Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
|
#1
Posted to rec.audio.pro
|
|||
|
|||
only one real issue I'm finding with monitor speaker setup versus car
Been over a week now since using the recommended Presonus E5's and
Behringer 202. While I'm finding it much easier to judge and correct for proper equalization, anytime I try and manipulate either stereo width, add reverb or similar, it never sounds very good in the car but will sound good on these monitors. Recommendations? |
#2
Posted to rec.audio.pro
|
|||
|
|||
only one real issue I'm finding with monitor speaker setup versus car
Sighhhhhh.. This again!
If your monitor speaker setup ISN'T in your car it will never be able to recreate that exact acoustic environment. Unless you buy a second car identical in year, make, model, and trim level to yours, then, install the monitoring & mastering suite *in that duplicate vehicle*. Then you can mix and master away and be able to create masters that will sound terrific in your daily driver and sound like shyte anywhere else on Earth you play them back over. !... |
#3
Posted to rec.audio.pro
|
|||
|
|||
only one real issue I'm finding with monitor speaker setup versuscar
|
#4
Posted to rec.audio.pro
|
|||
|
|||
only one real issue I'm finding with monitor speaker setup versuscar
On 09/03/2018 20:37, JBI wrote:
I thought the whole point of getting this set up and mixing with monitors in the house was so that mixes would sound better on anything, not just in the car!Â* Correct me if I'm wrong.... Only one reverb so far has been passable, and that was a convolution reverb with very gentle settings.Â* It actually sound worse on the monitors, but better in the car.Â* Perhaps I'll have to go back to that but it's a darned shame that the current reverb sounds like crap in the auto as it really sounds good on these new monitors.Â* Oh well..... Part of the problem may be that you are not used to your new system yet, another is that reverb generally sounds better is if it used in small doses, especially if you are adding it to material that already has some reverb or room tone in the source. Another point is that when monitoring,it's recommended that you install sound deadening pads at the reflection points between your ears and the speakers, say on the ceiling and desktop,and that your head and the speakers fall at the points of an equilateral triangle. There is another way, of course, which is to get a better quality system installed in the car and set up to sound as good as the environment permits. Decent door speakers, and a decent quality subwooofer, set not to overpower the others is one way I've had success with. -- Tciao for Now! John. |
#5
Posted to rec.audio.pro
|
|||
|
|||
only one real issue I'm finding with monitor speaker setup versuscar
On 03/09/2018 03:57 PM, John Williamson wrote:
On 09/03/2018 20:37, JBI wrote: I thought the whole point of getting this set up and mixing with monitors in the house was so that mixes would sound better on anything, not just in the car!Â* Correct me if I'm wrong.... Only one reverb so far has been passable, and that was a convolution reverb with very gentle settings.Â* It actually sound worse on the monitors, but better in the car.Â* Perhaps I'll have to go back to that but it's a darned shame that the current reverb sounds like crap in the auto as it really sounds good on these new monitors.Â* Oh well..... Part of the problem may be that you are not used to your new system yet, another is that reverb generally sounds better is if it used in small doses, especially if you are adding it to material that already has some reverb or room tone in the source. Yes, I've noticed that (reverb only in small doses). I also have better luck allocating it only to certain frequencies and not to all of them, plus adding some random variance with automation. Oh well, I'll have to retry. There is no longer noise issues in the car since using the ground loop filter I built, so I may give it another go in the car just temporarily as I don't want to start doing everything in the car once again! Another point is that when monitoring,it's recommended that you install sound deadening pads at the reflection points between your ears and the speakers, say on the ceiling and desktop,and that your head and the speakers fall at the points of an equilateral triangle. The triangle is already established, but I've been a bit concerned as the monitors are are further away than I had hoped (roughly 5 feet away for each one). I suppose some extra reverb could creep in over that distance. There is another way, of course, which is to get a better quality system installed in the car and set up to sound as good as the environment permits. Decent door speakers, and a decent quality subwooofer, set not to overpower the others is one way I've had success with. With this old hunk of a car that I have, it's not worth it. About the most I tried recently was modifying the radio harness wires to add an external auxiliary input since I've been using a cassette adapter for years. While the modification worked, I was left with only about half of the volume I could obtain with the adapter. Solution was either a stronger amp or just keep what I have and I chose the latter. |
