A Audio and hi-fi forum. AudioBanter

Go Back   Home » AudioBanter forum » rec.audio » Pro Audio
Site Map Home Register Authors List Search Today's Posts Mark Forums Read Web Partners

HDMI vs Analog, Slight humming via HDMI



 
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #1  
Old December 13th 18, 12:44 PM posted to rec.audio.pro
[email protected]
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 39
Default HDMI vs Analog, Slight humming via HDMI

Ladies and Gentlemen,

Today I will go to the repair shop, to tell them the story, and to try and have the DVI monitor repaired.

If it is repaired I will repeat the setup to see if the PC<->receiver HDMI setup will cause damage again.

If it does Ladies and Gentlemen of the electronics industry, then I have you by your BALLS, cause then I have proven that HDMI spec is somewhat FLAWED.

I was just thinking about the difference between Analog and HDMI experiment.

There was something else I NOTICED !

The HDMI connection to the receiver actually produces a SLIGHT HEARABLE HUMMING.

So there is apperently some voltage flowing into the receiver via the HDMI connection which is causing this.

This may seem irrelevant at first but it may actually be very significant.

My hypothesis is that this is the ETHERNET channel that is flowing over the HDMI connection, from laptop to receiver.

The laptop is sending ETHERNET packets over the HDMI cable... the receiver is expecting "audio return channel" packets, but instead receives ethernet packets.

Perhaps it is trying to interpret these packets as AUDIO packets and thus it produces HUMMING.

These are probably ETHERNET handshaking packets.

Very maybe it's possible to send RAW ethernet packets to the receiver with custom software.

In that case the HUMMING might be manipulated into sounding different, proving that this ETHERNET is indeed hearable on the denon 1909 receiver which is 1.3a HDMI.

GT 510 was 1.4 HDMI.

Today I will purchase GT 1030... HDMI unknown... will check later, but will probably not matter much.

IF YOU HATE HUMMING for whatever reason then HDMI is actually a DOWNGRADE HAHA.

FASCINATING ISNT IT.

Turning up the volume on the receiver will probably make the HDMI humming more NOTICEABLE.

Bye,
Skybuck.
Ads
  #2  
Old December 13th 18, 01:05 PM posted to rec.audio.pro
Mike Rivers[_2_]
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 1,968
Default HDMI vs Analog, Slight humming via HDMI

I have two words for you, son: Ground loop.

It happens a lot when there are connections between two pieces of
equipment when the manufacturers of each one haven't taken care of
internal grounding properly. Internet terminal equipment has always been
a prime suspect.

See if the hum goes away when you disconnect the Ethernet cable. Then,
when you've isolated the source of the problem, tear your hair out
trying to find a solution.


--
For a good time, call http://mikeriversaudio.wordpress.com
  #3  
Old December 13th 18, 02:10 PM posted to rec.audio.pro
[email protected]
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 39
Default HDMI vs Analog, Slight humming via HDMI

I found the source of the noise.

I have made a video comparing HDMI vs Analog.

https://youtu.be/7vfPUiGABwI

I tried out different settings.

And ultimately at the end of the video different audio processing options of the denon 1909 receiver.

For some strange reason audio processing is not available for the analog inputs, perhaps this is because HDMI is connected, when HDMI is disconnected maybe audio processing will become available again, not sure about that, will have to do a seperate test of that. (I will check manual too about this might be mentioned).

Anyway at the end of the video when playing around with last ninja music right before I switch to it I notice the "noise" on the speakers. It's maybe not hearable on the video unless maybe setting volume to max, but I do not recommend it for now, I may have to make a new video about this particular noise.

In the video at 13:36 and 13:40 you can see me switching to HDMI/HDP mode and that's when I notice the noise on the speakers (slightly).

I say: "Yeah"

(If you download video try playing it with windows media player, it's a bit faster than vcl media player for playing on low end systems).

I think I now know what/where this noise is coming from.

