Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
|
#1
Posted to rec.audio.tech
|
|||
|
|||
How safe operating an amp with no fuse?
Did some experiments on the fuse of my amp... I replaced a 500mA 250v fuse with a 1.6a 125v fuse and found the sound much improved. Then I decided to replace the 1.6a fuse with a jumper made of a silver paperclip, and found the sound improved much further. Then I replaced the paper clip with silver solder, and found it improved further (though I'm less sure about the solder being better than the clip overall...). Question is: Exactly what risks are there in running an integrated amp or a preamp sans fuse? I don't care so much about the gear blowing up, since its old gear anyway. But nor do I want a fire started when I leave the amp running all night or am not at home. In the case of the preamp, the casing is solid metal, with the integrated, its a wood casing. What are the chances of fire and how would it start? What are the chances of it blowing up and how might that occur? (so far, no problems!). Is electrical shock a risk with a fuseless amp? |
#2
Posted to rec.audio.tech
|
|||
|
|||
How safe operating an amp with no fuse?
|
#3
Posted to rec.audio.tech
|
|||
|
|||
How safe operating an amp with no fuse?
This has to be the most nonsensical claim I've evr heard.
Do a search on the placebo effect. Fuses don't do ANYTHING to the sound. What a friggin moron. |
#4
Posted to rec.audio.tech
|
|||
|
|||
How safe operating an amp with no fuse?
wrote:
This has to be the most nonsensical claim I've evr heard. Do a search on the placebo effect. Fuses don't do ANYTHING to the sound. What a friggin moron. Do you always talk like this to people in real life, or only when safely ensconced behind a computer? Because if you do, I imagine you have no teeth by now, and its probably hard for you to type anything. As for "the most nonsensical claim I ever heard", you only display your extreme ignorance in matters of audio. First off, I didn't make any "claim" on anything, I only mentioned what I did and heard in order to find out more about the process. Secondly, there are FAR more "nonsensical sounding claims" than the idea that fuses contribute to sonic degradation. That doesn't make those claims false. It just means you are an ignorant clueless asswipe, and you're better off shutting your piehole when certain subjects on audio are discussed that you dont know **** all about. You haven't even heard the effect of what you are stupidly criticizing, in order to realize what an ignorant asswipe you are in the first place. For one thing, Yves Bernard André has fuses custom made for his amplifiers, and his amplifiers are unanimously praised as sounding quite excellent. YOU are the one that needs to "do the research" on the sonic effects of fuses, since you're the one misguided by false information. When you can design amplifiers of this calibre, you might have something relevant to say here. But since you don't have anything useful to contribute to the world, please refer back to my earlier advice about shutting your ignorant piehole. Thank you. |
#5
Posted to rec.audio.tech
|
|||
|
|||
How safe operating an amp with no fuse?
Then both you AND Bernard Andre are fools.
|
#6
Posted to rec.audio.tech
|
|||
|
|||
How safe operating an amp with no fuse?
|
#7
Posted to rec.audio.tech
|
|||
|
|||
How safe operating an amp with no fuse?
|
#8
Posted to rec.audio.tech
|
|||
|
|||
How safe operating an amp with no fuse?
On Tue, 24 Jan 2006 13:21:35 -0500, Walt
wrote: wrote: Did some experiments on the fuse of my amp... I replaced a 500mA 250v fuse with a 1.6a 125v fuse and found the sound much improved. Then I decided to replace the 1.6a fuse with a jumper made of a silver paperclip, and found the sound improved much further. Then I replaced the paper clip with silver solder, and found it improved further (though I'm less sure about the solder being better than the clip overall...). Let me guess: It sounds much more warm without the fuse. LOL. Question is: Exactly what risks are there in running an integrated amp or a preamp sans fuse? You could burn up the power supply, or it could catch on fire. Put the damn fuse back in. You can't fight Darwin. He'll only find some other way to fry himself. d Pearce Consulting http://www.pearce.uk.com |
#9
Posted to rec.audio.tech
|
|||
|
|||
How safe operating an amp with no fuse?
Walt wrote: wrote: Let me guess: It sounds much more warm without the fuse. LOL. No, I wouldn't describe it as that. Without going into minute details, the overall resolution is much higher. Question is: Exactly what risks are there in running an integrated amp or a preamp sans fuse? You could burn up the power supply, or it could catch on fire. Put the damn fuse back in. Could you describe just what condtions would cause the power supply to burn up or catch on fire (I would not have thought this component to be flammable!)? As I say, I've been running it a couple of hours so far and there's been no change. As a matter of fact, a few weeks ago I had previously removed the heatsink from the output transistors in order to improve the sound, and there was never any overheating problem. |
#11
Posted to rec.audio.tech
|
|||
|
|||
How safe operating an amp with no fuse?
Walt wrote: wrote: Walt wrote: wrote: Could you describe just what condtions would cause the power supply to burn up or catch on fire (I would not have thought this component to be flammable!)? As I say, I've been running it a couple of hours so far and there's been no change. Fuses are for protection in case something goes wrong. As long as nothing goes wrong, you don't need them at all. In that respect, they're like seatbelts or smoke detectors. But if you do need them, you really want to have them. Put the fuse back in. If you don't know enough about electronics to understand how a fuse works you shouldn't be messing around inside the case. All I'm asking is for information on what conditions would cause the amp to catch on fire (ie. what exactly can go wrong and what exactly is flammable inside an amp) so I can do a risk assessment and decide how likely the risk of fire is. If you understand how a fuse works yourself, you would be easily able to explain this, other than simply repeating what you've read on a printed circuit board. //Walt |
#12
Posted to rec.audio.tech
|
|||
|
|||
How safe operating an amp with no fuse?
|
#14
Posted to rec.audio.tech
|
|||
|
|||
How safe operating an amp with no fuse?
On 24 Jan 2006 10:30:24 -0800, wrote:
Walt wrote: wrote: Let me guess: It sounds much more warm without the fuse. LOL. No, I wouldn't describe it as that. Without going into minute details, the overall resolution is much higher. Question is: Exactly what risks are there in running an integrated amp or a preamp sans fuse? You could burn up the power supply, or it could catch on fire. Put the damn fuse back in. Could you describe just what condtions would cause the power supply to burn up or catch on fire (I would not have thought this component to be flammable!)? As I say, I've been running it a couple of hours so far and there's been no change. As a matter of fact, a few weeks ago I had previously removed the heatsink from the output transistors in order to improve the sound, and there was never any overheating problem. What you need to do is remove the heat sink again ( that was a good start). Now pack the heads of matches around the output devices, and fix a can of lighter fluid close to them. Actually, a couple of disposable lighters will do as well. That should achieve the effect you are seeking. Play some music loudly to complete the picture. d Pearce Consulting http://www.pearce.uk.com |
#15
Posted to rec.audio.tech
|
|||
|
|||
How safe operating an amp with no fuse?
Well it certainly isn't going to be people like you that others will praise for advancing the state of music reproduction. You're not a heavy thinker but, you make a good follower. I guess. Don Pearce wrote: On 24 Jan 2006 10:30:24 -0800, wrote: Walt wrote: wrote: Let me guess: It sounds much more warm without the fuse. LOL. No, I wouldn't describe it as that. Without going into minute details, the overall resolution is much higher. Question is: Exactly what risks are there in running an integrated amp or a preamp sans fuse? You could burn up the power supply, or it could catch on fire. Put the damn fuse back in. Could you describe just what condtions would cause the power supply to burn up or catch on fire (I would not have thought this component to be flammable!)? As I say, I've been running it a couple of hours so far and there's been no change. As a matter of fact, a few weeks ago I had previously removed the heatsink from the output transistors in order to improve the sound, and there was never any overheating problem. What you need to do is remove the heat sink again ( that was a good start). Now pack the heads of matches around the output devices, and fix a can of lighter fluid close to them. Actually, a couple of disposable lighters will do as well. That should achieve the effect you are seeking. Play some music loudly to complete the picture. d Pearce Consulting http://www.pearce.uk.com |
#16
Posted to rec.audio.tech
|
|||
|
|||
How safe operating an amp with no fuse?