#6
Posted to rec.audio.pro
|
|||
|
|||
only one real issue I'm finding with monitor speaker setup versuscar
On 3/9/2018 2:43 PM, JBI wrote:
Been over a week now since using the recommended Presonus E5's and Behringer 202.Â* While I'm finding it much easier to judge and correct for proper equalization, anytime I try and manipulate either stereo width, add reverb or similar, it never sounds very good in the car but will sound good on these monitors.Â* Recommendations? What, specifically, are the problems with reverb and stereo panning when listening in the car? I suspect that the real problem is that reflections in your room are changing what's coming out of reasonably accurate monitors, so in your room, you aren't really hearing what you paid for. One cheap trick is to mix using the speakers, then check your mix on headphones. Headphones aren't good for mixing, but they're closer to representing what car audio sounds like than a small, untreated room, so you can use them to decide if your panning is where you want it, and if you have too much or too little reverb. Also, make sure that your car radio isn't applying some signal processing. Lots of car radios, even going back 15 years or more, have presets for jazz, classical, pop, dance, etc. One of those might be selected and you don't know it or don't remember engaging it. Room reflections can affect stereo imaging, reverberation, and frequency response. Getting the speakers close to you (5 feet is too far to be considered "near field" in a small room) lets you hear more of the speakers and less of the room, which will get you closer to the right track. There are some pretty good articles at http://www.gikacoustics.com/articles/ that might help. Start out using their guide to speaker placement (but of course they want you to buy their room treatment materials in the end). Move some furniture if you need to. Improvise speaker stands from a stack of concrete "cinder blocks." $15 at Home Depot plus an afternoon's work might get your mixes to travel a bit better. -- For a good time, call http://mikeriversaudio.wordpress.com |
#7
Posted to rec.audio.pro
|
|||
|
|||
only one real issue I'm finding with monitor speaker setup versuscar
On 03/09/2018 06:14 PM, Mike Rivers wrote:
On 3/9/2018 2:43 PM, JBI wrote: Been over a week now since using the recommended Presonus E5's and Behringer 202.Â* While I'm finding it much easier to judge and correct for proper equalization, anytime I try and manipulate either stereo width, add reverb or similar, it never sounds very good in the car but will sound good on these monitors.Â* Recommendations? What, specifically, are the problems with reverb and stereo panning when listening in the car? You know what, I think it has to do with the volume in the car as well as the placement of my head and/or stereo balance between speakers. I suspect that the real problem is that reflections in your room are changing what's coming out of reasonably accurate monitors, so in your room, you aren't really hearing what you paid for. One cheap trick is to mix using the speakers, then check your mix on headphones. Headphones aren't good for mixing, but they're closer to representing what car audio sounds like than a small, untreated room, so you can use them to decide if your panning is where you want it, and if you have too much or too little reverb. Thanks, I'll give the headphones a try the next time around. Also, make sure that your car radio isn't applying some signal processing. Lots of car radios, even going back 15 years or more, have presets for jazz, classical, pop, dance, etc. One of those might be selected and you don't know it or don't remember engaging it. I'm almost certain it does have some sort of compression or limiting, but I've never known it to have presets for anything; very old radio, in fact it's the stock radio in the 2000 Taurus. Room reflections can affect stereo imaging, reverberation, and frequency response. Getting the speakers close to you (5 feet is too far to be considered "near field" in a small room) lets you hear more of the speakers and less of the room, which will get you closer to the right track. I figured 5 feet was a little too far. I'm not sure how to get them any closer. I run an electric heater in this room this time of the year and I have to have about a 5 foot area in front of me in the clear. If I tried to move the speakers closer on their makeshift stands, they'd block the heater. Maybe when Summer comes, I'll be able to get around it. There are some pretty good articles at http://www.gikacoustics.com/articles/ that might help. Start out using their guide to speaker placement (but of course they want you to buy their room treatment materials in the end). Move some furniture if you need to. Improvise speaker stands from a stack of concrete "cinder blocks."