Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
#24
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
OK here is some math.
The first pair of sidebands are about -40dBc. Assuming this is caused by FM for the moment and as stated before, using the standard FM sideband calculations, this corresponds to a frequency deviation of about +/- 1 Hz at 4000 Hz. (The 4000 Hz tone is raised and lowered by 1 Hz at a 50 Hz rate.) Using 344.3 m/sec for the speed of sound and the Doppler equations found he http://www.mathpages.com/rr/s2-04/2-04.htm The relative speed needed to shift 4kHz by 1 HZ is about 0.2 MPH or 0.3 feet/ sec or about 3.5 inches per second. If I make the simplifying assumption that the loudspeaker cone is moving back and forth at 50 Hz with a triangular wave rather than sinusoidal (just to make the math a bit easier). At 50Hz the cycle is 0.02 seconds and the speaker cone would move about 0.07 inches in that time. Since it is moving back and forth that is +/-0.035 inches. This seems perfectly reasonable to me. Working it the other way round, if you assume a loudspeaker is reproducing a 50 Hz tone, and the cone is moving +/-0.035 inches at 50 Hz, that is about 3.5 inches per second or 0.2 miles per hour. This speed produces a Doppler shift (frequency deviation) of about 1 Hz to a 4 kHz tone which corresponds to -40 dBc first sidebands. So this is an inherent non-linear distortion but it can be reduced by using a separate woofer and tweeter or making the speaker cone larger so it does not have to move as far and therefore as fast. But I don't think it sounds any different than any other form of non-linear distortion such as intermodulation. But also the magnitude if this distortion is much larger than produced by any reasonable electronics it points out that we should stop worrying about the electronics so much. The electronics are much better than the speakers. Interesting question, how does the VELOCITY of the cone change as the 50 Hz is increased in frequency at a fixed amplitude. I know from looking at a speaker that the excursion reduces as the frequency goes up, but in this case it is the velocity (not the excursion) of the cone that it key. Mark |