On 24 Jan 2006 10:52:35 -0800, wrote:
I guess. So we can see. I suggest you stop guessing, and start thinking. d Pearce Consulting http://www.pearce.uk.com |
#17
Posted to rec.audio.tech
|
|||
|
|||
How safe operating an amp with no fuse?
Best if your in the house when the thing goes up.
You can get your Darwin award....putz. |
#18
Posted to rec.audio.tech
|
|||
|
|||
How safe operating an amp with no fuse?
wrote in message oups.com... Walt wrote: wrote: Let me guess: It sounds much more warm without the fuse. LOL. No, I wouldn't describe it as that. Without going into minute details, the overall resolution is much higher. Question is: Exactly what risks are there in running an integrated amp or a preamp sans fuse? You could burn up the power supply, or it could catch on fire. Put the damn fuse back in. Could you describe just what condtions would cause the power supply to burn up or catch on fire (I would not have thought this component to be flammable!)? As I say, I've been running it a couple of hours so far and there's been no change. As a matter of fact, a few weeks ago I had previously removed the heatsink from the output transistors in order to improve the sound, and there was never any overheating problem. In a fault condition. That's why there is a fuse in the first place. A 'normal' current is the criteria determining minimum fuse rating.. geoff |
#19
Posted to rec.audio.tech
|
|||
|
|||
How safe operating an amp with no fuse?
writes:
Walt wrote: wrote: Let me guess: It sounds much more warm without the fuse. LOL. No, I wouldn't describe it as that. Without going into minute details, the overall resolution is much higher. Question is: Exactly what risks are there in running an integrated amp or a preamp sans fuse? You could burn up the power supply, or it could catch on fire. Put the damn fuse back in. Could you describe just what condtions would cause the power supply to burn up or catch on fire (I would not have thought this component to be flammable!)? Let's think your amplifier has a transformer that is designed togive out 100W output power at 90% effeciency. So when amplifier takes 100W, then tranformer has 10W loss and this is what gets it somewhat warm (transformer takes somwehat less power loss when it not fully loaded). If the transformer secondary gots shorted (insulation on transformer secondary wires fails and thei copper ouches each other, amplifier brige rectifier fails short, transformer main storage capacitor fails short or amplifier main output transformer fail fully short...). In this case the transformer secondary is practically short circuited, and transformer tries to push as much power as it can to the output... taking this power from the input. Typically you can expect this input power become something like 10 times the nominal power power of the transformer (or somewhat more or less depending on transformer design, but 10 times is a quite good approximation for average transformer). No actual power is transported out of tranformer (output is shorted so lots of current flows but no voltage, thus no power, in actual life there is some voltage so some little power gets here as well). So that 100W transformer is now taking in 1000W of and outputting practically nothing, thus there is 1000W power heatring tht transformer that was designed to handle 10W heating power loss in it... You can think how quicly and how hot the transformer and wiring inside it quicly becomes where is one kilowatt of power heating that quite small transformer!! As I say, I've been running it a couple of hours so far and there's been no change. As a matter of fact, a few weeks ago I had previously removed the heatsink from the output transistors in order to improve the sound, and there was never any overheating problem. You stupid! Heatsinks on the output transistors are there for a very good reasons. The output transistors have considerable power loss and get hot. If you remove the heatsinks, then the transistors gets mugh hotter much sooner. When transistor gets hot it's parameters change, causing first poor operation of amplifier (worse sound easily), then starting to smell bad (your figerprints on the cases start buring...), and then transistors fail short... not always in this order. Your amplifier if you are lucky might work some time without the heatsinks if you play at very low volume... if you use higher volumes or play longer time, it is very propable that sooner or later your output transistors fail! The hotter they run the sooner they fail! So sooner or later I expect that your output transistors will fail short... this will cause quite propably a chain-reaction that would in normal case burn your amplifier fuse... When you have removed the fuse, then in this case I expect you get the smome coming out sooner or later from your autput transistors, amplifier power transformer and/or your speakers. And possibly flames soon after that.. -- Tomi Engdahl (http://www.iki.fi/then/) Take a look at my electronics web links and documents at http://www.epanorama.net/ |
#20
Posted to rec.audio.tech
|
|||
|
|||
How safe operating an amp with no fuse?
Tomi Holger Engdahl
25 jan 07:35 afficher les options writes: Did some experiments on the fuse of my amp... I replaced a 500mA 250v fuse with a 1.6a 125v fuse and found the sound much improved. Then I decided to replace the 1.6a fuse with a jumper made of a silver paperclip, and found the sound improved much further. Then I replaced the paper clip with silver solder, and found it improved further (though I'm less sure about the solder being better than the clip overall...). I doubt that you could hear the difference of changing the fuse, especially if you are changing the main amplifier use. Yeah right. You and all the other queenies on this group, who've gone to great lengths to attack me for this, because it defies your stupid old religious beliefs. There are enough of you shouting "You are not hearing differences, you are hearing placebos...", that you sound like a chorus of drooling imbeciles to me. But I didn't ask for your opinion or anyone else's on the question of whether the fuse tweak is audible or not, did I? Unlike you and your cabal of religious audio zealots, I have a mind of my own and a pair of ears that go with it. I can decide for myself. Since you HAVEN'T heard the effects of this yourself, do yourself a favor and shut your ****ing trap about things you know nothing about, next time you offer your opinion on something to someone. If you did ever want to learn something new and not just repeat what you're told, it would have taken you less time to conduct the same experiment I did and find out for yourself, than it did to formulate your response here. I think what you heard is caused memery by the psychological effect that you though you were improving the device by changing the fuse. aka "placebo". Yeah, I get it, Einstein. You're a dumbass ****wit who thinks the world begins and ends with the very limited amount of information you've learned about electronics. You don't know just how ignorant you are and how little you know about audio. Im sure you know more about electronics, but Ive forgotten more about music reproduction than you now know. But since you think you're smarter than the top engineer at YBA, why don't you name the world class amp YOU designed, so I can have a listen and compare it? Just to make it easy on you, I'll compare it to YBAs ****tiest amplifier. If you haven't designed anything better, then there's another reason for you to shut the **** up about things you know nothing about. I quess that in real life systems if changing that fuse had any noticeable effect on the audio amplifier, that amplifier was not well designed, and turnign other loads on your house on/off would have more effect on the amplifier performance than changing the fuse. Wrong guess. I already mentioned elsewhere that I did the same fuse substitution thing to my other amp, my cd player, etc., it all had the same effect of improving the sound. Like I also said elsewhere in this thread, you wanna-be engineers always rationalize things you don't understand, because they don't follow what you think is true according to your religious beliefs in audio (and which often, isn't). STOP guessing and do the damn experiment for yourself, or shut up already. "Guessing" is what people did when they tried to explain why the sky was leaking, you blithering idiot. "Science" is