Â* $15 at Home Depot plus an afternoon's work might get your mixes to travel a bit better. I was also thinking of adding wheels to my current stands, then I could just roll them closer when I'm using the system. I'll take a look at the articles. Thanks. |
#8
Posted to rec.audio.pro
|
|||
|
|||
only one real issue I'm finding with monitor speaker setup versus car
The more I see discussions like this, the more I think someone out there
is missing a fabulous business opportunity making mixer consoles that mount on your dashboard. After all, haven't we all already decided that our cars are the only monitoring environment we really trust? -- He that would make his own liberty secure must guard even his enemy from oppression; for if he violates this duty, he establishes a precedent that will reach to himself. --Thomas Paine |
#9
Posted to rec.audio.pro
|
|||
|
|||
only one real issue I'm finding with monitor speaker setup versuscar
On 12/03/2018 9:20 AM, Hikaru Ichijyo wrote:
The more I see discussions like this, the more I think someone out there is missing a fabulous business opportunity making mixer consoles that mount on your dashboard. After all, haven't we all already decided that our cars are the only monitoring environment we really trust? Put it all thru a Behringer X-18 or whatever and you can use the X-Air Android or Apple appon your smartphone to finely tweak the sound to your liking (eq, dynamics, gating, reverb, whatever !) while you are speeding along. geoff |
#10
Posted to rec.audio.pro
|
|||
|
|||
only one real issue I'm finding with monitor speaker setup versus car
Hikaru Ichijyo wrote:
The more I see discussions like this, the more I think someone out there is missing a fabulous business opportunity making mixer consoles that mount on your dashboard. After all, haven't we all already decided that our cars are the only monitoring environment we really trust? I don't know about this, but I did once work at a studio that had mounted a Chrysler cigarette lighter and ashtray into a Neve module and bolted it into the console. It was very convenient and between that and the oversized studio glass most of the benefits of the automobile were achieved. --scott -- "C'est un Nagra. C'est suisse, et tres, tres precis." |
#11
Posted to rec.audio.pro
|
|||
|
|||
only one real issue I'm finding with monitor speaker setup versus car
|
#12
Posted to rec.audio.pro
|
|||
|
|||
only one real issue I'm finding with monitor speaker setup versus car
When deciding how much reverb to add to a mix, I have a pretty simple technique:
1. Start out with no reverb. 2. Turn up the reverb until it sounds right. 3. Then turn it down 6dB from that point. I won't say it works every time, but it works more often than not. The idea is that your brain becomes acclimated to a given level of reverb quite quickly; the natural inclination in Step 2 is to add reverb until you can "hear it working". That's how we get so many mixes that sound like they were recorded in a cave. This method is an attempt to work around the brain's tendency. Give it a try. Peace, Paul |
#13
Posted to rec.audio.pro
|
|||
|
|||
only one real issue I'm finding with monitor speaker setup versus car
On Saturday, March 10, 2018 at 2:18:12 PM UTC-5, PStamler wrote:
When deciding how much reverb to add to a mix, I have a pretty simple technique: 1. Start out with no reverb. 2. Turn up the reverb until it sounds right. 3. Then turn it down 6dB from that point. I won't say it works every time, but it works more often than not. The idea is that your brain becomes acclimated to a given level of reverb quite quickly; the natural inclination in Step 2 is to add reverb until you can "hear it working". That's how we get so many mixes that sound like they were recorded in a cave. This method is an attempt to work around the brain's tendency. Give it a try. Peace, Paul +1 |
#14
Posted to rec.audio.pro
|
|||
|
|||
only one real issue I'm finding with monitor speaker setup versuscar
On 03/10/2018 11:18 AM, PStamler wrote:
