Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Multimeters w/Inductance/Capacitance
Your nominations please: USA-sales, something that has inductance and
capacitance as well as the usual others (V/A/ohms), other things I am not concerned about, or am I? I see a few have temperature probes, might be handy. I can go maybe $100 or so. Within this price range, is there any great reason to buy one over another? ----------- |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
Take a look at this listing on EBay:
http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll...8003 423&rd=1 Wavetek is a good brand. They used to be a publicly traded company in the US but were bought out by another instrumentation company. Meters with inductance aren't that common. If you can just buy one device it's really helpful to have frequency, continuity and diode test - transistor beta is helpful too - For Inductance and Capacitance , Q and D I use a GenRad 1658 Digibridge which I bought for $50 -- I don't see many of them now. I also have a Heathkit RLC bridge which is pretty darn good -- these usually go for around $20. Jack "DougC" wrote in message ... Your nominations please: USA-sales, something that has inductance and capacitance as well as the usual others (V/A/ohms), other things I am not concerned about, or am I? I see a few have temperature probes, might be handy. I can go maybe $100 or so. Within this price range, is there any great reason to buy one over another? ----------- |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
"DougC" Your nominations please: USA-sales, something that has inductance and capacitance as well as the usual others (V/A/ohms), other things I am not concerned about, or am I? ** You may be concerned to learn that inductance ranges as found on DMMs are all but useless for correctly measuring the inductance of iron core chokes or transformer primaries as found in tube amps etc. Worse - the same meter's capacitance ranges are not much use for testing PSU electros either since ESR is the parameter of interest and goes high long before any uFs are found missing. An LCR bridge is far more useful for analysing iron inductors and electros. ......... Phil |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
Phil Allison wrote:
** You may be concerned to learn that inductance ranges as found on DMMs are all but useless for correctly measuring the inductance of iron core chokes or transformer primaries as found in tube amps etc. I looked at a Wavetek Meterman on a scope and it uses a 400hz sawtooth for measuring inductance. They seem more of a good/bad test than an accurate measurement. Adam |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
DougC wrote:
Your nominations please: USA-sales, something that has inductance and capacitance as well as the usual others (V/A/ohms), other things I am not concerned about, or am I? I see a few have temperature probes, might be handy. I can go maybe $100 or so. Within this price range, is there any great reason to buy one over another? ----------- I've seen cheap multimeters in the Parts Express,and MCM flyers,and other places for like $30 or less that do C/L and transistors (hfe,I suppose?)Mostly generic or no-name stuff,might not be dead-accurate,but close enough,and it's cheap.. I remember seeing a Fluke somewhere (MCM,maybe?) that I was eye-balling for it's L/C capabilities,i'm not sure if did transistors or not,but it looked pretty nice,and was just under $50. |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
Go to www.aade.com and take a look.....George
"ptaylor" wrote in message ... DougC wrote: Your nominations please: USA-sales, something that has inductance and capacitance as well as the usual others (V/A/ohms), other things I am not concerned about, or am I? I see a few have temperature probes, might be handy. I can go maybe $100 or so. Within this price range, is there any great reason to buy one over another? ----------- I've seen cheap multimeters in the Parts Express,and MCM flyers,and other places for like $30 or less that do C/L and transistors (hfe,I suppose?)Mostly generic or no-name stuff,might not be dead-accurate,but close enough,and it's cheap.. I remember seeing a Fluke somewhere (MCM,maybe?) that I was eye-balling for it's L/C capabilities,i'm not sure if did transistors or not,but it looked pretty nice,and was just under $50. |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
Phil Allison wrote:
** You may be concerned to learn that inductance ranges as found on DMMs are all but useless for correctly measuring the inductance of iron core chokes or transformer primaries as found in tube amps etc. Worse - the same meter's capacitance ranges are not much use for testing PSU electros either since ESR is the parameter of interest and goes high long before any uFs are found missing. An LCR bridge is far more useful for analysing iron inductors and electros. So, I would guess use the unknown L or C with a known C or L, apply different freq signals and see where the peak is, and then figure backwards?.... I only had classes in high-school, they didn't ask you to figure out unknown component values real often, other than on paper. -------- Where can I get a SIMPLE a-f/low r-f signal generator? When I took electronics classes in high-school, we used these simple little boxes that had a single graduated knob for generating signals--but when I search Google for "signal generators" all I am finding are massive, complex, fully-digital industrial-grade test instruments that cost thousands of dollars....? Lots for TV use, RF-only. I have looked fairly all afternoon now and found NOTHING that approaches the small, simple thing I am looking for. Someone must sell them, is it called something else? |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
DougC said:
Where can I get a SIMPLE a-f/low r-f signal generator? When I took electronics classes in high-school, we used these simple little boxes that had a single graduated knob for generating signals--but when I search Google for "signal generators" all I am finding are massive, complex, fully-digital industrial-grade test instruments that cost thousands of dollars....? Lots for TV use, RF-only. I have looked fairly all afternoon now and found NOTHING that approaches the small, simple thing I am looking for. Someone must sell them, is it called something else? http://www.tequipment.net/TMT.html If you can't find it here, it probably doesn't exist :-) -- Sander deWaal "SOA of a KT88? Sufficient." |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
"DougC" wrote in message ... Where can I get a SIMPLE a-f/low r-f signal generator? When I took electronics classes in high-school, we used these simple little boxes that had a single graduated knob for generating signals--but when I search Google for "signal generators" all I am finding are massive, Doug - You got what you searched for. Signal generator is generally synonymous with RF generator. Do a google search for " audio generator -software " without the quotes, and you'll find what you want. --Chuck |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
On Fri, 10 Sep 2004 04:34:25 -0500, DougC wrote:
Your nominations please: USA-sales, something that has inductance and capacitance as well as the usual others (V/A/ohms), other things I am not concerned about, or am I? I see a few have temperature probes, might be handy. I can go maybe $100 or so. Within this price range, is there any great reason to buy one over another? ----------- I bought a Metex in Canada, might be available in the US... about $80. it has capacitance, frequency, and hfe if you need it! Doesn't do L, I don't know of any that do. You would be better off with a bridge to do L and C. |
#11
|
|||
|
|||
"DougC" wrote in message ... Phil Allison wrote: ** You may be concerned to learn that inductance ranges as found on DMMs are all but useless for correctly measuring the inductance of iron core chokes or transformer primaries as found in tube amps etc. Worse - the same meter's capacitance ranges are not much use for testing PSU electros either since ESR is the parameter of interest and goes high long before any uFs are found missing. An LCR bridge is far more useful for analysing iron inductors and electros. So, I would guess use the unknown L or C with a known C or L, apply different freq signals and see where the peak is, and then figure backwards?.... ** That is one way - for iron core inductors and audio trannies. The problem is that for different test frequencies and different signal levels the answer you get is not the same. The capacitatance tester on a DMM will work fine with plastic film, paper, tantalum, ceramic and other types. The problem is that faulty electro caps in PSUs will not show a loss of uFs - you need an ESR meter for them or simply substitute a new one if in doubt. ............. Phil |
#12
|
|||
|
|||
I'm gonna have to disagree with that. I or should i say we have Wavetek 34xr handheld meters at work,($109 or something) somebody
decided these were a lot cheaper than buying all the technicians Flukes or HP's. I never really used my handheld, mostly my bench Fluke, then when i did use the handheld i ran into problems. Measuring 5.0vac (i had a old analog meter which i though was reading wrong) on the handheld it was reading high 5.3 volts. I was looking for 5.0v +- 5% which is the spec. This was with the meter hanging from a rackmount with the magnet on the strap. When i held the meter in my hand, i could get it to read as high as 5.6v depending on where i held it! When the meter was placed next to anything metal, the reading was changed. It's very affected. If i held it by the leads, the meter dangling in the air, it read 5.0v which is what i was looking to verify. Later when i asked 4 other technicians about the Waveteks, each and every one of them told me "oh, they are junk, don't use those Waveteks for anything other than checking 9 volt batteries or checking for continuity". It actually doesn't look like a bad meter at all, has capacitance and other features but i won't use mine anymore for ANY critical measurments. These are all brand new, 3 months old at most. "John Walton" wrote in message ... Take a look at this listing on EBay: http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll...8003 423&rd=1 Wavetek is a good brand. They used to be a publicly traded company in the US but were bought out by another instrumentation company. Meters with inductance aren't that common. If you can just buy one device it's really helpful to have frequency, continuity and diode test - transistor beta is helpful too - For Inductance and Capacitance , Q and D I use a GenRad 1658 Digibridge which I bought for $50 -- I don't see many of them now. I also have a Heathkit RLC bridge which is pretty darn good -- these usually go for around $20. Jack "DougC" wrote in message ... Your nominations please: USA-sales, something that has inductance and capacitance as well as the usual others (V/A/ohms), other things I am not concerned about, or am I? I see a few have temperature probes, might be handy. I can go maybe $100 or so. Within this price range, is there any great reason to buy one over another? ----------- |
