Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Componenet Speaker Setup Questions
Hi all,
I have a pair of Infinity Kappa Perfect 6.5" separates that are currently running off a 4-channel amp in bridged mode (1+2 channels to left, 3+4 channels to right). The amp is 60w RMS x 4 IIRC, so I'm guessing about 150 x 2 in the bridged mode (right?). The separates are rated (again IIRC) at 90w per side. I'm thinking about getting rid of the crossovers that came with the separates and biamping them instead. Since the tweeters are placed about a foot away from the woofers, this will allow me to take better advantage of the time alignment settings on my HU as well as the crossover selections. My HU is an Eclipse 8443. Also, the parametric EQ on the unit is 5 bands for the highs and 5 bands for the mids--"highs" being one pair of RCAs and "mids" being another pair. Since I have the components connected to only one pair right now, I can only use half the EQ. I would like to know if the tweeters use significantly less power than the woofers. If so, I'd hate to use the amp in 4 channel mode and "waste" 2 60w channels on the tweets and have only 60w left over for the woofers. Would it work out better to keep the amp in bridged mode driving only the woofers and let the tweeters run straight off the HU? I believe this unit has a pretty capable amp section, but I'm not sure if (a) it would sound better than using the amp in 4 channel mode or (b) if the Eclipse keeps it's amp section on in PRO mode. Sorry if I've left anything out, not sure if I'm being clear enough here. Thanks! -Bill |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
Componenet Speaker Setup Questions
Bill Pallies wrote
Hi all, I have a pair of Infinity Kappa Perfect 6.5" separates that are currently running off a 4-channel amp in bridged mode (1+2 channels to left, 3+4 channels to right). The amp is 60w RMS x 4 IIRC, so I'm guessing about 150 x 2 in the bridged mode (right?). All things being equal you should get ~240 x 2 bridged (60 x 4 @ 4ohm, 120 x 4 @ 2ohm, 240 x 2 @ 4ohm) The separates are rated (again IIRC) at 90w per side. I'm thinking about getting rid of the crossovers that came with the separates and biamping them instead. Since the tweeters are placed about a foot away from the woofers, this will allow me to take better advantage of the time alignment settings on my HU as well as the crossover selections. My HU is an Eclipse 8443. Also, the parametric EQ on the unit is 5 bands for the highs and 5 bands for the mids--"highs" being one pair of RCAs and "mids" being another pair. Since I have the components connected to only one pair right now, I can only use half the EQ. I would like to know if the tweeters use significantly less power than the woofers. If so, I'd hate to use the amp in 4 channel mode and "waste" 2 60w channels on the tweets and have only 60w left over for the woofers. You won't waste power bi-amping. But you will have more control given the extra eq available. Would it work out better to keep the amp in bridged mode driving only the woofers and let the tweeters run straight off the HU? I doubt it would work out better, you could try it to see what it sounds like though (of course, that would leave you with ~240W for each 6 1/2) I believe this unit has a pretty capable amp section, but I'm not sure if (a) it would sound better than using the amp in 4 channel mode or (b) if the Eclipse keeps it's amp section on in PRO mode. Sorry if I've left anything out, not sure if I'm being clear enough here. You will have to try running it both ways (for a week at least) to develop a preference ... then go with what you like best. Your opinion will differ from everyone else's, so just make yourself happy. If it were me ... I would bi-amp it (in fact, that will be what I do with my setup once I get an amp for the sub) -- Regards, Dan Snooks |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
Componenet Speaker Setup Questions
I doubt he'll get over 180x2. Very few amps will double in power when you