what led the more developed man to experiment, find out where the truth lies, and stop the ****ing guessing. Why is why I will always be way ahead of the (audio) game than you and your RAT zealots here. It is dangerous to run equipment without fuse or wrong size fuse. It can easily burn down your house. And if your insurance company finds out that you intentianally replaces your fuses with something else, they most definately will not pay any money to you. So if this gambling you made on operating equipment without proper fuses blows, you will need to start thinking what is to live without your house and things inside it and no compensation for them. And possibley killing/injuring/harming somebody else living on the house or nearby, and getting sued because of the illegal electrical modifications you made to your equipment that caused that fire! But I think the important thing here is, "Jesus will forgive me". Hey, if He can forgive a child pornographer like Arny Krueger, I'm sure he can forgive me for wanting to improve the sound of my audio system. I'm not worried about the insurance company paying out, since I don't have an insurance policy. I.m not worried about getting sued, since the lawyers would cost more than anything they could ever hope to get out of me. I'm not worried about killing my neighbors, since I hate my neighbors (they have a baby kid thats CONSTANTLY crying all the time - just shutting him up for good might be worth the damage to my property). And as for that property in question, well I'm currently developing a "volunatry simplicity" approach, and I'm not attached to material things any more. So maybe having my things destroyed is exactly what I need to free myself. Spiritually speaking. And as my dear old dad always said, "if you never gamble, you never win". Hard to say. But there are real changes. As you know from other electrical equipment, they will not last forever.. usually fail within 5-20 years more or less... Maybe todays cheap **** gear, but both these SS amps are over 25 years old, and they don't look to be close to failing. As I say, I've been running it a couple of hours so far and there's been no change. As a matter of fact, a few weeks ago I had previously removed the heatsink from the output transistors in order to improve the sound, and there was never any overheating problem. You stupid! Now that's very rude of you to call me names like that. Especially when YOU'RE the ignorant **** who pretends to be an expert on issues that you clearly don't know what the hell you're talking about. As we shall see below.... Heatsinks on the output transistors are there for a very good reasons. The output transistors have considerable power loss and get hot. If you remove the heatsinks, then the transistors gets mugh hotter much sooner. When transistor gets hot it's parameters change, causing first poor operation of amplifier (worse sound easily), then starting to smell bad (your figerprints on the cases start buring...), and then transistors fail short... not always in this order. I'm sorry that reality has a way of proving the theoretical world in which you live to be WRONG you ignoramus, but you can stop blabbing now, because nothing you've said here has turned out to be true. This is what I try to drum into the heads of you dumbass wanna-be techies: when you have NO real-world experience of what you're talking about, and you just repeat by rote whatever the hell you've read in Popular Electronics, that does not make you an expert on ANYTHING. I can tell you without flinching that a month ago, I took out the heatsinks in both the aforementioned preamp and amplifier (the amp had a particularly massive heatsink, and an equally massive output transistor array). Why? Because I thought it'd improve the sound. And it most certainly DID. In BOTH components. So that already shoots down your theoretical BS about "worse sound easily". I also removed a wire that was screwed into the large output transistor array (soldered at the other end to the underside of the circuit board). I don't know what that was for (some sort of grounding I would presume), but I do know that removing it from the surface of the output transistor further improved the sound. Next, about the heat: there WAS none. I carefully monitored the heat output in both the amp and preamp after I took the heatsink out. There was very little, if any, warmth coming through the grill in the casing above the heatsink. Thats pretty much normal for this amp, it never got hot. I played music through the amp all night to test it out, it was fine the next day. I even touched the output transistors with my bare fingers after leaving both components on for hours. Guess what, dumbo? They were no hotter than warm. No "bad smell" (well, no worse than with this stuff already smelled like!). So much for all your stupid bull**** about how they'll get "much hotter much sooner" and I will fry my amp. The only thing you wrote that was correct here, is that the parameters change when transistors get hotter (but NOT in the ways you predicted). I already knew that from experiences with my Class A amp. That's why I took out the heatsinks in the first place, genius. Well, Tomi, I hope you've learned something here about what you don't know about audio. And if not, then you're even stupider than I give you credit for. Your amplifier if you are lucky might work some time without the heatsinks if you play at very low volume... if you use higher volumes or play longer time, it is very propable that sooner or later your output transistors fail! The hotter they run the sooner they fail! Yeah, yeah, blah blah blah... see above for why you are a presuptious fool, and don't know what you're talking about. Ive worked this amp for over a month without heatsink at loud volumes, day and night, never had a problem. Im so confident it has no detrimental effect on the amp, Ive already thrown out the heatsink. My concnlusion is that sometimes these things are added in order to prevent failures when used in a variety of ways, but just because theyre desinged in, does not mean they're always needed. And ive PROVEN they can do more harm than good. Lets see one of you crackerheads actually prove ANYTHING that youve been saying. So sooner or later I expect that your output transistors will fail short... this will cause quite propably a chain-reaction that would in normal case burn your amplifier fuse... Wrong again, chumly. If they haven't burnt out after playing loud music for a months time, then they're simply not going to (not for reasons of overheating, since they dont get that hot!). Surely you must tire of being wrong all the time... The only chain reaction I see is that when one of you posts some ignorant BS to me, it incites another to do the same. When you have removed the fuse, then in this case I expect you get the smome coming out sooner or later from your autput transistors, amplifier power transformer and/or your speakers. And possibly flames soon after that.. The only flames I see is from the RATs on this newsgroup because I dared say something in their presence that contradicts all of your inane religious beliefs.... -- Tomi Engdahl (http://www.iki.fi/then/) Take a look at my electronics web links and documents at http://www.epanorama.net/ |
#21
Posted to rec.audio.tech
|
|||
|
|||
How safe operating an amp with no fuse?
wrote in message oups.com... Yeah right. You and all the other queenies on this group, who've gone to great lengths to attack me for this, because it defies your stupid old religious beliefs. You are the one with relgious beliefs. We are objective. geoff |
#22
Posted to rec.audio.tech
|
|||
|
|||
How safe operating an amp with no fuse?
Let me toss the ball back into your court. Assuming this effect is real,
what can you tell us about it and what measurements have you made? Was it accompanied by a change in the output voltage from the amplifier's power supply? How long had the amplifier gone unused before you did the experiment, and could it be improving simply because the electrolytic capacitors are re-forming after a long period of disuse? What was the nature of the change in the audio output -- have you measured distortion, frequency response, etc.? Have you compared old and new fuses with the same electrical ratings? Can anyone other than you hear the difference? |
#23
Posted to rec.audio.tech
|
|||
|
|||
How safe operating an amp with no fuse?