#13
|
|||
|
|||
Doug:
Getting a little back on track he http://store.yahoo.com/webtronics/protek506.html I think this is a really nice meter. It's loaded with nice features, and most important the internal shunt resistance is low so your bias settings (if you use OPT shunt method) will be accurate. dre |
#14
|
|||
|
|||
Chuck wrote:
Doug - You got what you searched for. Signal generator is generally synonymous with RF generator. Do a google search for " audio generator -software " without the quotes, and you'll find what you want. --Chuck -Heh he heh, the questions are endless: are the small/inexpensive PCB signal generator kits worth using? I can either spend more for a better-quality signal generator (that has a digital or graduated-dial readout) and use it with my current "vanilla" DMM, or buy an inexpensive PCB-type signal generator that has no readout or graduated dial, and then buy a new DMM that does frequency counting... The inexpensive generator I am looking at is he http://www.hobbytron.net/UK307.html; do these sorts of circuits put out a clean enough signal to be useable, and can the DMM's measure well enough up to 30-50Khz or so? --The cheap generator and counting-DMM is cheaper ($150) than the "better" generator ($250) used with my existing "vanilla" DMM, but I have no way to tell what the cheap gnerator is really putting out without an oscilloscope,,, but that is another thing I currently do not have. |
#15
|
|||
|
|||
Could be -- I had an old Wavetek hand-held which worked quite well, but it
"disappeared" -- I still use an 1970's vintage Wavetek sweep generator. I have hand-helds from Beckman, Keithley and Radio Shack -- but most recently a Fluke 177 which is a tough, durable instrument. The Beckman has a broken knob which makes it useless, the Keithley died (I bought it new in the 1970's), the Radio Shack works but the LCD is dying. "Robert Mozeleski" wrote in message ... I'm gonna have to disagree with that. I or should i say we have Wavetek 34xr handheld meters at work,($109 or something) somebody decided these were a lot cheaper than buying all the technicians Flukes or HP's. I never really used my handheld, mostly my bench Fluke, then when i did use the handheld i ran into problems. Measuring 5.0vac (i had a old analog meter which i though was reading wrong) on the handheld it was reading high 5.3 volts. I was looking for 5.0v +- 5% which is the spec. This was with the meter hanging from a rackmount with the magnet on the strap. When i held the meter in my hand, i could get it to read as high as 5.6v depending on where i held it! When the meter was placed next to anything metal, the reading was changed. It's very affected. If i held it by the leads, the meter dangling in the air, it read 5.0v which is what i was looking to verify. Later when i asked 4 other technicians about the Waveteks, each and every one of them told me "oh, they are junk, don't use those Waveteks for anything other than checking 9 volt batteries or checking for continuity". It actually doesn't look like a bad meter at all, has capacitance and other features but i won't use mine anymore for ANY critical measurments. These are all brand new, 3 months old at most. "John Walton" wrote in message ... Take a look at this listing on EBay: http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll...8003 423&rd=1 Wavetek is a good brand. They used to be a publicly traded company in the US but were bought out by another instrumentation company. Meters with inductance aren't that common. If you can just buy one device it's really helpful to have frequency, continuity and diode test - transistor beta is helpful too - For Inductance and Capacitance , Q and D I use a GenRad 1658 Digibridge which I bought for $50 -- I don't see many of them now. I also have a Heathkit RLC bridge which is pretty darn good -- these usually go for around $20. Jack "DougC" wrote in message ... Your nominations please: USA-sales, something that has inductance and capacitance as well as the usual others (V/A/ohms), other things I am not concerned about, or am I? I see a few have temperature probes, might be handy. I can go maybe $100 or so. Within this price range, is there any great reason to buy one over another? ----------- |
#16
|
|||
|
|||
"DougC" wrote in message ... .. -Heh he heh, the questions are endless: are the small/inexpensive PCB signal generator kits worth using? Doug- It depends on how you are going to use them. The kit you identified is a Function Generator. That means it is a square wave generator that creates triangle and sine-like outputs by linear and non-linear signal processing of the square wave. Function generators often have a provision to accept a control voltage to adjust or modulate the frequency. The downside is that function generators have more harmonic distortion in the sinewave output than a good sinewave oscillator. For many applications this is not a problem. Cost shouldnt be a problem either. My HP 200CD oscillator cost me $2 at a swap meet. So far, all it has needed for maintenance was a coat of paint on the cabinet. --Chuck |