View Single Post
  #4   Report Post  
Posted to rec.audio.pro
Arny Krueger Arny Krueger is offline
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 17,262
Default Dither randomizes file?

"alex reznick" wrote in message


You can probably change the size of the delta by
adjusting the amount and shaping of the dither.


But then how could the same dither Pow-3 cause different
deltas when applied in Samplitude and Sonar?


Same reason - different means of generating the pseudo random noise for
dithering.

Another reason - the details of the implementation of Pow-r 3 are slightly
different.

Samplitude -59.679 dB (consistently from one conversion
to another) Sonar -60.26 (consistently)


Not much of a difference in my book.

Also, when running 32 bit to 16 bit conversion with
dither in the batch in Samplitude, I get, on average, 1
out of 10 files with a glitch. The glitch looks like an
interruption of the sound with silence (with noise) for
about half a second. It is not exactly reproducible: each
batch conversion compromises different files. Could not
find any similar complaints on Samplitude forums or
Google.


That's a completely different issue that could have any number of different
causes.

When I convert without a batch - manually, file by file -
there is no such glitching.


Sounds the the batch mode stresses the machine over a period of time and
eventually it gitches.

Does this mean that batch processing uses dither differently than the main
program?


Not necessarily - the load on the system is different because the batch mode
just bangs away on the machine quite relentlessly.