To re-produce the following steps have to be taken:

1. Switch to HDMI/HDP input

2. Have Auddyssey processing on

3. Have Dynamic EQ/Volume on.

What these "audio processing functions" do is:

They enhance "low volume sounds" which can be very cool especially in combination with 7 CH stereo for games like Warcraft Frozen Throne.

The AL/DirectX 3D sound positioning of the camera high above the battlefield will cause soft sounds like footsteps of soldiers or magic spells or creatures to be very soft/distant and basically not hearable on surround sound systems, maybe even stereo too.

What this denon 1909 receiver processing does, especially if in 7 ch stereo mode:

1. 7 ch stereo mode plays steroe on all channels, especiall sides and rear both basically.

2. The auddyssey processing and dynamic eq/volume further enhance low volume sounds and tune down high volume sounds.

So basically what is happening is:

Where there is no sound playing... apperently there is still a little bit of sound somewhere in the system... some voltages or signal might still be coming in over hdmi...

Maybe just sound from the universe or something.

And auddyssey/dynamic eq/volume picks up on this signal... maybe through fourrier transform techniques.

Or perhaps it's simply enhancing the noise in the denon receiver itself.

Somehow it's detecting a faint noise and basically boosting/enhancing it... which is ofcourse kinda weird.

Reminds me of tape casette decks and playing empty casette tape or something and basically playing noise ?!

Well that's my explanation at least for now.

Though I could do some further experimentation with this auddyssey and dynamic eq/volume and try and see what kind of noise this is by setting the volume really high.

Maybe it will pick up something interesting, ofcourse I shouldn't play any sound otherwise my ears getting blasted =D

Well at least this solves the mystery a little bit and I am not getting closer to solving/digging deeper into this mystery ! =D LOL.

Bye for now,
Skybuck.
  #4  
Old December 13th 18, 02:29 PM posted to rec.audio.pro
[email protected]
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 39
Default HDMI vs Analog, Slight humming via HDMI

On Thursday, December 13, 2018 at 2:10:59 PM UTC+1, wrote:
> I found the source of the noise.
>
> I have made a video comparing HDMI vs Analog.
>
> https://youtu.be/7vfPUiGABwI
>
> I tried out different settings.
>
> And ultimately at the end of the video different audio processing options of the denon 1909 receiver.
>
> For some strange reason audio processing is not available for the analog inputs, perhaps this is because HDMI is connected, when HDMI is disconnected maybe audio processing will become available again, not sure about that, will have to do a seperate test of that. (I will check manual too about this might be mentioned).
>
> Anyway at the end of the video when playing around with last ninja music right before I switch to it I notice the "noise" on the speakers. It's maybe not hearable on the video unless maybe setting volume to max, but I do not recommend it for now, I may have to make a new video about this particular noise.
>
> In the video at 13:36 and 13:40 you can see me switching to HDMI/HDP mode and that's when I notice the noise on the speakers (slightly).
>
> I say: "Yeah"
>
> (If you download video try playing it with windows media player, it's a bit faster than vcl media player for playing on low end systems).
>
> I think I now know what/where this noise is coming from.
>
> To re-produce the following steps have to be taken:
>
> 1. Switch to HDMI/HDP input
>
> 2. Have Auddyssey processing on
>
> 3. Have Dynamic EQ/Volume on.
>
> What these "audio processing functions" do is:
>
> They enhance "low volume sounds" which can be very cool especially in combination with 7 CH stereo for games like Warcraft Frozen Throne.
>
> The AL/DirectX 3D sound positioning of the camera high above the battlefield will cause soft sounds like footsteps of soldiers or magic spells or creatures to be very soft/distant and basically not hearable on surround sound systems, maybe even stereo too.
>
> What this denon 1909 receiver processing does, especially if in 7 ch stereo mode:
>
> 1. 7 ch stereo mode plays steroe on all channels, especiall sides and rear both basically.
>
> 2. The auddyssey processing and dynamic eq/volume further enhance low volume sounds and tune down high volume sounds.
>
> So basically what is happening is:
>
> Where there is no sound playing... apperently there is still a little bit of sound somewhere in the system... some voltages or signal might still be coming in over hdmi...
>
> Maybe just sound from the universe or something.
>
> And auddyssey/dynamic eq/volume picks up on this signal... maybe through fourrier transform techniques.
>
> Or perhaps it's simply enhancing the noise in the denon receiver itself.
>
> Somehow it's detecting a faint noise and basically boosting/enhancing it.... which is ofcourse kinda weird.
>
> Reminds me of tape casette decks and playing empty casette tape or something and basically playing noise ?!
>
> Well that's my explanation at least for now.
>
> Though I could do some further experimentation with this auddyssey and dynamic eq/volume and try and see what kind of noise this is by setting the volume really high.
>
> Maybe it will pick up something interesting, ofcourse I shouldn't play any sound otherwise my ears getting blasted =D
>
> Well at least this solves the mystery a little bit and I am not getting closer to solving/digging deeper into this mystery ! =D LOL.


