On Sun, 3 Aug 2003 05:10:13 -0400, "Arny Krueger"
wrote:

"dave weil" wrote in message

On Sat, 2 Aug 2003 18:15:23 -0400, "Arny Krueger"
wrote:

"dave weil" wrote in message


There's no way that the VTF-2 "outperforms" the Sunfire in 33% of
what's important to the poster.

Prove it.

Is or is not one of the most important items mentioned the size of the
unit?

It's very unlikely that two subwoofers would be identical. Most people don't
care about size unless its grossly different, or the larger speaker is
difficult or impossible to use because of its size.

NOW you've gone int o the area of not caring what someone wants.

Here are the clues that show that this is CLEARLY not the case:

"How to choose a subwoofer for a _small_ room"?

"I want to buy the Sunfire Junior cos it's small that I need"

IOW do want something that is at least as small, goes as least as deep,
and costs no more, preferably less?

Yes.

Note that you said, "at least as small". The HSU is CLEARLY not at
least as small.

Does the VTF-2 outperform the Sunfire in that important category?

If the VTF-2 were 0.001" larger than the Sunfire Junior, then it would in
fact outperform the VTF-2 in terms of size. How meaningful would that be?

But it would *barely* be larger.

The size of the Sunfire Junior is Dimensions: 9" by 9" by 9" .

The size of the VTF-2 is 16"(height) x 16"(width) x 19.5"(depth)

One would have to have very tight space constraints for this to be a serious
consideration.

That's your idea and you can't reasonably make this statement, because
YOU DON"T KNOW whether something that is over a third larger would be
an issue. This person wants it for their bedroom. They apparently want
it to be inobtrusive. If they live in Hong Kong, one of the most
crowded cities in the world, it's likely that every square inch is at
a premium.

Then brush up on your reading comprehension skills Weil, and note
that the question was not about the Sunfire, but rather the question
was about the Sunfire Junior.

Sunfire being shorthand for the Sunfire Junior - referring obviously
to the indicated subwoofer.

Sunfire being a name that relates equally well to five different products.
It's just as valid here as "Hsu" a name that relates equally well to at
least 9 different products.

But we were only talking about one product, not any of the others. If
you want to nitpick, feel free to.

Besides, *any* of the Carver subwoofers are substantially smaller than
the HUSs, so it's irrevelant anyway.

Nice try though.

Keep flailing. You are now one of "those guys" that I said you weren't
in my previous post. And it's only because it's me that you're taking
issue with.