD-RAM drive could be used or an additional hard drive. Why not use a hard drive. I already have the DVD drive hooked up. He's laid down some drums on some of my stuff and shipped the .wav files out over the 'net without problems, or at least he didn't mention any. How did you do that John? Actually, for the stuff I did for Roger I was only using the converters in the Fostex and running the lightpipes over to the MOTU 2408 to record in Cubase in real time. My band has done a lot of recordings though where tracks were recorded at one house on a D2424LV ( or other D series recorder ) and then the hard drive was taken to my place and the hard drive put in my machine, sync'd up with Cubase and the new tracks recorded in real time via lightpipe again. We've been slowly moving to doing all PC stuff though so the Fostex is getting less use. John L Rice |
#14
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
Notes about saving loading WAV files :
You have to use an MS DOS FAT 16 formated drive The D2424LV can't format disks as MS DOS FAT 16. You'll have to format them first on your PC. Yes, I was thinking about this. So let's say I get the scsi adapter card for my PC. Can I hook the external scsi dvd-ram drive to it, format it properly for the wav files, hook up the drive to my fostex for backup in wav file format, then come BACK to the pc with the dvd-ram drive and dump the info onto the pc? |
#16
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
So you also need to know how to format a drive as FAT16, which on most
modern PCs isn't an automatic process. I can hear the echos of "My head hurts!" The fact that you need some sort of rig to make a drive portable between the recorder and the computer (a couple of SCSI removable drive bays) seems like a whole lot of trouble to avoid using a mixing console. Actually, the big problem I've always had with my setup is that I use other studios/people to mix in/with, and the compatability of my stuff with other studios is minimal. So I wouldn't be mixing on my pc. I just need to somehow get the tracks onto cd-r in wav file so that I can send to other studios. I'm so bummed that the fostex doesn't just do that already. |
#17
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]() |
#18
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
I hate to say "I told you so" but I told you so when you were
considering which recorder to buy. While I didn't know what the Fostex did or didn't do, I'm sure I pointed out that this sort of thing was something you should consider when making your decision. It looks like the Fostex will do what you want, it's just a pain in the butt doing it with a disk drive. Perhaps the Ethernet option is more sensible, but be sure you know exactly how that works before you spring for the money. It might be worth finding someone within reasonable travel distance from you who has that setup and pay him a visit. Remember, plane fares are cheaper than ever. Believe me, I knew what I was getting into. For the money I had/have, the Fostex was still the best solution for me all around. I had to make a concession somewhere, and the compatibility was it. But I'm thinking there are ways around that. It's probably going to take some headaches and a trial and error type of approach (sort of like I had finding the right dvd-ram drive to back up onto). But I think once I have a system figured out, it won't be that big of a deal. I'm getting a cheap scsi card adapter first. If that doesn't work, I'll go for the ethernet thing. |
#19
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
Doc Gorpon wrote:
So you also need to know how to format a drive as FAT16, which on most modern PCs isn't an automatic process. I can hear the echos of "My head hurts!" The fact that you need some sort of rig to make a drive portable between the recorder and the computer (a couple of SCSI removable drive bays) seems like a whole lot of trouble to avoid using a mixing console. Actually, the big problem I've always had with my setup is that I use other studios/people to mix in/with, and the compatability of my stuff with other studios is minimal. So I wouldn't be mixing on my pc. I just need to somehow get the tracks onto cd-r in wav file so that I can send to other studios. I'm so bummed that the fostex doesn't just do that already. I have another Fostex product ( not the 2424 series ), and export over Lightpipe works great. YMMV. -- Les Cargill |
#20
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]() "Doc Gorpon" wrote in message ... I hate to say "I told you so" but I told you so when you were considering which recorder to buy. While I didn't know what the Fostex did or didn't do, I'm sure I pointed out that this sort of thing was something you should consider when making your decision. It looks like the Fostex will do what you want, it's just a pain in the butt doing it with a disk drive. Perhaps the Ethernet option is more sensible, but be sure you know exactly how that works before you spring for the money. It might be worth finding someone within reasonable travel distance from you who has that setup and pay him a visit. Remember, plane fares are cheaper than ever. Believe me, I knew what I was getting into. For the money I had/have, the Fostex was still the best solution for me all around. I had to make a concession somewhere, and the compatibility was it. But I'm thinking there are ways around that. It's probably going to take some headaches and a trial and error type of approach (sort of like I had finding the right dvd-ram drive to back up onto). But I think once I have a system figured out, it won't be that big of a deal. I'm getting a cheap scsi card adapter first. If that doesn't work, I'll go for the ethernet thing. Another thing you could consider that I know of people who have gotten it to work great on earlier Fostex D series recorders. Instead of putting in the DVD-RAM or doing an external SCSI thing, put a second internal IDE hard drive in BUT instead of getting the official Fostex frame / caddy system get one of the shelf from a third party like a CRU Dataport. Then get an extra frame and put that in your PC. Then you can just swap the hard drives back and forth. The reason to not get the Fostex one is because they seem to like to tweak the frames so that only their caddies will work. John L Rice |
