[ScottW]

"John Atkinson" wrote in message
ups.com...

He also indicated that the editorial staff at Stereo Review
did an exemplary job of working over his article.

According to the new rule instituted by ScottW, all
such declarations on r.a.o. must be accompanied by
documentary proof, Howard. Sorry.


Since Larry is your friend that shouldn't be too difficult.
Seriously though, since you insist on misstating my
intent I must clarify. It's really quite simple. You've
created controversy by challenging SR interpretation
of Greenhill's tests with your own conclusions and
you put it to the public to choose one over the other.
I think it is quite reasonable to ask to see the test
data before making a decision.
Matter of fact, I find it rather
absurd for you to even press the matter given
Greenhill won't grant you approval to publish his work
in entirety. Why is that? Your "friend" places you
on shaky ground.

ScottW