View Single Post
  #14   Report Post  
GaryMedia
 
Posts: n/a
Default

It's almost ironic that you'd offer the Behringer 3242's. This all
started because I had two Behringer MX3242X's and added a third for my
home studio. I fired up a mix that I had been working on thru my Alesis
Studio 24 (not a typo, ...just follow the story) and listened to it thru
the MX3242X.

I was surprised at the difference in sound. There had been all kinds of
impolite and downright degrading commentary on this newsgroup and others
about Behringer sound, but this was the first time that I had an
opportunity to do some A/B comparisons in a controlled and known
environment.

After about 2 hours of going back and forth between the Studio 24 and
the MX3242X, I concluded that it was the handling of low-level signal
information that causes the downfall in the Behringer sound quality.
That is, the little reverb tails and soft decay edges of a variety of
instruments don't fade into the noise floor as gently as they do in the
Alesis. There was a secondary effect in that the bass seemed louder
relative to the rest of the mix when played thru the Behringer even
though the EQ controls were bypassed.

I'm not sure of which specification would affect this phenomenon the
most (THD+N?) but that was the only arena in the spec sheets where the
products differed in any great respect.

The subjective effect of the "rapid fade" problem in the MX3242X is that
the music is "dry", and "loses dimension" and is "flat" and certainly
less emotionally satisfying. It is much the same effect as like losing
bit resolution. The overall intuitive effect is quite surprising and
for the first time I understood a lot more about the reactions of people
who prefer the analog world.

Just as people have different visual sensitivities to vertical scan
rates in CRT monitors (some can tolerate 60hz and don't notice the
flicker, while it absolutely drives me out of the room), I imagine that
people have difference emotional sensitivities to the low-level
information in audio recordings.

Going back to THD+N as a suspect, I took the time to translate the
traditional percentage specification into dB in order to get a better
feel for what numbers the relationships are.

Behringer MX3242X THD+N = 0.005% = -86dB
Alesis Studio 24 and 32 THD+N = 0.001% = -100dB

Checking through some of my other equipment and looking around on the
web *almost* convinced me that I was on to something in that the
Focusrite, dbx, MOTU 1224 all had this spec in the -100 dB or better
ranges ...even the Studio Projects VTB-1 was at -97dB.

The theory took a torpedo in the side when I looked at the Avalon
preamps. The AD2022 had a spec of 0.05% for distortion which is -66dB.

Either that figure is a typo, or just more evidence that clearly
something else is going on here in the world of audio. Anyway, I
thought y'all would like read about my little rabbit trail of research.
The best quote I've read on this topic is "Reading specifications will
make you deaf."

The rest of the story is that I bought two Alesis Studio 32's to replace
the Behringers, and one turned up with a bad channel-11, so that
prompted this thread.


George Gleason wrote:
GaryMedia wrote:

I have an Alesis Studio 32 mixer that makes a "seashore" noise in the
right outputs of both subgroups and in the main output. The source of
the noise in channel-11, and it's there regardless of the position of
the mute and pan controls for that channel.

To further describe the "seashore" noise, its a hissy, static-y (like
AM radios during a thunderstorm) sound with occasional deeper rumbles.

Although the problem has also surfaced on channel-6, it's most
reproducable in channel-11. It will start a few minutes after the
mixer is turned on, then will quiet down for hours at a time before
re-occuring. No signal needs to be present on any channel for this
problem to manifest.

Before I open this thing (or send it out for repair), I'd like to have
some idea of what components are the likely culprits.

Any ideas?




If you decide on a low cost replacment I have two Behringer 3242's for
sale perfect condition 350.00
george