^

Typo, I ment to write now, but I wrote not, a typo I frequently make.

Corrected:

Well at least this solves the mystery a little bit and I am now getting closer to solving/digging deeper into this mystery ! =D LOL.

(Or maybe I am never gonna get closer to anything lol, time will tell).

Description from/for youtube video:

"
In this video I try to find the source of the HDMI noise.

At 13:36 to 13:40 I notice it and I say: "yeah I hear the noise" something like that.

My explanation/hypothesis for this noise is as follows:

1. It's when HDMI/HDP input is selected.
and possibly
2. It's when auddyssey is ON.
and
3. It's when dynamic EQ/volume is ON

These are audio processing functions of the denon 1909 receiver.

These audio processing functions listen for weak signals in the audio HDMI input signals and ENHANCE then, low signals are increased in volume, loud signals are decreased in volume.

This can be nice for gaming, where weak signals might be unhearable because of 3D positioning/processing by game/directx/audio engines/camera positioning about battlefields like warcraft frozen throne.

Further enhancement can be done with 7 ch stereo playback, which sacrifices surround sound for massive increase in stereo sound, this will sound 2 channel stereo to all speakers.

For true surround sound direct 7.1 or multi ch should be selected, this great for games like World of Warships to hear sounds coming from certain directions and ofcourse for First Person Shooters like Quake, Wolfenstein and so forth.

(The right monitor is actually analog/vga too, it's remarkably sharp thx to it's auto config option in menu).

As far as I am concerned there is very little difference between HDMI and ANALOG audio quality.

The DACs are simply way too good. (Digital to Analog Convertors).

(Only advantage I see so far is more audio processing for HDMI on receiver side, perhaps unplugging HDMI might make this capability available for analog inputs too, not yet sure about that).
"

Bye for now,
Skybuck.
  #5  
Old December 13th 18, 04:14 PM posted to rec.audio.pro
Scott Dorsey
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 16,483
Default HDMI vs Analog, Slight humming via HDMI

> wrote:
>Ladies and Gentlemen,
>
>Today I will go to the repair shop, to tell them the story, and to try and have the DVI monitor repaired.


You have a ground loop. Fix that first.
--scott

--
"C'est un Nagra. C'est suisse, et tres, tres precis."
 




Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

vB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
HDMI in-ports vs HDMI out-ports (possibly related to damaged monitorHDMI OUT to OUT) [email protected] Pro Audio 4 December 7th 18 05:52 AM
verschiedene hdmi kabel , hochwertiges hdmi kabel , hdmi kabelbewertung , hdmi zu hdmi kabel , hdmi kabel forum , dvi kabel zu , hdmi kabeladapter , dvi kabel zu , dvi kabel probleme , hdmi kable , [email protected] Pro Audio 0 May 27th 09 09:37 AM
HDMI to Analog Wayne[_5_] Pro Audio 2 February 10th 08 02:13 PM
Is 5 ch analog out better than HDMI? [email protected] Tech 15 December 26th 07 12:19 AM


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 07:58 PM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2019, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright 2004-2019 AudioBanter.
The comments are property of their posters.