halve the load. Paul Vina "Daniel Snooks" wrote in message ... Bill Pallies wrote Hi all, I have a pair of Infinity Kappa Perfect 6.5" separates that are currently running off a 4-channel amp in bridged mode (1+2 channels to left, 3+4 channels to right). The amp is 60w RMS x 4 IIRC, so I'm guessing about 150 x 2 in the bridged mode (right?). All things being equal you should get ~240 x 2 bridged (60 x 4 @ 4ohm, 120 x 4 @ 2ohm, 240 x 2 @ 4ohm) The separates are rated (again IIRC) at 90w per side. I'm thinking about getting rid of the crossovers that came with the separates and biamping them instead. Since the tweeters are placed about a foot away from the woofers, this will allow me to take better advantage of the time alignment settings on my HU as well as the crossover selections. My HU is an Eclipse 8443. Also, the parametric EQ on the unit is 5 bands for the highs and 5 bands for the mids--"highs" being one pair of RCAs and "mids" being another pair. Since I have the components connected to only one pair right now, I can only use half the EQ. I would like to know if the tweeters use significantly less power than the woofers. If so, I'd hate to use the amp in 4 channel mode and "waste" 2 60w channels on the tweets and have only 60w left over for the woofers. You won't waste power bi-amping. But you will have more control given the extra eq available. Would it work out better to keep the amp in bridged mode driving only the woofers and let the tweeters run straight off the HU? I doubt it would work out better, you could try it to see what it sounds like though (of course, that would leave you with ~240W for each 6 1/2) I believe this unit has a pretty capable amp section, but I'm not sure if (a) it would sound better than using the amp in 4 channel mode or (b) if the Eclipse keeps it's amp section on in PRO mode. Sorry if I've left anything out, not sure if I'm being clear enough here. You will have to try running it both ways (for a week at least) to develop a preference ... then go with what you like best. Your opinion will differ from everyone else's, so just make yourself happy. If it were me ... I would bi-amp it (in fact, that will be what I do with my setup once I get an amp for the sub) -- Regards, Dan Snooks |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
Componenet Speaker Setup Questions
Paul Vina wrote
I doubt he'll get over 180x2. Very few amps will double in power when you halve the load. Paul Vina Very few? That's a bit harsh. Besides, we are throwing ratings around, which is significantly different than what may happen with real world output. It would help if the OP let us know who makes the amp he has. I know that my two amps are rated conservatively at : Zapco AG200 - 50 x 2 @ 4ohm - 100 x 2 @ 2ohm - 195 x 1 @ 4ohm PPI PC450 - 50 x 4 @ 4ohm - 100 x 4 @ 2ohm - 200 x 2 @ 4ohm You are suggesting that he will only realize ~75% power when bridging (180 instead of 240). I very much doubt my Zapco is only good for 145 x 1 @ 4ohm, despite the ratings given. -- Regards, Dan Snooks |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
Componenet Speaker Setup Questions
It's been proven in just about every product test done on an amp. Look at
the online reviews at CarSound for instance. Very few off them will double. I'm not saying that none of them do, but it's only the very best amps that will do it. Most mid and low end amp will current limit and prevent a doubling. Paul Vina "Daniel Snooks" wrote in message ... Paul Vina wrote I doubt he'll get over 180x2. Very few amps will double in power when you halve the load. Paul Vina Very few? That's a bit harsh. Besides, we are throwing ratings around, which is significantly different than what may happen with real world output. It would help if the OP let us know who makes the amp he has. I know that my two amps are rated conservatively at : Zapco AG200 - 50 x 2 @ 4ohm - 100 x 2 @ 2ohm - 195 x 1 @ 4ohm PPI PC450 - 50 x 4 @ 4ohm - 100 x 4 @ 2ohm - 200 x 2 @ 4ohm You are suggesting that he will only realize ~75% power when bridging (180 instead of 240). I very much doubt my Zapco is only good for 145 x 1 @ 4ohm, despite the ratings given. -- Regards, Dan Snooks |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
Componenet Speaker Setup Questions
For some reason it didn't occur to me to actually look up the numbers when I