writes:
Tomi Holger Engdahl 25 jan 07:35 afficher les options writes: Did some experiments on the fuse of my amp... I replaced a 500mA 250v fuse with a 1.6a 125v fuse and found the sound much improved. Then I decided to replace the 1.6a fuse with a jumper made of a silver paperclip, and found the sound improved much further. Then I replaced the paper clip with silver solder, and found it improved further (though I'm less sure about the solder being better than the clip overall...). I doubt that you could hear the difference of changing the fuse, especially if you are changing the main amplifier use. Yeah right. You and all the other queenies on this group, who've gone to great lengths to attack me for this, because it defies your stupid old religious beliefs. There are enough of you shouting "You are not hearing differences, you are hearing placebos...", that you sound like a chorus of drooling imbeciles to me. But I didn't ask for your opinion or anyone else's on the question of whether the fuse tweak is audible or not, did I? You might not have asked the question of whether the fuse tweak is audible or not, but when posting this kind of things questions to the newsgroups, you should be prepared to also be ready to take the commends that doubt the general idea of your modification. I have gone to the lengths of describing the the dangers of running the equipment without any fuse. And given few words on why the general idea of running the equipment without fuse is bad, and does not have any considerable effect on sound reproduction. If there is any effect on the exhanging the fuse, then other changing effects around (mains voltage varitions, equipment temperature, RFI) etc. have much more effect on sound reproduction than that fuse has! My experices on the on this field are not just my beliefs. I have anysed the siautaion on my eariler posting based on well recognized electrical/electronics circuit theory. And I have also practical experience: I have designed and built my own audio equipment, I have repaired some of my own audio equipment etc.. I have operated the same audio equipment on my test bench with original fuze, with wrong size fuse and even with fuse temporarily short circuited with piece of wire when ruight fuse has been missing (typically in well controlled environment where the equipment is constantly monired..). There are some years on those experiments, but I don't remeber ever hearing any difference when changing the mains fuse to another or replacing with short circuit. Unlike you and your cabal of religious audio zealots, I have a mind of my own and a pair of ears that go with it. I have also pair of ears. And I use them. I can decide for myself. You are free to make your won decisions, and we are all free in this open forums to make our own desicisions and pos them here if we want. This is a free world and open public forum. Since you HAVEN'T heard the effects of this yourself, do yourself a favor and shut your ****ing trap about things you know nothing about, next time you offer your opinion on something to someone. I haven't heard the difference on my experiments I have made on my laboratory table. And I have not heard your system so hard to say. I am free to offer my opinion on this forum. As free as you are to express your own. And I think is know pretty much in the things I talk about here. I think this there pretty many things in my home country and users of this discussion group who agree on this with me. If you did ever want to learn something new and not just repeat what you're told, it would have taken you less time to conduct the same experiment I did and find out for yourself, than it did to formulate your response here. I have conducted prety many experiment on many audio things.. Experiemtnally tested many things before believing them. I think what you heard is caused memery by the psychological effect that you though you were improving the device by changing the fuse. aka "placebo". Yeah, I get it, Einstein. You're a dumbass ****wit who thinks the world begins and ends with the very limited amount of information you've learned about electronics. You have misjudged me. You don't know just how ignorant you are and how little you know about audio. Im sure you know more about electronics, but Ive forgotten more about music reproduction than you now know. But since you think you're smarter than the top engineer at YBA, Where have I said that that I claim to be smarter than the too engineer at YBA ? why don't you name the world class amp YOU designed, so I can have a listen and compare it? Name one you designed. Just to make it easy on you, I'll compare it to YBAs ****tiest amplifier. If you haven't designed anything better, then there's another reason for you to shut the **** up about things you know nothing about. I quess that in real life systems if changing that fuse had any noticeable effect on the audio amplifier, that amplifier was not well designed, and turnign other loads on your house on/off would have more effect on the amplifier performance than changing the fuse. Wrong guess. I already mentioned elsewhere that I did the same fuse substitution thing to my other amp, my cd player, etc., it all had the same effect of improving the sound. How did the sound really improve ? Can you describe how did that removing the fuse help. Like I also said elsewhere in this thread, you wanna-be engineers always rationalize things you don't understand, because they don't follow what you think is true according to your religious beliefs in audio (and which often, isn't). STOP guessing and do the damn experiment for yourself, or shut up already. I don't need to repeat the experiments. I have hear didfferences between different CD players, amplifiers, speakes, even between some cables... Changing the mains fuse to another has not made absolutely no difference on the sound heard on the systems. "Guessing" is what people did when they tried to explain why the sky was leaking, you blithering idiot. "Science" is what led the more developed man to experiment, find out where the truth lies, and stop the ****ing guessing. Why is why I will always be way ahead of the (audio) game than you and your RAT zealots here. I have done experimenting on many audio things. And on those experiements I have also learned how easy it is to fool your hearing by the beliefs.. Ever been in "blind test" where you just try to hear the difference without previous knowlege on the things you test... It is dangerous to run equipment without fuse or wrong size fuse. It can easily burn down your house. And if your insurance company finds out that you intentianally replaces your fuses with something else, they most definately will not pay any money to you. So if this gambling you made on operating equipment without proper fuses blows, you will need to start thinking what is to live without your house and things inside it and no compensation for them. And possibley killing/injuring/harming somebody else living on the house or nearby, and getting sued because of the illegal electrical modifications you made to your equipment that caused that fire! But I think the important thing here is, "Jesus will forgive me". Hey, if He can forgive a child pornographer like Arny Krueger, I'm sure he can forgive me for wanting to improve the sound of my audio system. I'm not worried about the insurance company paying out, since I don't have an insurance policy. I.m not worried about getting sued, since the lawyers would cost more than anything they could ever hope to get out of me. I'm not worried about killing my neighbors, since I hate my neighbors (they have a baby kid thats CONSTANTLY crying all the time - just shutting him up for good might be worth the damage to my property). And as for that property in question, well I'm currently developing a "volunatry simplicity" approach, and I'm not attached to material things any more. So maybe having my things destroyed is exactly what I need to free myself. Spiritually speaking. And as my dear old dad always said, "if you never gamble, you never win". That's your view. On my viewpoint what you are doing with your equipment is plain stupid and potentially dangerous! Even if it had some noticeable effect on the system perfomance (which I very much doubt), I think the risk/reward ratio is not good on your approach. That's my optinion. Hard to say. But there are real changes. As you know from other electrical equipment, they will not last forever.. usually fail within 5-20 years more or less... Maybe todays cheap **** gear, but both these SS amps are over 25 years old, and they don't look to be close to failing. Components do age! And you can't see that with your eyes. As I say, I've been running it a couple of hours so far and there's been no change. As a matter of fact, a few weeks ago I had previously removed the heatsink from the output transistors in order to improve the sound, and there was never any overheating problem. You stupid! Now that's very rude of you to call me names like that. Especially when YOU'RE the ignorant **** who pretends to be an expert on issues that you clearly don't know what the hell you're talking about. As we shall see below... Maybe I as a rude. Sorry on that. Usually you need to be a little bit rude to weak up people that are doign stupid dangerous things. You said that: "YOU'RE the ignorant **** who pretends to be an expert on issues that you clearly don't know what the hell you're talking about." Based on the postings you have posted here I think pretty much same about you. And I am free to keep my opinion until there is a reason to change that. Heatsinks on the output transistors are there for a very good reasons. The output transistors have considerable power loss and get hot. If you remove the heatsinks, then the transistors gets mugh hotter much sooner. When transistor gets hot it's parameters change, causing first poor operation of amplifier (worse sound easily), then starting to smell bad (your figerprints on the cases start buring...), and then transistors fail short... not always in this order. I'm sorry that reality has a way of proving the theoretical world in which you live to be WRONG you ignoramus, but you can stop blabbing now, because nothing you've said here has turned out to be true. This is what I try to drum into the heads of you dumbass wanna-be techies: when you have NO real-world experience of what you're talking about, I have real world experice. But you don't seem to believe that. and you just repeat by rote whatever the hell you've read in Popular Electronics, that does not make you an expert on ANYTHING. I don't repeat what I have read in Popular Electronics. I don't read that magazine.. I can tell you without flinching that a month ago, I