Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
#1
Posted to rec.audio.pro
|
|||
|
|||
Tektronix 2430A noisey traces
I recently acquired a used Tektronix 2430A with a P6122 probe that is
showing a good deal of noise on lower level traces and I'm wondering if it is "normal" or if there may be something wrong with the scope or probe. A 140 mV P-P sine wave from a Minirator is showing about 5 mV of noise on a sine wave: P6122http://img39.imageshack.us/img39/9206/img1851m.jpg I also see the same sort of noise on a square wave from my signal generator connected to the scope with a coax cable: http://img192.imageshack.us/img192/9158/img1849fn.jpg It shows the same thing when connected to the internal calibration oscillator on the scope. I really have only a very basic knowledge of oscilloscope use and I can't remember measuring signal this low with my old BK Precision 2120. I have the Tektronix on a 1 week evaluation and can return it if I choose, but I wouldn't want to do that if there isn't anything wrong with it. I tried it with the TEK P6122 probe that came with the scope and with the generic scope probe from my old BK 2120 and the noise was worse with the generic probe. Is it normal to be fighting noise in this range with scope measurements? Would this be a common issue with a maladjusted scope that would be cleared up with a calibration (this one was calibrated 2 years ago according to the sticker on it)? Are there other tests I could run to confirm normal functioning? Any help would be much appreciated. Thanks, Andy |
#2
Posted to rec.audio.pro
|
|||
|
|||
Tektronix 2430A noisey traces
On 3/27/2012 6:27 AM, apa wrote:
I recently acquired a used Tektronix 2430A with a P6122 probe that is showing a good deal of noise on lower level traces and I'm wondering if it is "normal" or if there may be something wrong with the scope or probe. A 140 mV P-P sine wave from a Minirator is showing about 5 mV of noise on a sine wave: Do you have another test source other than the Minirator? I have an MR-Pro and an MR-1 and both are a bit noisy at low levels, though it's not usually a problem until getting down to levels around -60 dBu, some 30 dB lower than what you're looking at. The old style with the swing-out XLR connector had connector problems that requires a little fiddling with either hte XLR or RCA connector to get a quiet signal. The MR-PRO doesn't have an output attenuator, so the level adjustment is done digitally - lower level = fewer bits = more noise. They recommend putting a 20 or 40 dB pad after the output for testing with low levels. Be that as it may, it looks like "digital" noise and that might be a characteristic of the scope. I'd check it with a shorted input and see if a straight line looks ragged (like the top and bottom of your square wave). If it does, I'd return the scope. It may or may not be defective, but either way it's not suitable if you want to be looking at low level audio signals. -- "Today's production equipment is IT based and cannot be operated without a passing knowledge of computing, although it seems that it can be operated without a passing knowledge of audio." - John Watkinson http://mikeriversaudio.wordpress.com - useful and interesting audio stuff |
#3
Posted to rec.audio.pro
|
|||
|
|||
Tektronix 2430A noisey traces
On Mar 27, 8:02*am, Mike Rivers wrote:
On 3/27/2012 6:27 AM, apa wrote: I recently acquired a used Tektronix 2430A with a P6122 probe that is showing a good deal of noise on lower level traces and I'm wondering if it is "normal" or if there may be something wrong with the scope or probe. A 140 mV P-P sine wave from a Minirator is showing about 5 mV of noise on a sine wave: Do you have another test source other than the Minirator? I have an MR-Pro and an MR-1 and both are a bit noisy at low levels, though it's not usually a problem until getting down to levels around -60 dBu, some 30 dB lower than what you're looking at. The old style with the swing-out XLR connector had connector problems that requires a little fiddling with either hte XLR or RCA connector to get a quiet signal. The MR-PRO doesn't have an output attenuator, so the level adjustment is done digitally - lower level = fewer bits = more noise. They recommend putting a 20 or 40 dB pad after the output for testing with low levels. Be that as it may, it looks like "digital" noise and that might be a characteristic of the scope. I'd check it with a shorted input and see if a straight line looks ragged (like the top and bottom of your square wave). If it does, I'd return the scope. It may or may not be defective, but either way it's not suitable if you want to be looking at low level audio signals. -- "Today's production equipment is IT based and cannot be operated without a passing knowledge of computing, although it seems that it can be operated without a passing knowledge of audio." - John Watkinson http://mikeriversaudio.wordpress.com- useful and interesting audio stuff Thanks Mike. It does look the same with a shorted input. I've never had a digital scope so I don't know what's normal for digital noise. I have a lot of higher level signals to work with too and the storage function is really nice to have so I may keep it if it's not overtly dysfunctional. Best, Andy |
#4
Posted to rec.audio.pro
|
|||
|
|||
Tektronix 2430A noisey traces
apa wrote:
Thanks Mike. It does look the same with a shorted input. I've never had a digital scope so I don't know what's normal for digital noise. I have a lot of higher level signals to work with too and the storage function is really nice to have so I may keep it if it's not overtly dysfunctional. The digital scope has the same front end as the analogue scope... it does not digitize the signal until it's already been amplified. So the noise should not be any different. Most of those scopes have 8 or 12 bit resolution, and no anti-aliasing. The resolution is high enough for the LCD display, but if the display were much larger (or if you used a trace-expand function) it might not be. Still, if that were the case, you wouldn't see noise so much as jaggies. The lack of anti-aliasing is what really gets me using the digital scopes. When you have high frequency junk, instead of seeing smearing, you see weird waveform changes. You can tell this is going on because when you change the sweep rate on the scope, the waveform changes, so it's not a major problem. But you have to bother to look for it, unlike the smearing on analogue scopes that you can't help but see. I find the latency on the digital scopes makes tweak-and-peak stuff like setting tape machine azimuth to be very frustrating. On the other hand, the ability to do very very low speed sweeps is wonderful for doing swept sine testing, and and you can see glitches and popcorn noise much more easily with the ability to freeze a waveform and go back to it. --scott -- "C'est un Nagra. C'est suisse, et tres, tres precis." |