first posted. The specs state 180w x 2 when bridged. The amp is a Kenwood by the way. http://tinyurl.com/ub1b -Bill "Paul Vina" wrote in message news:Gawrb.113194$275.321464@attbi_s53... It's been proven in just about every product test done on an amp. Look at the online reviews at CarSound for instance. Very few off them will double. I'm not saying that none of them do, but it's only the very best amps that will do it. Most mid and low end amp will current limit and prevent a doubling. Paul Vina "Daniel Snooks" wrote in message ... Paul Vina wrote I doubt he'll get over 180x2. Very few amps will double in power when you halve the load. Paul Vina Very few? That's a bit harsh. Besides, we are throwing ratings around, which is significantly different than what may happen with real world output. It would help if the OP let us know who makes the amp he has. I know that my two amps are rated conservatively at : Zapco AG200 - 50 x 2 @ 4ohm - 100 x 2 @ 2ohm - 195 x 1 @ 4ohm PPI PC450 - 50 x 4 @ 4ohm - 100 x 4 @ 2ohm - 200 x 2 @ 4ohm You are suggesting that he will only realize ~75% power when bridging (180 instead of 240). I very much doubt my Zapco is only good for 145 x 1 @ 4ohm, despite the ratings given. -- Regards, Dan Snooks |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
Componenet Speaker Setup Questions
Bill Pallies wrote
For some reason it didn't occur to me to actually look up the numbers when I first posted. The specs state 180w x 2 when bridged. The amp is a Kenwood by the way. http://tinyurl.com/ub1b -Bill Heh ... well, there you have it :-) The good news is that I don't have to change my advice from my previous reply. -- Regards, Dan Snooks |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
Componenet Speaker Setup Questions
"Paul Vina" wrote in message news:Gawrb.113194$275.321464@attbi_s53... It's been proven in just about every product test done on an amp. Look at the online reviews at CarSound for instance. Very few off them will double. I'm not saying that none of them do, but it's only the very best amps that will do it. Most mid and low end amp will current limit and prevent a doubling. Paul Vina Very true indeed! Home amplifiers don't always do this either. Nelsen Pass has a saying about amps and it deals with weight per wattage. A mild mannered amp should weigh at least 75-80 pounds due to the amount of copper in it. If its light, you aint getting what you think and a great amp will double as the load halves. Digital and Class D amps are all they're cracked up to be either...yet. I've heard the big dollar bel~Cantos and a few of the others. I'll keep my house vice the two mono-blocks. John |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
Componenet Speaker Setup Questions
Amps (home and car) dont have a specific way to rate them.
If I were an amp manufacturer I could rate my amps at .002% or .02% or .2% or 2.0% or RMS or PEAK or whatever I wanted. (or any other numbers you wanted to make up) (each rating would give me a different power!!!!!) comparing an amp rated at 100watts @ 0.0004% @ 4 ohms to an amp rated at 400watts @ 0.2% @ 4 ohms isnt a fair comparison without knowing alot more. SO, comparing an amp BRIDGED and NONBRIDGED could be the same discrepency.... A manufacturer has the right (as does and amp tester in a review) to rate the amp at any distortion and power output they want to choose... EVEN THOUGH an amp may ACTUALLY double its power the ratings (or the ones that choose which ratings to publish) can and usually do, show other wise. Typicly bridging an amp is just hooking it up differently, if there is 10 volts on one channel and 10 volts on the other channel, then when bridged there is 20 volts on one channel... NO OTHER CHANGE. So, 10 volts into 4 ohms is 25watts and, 20 volts into 4 ohms is 100watts This is a simple matter of unhooking a 4 ohm speaker (or dummy load) from one set of terminals and hooking it up to a different set of terminals... WOULD THE OUTPUT VOLTAGE DROP WHEN YOU DO THIS??? probably not..... But on the other hand... When a manufacture rates an amp or when a tech bench checks an amp he hooks it up to a proper power supply and dummy load then reads output voltage on one meter and percentage of distortion on another meter...He usually chooses a high power rating while still a low distortion and he chooses when to stop turning up the volume knob and he writes down the rating. THEN, he hooks the amp up in a bridged configureation and