Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Echo Indigo as replacement to frustrating MBOX?
Hi there,
You may have read of my year long and somewhat pathetic attempts to get an MBOX to work with my Thinkpad. I've decided that enough is enough and I'm going to ebay it. I would like to replace it with something rock solidly reliable and not finicky. And smaller than the MBOX would be ideal. I was thinking that the Echo Indigo I/O would fit the bill. Has anyone used this for pro recording? The things that I would be using it for would be for recording my voice for radio documentary projects, transferring audio from minidiscs and tapes and occasionally recording live stereo of acoustic music. I have a Beyer Dynamic M58, and I'm not sure what I would need to do to get that to interface with the Indigo. Also I would like to get some recomendations of a good, audio editor with some good eq control (while being fairly user friendly). Any suggestions? Thanks! Paul |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
wrote in message ups.com... Hi there, You may have read of my year long and somewhat pathetic attempts to get an MBOX to work with my Thinkpad. I've decided that enough is enough and I'm going to ebay it. Yes... and I posted a rather inflammatory response there moments ago. I would like to replace it with something rock solidly reliable and not finicky. And smaller than the MBOX would be ideal. I suggest not replacing it with anything until you get a grip on using customer service routes and problem solving in time periods of less that a year. Sorry.... DM |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
Ummm...
thanks for that. Paul |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
wrote in message ups.com... Ummm... thanks for that. Paul No sweat. g If I was familiar with XP, I would honestly be quite willing to try and get your M-Box working for you... but I'm no fan of XP yet and I've never tried any of the Digi stuff on a Windows platform. I wish I could say more. If you had been on any version of Windows other than XP, I might have been able to offer some helpful advice in troubleshooting the problem. DM |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
Hey Kurt,
Thanks for the suggestion. The other thing I failed to mention is price. Looking to find something that sounds reasonable in the under $300 range. Paul |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
Paul,
I suggest that you go to a pro audio store and have the hardware and software installed and tested before making any more purchases or sales. If you're running anti-virus, messenger, games, internet utilities, microsoft office etc., they are all likely to have at least one component that conficts with pro audio hardware/software. You would be surprised what these programs do in the background (even if they are not open and running). And that's only the software conflicts. There may be hardware issues as well. Mike |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
|
#10
|
|||
|
|||
I can't record for more than 1 minute consistently without constant
9129 errors. The buffer is set to its highest setting. I've used both SP1 and SP2, reinstalled everything, etc. I thought it was because I was using a USB 2.0 drive external drive which is not supported, but I disconnected that last night and tried it on the internal drive and the same thing happened. My last idea was to get a PCMIA firewire card and run the external drive off that (it has Firewire and USB 2.0) but DIGI doesn't seem to support PCMIA firewire cards. Which confuses me because I don't know how they support the IBM T series laptops, but no way to use a Firewire card. The honest truth is that I use this computer for a lot of things, but I'm pretty careful regarding what I put on it. I do have Office, which I need, also photoshop, etc. But I don't really have a choice with those things, and I can't afford two laptops. I don't need a ton of power, just something that can record well without too much hassle. Thanks for your thoughts Paul |
#11
|
|||
|
|||
|
#12
|
|||
|
|||
Hi Mike,
Thanks again for your advice. If I could get the Mbox to work, I would be very pleased BUT I really am not sure what else to do. I've already done a clean install of Windows XP and that didn't seem to help. I've disabled everything that I could think of and that didn't help. I've just spent so many hours trying to figure this thing out. I guess it's too late to ask this question, but is it possible that I have a bum unit? It does function and occasionally I have been able to record 1 track as long as 20 minutes. I'm not sure where I'm going wrong. Paul |
#13
|
|||
|
|||
During boot up press the key for bios setup...... disable the laptop's
internal sound card...... alternately go into control panel and disable the internal soundcard. See if you get better results..... Are there more than one flavor of drivers for the MBOX ie ASIO or others try different ones. The option to have just the OS and your audio program does not require a separate machine..... You can either set it up for dual boot with two copies of XP or get a drive caddy and another hard drive. You don't mention the software you are using but possibly this is a software problem rather than hardware..... does it give the same errors using the internal sound card?..... what type of driver is that card using? I work in a Win 2K environment so cannot give you more specific instructions.... Regards: Eric |