When deciding how much reverb to add to a mix, I have a pretty simple technique: 1. Start out with no reverb. 2. Turn up the reverb until it sounds right. 3. Then turn it down 6dB from that point. That sounds like a good method, although once accustomed to the 6dB down level, it might replace it self as #2 which would make #3 detrimental. |
#15
Posted to rec.audio.pro
|
|||
|
|||
only one real issue I'm finding with monitor speaker setup versus car
In article , JBI wrote:
Been over a week now since using the recommended Presonus E5's and Behringer 202. While I'm finding it much easier to judge and correct for proper equalization, anytime I try and manipulate either stereo width, add reverb or similar, it never sounds very good in the car but will sound good on these monitors. Recommendations? Keep doing it, and keep listening, and if possible listen on as many other systems as you can. Eventually you will figure out that really nothing ever sounds very good in the car, but you may specifically learn some things that always sound bad and can be avoided (like excessive stuff in the 120 Hz range where cars are frequently boomy). --scott -- "C'est un Nagra. C'est suisse, et tres, tres precis." |
#16
Posted to rec.audio.pro
|
|||
|
|||
only one real issue I'm finding with monitor speaker setup versuscar
On 03/09/2018 11:43 AM, JBI wrote:
Been over a week now since using the recommended Presonus E5's and Behringer 202. While I'm finding it much easier to judge and correct for proper equalization, anytime I try and manipulate either stereo width, add reverb or similar, it never sounds very good in the car but will sound good on these monitors. Recommendations? I didn't read the whole thread, but does the car have Aux in or Bluetooth? If so, couldn't you just do your mixing in the car with a laptop? |
#17
Posted to rec.audio.pro
|
|||
|
|||
only one real issue I'm finding with monitor speaker setup versuscar
On 10/03/2018 8:43 AM, JBI wrote:
Been over a week now since using the recommended Presonus E5's and Behringer 202.Â* While I'm finding it much easier to judge and correct for proper equalization, anytime I try and manipulate either stereo width, add reverb or similar, it never sounds very good in the car but will sound good on these monitors.Â* Recommendations? I think we need to get this straight again, 'cos I'm a bit confused. Pick one or mo 1 - You want to master on speakers that are made to sound like things did when listening in your car ? 2 - Destination listening environment is your car ? 3 - Destination listening environment is anywhere (everywhere) else ? 4 - You want to make things sound on hi-fi systems like stuff does in your car ? 5 - You want to make the mastering results (for 'anywhere' listening environments) sound like the resultant sound like it did when mastering in your car ? 6 - You do not wish to adjust your technique to mastering on a system that sounds simply as good as it can be, forgetting the car scenario entirely ? Or something else ? geoff |
#18
Posted to rec.audio.pro
|
|||
|
|||
only one real issue I'm finding with monitor speaker setup versuscar
On 03/12/2018 09:14 PM, geoff wrote:
On 10/03/2018 8:43 AM, JBI wrote: Been over a week now since using the recommended Presonus E5's and Behringer 202.Â* While I'm finding it much easier to judge and correct for proper equalization, anytime I try and manipulate either stereo width, add reverb or similar, it never sounds very good in the car but will sound good on these monitors.Â* Recommendations? I think we need to get this straight again, 'cos I'm a bit confused. Pick one or mo 1 - You want to master on speakers that are made to sound like things did when listening in your car ? Yes, but since I have the speakers, I have found it much easier to adjust the eq coming over the monitors to come much closer to how the car sounds. 2 - Destination listening environment is your car ? Pretty much as that's all I have (besides the recent new monitor additions in the house). 3 - Destination listening environment is anywhere (everywhere) else ? Not really, just the house now on the monitors or mostly in the car. 4 -Â* You want to make things sound on hi-fi systems like stuff does in your car ? 5 - You want to make the mastering results (for 'anywhere' listening environments) sound like the resultant sound like it did when mastering in your car ? Not sure what you mean by 4 & 5. 6 - You do not wish to adjust your technique to mastering on a system that sounds simply as good as it can be, forgetting the car scenario entirely ? No, not entirely. These monitors have pretty much solved the issue of mixing in the house to sound similar to the car. I can roughly add the same amount of EQ I get in the car at the DAW output and, on these new monitors, for the first time ever, the sound is close enough. The only issue remaining is reverb/ echo and/or stereo. I'm finding it hard to mimic what I hear in the house versus the car, but someone earlier in the week suggested to adjust to what sounded good in the house, then back off a certain amount of db. That seems to be the best compromise. I don't think the car's ever going to sound any better without better speakers or better placement. Overall, I'm pretty happy now, and it certainly beats what I used to do by dragging the laptop out to the car everytime I wanted to adjust EQ on something or mix. Or something else ? geoff |