#21
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
Another thing you could consider that I know of people who have gotten it to
work great on earlier Fostex D series recorders. Instead of putting in the DVD-RAM or doing an external SCSI thing, put a second internal IDE hard drive in BUT instead of getting the official Fostex frame / caddy system get one of the shelf from a third party like a CRU Dataport. Then get an extra frame and put that in your PC. Then you can just swap the hard drives back and forth. The reason to not get the Fostex one is because they seem to like to tweak the frames so that only their caddies will work. Really? Other caddies will fit the fostex machine? |
#22
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]() "Doc Gorpon" wrote in message ... Another thing you could consider that I know of people who have gotten it to work great on earlier Fostex D series recorders. Instead of putting in the DVD-RAM or doing an external SCSI thing, put a second internal IDE hard drive in BUT instead of getting the official Fostex frame / caddy system get one of the shelf from a third party like a CRU Dataport. Then get an extra frame and put that in your PC. Then you can just swap the hard drives back and forth. The reason to not get the Fostex one is because they seem to like to tweak the frames so that only their caddies will work. Really? Other caddies will fit the fostex machine? Sort of. You have to replace the frame that mates with the caddy too. Most other caddies on earth will not work in Fostex frames. Since the D2424LV has two bays you could leave the original and put an aftermarket setup in the second bay. You wouldn't be able to swap caddies between bays then, but you could put the same frame in your PC to swap caddies between the PC and bay 2 of the D2424LV. This all sounds pretty sweet BUT there is no guarantee that this will work for you and it will void your warranty. You'll probably have to do the work yourself of installing it too. ( an authorized Fostex repair center might not tough it ) Caddy prices have shot WAY up in the last six months so getting third party frame/caddy sets may be as expensive if not more expensive than getting the Fostex ones. You might just get one extra Fostex setup and put it in your PC, it 'should' work OK. ( the frame just has a standard IDE and power connectors ) You can get great deals on Ebay for used and / or overstocked new frame / caddie setups but if you don't know for sure what you are buying and what you really need ( there are many variations and most wont be right ) you could spend more trying several different 'cheep' ones than just buying new in the first place. Best of luck! John L Rice |
#23
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]() "Doc Gorpon" wrote in message ... Another thing you could consider that I know of people who have gotten it to work great on earlier Fostex D series recorders. Instead of putting in the DVD-RAM or doing an external SCSI thing, put a second internal IDE hard drive in BUT instead of getting the official Fostex frame / caddy system get one of the shelf from a third party like a CRU Dataport. Then get an extra frame and put that in your PC. Then you can just swap the hard drives back and forth. The reason to not get the Fostex one is because they seem to like to tweak the frames so that only their caddies will work. Really? Other caddies will fit the fostex machine? For your reference : http://www.cruinc.com/htmldocs/products/dp4.htm John L Rice |
#24
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
Doc Gorpon wrote:
Howdy. I have a Fostex D2424LV that backs up (annoyingly) to an external, scsi, DVD-Ram drive. My computer is on the other side of the house from my studio. If I get a scsi card, can I import the tracks into my computer? What version SCSI ? How many pins / what connector ? The older 'flavours' were 18 feet maximum total cable length. Differential goes further IIRC but you're unlikely to have that. Graham |
#25
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
The older 'flavours' were 18 feet maximum total cable length. Differential
goes further IIRC but you're unlikely to have that. I would be removing the dvd drive and carrying it across my house for hookup to my pc. So length of cable isn't an issue. |
#26
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
Doc Gorpon wrote:
Yes, you can do what you're talking about doing. In fact, I have a Panasonic DVD-RAM drive I'd sell you cheap if you like. How cheap, Jack? How much you got? If you say more than $50 or less than $10, I won't take you seriously. ulysses |
#27
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
Doc Gorpon wrote:
I would be removing the dvd drive and carrying it across my house for hookup to my pc. So length of cable isn't an issue. Why not just have a 2nd DVD-RAM drive? One installed in your recorder, one installed in your computer. Then you only need to carry the disk itself across the room. You know, that's why they call it removable media. And if you do the formatting on the Fostex, it'll probably be easier than trying to pick the right format on the PC. I'm sure the computer will still READ the FAT16 format, right? ulysses |
#28
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
Doc Gorpon wrote:
The older 'flavours' were 18 feet maximum total cable length. Differential goes further IIRC but you're unlikely to have that. I would be removing the dvd drive and carrying it across my house for hookup to my pc. So length of cable isn't an issue. Ok, check if it has a 50 pin cable going to it with a connector that looks like a printer connector but bigger ( or a 25 pin D type ). That version of SCSI is/was the most popular and adaptors widely available. They tend not to be that cheap though, it's a bit of specialised market almost 'owned' by Adaptec. Grham |
#29
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
How much you got?