#14
|
|||
|
|||
|
#15
|
|||
|
|||
On Tue, 14 Jun 2005 09:18:34 -0400, wrote
(in article . com): I can't record for more than 1 minute consistently without constant 9129 errors. The buffer is set to its highest setting. I've used both SP1 and SP2, reinstalled everything, etc. I thought it was because I was using a USB 2.0 drive external drive which is not supported, but I disconnected that last night and tried it on the internal drive and the same thing happened. My last idea was to get a PCMIA firewire card and run the external drive off that (it has Firewire and USB 2.0) but DIGI doesn't seem to support PCMIA firewire cards. Which confuses me because I don't know how they support the IBM T series laptops, but no way to use a Firewire card. The honest truth is that I use this computer for a lot of things, but I'm pretty careful regarding what I put on it. I do have Office, which I need, also photoshop, etc. But I don't really have a choice with those things, and I can't afford two laptops. I don't need a ton of power, just something that can record well without too much hassle. Thanks for your thoughts Paul Paul, Do you have two internal drives? Are they both 5400 rpm or faster? The fact that you use the computer for a lot of other things may also be a problem. The rule of thumb for good DAW operation has always been a stripped down system. Can you create different startup sets with the rest of the stuff turned off? Ty Ford -- Ty Ford's equipment reviews, audio samples, rates and other audiocentric stuff are at www.tyford.com |
#16
|
|||
|
|||
Paul,
Did you try disabling Microsoft Office's Find Fast utility? This software runs constantly unless you disable it. It will interfere with many high demand applications. Now that you mention installing a USB hard drive... how did you install it? Was it installed on one USB port or have you used it at any time on the port that the Mbox is intalled on? Thanks, Mike |
#17
|
|||
|
|||
I use Indigo IO cards with multiple Windows 2k and XP laptops for
location work, mostly recording speech from meetings. I also record 2-track music stuff with it, but this is less frequent. The IO is rock-solid, totally reliable, and I do not hesitate to recommend it. However, it does not have built-in preamps like the M-box. I either plug in to whatever mixer is on-site, or bring a small portable mixer with me. -dave www.themoodrings.com wrote: Hi there, You may have read of my year long and somewhat pathetic attempts to get an MBOX to work with my Thinkpad. I've decided that enough is enough and I'm going to ebay it. I would like to replace it with something rock solidly reliable and not finicky. And smaller than the MBOX would be ideal. I was thinking that the Echo Indigo I/O would fit the bill. Has anyone used this for pro recording? The things that I would be using it for would be for recording my voice for radio documentary projects, transferring audio from minidiscs and tapes and occasionally recording live stereo of acoustic music. I have a Beyer Dynamic M58, and I'm not sure what I would need to do to get that to interface with the Indigo. Also I would like to get some recomendations of a good, audio editor with some good eq control (while being fairly user friendly). Any suggestions? Thanks! Paul |
#18
|
|||
|
|||
Hi Ty,
It's a laptop, it only has one internal drive. I believe it is at least 5400 rpm, I thought it was 7200 but I'm not sure. I'm thinking one solution would be a dual-boot system with another copy of XP and Pro Tools on a seperate partition. I'd lose 6 gigs, I think, but I probably can do it. I'm not sure if there is a way to set up a profile where PT would be the only program running? That would be a lot better than having to do a whole partition. Then I could get a firewire card and run my external drive off of that and free up the USB. DIGI doesn't seem to support PCMIA firewire cards, I still don't understand how you are supposed to run your firewire drive on a USB only computer if they don't support PCMIA cards. Paul |
#19
|
|||
|
|||
Hi Mike,
I don't think that I was very particular about it, to be honest. I didn't know it was an issue. I've used on both of the two usb ports. How could I rectify? I will try disabling the Find Fast utility. Is it possible to create a seperate profile that will not load anything but PT without creating a dual boot operating system? Thanks Paul |
#21
|
|||
|
|||
Paul,
These were both big issues for me to get Pro Tools working on the USB port. You can disable or even remove Find Fast. Perhaps a computer geek can assist on your USB issue. I believe you right click on My Computer, choose Properties, choose Hardware, click on Device Manager, open Universal Serial Bus Controllers. At the stage you're in, I'm not 100% sure from here if you just delete them and re install all your USB devices, or what. But, I found that by only using a hard drive on the one port and Mbox on one port, and an external mouse on one port, and never interchanging between, I had stability and the software never hung up. Mike |
#22
|
|||
|
|||
Ohmigod.