#19
Posted to rec.audio.pro
|
|||
|
|||
only one real issue I'm finding with monitor speaker setup versuscar
On 3/13/2018 11:03 PM, JBI wrote:
6 - You do not wish to adjust your technique to mastering on a system that sounds simply as good as it can be, forgetting the car scenario entirely ? No, not entirely.Â* These monitors have pretty much solved the issue of mixing in the house to sound similar to the car.Â* I can roughly add the same amount of EQ I get in the car at the DAW output and, on these new monitors, for the first time ever, the sound is close enough. So what you hear in the house (after EQ and other adjustments) sounds like what you're accustomed to hearing in the car? And when you take this mucked-up-to-sound-like-the-car mix out to the car, it still sounds like you mixed it in the house? That would be odd. That sounds like maybe you're taking out frequencies that the car environment emphasizes - then in the car, there's nothing there (or rather less there) to emphasize so it doesn't change much traveling from the house to the car. The only issue remaining is reverb/ echo and/or stereo.Â* I'm finding it hard to mimic what I hear in the house versus the car, but someone earlier in the week suggested to adjust to what sounded good in the house, then back off a certain amount of db.Â* That seems to be the best compromise.Â* I don't think the car's ever going to sound any better without better speakers or better placement. The other thing about listening in the car is that if the left/right balance is centered (in the car radio) and you're in the driver's seat, you aren't hearing very much of what's in the right channel - neither program material nor ambience. It won't be right either if you adjust the radio's panning control (by 2000, most car radios did have one) so, from your listening position, what's in the center sounds like it's in the center, but it might give you a clue as to how to make an "unbalanced" mix that will work better from where you're sitting while driving. -- For a good time, call http://mikeriversaudio.wordpress.com |
#20
Posted to rec.audio.pro
|
|||
|
|||
only one real issue I'm finding with monitor speaker setup versus car
Mike Rivers wrote: "the radio's panning control (by 2000, most car radios did
have one) so," Are you referring to the BALANCE control? Because every car I have ever riden in or drove has had one of those, even cars from the sixties. On the other hand, I have never seen, in any post-2000 model I've been in, a "panning" control. And we're taking Chevys, Hyundais, Toyotas, Subarus, Hondas, you name it. As for what this guy is attempting to do, it sounds like he wants to master stuff so it sounds great from his position in the drivers seat of his daily driver. So some advice for how to configure the front seat area as a mastering suite while parked might be helpful here. He should be forewarned that such masters will sound like CRAP anywhere else they are played, except maybe in a car of identical make, year, and model, with same sound system with same tone/EQ settings. |
#22
Posted to rec.audio.pro
|
|||
|
|||
only one real issue I'm finding with monitor speaker setup versuscar
|
#23
Posted to rec.audio.pro
|
|||
|
|||
only one real issue I'm finding with monitor speaker setup versuscar
On 03/14/2018 08:11 AM, Mike Rivers wrote:
On 3/13/2018 11:03 PM, JBI wrote: 6 - You do not wish to adjust your technique to mastering on a system that sounds simply as good as it can be, forgetting the car scenario entirely ? No, not entirely.Â* These monitors have pretty much solved the issue of mixing in the house to sound similar to the car.Â* I can roughly add the same amount of EQ I get in the car at the DAW output and, on these new monitors, for the first time ever, the sound is close enough. So what you hear in the house (after EQ and other adjustments) sounds like what you're accustomed to hearing in the car?