#5
Posted to rec.audio.pro
|
|||
|
|||
Tektronix 2430A noisey traces
When I short the probe I get the same sort of "noise" on an otherwise
straight line at 0 volts. On Mar 27, 9:49*am, "Soundhaspriority" wrote: What happens when you short the probe tip? Bob Morein (310) 237-6511 "apa" wrote in message ... I recently acquired a used Tektronix 2430A with a P6122 probe that is showing a good deal of noise on lower level traces and I'm wondering if it is "normal" or if there may be something wrong with the scope or probe. A 140 mV P-P sine wave from a Minirator is showing about 5 mV of noise on a sine wave: P6122http://img39.imageshack.us/img39/9206/img1851m.jpg I also see the same sort of noise on a square wave from my signal generator connected to the scope with a coax cable: http://img192.imageshack.us/img192/9158/img1849fn.jpg It shows the same thing when connected to the internal calibration oscillator on the scope. I really have only a very basic knowledge of oscilloscope use and I can't remember measuring signal this low with my old BK Precision 2120. I have the Tektronix on a 1 week evaluation and can return it if I choose, but I wouldn't want to do that if there isn't anything wrong with it. I tried it with the TEK P6122 probe that came with the scope and with the generic scope probe from my old BK 2120 and the noise was worse with the generic probe. Is it normal to be fighting noise in this range with scope measurements? Would this be a common issue with a maladjusted scope that would be cleared up with a calibration (this one was calibrated 2 years ago according to the sticker on it)? Are there other tests I could run to confirm normal functioning? Any help would be much appreciated. Thanks, Andy |
#6
Posted to rec.audio.pro
|
|||
|
|||
Tektronix 2430A noisey traces
Is this a 10x probe?
If you are reading 5mV of noise on a 10x probe, that is 0.5mV of noise of actual noise in the scope. Even if it a x1 probe, that does not seem like an excess amount of noise. The trace on my 60MHz scope looks a little fuzzy on the highest gain setting which is 5mV on x1 or 50mV on 10x. Its probably perfectly normal. Mark "apa" wrote in message ... When I short the probe I get the same sort of "noise" on an otherwise straight line at 0 volts. On Mar 27, 9:49 am, "Soundhaspriority" wrote: What happens when you short the probe tip? Bob Morein (310) 237-6511 "apa" wrote in message ... I recently acquired a used Tektronix 2430A with a P6122 probe that is showing a good deal of noise on lower level traces and I'm wondering if it is "normal" or if there may be something wrong with the scope or probe. A 140 mV P-P sine wave from a Minirator is showing about 5 mV of noise on a sine wave: P6122http://img39.imageshack.us/img39/9206/img1851m.jpg I also see the same sort of noise on a square wave from my signal generator connected to the scope with a coax cable: http://img192.imageshack.us/img192/9158/img1849fn.jpg It shows the same thing when connected to the internal calibration oscillator on the scope. I really have only a very basic knowledge of oscilloscope use and I can't remember measuring signal this low with my old BK Precision 2120. I have the Tektronix on a 1 week evaluation and can return it if I choose, but I wouldn't want to do that if there isn't anything wrong with it. I tried it with the TEK P6122 probe that came with the scope and with the generic scope probe from my old BK 2120 and the noise was worse with the generic probe. Is it normal to be fighting noise in this range with scope measurements? Would this be a common issue with a maladjusted scope that would be cleared up with a calibration (this one was calibrated 2 years ago according to the sticker on it)? Are there other tests I could run to confirm normal functioning? Any help would be much appreciated. Thanks, Andy |
#7
Posted to rec.audio.pro
|
|||
|
|||
Tektronix 2430A noisey traces
"apa" wrote in message ... I recently acquired a used Tektronix 2430A with a P6122 probe that is showing a good deal of noise on lower level traces and I'm wondering if it is "normal" or if there may be something wrong with the scope or probe. A 140 mV P-P sine wave from a Minirator is showing about 5 mV of noise on a sine wave: P6122http://img39.imageshack.us/img39/9206/img1851m.jpg I also see the same sort of noise on a square wave from my signal generator connected to the scope with a coax cable: http://img192.imageshack.us/img192/9158/img1849fn.jpg It shows the same thing when connected to the internal calibration oscillator on the scope. I really have only a very basic knowledge of oscilloscope use and I can't remember measuring signal this low with my old BK Precision 2120. I have the Tektronix on a 1 week evaluation and can return it if I choose, but I wouldn't want to do that if there isn't anything wrong with it. I tried it with the TEK P6122 probe that came with the scope and with the generic scope probe from my old BK 2120 and the noise was worse with the generic probe. Is it normal to be fighting noise in this range with scope measurements? Would this be a common issue with a maladjusted scope that would be cleared up with a calibration (this one was calibrated 2 years ago according to the sticker on it)? Are there other tests I could run to confirm normal functioning? Any help would be much appreciated. Thanks, Andy This site has a screnshot very similar to yours: http://www.ecrunch.com/listing/Tektr...illoscope.html Gareth. |
Reply |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
Interpreting scope traces | Vacuum Tubes | |||
noisey tube | Vacuum Tubes | |||
stripping pcb traces? | Tech | |||
stripping pcb traces? | Vacuum Tubes |