View Single Post
  #2   Report Post  
Posted to rec.audio.opinion
Arny Krueger Arny Krueger is offline
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 17,262
Default Are you willing to buy SACDs?

"Jack" wrote in message

I don't own a SACD player now but buy the disks of
new releases (Goldfrapp - Supernature; Depeche
Mode - Playing the Angel) as my next player will
be SACD compatible. I don't care about DVD-A,
since even fewer of them are available.

I am willing to spend say 10% more for them than
for normal CD's, but not much more.

a) Do you think SACD is doomed?


No doubt, but look for a ressurection of the concept on DVD-HD or Blu Ray,
real soon now.

b) Have you listened to a new recording mastered
for SACD from step 1 instead of an old recording
converted for SACD? What was the sound like?


More to the point,

Q: what did that SACD (Norah Jones) sound like when downsampled to 24/96?

A: The same.

c) What are your thoughts on SACD in general.


It was among other things, an attempt to make a lot of money by remastering
existing CD catalogs for a new format. Trouble was, hardly anybody wanted to
play.