Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
#1
Posted to rec.audio.tech
|
|||
|
|||
Req - info on Bill Fitzmaurice's speaker designs
When I occasionally feel the need to build a set of pro speakers, it is usually because I
want a light, compact, high power, high efficiency system for the cost of a box-on-a-stick. I couldn't justify the design time commitment, and most designs I've found on the www are either innovative but misguided, or simple reflex boxes, and don't help me at all. Bill Fitzmaurice (www.billfitzmaurice.com) seems to design speakers whose SPL plots look useful, but Bill's website gives very little real information, the graphs seem a little inconsistent, the test facilities seem limited, and he even uses cheap piezo tweeters in some models, so I'd appreciate hearing from anyone who has experience with them, or has plans for good light tops (on sticks) and a sub. The DR-200 and DR-250 are said to offer the absolute best possible performance, but also the most build difficulty. Maybe they really do need to be complex to get the performance? Maybe they contain unnecessary complications? Maybe the design hasn't been thought through properly and optimized for manufacture? Also, I tried tweeter line arrays decades ago and found the phasing colouration unacceptable for any system, so what might make these designs any better? Ditto for the somewhat different kind of colouration of crossfire arrays? The OT-12 is a much simpler contender, but it would need a complex crossover to avoid both tweeter damage when driven hard, and a notch around the crossover frequency. The T-36 and T-HT subs seem to perform very well, but both are far too large for me, and all the others seem to be aimed at DJ / club applications with good extension to 30 Hz, but lacking in the 50 Hz region critical for bass and kick drum in bands (my application). This may also imply that the drivers are not well loaded around 50 Hz, greatly reducing the available SPL. Maybe the lower resonance (presumably a port) could be tuned higher to fix this? Or maybe a 6th order bandpass might still be better for my sub? Without more detail its impossible to judge all these things from the website, or whether Bill's SPL efficiencies are gained by just omitting the proper damping, or how much the various SPL plots are averaged. Bill's plans don't cost much, but with so many unknowns I'd prefer some feedback before buying any. |
#2
Posted to rec.audio.tech
|
|||
|
|||
Req - info on Bill Fitzmaurice's speaker designs
Tony wrote:
When I occasionally feel the need to build a set of pro speakers, it is usually because I want a light, compact, high power, high efficiency system for the cost of a box-on-a-stick. I couldn't justify the design time commitment, and most designs I've found on the www are either innovative but misguided, or simple reflex boxes, and don't help me at all. Bill Fitzmaurice (www.billfitzmaurice.com) seems to design speakers whose SPL plots look useful, but Bill's website gives very little real information, the graphs seem a little inconsistent, the test facilities seem limited, and he even uses cheap piezo tweeters in some models, so I'd appreciate hearing from anyone who has experience with them, or has plans for good light tops (on sticks) and a sub. Ah yes, light-weight, easy to build, and inexpensive speakers that don't sound inferior to good speakers that cost much more. I wonder why nobody has chanced upon the answer in the last couple of decades..... ? geoff |
#3
Posted to rec.audio.tech
|
|||
|
|||
Req - info on Bill Fitzmaurice's speaker designs
On Fri, 16 May 2008 12:38:03 +1000, Tony wrote:
www.billfitzmaurice.com The DR-200 and DR-250 The model 200 looks like an array of piezo tweeters with some un-named other drivers in a ported box. The claimed 104 dB SPL/1W/1M sensitivity is actually possible in this volume and with the claimed about-190 Hz pole. It would require lower-range drivers of 98 dB/1W/1M sensitivity if four drivers were connected in series-parallel, maintaining the impedance of a single driver and the ability to connect safely to conventional amplifiers. Or, it could be made with four drivers of conventional but high-ish (in this case, 92 dB/1W/1M) sensitivity connected all in parallel, presenting a possibly dangerously low impedance to the driving amplifier. Stick an OhmMeter across the terminals, and report back. A number around an Ohm will be fine for a pro-sound amplifier designed for that gig, but death for anything less. I can't in good conscience say anything comforting about the DR250. Too many holes, too bogus. Just my personal take, of course. I can almost believe the asymtotic 160 Hz knee in that size folded horn, but the sensitivity (a *very* difficult to both measure and, even, to define, number) of 106 dB/1W/1M is *way, way* biggie big. To put it in context, the Klipschorn was (pretty much honestly) rated at 104 dB/1W/1M and the highest sensitivity drivers made (which closely approach the theoretical maximum) are rated at an agreed-upon number of 110 dB/1W/1M. The last number is equivalent to about 30% conversion efficiency, an amazingly big number in the scheme of things. And both at conventional impedances. Well, you wanted opinions; like assholes, everybody's got one. Please forgive if mine is too public. All the best fortune, Chris Hornbeck "I have a gift for enraging people, but if I ever bore you, it'll be with a knife." -Louise Brooks |
#4
Posted to rec.audio.tech
|
|||
|
|||
Req - info on Bill Fitzmaurice's speaker designs
I've never done any measurements on Bill's stuff BUT everyone who builds
them likes them. Where IMO they do a good job especially is for electric bass. If you do not need an extremely percussive and harsh popping sound (which I personally hate) they are very efficient and give great volume out of relatively low powered amps. I wouldn't recommend them for home audio. The K-horn I would, IF you have the right room. I would replace the vintage ass sucking Avedon T-35 tweeter with a JBL or Beyma product for sure. -- Message posted using http://www.talkaboutaudio.com/group/rec.audio.tech/ More information at http://www.talkaboutaudio.com/faq.html |
Reply |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
Looking for info: Digital Designs LS161 | Pro Audio | |||
Looking for info: Digital Designs LS161 | Tech | |||
Gauss speaker info | Pro Audio | |||
Need info about an old limited edition Bose speaker | General | |||
Audax A120-x Speaker...Any info on this model? | Vacuum Tubes |