I finally figured it out. I just got 26 tracks on the Dave C test (from the DUC). No problem. All thanks to this post http://duc.digidesign.com/showflat.p...fpart=1#837904 I really can't understand why it is so difficult for DIGI to give clear technical advice. If I had had this information 6 months ago I would never have had a problem. It seems to be working flawlessly now. I really can't understand why this thing has to be such a mystery. Thanks for all your help everyone, you kept me from ebaying this thing. I hope it keeps working! Paul wrote: Paul, These were both big issues for me to get Pro Tools working on the USB port. You can disable or even remove Find Fast. Perhaps a computer geek can assist on your USB issue. I believe you right click on My Computer, choose Properties, choose Hardware, click on Device Manager, open Universal Serial Bus Controllers. At the stage you're in, I'm not 100% sure from here if you just delete them and re install all your USB devices, or what. But, I found that by only using a hard drive on the one port and Mbox on one port, and an external mouse on one port, and never interchanging between, I had stability and the software never hung up. Mike |
#23
|
|||
|
|||
|
#24
|
|||
|
|||
On Wed, 15 Jun 2005 10:47:53 -0400, wrote
(in article .com): Hi Ty, It's a laptop, it only has one internal drive. I believe it is at least 5400 rpm, I thought it was 7200 but I'm not sure. I'm thinking one solution would be a dual-boot system with another copy of XP and Pro Tools on a seperate partition. I'd lose 6 gigs, I think, but I probably can do it. I'm not sure if there is a way to set up a profile where PT would be the only program running? That would be a lot better than having to do a whole partition. Then I could get a firewire card and run my external drive off of that and free up the USB. DIGI doesn't seem to support PCMIA firewire cards, I still don't understand how you are supposed to run your firewire drive on a USB only computer if they don't support PCMIA cards. Paul Paul, Most Macs fast enough to do audio have FW 400 ports. I don't know the PC laptop world well enough to know if things are similar. Could be this is another of those "Macs cost more....(and here's why)" things. When I bought my Ti book, the seller said, "Wait a week. Mac is shipping a Ti Book with an analog input.That might be useful for you, right?" Boy Howdy. it sure was! The 2 channel A/D converter is actually pretty darn nice. I forget, does the Mbox have ANY firewire ports? I'm thinking NOT. The Digi 002R has two of them. I can plug my laptop into one and an external FW drive into the other Maybe you need an 002R. Keep the Mbox and use it as a dongle so you can mix on the road. Good luck. Ty Ford -- Ty Ford's equipment reviews, audio samples, rates and other audiocentric stuff are at www.tyford.com |
#25
|
|||
|
|||
Sorry Mike, it was actually a link within a link.
http://www.digidesign.com/digizine/d...n_id=1&navid=4 I went into MSCONFIG and eliminated all the programs that were running on startup. I had about 60 processes running and that brought it down to 30. Seems like a solution. I'm not 100% sure what I did, but the computer seems to be running fine. I saw a lot of junk on there like Real audio, MS Office, etc. Point he I think if Digi wants to market the MBOX as something that someone without a ton of money can use to record music (or in my case radio), they have to deal with the fact that some people may be using their computers for other things. I really can't afford two laptops. So I think they need to provide some solutions as to how to make that work. If I had read this article 6 months ago, I would have saved a bunch of time. Paul PS Please let me know if I have done something that is going to make my computer explode. Seems to be running just fine though. |
#26
|
|||
|
|||
Ty,
The Thinkpad is a really great laptop...I love it (love it so much that when I fell on it and cracked the LCD I spent $500 getting it fixed). It's not specifically a multimedia laptop, and its onboard sound is pretty crappy, but it is stable and tough and works great. I'm definitely a fan. That said, more USB ports and a firewire port would be great additions. And speakers louder than my earbuds would be nice too. Paul |
#27
|
|||
|
|||
|
#28
|
|||
|
|||
wrote in message oups.com... Sorry Mike, it was actually a link within a link. http://www.digidesign.com/digizine/d...n_id=1&navid=4 I went into MSCONFIG and eliminated all the programs that were running on startup. I had about 60 processes running and that brought it down to 30. Seems like a solution. I'm not 100% sure what I did, but the computer seems to be running fine. I saw a lot of junk on there like Real audio, MS Office, etc. Wow! 60 running processes !!! This must be XP, yes? very curious I have only shut down 2 processes on my 98SE internet surfing toy and my number of running processes is only 17. I could easily shut down about 9 more, but I've found that they aren't interfering with anything, so I just leave them alone. On my 98SE audio workstations I have 9 running processes, a couple of which I could easily shut down, but they aren't really in the way either, since these boxes never see the light of the internet. I'm just getting into XP (don't have my own yet), so I'd love to know more about these 30 running background processes. Remove NOSPA to reply by mail, or post here. Thanks... DM |
#29
|
|||
|
|||
wrote:
If I had read this article 6 months ago, I would have saved a bunch of time. Paul, swear to me that the subject you described is not covered in the literature that comes with the Mbox. I'm almost positive it used to, but then I take in info from so many sources every day that my recall may have become corrupted. -- "It CAN'T be too loud... some of the red lights aren't even on yet!" - Lorin David Schultz in the control room making even bad news sound good (Remove spamblock to reply) |
Reply |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
FS: Echo Indigo i/o PCMCIA 24 bit audio | Pro Audio | |||
Echo Indigo io: setting input levels ? | Pro Audio | |||
FA: Echo INDIGO IO Stereo 24/96 Laptop Recorder | Pro Audio | |||
FA: Echo INDIGO IO Stereo 24/96 Laptop Recorder | Pro Audio | |||
FA: Echo INDIGO IO Stereo 24/96 Laptop Recorder | Pro Audio |