took out the heatsinks in both the aforementioned preamp and amplifier (the amp had a particularly massive heatsink, and an equally massive output transistor array). Why? Because I thought it'd improve the sound. And it most certainly DID. In BOTH components. What was your initial jurgement on thinking why removing them would improve sound ? So that already shoots down your theoretical BS about "worse sound easily". I am talking on experience here.. I have expriemtned with transistor amplifier circuits... and run transistors without heatsik when they should have had one... and hard and seen effects that happen when you run them for some time... Burned few fingers and transistors back them. I also removed a wire that was screwed into the large output transistor array (soldered at the other end to the underside of the circuit board). I don't know what that was for (some sort of grounding I would presume), but I do know that removing it from the surface of the output transistor further improved the sound. Next, about the heat: there WAS none. I carefully monitored the heat output in both the amp and preamp after I took the heatsink out. There was very little, if any, warmth coming through the grill in the casing above the heatsink. Thats pretty much normal for this amp, it never got hot. I played music through the amp all night to test it out, it was fine the next day. I even touched the output transistors with my bare fingers after leaving both components on for hours. Guess what, dumbo? They were no hotter than warm. No "bad smell" (well, no worse than with this stuff already smelled like!). Can you tell which specific amplifeir you have modified ? So much for all your stupid bull**** about how they'll get "much hotter much sooner" and I will fry my amp. Been there, seen that when transistors fail. The only thing you wrote that was correct here, is that the parameters change when transistors get hotter (but NOT in the ways you predicted). I already knew that from experiences with my Class A amp. That's why I took out the heatsinks in the first place, genius. Well, Tomi, I hope you've learned something here about what you don't know about audio. And if not, then you're even stupider than I give you credit for. Nothing particularly new about audio that I would have not known earlier. Maybe I should have written my earlier posting in a little bit different format... less theory and more real world experiment results. The end of your posting gave a better picture on you. It seems that you have been pretty careful on your experiments, and know more on things you do that seemed based on the first posting. Sorry. It is pretty easy to get wrong impressions on the people based on their postins. Your amplifier if you are lucky might work some time without the heatsinks if you play at very low volume... if you use higher volumes or play longer time, it is very propable that sooner or later your output transistors fail! The hotter they run the sooner they fail! Yeah, yeah, blah blah blah... see above for why you are a presuptious fool, and don't know what you're talking about. Ive worked this amp for over a month without heatsink at loud volumes, day and night, never had a problem. Im so confident it has no detrimental effect on the amp, Ive already thrown out the heatsink. My concnlusion is that sometimes these things are added in order to prevent failures when used in a variety of ways, but just because theyre desinged in, does not mean they're always needed. That can happens on some equipment. There are amplifiers that designed in such way that there is overuse of all kind of things. Much larger hetsinks that are needed, overrated components etc.. just to be on safe side in all cases. And there are also amplifiers that are pretty much optimized to provide what is promised with close to minimal cost... Taking out parts in such design can cause pretty nasty consequences. And ive PROVEN they can do more harm than good. Lets see one of you crackerheads actually prove ANYTHING that youve been saying. So sooner or later I expect that your output transistors will fail short... this will cause quite propably a chain-reaction that would in normal case burn your amplifier fuse... Wrong again, chumly. If they haven't burnt out after playing loud music for a months time, then they're simply not going to (not for reasons of overheating, since they dont get that hot!). Feel lucky that you have picked such conservatively designed amplifier that you can take out the heatsinks, and still no overhating on your use. Surely you must tire of being wrong all the time... The only chain reaction I see is that when one of you posts some ignorant BS to me, it incites another to do the same. When you have removed the fuse, then in this case I expect you get the smome coming out sooner or later from your autput transistors, amplifier power transformer and/or your speakers. And possibly flames soon after that.. The only flames I see is from the RATs on this newsgroup because I dared say something in their presence that contradicts all of your inane religious beliefs.... -- Tomi Engdahl (http://www.iki.fi/then/) Take a look at my electronics web links and documents at http://www.epanorama.net/ |
#24
Posted to rec.audio.tech
|
|||
|
|||
How safe operating an amp with no fuse?
wrote:
Walt wrote: wrote: Let me guess: It sounds much more warm without the fuse. LOL. No, I wouldn't describe it as that. Without going into minute details, the overall resolution is much higher. Have you tried putting a new fuse of the same rating in? Replacin a fuse with one with a higher rating is one of the certified ways of voiding fire insurance. Question is: Exactly what risks are there in running an integrated amp or a preamp sans fuse? You could burn up the power supply, or it could catch on fire. Put the damn fuse back in. Could you describe just what condtions would cause the power supply to burn up or catch on fire A transistor that for some reason fails. (I would not have thought this component to be flammable!)? I trust that you have not thought. As I say, I've been running it a couple of hours so far and there's been no change. As a matter of fact, a few weeks ago I had previously removed the heatsink from the output transistors in order to improve the sound, and there was never any overheating problem. Ah, good idea, the auto-incinerating amp, much better than planned obsolesence. The cooler transistors run, the better they behave. The ever so slight chance there is of warm up and/or burn in effects is related to capacitors re-forming in case they have been unused for too long. PUT THE THINGS YOU TOOK OUT BACK IN! - remember to add new cooling paste, if do you not know what that is, then let qualified service personnel assemble your amp prior to having to pay themn for also repairing failed components. Kind regards Peter Larsen -- ******************************************* * My site is at: http://www.muyiovatki.dk * ******************************************* |
#25
Posted to rec.audio.tech
|
|||
|
|||
How safe operating an amp with no fuse?
wrote in message
ups.com Did some experiments on the fuse of my amp... I replaced a 500mA 250v fuse with a 1.6a 125v fuse and found the sound much improved. Then I decided to replace the 1.6a fuse with a jumper made of a silver paperclip, and found the sound improved much further. Then I replaced the paper clip with silver solder, and found it improved further (though I'm less sure about the solder being better than the clip overall...). Question is: Exactly what risks are there in running an integrated amp or a preamp sans fuse? I don't care so much about the gear blowing up, since its old gear anyway. But nor do I want a fire started when I leave the amp running all night or am not at home. In the case of the preamp, the casing is solid metal, with the integrated, its a wood casing. What are the chances of fire and how would it start? What are the chances of it blowing up and how might that occur? (so far, no problems!). Is electrical shock a risk with a fuseless amp? Good question for rec.audio.opinion. Ask for Middius. |
#26
Posted to rec.audio.tech
|
|||
|
|||
How safe operating an amp with no fuse?
Arny Krueger wrote: wrote in message ups.com Did some experiments on the fuse of my amp... I replaced a 500mA 250v fuse with a 1.6a 125v fuse and found the sound much improved. Then I decided to replace the 1.6a fuse with a jumper made of a silver paperclip, and found the sound improved much further. Then I replaced the paper clip with silver solder, and found it improved further (though I'm less sure about the solder being better than the clip overall...). Question is: Exactly what risks are there in running an integrated amp or a preamp sans fuse? I don't care so much about the gear blowing up, since its old gear anyway. But nor do I want a fire started when I leave the amp running all night or am not at home. In the case of the preamp, the casing is solid metal, with the integrated, its a wood casing. What are the chances of fire and how would it start? What are the chances of it blowing up and how might that occur? (so far, no problems!). Is electrical shock a risk with a fuseless amp? Good question for rec.audio.opinion. Ask for Middius. Aren't you the sick ******* that was collecting all sorts of kiddie porn, and falsely accused others of sending it to you? |
#27
Posted to rec.audio.tech
|
|||
|
|||
How safe operating an amp with no fuse?
wrote in message oups.com... Arny Krueger wrote: wrote in message ups.com Did some experiments on the fuse of my amp... I replaced a 500mA 250v fuse with a 1.6a 125v fuse and found the Aren't you the sick ******* that was collecting all sorts of kiddie porn, and falsely accused others of sending it to you? Pretty clear than from this little slip that rladchap is really a troll. After all, nobody could really be quite that thick. geoff |
#28
Posted to rec.audio.tech
|
|||
|
|||
How safe operating an amp with no fuse?
"Geoff@work" wrote in
message wrote in message oups.com... Arny Krueger wrote: wrote in message ups.com Did some experiments on the fuse of my amp... I replaced a 500mA 250v fuse with a 1.6a 125v fuse and found the Aren't you the sick ******* that was collecting all sorts of kiddie porn, and falsely accused others of sending it to you? Pretty clear than from this little slip that rladchap is really a troll. After all, nobody could really be quite that thick. Not only that, but he's obviously a sockpuppet that is being manipulated by someone that we are already being subjected to - a friend of Middius as it were. |
#29
Posted to rec.audio.tech
|
|||
|
|||
How safe operating an amp with no fuse?
|
#30
Posted to rec.audio.tech
|
|||
|
|||
How safe operating an amp with no fuse?
