View Single Post
  #24   Report Post  
Posted to rec.audio.tech
[email protected] dpierce@cartchunk.org is offline
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 402
Default Julian Hirsch and the 5% solution



On Jan 29, 3:28 pm, Chris Morriss wrote:
.So does a competently set up M-S recording, or even a proper 4-channel
M-S recording or a soundfield mic. (Have a listen to the 'Cowboy
Junkies' 'Trinity Sessions' to see what I mean.


Not over stereo speakers in rooms, it doesn't. You might well
like the effect, but you cannot reproduce the sound field of the
original event using two spealer in a room. Pray tell, how does
ANY recording, be it binaural, M-S, whatever, repdruce the fact
that the sound field in the original venue includes delayed paths
in 3d space. How do you propose to accomplish this with two
speakers in a room? (And before anyone runs away with that
conclusion, it can't be done with 5.1 either).