Â* And when you take this mucked-up-to-sound-like-the-car mix out to the car, it still sounds like you mixed it in the house? That would be odd. That sounds like maybe you're taking out frequencies that the car environment emphasizes - then in the car, there's nothing there (or rather less there) to emphasize so it doesn't change much traveling from the house to the car. No, Mike, I should have clarified that I just have one of the EQ's in the DAW adjusted as a plug-in. I disable it before saving the audio file, then it sounds good in the car. I just use the plug in activated while mixing on the monitors to get a feel for what the audio will sound like in the vehicle, then turn it off before saving. I have the car MP3 player EQ already preadjusted. The only issue remaining is reverb/ echo and/or stereo.Â* I'm finding it hard to mimic what I hear in the house versus the car, but someone earlier in the week suggested to adjust to what sounded good in the house, then back off a certain amount of db.Â* That seems to be the best compromise.Â* I don't think the car's ever going to sound any better without better speakers or better placement. The other thing about listening in the car is that if the left/right balance is centered (in the car radio) and you're in the driver's seat, you aren't hearing very much of what's in the right channel - neither program material nor ambience. It won't be right either if you adjust the radio's panning control (by 2000, most car radios did have one) so, from your listening position, what's in the center sounds like it's in the center, but it might give you a clue as to how to make an "unbalanced" mix that will work better from where you're sitting while driving. I basically just have to be very gentle with the reverb/ stereo settings. If I can just hear them on the house monitors, the result is ok in the car but because of the imbalance as you mention, I really don't hear either reverb or stereo that well. It's ok, much, much better than it used to be! |
#24
Posted to rec.audio.pro
|
|||
|
|||
only one real issue I'm finding with monitor speaker setup versuscar
On 15/03/2018 7:05 AM, JBI wrote:
On 03/14/2018 08:11 AM, Mike Rivers wrote: On 3/13/2018 11:03 PM, JBI wrote: 6 - You do not wish to adjust your technique to mastering on a system that sounds simply as good as it can be, forgetting the car scenario entirely ? No, not entirely.Â* These monitors have pretty much solved the issue of mixing in the house to sound similar to the car.Â* I can roughly add the same amount of EQ I get in the car at the DAW output and, on these new monitors, for the first time ever, the sound is close enough. So what you hear in the house (after EQ and other adjustments) sounds like what you're accustomed to hearing in the car?Â* And when you take this mucked-up-to-sound-like-the-car mix out to the car, it still sounds like you mixed it in the house? That would be odd. That sounds like maybe you're taking out frequencies that the car environment emphasizes - then in the car, there's nothing there (or rather less there) to emphasize so it doesn't change much traveling from the house to the car. No, Mike, I should have clarified that I just have one of the EQ's in the DAW adjusted as a plug-in.Â* I disable it before saving the audio file, then it sounds good in the car.Â* I just use the plug in activated while mixing on the monitors to get a feel for what the audio will sound like in the vehicle, then turn it off before saving. That makes sense ! Â* I have the car MP3 player EQ already preadjusted. I assume this music that you are mastering is your own recording ? So why not master stuff to sound 'good' anywhere, and leave the in-car sound to be adjusted in the car, to your liking, as would any music you may be hearing from other sources (radio, CD, downloads, etc) ? Or if you are adjusting music from other sources, then why bother at all - just readjust the EQ in you car listening environment instead ? .. I basically just have to be very gentle with the reverb/ stereo settings.Â* If I can just hear them on the house monitors, the result is ok in the car but because of the imbalance as you mention, I really don't hear either reverb or stereo that well.Â* It's ok, much, much better than it used to be! Don't know about your car, but road noise masks much subtlety unless I'm listening way too loud, or parked up. geoff |
#25
Posted to rec.audio.pro
|
|||
|
|||
only one real issue I'm finding with monitor speaker setup versus car
To JBI:
May I recommend to you the current (March) issue of Recording magazine? The issue's focus is on monitoring, and it's got several articles you might find valuable. Better hurry; the April issue will hit the stands any day now. Peace, Paul |
Reply |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
Kyoto Hypocracy - The Real Issue | Audio Opinions | |||
Kyoto Hypocracy - The Real Issue | Vacuum Tubes | |||
A *Real Engineer* Speaks on LP versus CD | Audio Opinions | |||
Denon AVR 3806 setup issue. | High End Audio | |||
Diamond Cut DC6 versus Adobe Audition versus GoldWave | Tech |