does the same test over again... He again chooses a point that suits him to stop turning the amp up and writes down the rating HE CHOOSES..... It may or may not be DOUBLE the unbridged power..... but that doesnt mean the amp CANT double the power (or more) if the tech had continued to turn up the volume and disreguaring the distortion ratings ect.... SO, in sumary, I think its kind of missleading to say an amp WONT double its power when bridging if you only look at the RATED SPECS.... The rated specs are simply a rating and no indication of whether an amp CAN DOUBLE (or more).. Hope you guys can follow this.... Eddie Runner http://www.installer.com/tech/ Midlant wrote: "Paul Vina" wrote in message news:Gawrb.113194$275.321464@attbi_s53... It's been proven in just about every product test done on an amp. Look at the online reviews at CarSound for instance. Very few off them will double. I'm not saying that none of them do, but it's only the very best amps that will do it. Most mid and low end amp will current limit and prevent a doubling. Paul Vina Very true indeed! Home amplifiers don't always do this either. Nelsen Pass has a saying about amps and it deals with weight per wattage. A mild mannered amp should weigh at least 75-80 pounds due to the amount of copper in it. If its light, you aint getting what you think and a great amp will double as the load halves. Digital and Class D amps are all they're cracked up to be either...yet. I've heard the big dollar bel~Cantos and a few of the others. I'll keep my house vice the two mono-blocks. John |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
Componenet Speaker Setup Questions
Eddie Runner wrote
Amps (home and car) dont have a specific way to rate them. If I were an amp manufacturer I could rate my amps at .002% or .02% or .2% or 2.0% or RMS or PEAK or whatever I wanted. (or any other numbers you wanted to make up) (each rating would give me a different power!!!!!) comparing an amp rated at 100watts @ 0.0004% @ 4 ohms to an amp rated at 400watts @ 0.2% @ 4 ohms isnt a fair comparison without knowing alot more. SO, comparing an amp BRIDGED and NONBRIDGED could be the same discrepency.... A manufacturer has the right (as does and amp tester in a review) to rate the amp at any distortion and power output they want to choose... EVEN THOUGH an amp may ACTUALLY double its power the ratings (or the ones that choose which ratings to publish) can and usually do, show other wise. Typicly bridging an amp is just hooking it up differently, if there is 10 volts on one channel and 10 volts on the other channel, then when bridged there is 20 volts on one channel... NO OTHER CHANGE. So, 10 volts into 4 ohms is 25watts and, 20 volts into 4 ohms is 100watts This is a simple matter of unhooking a 4 ohm speaker (or dummy load) from one set of terminals and hooking it up to a different set of terminals... WOULD THE OUTPUT VOLTAGE DROP WHEN YOU DO THIS??? probably not..... But on the other hand... When a manufacture rates an amp or when a tech bench checks an amp he hooks it up to a proper power supply and dummy load then reads output voltage on one meter and percentage of distortion on another meter...He usually chooses a high power rating while still a low distortion and he chooses when to stop turning up the volume knob and he writes down the rating. THEN, he hooks the amp up in a bridged configureation and does the same test over again... He again chooses a point that suits him to stop turning the amp up and writes down the rating HE CHOOSES..... It may or may not be DOUBLE the unbridged power..... but that doesnt mean the amp CANT double the power (or more) if the tech had continued to turn up the volume and disreguaring the distortion ratings ect.... SO, in sumary, I think its kind of missleading to say an amp WONT double its power when bridging if you only look at the RATED SPECS.... The rated specs are simply a rating and no indication of whether an amp CAN DOUBLE (or more).. Hope you guys can follow this.... Thanks Eddie, followed it very well ... and the truth is that both my Zapco and PPI are rated with a higher distortion allowance when bridged then in stereo. -- Regards, Dan Snooks |
#11
|
|||
|
|||
Componenet Speaker Setup Questions
Followed that perfectly. Thanks Eddie!