If you say more than $50 or less than $10, I won't take you seriously. $11? But seriously. If you still have if after the holidays cool down a little, I'll take it off your hands. $30? |
#30
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
Why not just have a 2nd DVD-RAM drive? One installed in your recorder,
one installed in your computer. I'll probably end up with that. But right now, I'm thinking cost effective. I only have one drive at the moment. |
#31
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]() "Pooh Bear" wrote in message ... Doc Gorpon wrote: The older 'flavours' were 18 feet maximum total cable length. Differential goes further IIRC but you're unlikely to have that. I would be removing the dvd drive and carrying it across my house for hookup to my pc. So length of cable isn't an issue. Ok, check if it has a 50 pin cable going to it with a connector that looks like a printer connector but bigger ( or a 25 pin D type ). That version of SCSI is/was the most popular and adaptors widely available. They tend not to be that cheap though, it's a bit of specialised market almost 'owned' by Adaptec. Grham It's a 'half-pitch 50 pin' connector (from the D2424LV manual page 19 and 93). John L Rice |
#32
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
And if you do the formatting on the Fostex, it'll probably be
easier than trying to pick the right format on the PC. I'm sure the computer will still READ the FAT16 format, right? ulysses Unfortunately, while the D2424LV can read MS DOS FAT 16 drives/disks, it doesn't have the ability to format disks as FAT 16. Which it pretty lame along with the fact that they never moved up to a FAT 32 system so you could effectively use disks bigger than 2 GB. I guess making that change would of cost way to much money or something. I just checked the Windows 2000 computer I'm currently on and I'm able to format a ZIP disk as either FAT 16 ( just says FAT in the menu ), FAT 32 or NTFS. John L Rice |
#33
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
John L Rice wrote:
"Pooh Bear" wrote in message ... Doc Gorpon wrote: The older 'flavours' were 18 feet maximum total cable length. Differential goes further IIRC but you're unlikely to have that. I would be removing the dvd drive and carrying it across my house for hookup to my pc. So length of cable isn't an issue. Ok, check if it has a 50 pin cable going to it with a connector that looks like a printer connector but bigger ( or a 25 pin D type ). That version of SCSI is/was the most popular and adaptors widely available. They tend not to be that cheap though, it's a bit of specialised market almost 'owned' by Adaptec. Grham It's a 'half-pitch 50 pin' connector (from the D2424LV manual page 19 and 93). Ok, that makes it pretty easy. That's the most popular, well, widely used version of SCSI. A SCSI 2 adaptor will do nicely. I checked some out btw. The basic ones aren't actually that expensive. Even the entry level Adaptecs. I would recomment Adaptec btw since their documentation is normally first class, although I used to buy bare ( OEM ) boards too, to save money. I'm assuming the the Drive is 'terminated' btw - i.e. it's at the end of the lead. Otherwise you need a terminator too. The adaptor card has to have termination enabled at its end too ( asuming you're not planning on adding any internal SCSI devices ). I found an Adaptec AVA-2904 here in the UK for £25 but can't see it on any US site. It appears to be an old model maybe ? The similar AVA-2906 is $65 direct from Adaptec - http://www.adaptecstore.com/index.cf...ctid=1 772900 Typical - the 2904 has a 'half pitch' 50 pin connector as on your drive but the 2906 has a standard pitch 25 pin external ( like Macs used to have ). Means a different cable. What cable do you currently have ? Graham |
#34
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
What cable do you currently have ?
Thanks for the massive research, Graham. It's very possible that I'll have the correct adapter/cable combo somewhere around here. I went through mail order hell trying to find the right cables through my search for scsi stuff at different times. So I have a few different variations to work with. |
Reply |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
![]() |
||||
Thread | Forum | |||
RCA out and Speaker Question in 2004 Ranger Edge Question | Car Audio | |||
Kenwood KDC-MP522 Question (just purchased it) | Car Audio |