Colin B. wrote: wrote: Question is: Exactly what risks are there in running an integrated amp or a preamp sans fuse? I don't care so much about the gear blowing up, since its old gear anyway. But nor do I want a fire started when I leave the amp running all night or am not at home. In the case of the preamp, the casing is solid metal, with the integrated, its a wood casing. What are the chances of fire and how would it start? What are the chances of it blowing up and how might that occur? (so far, no problems!). Is electrical shock a risk with a fuseless amp? Given your first paragraph, I'm inclined to say that you should accept the risks and eliminate the fuse. Hopefully it _will_ catch fire, and we'll have one fewer true believer in the newsgroup. Don't worry, I'm not trying to take over your little boys club. That's "little boys" club, and not "little boys club". I would like to take you up on it, but obviously, I can not "accept the risks" if none of you ignorant ****s (you included "Colin B"), are able to describe exactly what conditions would cause a preamp or integrated to "catch on fire", as you keep alleging. Is this why one of your colleagues proposed that i use lighter fluid and matches inside my amp? In order to "prove" how right you are, when it is probably highly unlikely that either of these two devices will "catch on fire"? And if they do "catch on fire", given that one of them is in my baby's room, what kind of stupid SICK ******* are you, that you would want to see a baby DIE?! You're a pure Asshole, you are. Now assuming I don't put vials of lighter fluid in the components, let's see if a true ignoramus like yourself can even name one thing that is flammable inside an amp and will make it "catch on fire", as you allege. DO you even know what solder is made of, moron? Try "metal". Holy cow! That's the same ingredient as what you find in a fuse! Has it ever occured to you, imbecile, that if the metal wire in a fuse breaks and shorts the connection, that this is EXACTLY what will happen to the silver solder wire that I've joined to the two ends of my fuse holder? Try THINKING, instead displaying your infinite igornance, before you post. |
#31
Posted to rec.audio.tech
|
|||
|
|||
How safe operating an amp with no fuse?
|
#32
Posted to rec.audio.tech
|
|||
|
|||
How safe operating an amp with no fuse?
|
#33
Posted to rec.audio.tech
|
|||
|
|||
How safe operating an amp with no fuse?
Thanks Greg. I was having so much fun swatting the ignorant flies that
breed around the **** they create on this newsgroup, I wasn't expecting an intelligent, respectful, and non-ridiculing response like this. Especially so "late in the game" (given that the flies on this group do nothing all day but post here, that means it only takes about 5-10 minutes for a thread to degenerate due to the inherent stupidity of low-level audio techies on the net...). It's always funny for me to see that once you start mentioning you can hear things to wannabe- engineers that they weren't taught in their local college courses, they start freaking out in fits of neuroses. Like babies who've had their security blankets rudely yanked away. They don't even TRY to debate the issue they contend with in the first place (because they actually can't...), they simply make COMPLETE asses out of themselves, because they simply don't know what to do with themselves... Anyway, not sure what you mean by "changing a fuse should do a bunch more than replacing a cord". Bunch more soundwise? Replacing one fuse for the same fuse, or for that of a different rating? As mentioned in my message, I didn't try replacing one fuse for another of the same type, but for that of a different type. I did try reversing the amps original fuse, and found that made an audible difference as well. What I'm still unsure about is: - What is the exact risk involved of changing the rating of a fuse (in my case, 1.6a 125v for a 500mA 250v)? - What is the exact risk involved in using solder wire instead of the original fuse and its filament wire? (Seems to me the solder would burn at an even lower temperature, - Would a transformer damaged by the absence of the original fuse be audibly apparent before leaking currents and creating a risk of shock? - How can I check to be sure my metal case is properly grounded? GregS wrote: In article . com, wrote: Did some experiments on the fuse of my amp... I replaced a 500mA 250v fuse with a 1.6a 125v fuse and found the sound much improved. Then I decided to replace the 1.6a fuse with a jumper made of a silver paperclip, and found the sound improved much further. Then I replaced the paper clip with silver solder, and found it improved further (though I'm less sure about the solder being better than the clip overall...). Question is: Exactly what risks are there in running an integrated amp or a preamp sans fuse? I don't care so much about the gear blowing up, since its old gear anyway. But nor do I want a fire started when I leave the amp running all night or am not at home. In the case of the preamp, the casing is solid metal, with the integrated, its a wood casing. What are the chances of fire and how would it start? What are the chances of it blowing up and how might that occur? (so far, no problems!). Is electrical shock a risk with a fuseless amp? Changing a fuse should do a bunch more than replacing a cord, especially a cooroded fuse connection. Relacing any connection is likely to improve the connection. A fuse can help prevent shocks, but there is no guarantee. Damaged transformers could leak currents. Its preferable to have all metal cases grounded, but not all metal cases are grounded. Wood can overheat with damaged components, and may or may not still work. Fires have been started with metal chassis equipment, allthough mostly with ventillated chassis. greg |
#34
Posted to rec.audio.tech
|
|||
|
|||
How safe operating an amp with no fuse?
It truly is a wonder that you are still alive.
If you don't even know how to check for a ground, take your amp to a qualified professional. Put the fuse back in. Somebody should probably take the kids out of your house... |
#35
Posted to rec.audio.tech
|
|||
|
|||
How safe operating an amp with no fuse?
In article .com, wrote:
Thanks Greg. I was having so much fun swatting the ignorant flies that breed around the **** they create on this newsgroup, I wasn't expecting an intelligent, respectful, and non-ridiculing response like this. Especially so "late in the game" (given that the flies on this group do nothing all day but post here, that means it only takes about 5-10 minutes for a thread to degenerate due to the inherent stupidity of low-level audio techies on the net...). It's always funny for me to see that once you start mentioning you can hear things to wannabe- engineers that they weren't taught in their local college courses, they start freaking out in fits of neuroses. Like babies who've had their security blankets rudely yanked away. They don't even TRY to debate the issue they contend with in the first place (because they actually can't...), they simply make COMPLETE asses out of themselves, because they simply don't know what to do with themselves... Anyway, not sure what you mean by "changing a fuse should do a bunch more than replacing a cord". Bunch more soundwise? Replacing one fuse for the same fuse, or for that of a different rating? As mentioned in my message, I didn't try replacing one fuse for another of the same type, but for that of a different type. I did try reversing the amps original fuse, and found that made an audible difference as well. Many change the replacable line cord which does very little in the big picture. I do like soldered line cords. A line cord normally has less resistance than a fuse, except slow blowing fuses under 1 amp will show definate resistance increases. The equipment should be built to go around these issues and perform OK. If you think you hear a difference, then a difference could possibly exist. What I'm still unsure about is: - What is the exact risk involved of changing the rating of a fuse (in my case, 1.6a 125v for a 500mA 250v)? Some fire potential. A fuse does not guarantee anything except current overflow. - What is the exact risk involved in using solder wire instead of the original fuse and its filament wire? (Seems to me the solder would burn at an even lower temperature, You probably mean silver solder vs silver bearing solder. It does not melt at too low of a temperature, but lower than copper. A fuse is made to have resistance and cause heat melting itself. The lower the rating, the more the resistance. Silver bearing solder could have at least 1 % silver content. Most of the non-lead solders have a higher melting temperature, but most solders have high resistance. - Would a transformer damaged by the absence of the original fuse be audibly apparent before leaking currents and creating a risk of shock? No. The fuse would not damage the transformer, but could cause a damaged transformer to get too hot or otherwise let it continue to opperate when it should not be opperating. - How can I check to be sure my metal case is properly grounded? It might have a 3 wire AC connector. Thats normally the only way to ground, but there are other ways. Most consumer audio equipment does not have a grounded case. Grounding it may cause ground loop noise. In non grounded equipment, a voltmeter connected to a resistor and parallel capacitor is normally attached from the equipment to earth ground. There is a limit on passing current, normally less than 100 uA. GregS wrote: In article . com, wrote: Did some experiments on the fuse of my amp... I replaced a 500mA 250v fuse with a 1.6a 125v fuse and found the sound much improved. Then I decided to replace the 1.6a fuse with a jumper made of a silver paperclip, and found the sound improved much further. Then I replaced the paper clip with silver solder, and found it improved further (though I'm less sure about the solder being better than the clip overall...). Question is: Exactly what risks are there in running an integrated amp or a preamp sans fuse? I don't care so much about the gear blowing up, since its old gear anyway. But nor do I want a fire started when I leave the amp running all night or am not at home. In the case of the preamp, the casing is solid metal, with the integrated, its a wood casing. What are the chances of fire and how would it start? What are the chances of it blowing up and how might that occur? (so far, no problems!). Is electrical shock a risk with a fuseless amp? Changing a fuse should do a bunch more than replacing a cord, especially a cooroded fuse connection. Relacing any connection is likely to improve the connection. A fuse can help prevent shocks, but there is no guarantee. Damaged transformers could leak currents. Its preferable to have all metal cases grounded, but not all metal cases are grounded. Wood can overheat with damaged components, and may or may not still work. Fires have been started with metal chassis equipment, allthough mostly with ventillated chassis. greg |
#36
Posted to rec.audio.tech
|
|||
|
|||
How safe operating an amp with no fuse?