So, um, if the component set is rated to handle 100w RMS, I'm still wondering if I'm better off keeping the bridged configuration and thus having plenty of power available to the speaker, or if I should give 60w to the woofer and 60w to the tweeters (which is a lot for a tweeter, no?). This is what I mean by "wasting" power. -Bill P.S. Also, I've heard that underpowering a speaker will blow it more than overpowering one, right guys? ..... Guys? .... Hello? :-) "Eddie Runner" wrote in message ... Amps (home and car) dont have a specific way to rate them. If I were an amp manufacturer I could rate my amps at .002% or .02% or .2% or 2.0% or RMS or PEAK or whatever I wanted. (or any other numbers you wanted to make up) (each rating would give me a different power!!!!!) comparing an amp rated at 100watts @ 0.0004% @ 4 ohms to an amp rated at 400watts @ 0.2% @ 4 ohms isnt a fair comparison without knowing alot more. SO, comparing an amp BRIDGED and NONBRIDGED could be the same discrepency.... A manufacturer has the right (as does and amp tester in a review) to rate the amp at any distortion and power output they want to choose... EVEN THOUGH an amp may ACTUALLY double its power the ratings (or the ones that choose which ratings to publish) can and usually do, show other wise. Typicly bridging an amp is just hooking it up differently, if there is 10 volts on one channel and 10 volts on the other channel, then when bridged there is 20 volts on one channel... NO OTHER CHANGE. So, 10 volts into 4 ohms is 25watts and, 20 volts into 4 ohms is 100watts This is a simple matter of unhooking a 4 ohm speaker (or dummy load) from one set of terminals and hooking it up to a different set of terminals... WOULD THE OUTPUT VOLTAGE DROP WHEN YOU DO THIS??? probably not..... But on the other hand... When a manufacture rates an amp or when a tech bench checks an amp he hooks it up to a proper power supply and dummy load then reads output voltage on one meter and percentage of distortion on another meter...He usually chooses a high power rating while still a low distortion and he chooses when to stop turning up the volume knob and he writes down the rating. THEN, he hooks the amp up in a bridged configureation and does the same test over again... He again chooses a point that suits him to stop turning the amp up and writes down the rating HE CHOOSES..... It may or may not be DOUBLE the unbridged power..... but that doesnt mean the amp CANT double the power (or more) if the tech had continued to turn up the volume and disreguaring the distortion ratings ect.... SO, in sumary, I think its kind of missleading to say an amp WONT double its power when bridging if you only look at the RATED SPECS.... The rated specs are simply a rating and no indication of whether an amp CAN DOUBLE (or more).. Hope you guys can follow this.... Eddie Runner http://www.installer.com/tech/ Midlant wrote: "Paul Vina" wrote in message news:Gawrb.113194$275.321464@attbi_s53... It's been proven in just about every product test done on an amp. Look at the online reviews at CarSound for instance. Very few off them will double. I'm not saying that none of them do, but it's only the very best amps that will do it. Most mid and low end amp will current limit and prevent a doubling. Paul Vina Very true indeed! Home amplifiers don't always do this either. Nelsen Pass has a saying about amps and it deals with weight per wattage. A mild mannered amp should weigh at least 75-80 pounds due to the amount of copper in it. If its light, you aint getting what you think and a great amp will double as the load halves. Digital and Class D amps are all they're cracked up to be either...yet. I've heard the big dollar bel~Cantos and a few of the others. I'll keep my house vice the two mono-blocks. John |
#12
|
|||
|
|||
Componenet Speaker Setup Questions
Bill Pallies wrote:
So, um, if the component set is rated to handle 100w RMS, Speaker ratings are another thing that MAY or MAYNOT be worth anything at all.... PRO speaker ratings will have a POWER and a frequency (pink noise) and a time (1 hour or more) that the speaker can withstand that rated power before they burn up. CAR speakers generally are nothing like that at all, usually the power ratings are mostly MADE UP and PLASTERED all over the box as a selling tool.... If one company puts 150 watts on the front of the box the next company may put 200 watts just for marketing purposes.... Also many companies have a 100watt, a 120 watt, a 175 watt and a 200 watt 6x9 all on the same motor, so you have to know the power ratings are just for customers to say I WANT THE 200WATT.... ha ha ha I'm still wondering if I'm better off keeping the bridged configuration and thus having plenty of power available to the speaker, or if I should give 60w to the woofer and 60w to the tweeters (which is a lot for a tweeter, no?). This is what I mean by "wasting" power. With most component systems (woofer, xover and tweeter) you would NOT want to hook a 60 watt amp to the woofer and a 60 watt amp to the tweeter. the one 60 watt channel should work fine through the xover distributing the sound correctly over the component set... P.S. Also, I've heard that underpowering a speaker will blow it more than overpowering one, right guys? I wouldnt say that. I might say that clipping blows more speakers that not clipping...!! ha ha ha Eddie Runner |
