Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
FM antenna?
Looking for recommendations for a *good* indoor FM antenna. Does
such a beast exist? Trying to improve reception of a college (88.3 MHz) station. Any ideas? Yes, I'm aware of the FM-2G-C. But that's an outdoor alternative. Is the "FM Reflect" any good? http://www.ccrane.com/fm-reflect-antenna.aspx Thanks. |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
Eric wrote:
Looking for recommendations for a *good* indoor FM antenna. Does such a beast exist? Trying to improve reception of a college (88.3 MHz) station. I've had very good results in a number of installations with the Magnum-Dynalab ST-2. |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
In article , Eric
wrote: Looking for recommendations for a *good* indoor FM antenna. Does such a beast exist? I have been using a B I C "Beam Box" for a couple of decades now. Very directional, but it comes with the means to direct it easily. They're sold frequently on "that auction site." Only two moving parts, so it's not like you can go wrong buying one. sd |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
Buster Mudd wrote:
Looking for recommendations for a *good* indoor FM antenna. Does such a beast exist? Trying to improve reception of a college (88.3 MHz) station. I've had very good results in a number of installations with the Magnum-Dynalab ST-2. You're the second one I've seen recommend this antenna. How does it perform in the 88-90 MHz range as compared to the FM-2G-C, which is really a 80-100 MHz range antenna? |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
sd wrote:
Looking for recommendations for a *good* indoor FM antenna. Does such a beast exist? I have been using a B I C "Beam Box" for a couple of decades now. Very directional, but it comes with the means to direct it easily. They're sold frequently on "that auction site." Only two moving parts, so it's not like you can go wrong buying one. I saw one at "that auction site" just the other day. Used, but he wanted $100-$150 for it. How does it play in the 88-90 MHz area? |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
In article , Eric
wrote: sd wrote: I have been using a B I C "Beam Box" for a couple of decades now. [snip] I saw one at "that auction site" just the other day. Used, but he wanted $100-$150 for it. How does it play in the 88-90 MHz area? As well as it does elsewhere. Keep in mind it's not an amplified antenna, so if the issue is incoming signal strength from a 10-watt FM or a tuner that's not as sensitive as you'd like, the Beam Box won't do that much for you. It's a passive antenna designed to weed out a good signal from among the distortion and garbage. As for paying $100 for it, I don't think I paid $100 for mine when it was brand new. I certainly wouldn't part with that kind of money for one now. They come cheaper than that; I'd wait a bit if your're inclined to go that way. sd |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
Eric wrote:
Looking for recommendations for a *good* indoor FM antenna. Does such a beast exist? No. All of those various indoor antennas are just varients on the standard twin lead dipole antenna, despite anyone's claims. If you were to compare any of them with a roof-mounted antenna, it would be like comparing a BB gun to an Atom Bomb. Trying to improve reception of a college (88.3 MHz) station. Winegard makes an antenna, though intended for outdoor use, could be used in a dorm room or such if you were to hang it from your ceiling. Google for the Winegard PR6010 FM antenna. It costs all of $24.95 at: http://www.teeveesupply.com/product_...d_antennas.htm If you are in a position to put up a roof mounted FM antenna, then by all means do so. The cheapest Pioneer receiver with a good roof mounted FM antenna will beat the pants off of any of the legendary, price-no-object tuners made by Marantz, McIntosh, Yamaha or Sequerra fed by one of those indoor FM antennas made by anyone. Those indoor antennas are little better than hanging a piece of wire off the back of your receiver. Russ |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
"sd" wrote in message
... In article , Eric wrote: sd wrote: I have been using a B I C "Beam Box" for a couple of decades now. [snip] I saw one at "that auction site" just the other day. Used, but he wanted $100-$150 for it. How does it play in the 88-90 MHz area? As well as it does elsewhere. Keep in mind it's not an amplified antenna, so if the issue is incoming signal strength from a 10-watt FM or a tuner that's not as sensitive as you'd like, the Beam Box won't do that much for you. It's a passive antenna designed to weed out a good signal from among the distortion and garbage. As for paying $100 for it, I don't think I paid $100 for mine when it was brand new. I certainly wouldn't part with that kind of money for one now. They come cheaper than that; I'd wait a bit if your're inclined to go that way. I sold one a few years ago on eBay for about $20 plus shipping. I paid $0 for it. I'd put the true value range at $0-25. I'd also stress that the unit won't work miracules. It essentially is a folded, folded dipole and it's signal boost is weaker than a straight folded dipole. What it can help with is orientation, since it can be turned 270 degrees pretty easily. |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
I can't say I've ever specifically checked its performance at any one
part of the spectrum; it's just been our go-to antenna whenever someone can't pick up their favorite stations using the stock dipole. The only time the Magnum-Dynalab ST-2 hasn't solved the problem perfectly was when we were dealing with folks in rural Connecticut who wanted to listen to a low-output college station in southern New Jersey. (The solution for them was an SE879 outdoor antenna from SE Engineering.) |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
Buster Mudd wrote:
I can't say I've ever specifically checked its performance at any one part of the spectrum; it's just been our go-to antenna whenever someone can't pick up their favorite stations using the stock dipole. The only time the Magnum-Dynalab ST-2 hasn't solved the problem perfectly was when we were dealing with folks in rural Connecticut who wanted to listen to a low-output college station in southern New Jersey. (The solution for them was an SE879 outdoor antenna from SE Engineering.) Thanks. I received email stating that the ST-2, at 54 inches, suffered in the 88-92 MHz range. Since the station I'm after is at 88.3 MHz, I was interested by the FM-2G-C. |
#11
|
|||
|
|||
sd wrote:
I have been using a B I C "Beam Box" for a couple of decades now. [snip] I saw one at "that auction site" just the other day. Used, but he wanted $100-$150 for it. How does it play in the 88-90 MHz area? As well as it does elsewhere. Keep in mind it's not an amplified antenna, so if the issue is incoming signal strength from a 10-watt FM or a tuner that's not as sensitive as you'd like, the Beam Box won't do that much for you. It's a passive antenna designed to weed out a good signal from among the distortion and garbage. As for paying $100 for it, I don't think I paid $100 for mine when it was brand new. I certainly wouldn't part with that kind of money for one now. They come cheaper than that; I'd wait a bit if your're inclined to go that way. That price included another piece of equipment, a "signal grabber" or some such thing. If it is just a dipole (or folded dipole), chances are that it is optimized for around 102 MHz, and suffers a little at 88.3 MHz. Thanks. |
#12
|
|||
|
|||
Russ Button wrote:
Looking for recommendations for a *good* indoor FM antenna. Does such a beast exist? No. All of those various indoor antennas are just varients on the standard twin lead dipole antenna, despite anyone's claims. If you were to compare any of them with a roof-mounted antenna, it would be like comparing a BB gun to an Atom Bomb. Yes, but a roof mount is not an option. All pre-made dipoles seem to be optimized for about 102 MHz (54" element.) So I guess my best option is to construct my own antenna optimized for 88.3 MHz. Thanks. |
Reply |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
How do I splice antenna wire, install new connectors? | Car Audio | |||
Suggestions Indoor Amplified AM/FM Antenna | Tech | |||
window antenna problem | Car Audio | |||
Radio reception worse than factory radio, antenna adapter? | Car Audio | |||
FM radio antenna height for car... ? | Pro Audio |