GregS wrote: In article .com, wrote: Anyway, not sure what you mean by "changing a fuse should do a bunch more than replacing a cord". Bunch more soundwise? Replacing one fuse for the same fuse, or for that of a different rating? As mentioned in my message, I didn't try replacing one fuse for another of the same type, but for that of a different type. I did try reversing the amps original fuse, and found that made an audible difference as well. Many change the replacable line cord which does very little in the big picture. Yes, I know about that. I've changed line cords on tape decks, turntables, etc.... always found significant differences. Didn't always like the difference, since so many characteristics change. Not easy to experiment with, unless you play around with IEC replaceable cords. I do like soldered line cords. A line cord normally has less resistance than a fuse, except slow blowing fuses under 1 amp will show definate resistance increases. The equipment should be built to go around these issues and perform OK. If you think you hear a difference, then a difference could possibly exist. The difference is tremendous (to me), and I have no doubt it exists, but then, I really didn't come here to prove that to anybody or debate this issue (especially with those who have preconceived notions about what can and can't be perceived in audio...)... only to find out what the "real risk" was of substituting the fuse for something else that would maintain the current, as the fuse did, but sound better. I don't claim to have an engineering background, which is why I came asking questions. What I was comparing was the silver solder that I used in place of the fuse (I dont nkow the percentage, but Im sure its very low, I nkow it contains lead and its from RadioShack), vs. the wire filament in the glass fuse tube. I'm thinking that if the wire filament is designed to cut off the current during an overload or short by breaking from the heat generated, would not the solder have the same effect of melting during an overload and thereby cutting off the current and preventing the amp from melting down or "catching fire"? The electronic solder used does not seem to have a particularly high melting point, but I don't know if it is much lower than that of a fuse filament. However, I understand you to say most solders have high resistance, and that resistance is what helps the filament in a fuse melt itself. Would this not make it easy for the Radio Shack silver (probly mostly lead!) solder to melt under overload conditions and prevent further damage? What I'm still unsure about is: - What is the exact risk involved of changing the rating of a fuse (in my case, 1.6a 125v for a 500mA 250v)? Some fire potential. A fuse does not guarantee anything except current overflow. So you're saying even the RIGHT fuse installed does not guarantee the amp wont catch on fire? Intersting, because all the crazy little boys here have been screaming at me that my amp will send me and family to a burning hell the minute I replace the fuse with anything but the rated type. Some are even prearing hot dogs to roast at my family's "personal barbecue", from what I've read. You probably mean silver solder vs silver bearing solder. It does not melt at too low of a temperature, but lower than copper. A fuse is made to have resistance and cause heat melting itself. The lower the rating, the more the resistance. Silver bearing solder could have at least 1 % silver content. Most of the non-lead solders have a higher melting temperature, but most solders have high resistance. - How can I check to be sure my metal case is properly grounded? It might have a 3 wire AC connector. Thats normally the only way to ground, but there are other ways. Most consumer audio equipment does not have a grounded case. Grounding it may cause ground loop noise. I guess my metal preamp isnt grounded then. Theres some kind of grounding going on inside of it, but the plug is a two prong ungrounded type. In non grounded equipment, a voltmeter connected to a resistor and parallel capacitor is normally attached from the equipment to earth ground. There is a limit on passing current, normally less than 100 uA. |
#37
Posted to rec.audio.tech
|
|||
|
|||
How safe operating an amp with no fuse?
In article .com, wrote:
GregS wrote: In article .com, wrote: Anyway, not sure what you mean by "changing a fuse should do a bunch more than replacing a cord". Bunch more soundwise? Replacing one fuse for the same fuse, or for that of a different rating? As mentioned in my message, I didn't try replacing one fuse for another of the same type, but for that of a different type. I did try reversing the amps original fuse, and found that made an audible difference as well. Many change the replacable line cord which does very little in the big picture. Yes, I know about that. I've changed line cords on tape decks, turntables, etc.... always found significant differences. Didn't always like the difference, since so many characteristics change. Not easy to experiment with, unless you play around with IEC replaceable cords. I do like soldered line cords. A line cord normally has less resistance than a fuse, except slow blowing fuses under 1 amp will show definate resistance increases. The equipment should be built to go around these issues and perform OK. If you think you hear a difference, then a difference could possibly exist. The difference is tremendous (to me), and I have no doubt it exists, but then, I really didn't come here to prove that to anybody or debate this issue (especially with those who have preconceived notions about what can and can't be perceived in audio...)... only to find out what the "real risk" was of substituting the fuse for something else that would maintain the current, as the fuse did, but sound better. I don't claim to have an engineering background, which is why I came asking questions. What I was comparing was the silver solder that I used in place of the fuse (I dont nkow the percentage, but Im sure its very low, I nkow it contains lead and its from RadioShack), vs. the wire filament in the glass fuse tube. I'm thinking that if the wire filament is designed to cut off the current during an overload or short by breaking from the heat generated, would not the solder have the same effect of melting during an overload and thereby cutting off the current and preventing the amp from melting down or "catching fire"? The electronic solder used does not seem to have a particularly high melting point, but I don't know if it is much lower than that of a fuse filament. However, I understand you to say most solders have high resistance, and that resistance is what helps the filament in a fuse melt itself. Would this not make it easy for the Radio Shack silver (probly mostly lead!) solder to melt under overload conditions and prevent further damage? You don't know what the fusing current will be, but it will be very erratic using a piece of solder. It is likely to be in the 10's of amps to fuse your solder. Fusing equipment is a little bit of engineering and a little bit of practical testing. The exact value can vary. One thing for sure, if any damage occurs, the insurance Co. could refrain from paying you. There is also the ladder effect. I once was sitting down and pushed a button, and a breaker 2 miles away tripped shutting down a complete satelite tracking station. Its quite an experiance. I pushed a button triggering a 75 HP electric motor, which shorted, tried to trip but fused the first breaker. This went to the next really big big breaker. Can you imagine the silence and darkness having pushed the button. It was really bright and very noisey with racks and racks of equipment and air handlers until pushing that button. So if you have a fusing problem, it can escalate problems at times. greg What I'm still unsure about is: - What is the exact risk involved of changing the rating of a fuse (in my case, 1.6a 125v for a 500mA 250v)? Some fire potential. A fuse does not guarantee anything except current overflow. So you're saying even the RIGHT fuse installed does not guarantee the amp wont catch on fire? Intersting, because all the crazy little boys here have been screaming at me that my amp will send me and family to a burning hell the minute I replace the fuse with anything but the rated type. Some are even prearing hot dogs to roast at my family's "personal barbecue", from what I've read. You probably mean silver solder vs silver bearing solder. It does not melt at too low of a temperature, but lower than copper. A fuse is made to have resistance and cause heat melting itself. The lower the rating, the more the resistance. Silver bearing solder could have at least 1 % silver content. Most of the non-lead solders have a higher melting temperature, but most solders have high resistance. - How can I check to be sure my metal case is properly grounded? It might have a 3 wire AC connector. Thats normally the only way to ground, but there are other ways. Most consumer audio equipment does not have a grounded case. Grounding it may cause ground loop noise. I guess my metal preamp isnt grounded then. Theres some kind of grounding going on inside of it, but the plug is a two prong ungrounded type. In non grounded equipment, a voltmeter connected to a resistor and parallel capacitor is normally attached from the equipment to earth ground. There is a limit on passing current, normally less than 100 uA. |
#38
Posted to rec.audio.tech
|
|||
|
|||
How safe operating an amp with no fuse?