#13
|
|||
|
|||
Componenet Speaker Setup Questions
On Wed, 12 Nov 2003 18:04:36 GMT, Eddie Runner
wrote: With most component systems (woofer, xover and tweeter) you would NOT want to hook a 60 watt amp to the woofer and a 60 watt amp to the tweeter. the one 60 watt channel should work fine through the xover distributing the sound correctly over the component set... Eddie Runner Speaking of crossovers: As one Eddie to another, ( forgive a newbie ) why do I need crossovers with the componet speakers and a crossover in the HU ? Should I leave the HU crossover off and just let the speaker crossovers connected to the external amp do the work? The amp has high and low pass filters. Are those redundant with speaker crossovers too? TIA Eddie |
#14
|
|||
|
|||
Componenet Speaker Setup Questions
The speaker crossovers only take care of the mid/high transition. The ones
in the HU and the amp would be a low pass for the sub or a high pass to protect the mid fromlow bass. The crossovers in the HU and the amp are also basically the same except the units in the amp are usually a lot more flexible. Paul Vina "Eddie" wrote in message ... On Wed, 12 Nov 2003 18:04:36 GMT, Eddie Runner wrote: With most component systems (woofer, xover and tweeter) you would NOT want to hook a 60 watt amp to the woofer and a 60 watt amp to the tweeter. the one 60 watt channel should work fine through the xover distributing the sound correctly over the component set... Eddie Runner Speaking of crossovers: As one Eddie to another, ( forgive a newbie ) why do I need crossovers with the componet speakers and a crossover in the HU ? Should I leave the HU crossover off and just let the speaker crossovers connected to the external amp do the work? The amp has high and low pass filters. Are those redundant with speaker crossovers too? TIA Eddie |
#15
|
|||
|
|||
Componenet Speaker Setup Questions
Very few off them will double.
I'm not saying that none of them do, Well I am. Paul, you're absolutely right. Speakers will not double their output because of the nonzero output impedance of every single amplifier on the planet. Even if you were using superconductors, there'd still be an output impedance. And Daniel, 75% is hardly unreasonable. The exception is the type of amplifier that adjusts its output voltage based on switches and current demands (eg. JL amps). |
#16
|
|||
|
|||
Componenet Speaker Setup Questions
Followed that perfectly. Thanks Eddie!
So, um, if the component set is rated to handle 100w RMS, I'm still wondering if I'm better off keeping the bridged configuration and thus having plenty of power available to the speaker, or if I should give 60w to the woofer and 60w to the tweeters (which is a lot for a tweeter, no?). This is what I mean by "wasting" power. Yes, I understand what you meant by wasting power. Though it's not a technically precise nomenclature, I'm sure everyone hear gets what you're saying. So you're correct that the bridged situation is optimal in that it provides more power to the speakers. The only benefit to biamping in such a case is to have the ability to adjust crossovers and level controls between the components. This ability shouldn't be overlooked. But if it's not a feature you anticipate needing, then bridge. -Bill P.S. Also, I've heard that underpowering a speaker will blow it more than overpowering one, right guys? .... Guys? ... Hello? :-) Sarcasm detected. |
#17
|
|||
|
|||
Componenet Speaker Setup Questions
Mark Zarella wrote
And Daniel, 75% is hardly unreasonable. Point taken ... if measurments were taken with care to match the distortion levels, I might only get 145W bridged. -- Regards, Dan Snooks |
Reply |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
Bose 901 Review | General | |||
Questions about Component Speaker Systems | Car Audio | |||
Weird static right-front speaker only: factory radio: 93 Civic (Very loud at times!) | Car Audio | |||
Ford Taurus Multiple amps CRAZY setup | Car Audio | |||
6 speaker setup | Car Audio |