On 24 Jan 2006 11:55:29 -0800, wrote:
What I'm still unsure about is: - What is the exact risk involved of changing the rating of a fuse (in my case, 1.6a 125v for a 500mA 250v)? - What is the exact risk involved in using solder wire instead of the original fuse and its filament wire? (Seems to me the solder would burn at an even lower temperature, - Would a transformer damaged by the absence of the original fuse be audibly apparent before leaking currents and creating a risk of shock? It seems that you do not know why fuses are used and how they work. Both my early teen kids know. You must either be a troll, less than 13, or very ignorant. If you really, really, are serious (which most of doubt, it seems) you can read about it he http://ourworld.compuserve.com/homep...tt/elect16.htm Per. |
#39
Posted to rec.audio.tech
|
|||
|
|||
How safe operating an amp with no fuse?
Per Stromgren wrote: On 24 Jan 2006 11:55:29 -0800, wrote: What I'm still unsure about is: - What is the exact risk involved of changing the rating of a fuse (in my case, 1.6a 125v for a 500mA 250v)? - What is the exact risk involved in using solder wire instead of the original fuse and its filament wire? (Seems to me the solder would burn at an even lower temperature, - Would a transformer damaged by the absence of the original fuse be audibly apparent before leaking currents and creating a risk of shock? It seems that you do not know why fuses are used and how they work. Both my early teen kids know. You must either be a troll, less than 13, or very ignorant. Considering the fact that you can't explain how or why silver solder would not do as a replacement fuse, or anything else to support whatever the hell you're supposed to be asserting, maybe you need to have your kids explain how fuses work to YOU. You're the one who is either a troll or very ignorant. I don't need your condescending web links, gaychub. I didn't claim to be an expert on fuses. Why do you suppose I came here asking questions on the subject, you stupid ****wad? Nor did I come here to be condescended to be having idiots simply repeat what they read on circuit board stickers, while they understand NOTHING of the subject. There are warnings on tags on mattreses too. You mindless trolls are probably afraid to remove those too, without understanding why exactly they are there. Me, I have no tags on my mattresses, as Im not a mindless fool like you and your ****wad friends who appear to know squat about audio. If you really, really, are serious (which most of doubt, it seems) you can read about it he http://ourworld.compuserve.com/homep...tt/elect16.htm Per. |
#40
Posted to rec.audio.tech
|
|||
|
|||
How safe operating an amp with no fuse? - reply to rladbury
(I really can't believe I'm replying to this... ;-) It's in the
interests of safety.) rladbury asked: What I'm still unsure about is: - What is the exact risk involved of changing the rating of a fuse (in my case, 1.6a 125v for a 500mA 250v)? Probably no "risk" as in danger to you, providing you pull the plug first! A fuse has a voltage rating because that is the maximum voltage that it is guaranteed to break, without flashing over inside. So you can't put a 125V fuse in a 250v system, but you can put a 250v fuse in a 125v system. If you use too low a voltage rating and the right sort of fault occurs then the fuse will blow, but won't actually break the current because it can pass through the now silvered layer on the inside - its like not having a fuse. The current rating is the maximum that the fuse can carry continuously without "blowing". So, if you put a 500mA fuse (i.e. 0.5A) fuse in instead of a 1.6A one it could very well blow immediately as the equipment could be taking up to 1.6A. Putting a 1.6A fuse in where it should be 500mA is giving you 1/3 of the protection that you should have. You are increasing the risk of permanent damage to the transformer primary in the event of a fault on the secondary (such as a blown rectifier going short-circuit). Note that the difference in resistance of a 500mA fuse and a 1.6A fuse is negligable as the rating depends on the composition of the wire as well as its cross-sectional area. The contact resistance is way higher. - What is the exact risk involved in using solder wire instead of the original fuse and its filament wire? (Seems to me the solder would burn at an even lower temperature, You may as well stick a nail in - effectively you don't have a fuse. The solder has a low enough resistance to not heat up enough to melt in most cases. There is a very real danger of fire in the event of a fault if you do this. If you try to use solder as a fuse it tends to explode in small firey globules of hot metal in the event of a fault. Not what you want... - Would a transformer damaged by the absence of the original fuse be audibly apparent before leaking currents and creating a risk of shock? Do you mean that the original fuse blew? If so it would probably blow a new fuse immediately. After all, that's why the original fuse blew isn't it? It *could* make the chassis live if there is an earth problem though, so the transformer should be properly tested before re-use. - How can I check to be sure my metal case is properly grounded? Are you using a 3pin mains plug? If so, a resistance test between the case and the earth pin is as close as you are going to get. It should be close to 0 ohms. It is *not safe* to do things like shorting out fuses or wrapping them in silver paper. There is no danger until a fault occurs, but then there is a very real danger of fire and even getting someone killed. Remember that the fuse has the job of breaking the current. It takes a finite time for the fuse element to heat up and blow. During that time the current into the fault is climbing higher and higher, up to a limit set by the resistance of the fault. It is quite possible to draw tens of amps through a 1A fuse for a small fraction of a second. Without the fuse that current goes through the load. Normally house wiring will have a bigger fuse further back, but that is designed to let enough current through to blow the fuse in the appliance. Consequently, if you short out a 500mA fast-blow fuse and you get a fault in the transformer primary (or in the wiring to it) it could put over a hundred amps through, say, a 13A fuse, down the lead and into the fault. You had better hope that the bigger fuse blows or the lead could set fire to your carpet or the transformer could explode (ok, its a worst case scenario, but these things *can* happen). Even worse, if the amp has a bad earth the fault could "silently" break it completely and make the case, and everything connected to it, live. That can easily kill someone but you won't know about it until you touch something and by then it could be too late. Just think of one thing to finish off though, suppose the resistance of the fuse and its connections is 0.5 ohm (*way* too high, even for a bad contact). The transformer primary impedance could be about 70 ohms for a 200VA transformer so it swamps the fuse's resistance even in that extreme case. If the maximum primary current is about 1.6A at 120V the fuse will drop 0.8 of a volt *at full power* - probably less drop than you'll get from putting the kettle on. You won't hear the difference at all if the fuse contacts are clean as the series resistance will simply be too low. If you think you can hear a difference the clean the contacts or clean your ears! Ignore anyone who tells you that there is a difference - there isn't. Don't ignore safety warnings - don't put people's lives at risk for an imaginary increase in sound quality which can be proved false both by measurement and by double-blind listening tests. -- Mick (no M$ software on here... :-) ) Web: http://www.nascom.info |
Reply |
|
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
New Orleans Musicians' 'Safe List" | Pro Audio | |||
KISS 112 by Andre Jute | Vacuum Tubes | |||
KISS 113 by Andre Jute | Vacuum Tubes | |||
15 amp fuse with 20 w fuse for wire? | Car Audio | |||
Need Help with Behringer T-1953 | Pro Audio |