Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Stereo Mini Plugs to RCA Plugs to Receiver Aux In-- Signal Degradation?
Hello. I'm in the process of putting together a PC-Stereo System setup
for my daughter. Budget limitations confine me to using a mini stereo system (Panasonic SCM PM39D, http://www.jr.com/JRProductPage.process?Product=3985852), which rules out using a digital link from her PC soundcard to the receiver (as no mini systems, to my knowledge, offer digital input). Ideally I would like to use a stereo mini plug adapter at the soundcard which includes an input for computer speakers as well as branching off into left and right RCA plugs for the stereo (see picture here, listed as "Option 2": http://www.pcstereolink.com/stereocomputer.html). Can any of you tell me whether this sort of adapter involves any signal degradation compared to a normal Y-adapter? Also, I'm thinking it might be more flexible to use an adapter that terminates in female RCAs and then use an extended Male-to-Male RCA cable to go the rest of the way. Since this uses an additional coupling, does it entail signal loss or weakening? Thx, JG |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
"Jim G" wrote...
... mini stereo system (Panasonic SCM PM39D, http://www.jr.com/JRProductPage.process?Product=3985852), ...stereo mini plug adapter...(... "Option 2": http://www.pcstereolink.com/stereocomputer.html). Can any of you tell me whether this sort of adapter involves any signal degradation Unlikely any that you would hear on your mini system. compared to a normal Y-adapter? It *is* a Y-adapter. Dunno why it would be any different than a "normal" one (whatever that is?) Also, I'm thinking it might be more flexible to use an adapter that terminates in female RCAs and then use an extended Male-to-Male RCA cable to go the rest of the way. Since this uses an additional coupling, does it entail signal loss or weakening? Not unless the connectors are falling apart. 95% of the quality of the sound is those speakers. You are worrying about 1/10 of one percent. I wouldn't even give it a second thought. There is a small possibility that the computer sound card won't like driving both the computer speakers AND the input to your mini system, but even that is a 2% chance, very unlikely in my opinion. |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
On Thu, 07 Apr 2005 19:47:57 -0400, Jim G
wrote: Ideally I would like to use a stereo mini plug adapter at the soundcard which includes an input for computer speakers as well as branching off into left and right RCA plugs for the stereo (see picture here, listed as "Option 2": http://www.pcstereolink.com/stereocomputer.html). Can any of you tell me whether this sort of adapter involves any signal degradation compared to a normal Y-adapter? Also, I'm thinking it might be more flexible to use an adapter that terminates in female RCAs and then use an extended Male-to-Male RCA cable to go the rest of the way. Since this uses an additional coupling, does it entail signal loss or weakening? Electrically, this IS a "normal Y-adaptor". We're not talking hi-fi here. As long as you keep the connectors clean I doubt quality will be an issue. Two thoughts: If she's connecting computer sound to a stereo system, does she really need an additional pair of crappy computer speakers? Why? The 3.5mm stereo minijack is possibly the least robust audio connection in general use. (Well OK - maybe the old DIN speaker plug was even crappier :-) When the socket on your soundcard collapses internally, a repair will probably not be practical. I would avoid attaching anything heavier than the standard plug. |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
I would beg to differ. Maybe it's a question of "how hi" is hi-fi, but
I think you should try listening to the system with one of the output cables disconnected from the "Y", and then connect the second output cable to see if you can tell the difference. I can tell quite a difference when I do this. The impedance mismatch resulting from connecting the two output cables in parallel really drags down the signal's amplitude and causes noticeable distortion. If you want to do it right insert, for example, a $30.00 Behringer mixer at this point just to isolate the amp output from the two devices that you want to drive. Another possibility is to construct a proper terminator to eliminate the impedance mismatch, but that will involve some signal loss, so the little mixer seems like the way to go. |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
bcrowell wrote ...
I would beg to differ. Maybe it's a question of "how hi" is hi-fi, but I think you should try listening to the system with one of the output cables disconnected from the "Y", and then connect the second output cable to see if you can tell the difference. I can tell quite a difference when I do this. The impedance mismatch resulting from connecting the two output cables in parallel really drags down the signal's amplitude and causes noticeable distortion. If you want to do it right insert, for example, a $30.00 Behringer mixer at this point just to isolate the amp output from the two devices that you want to drive. Another possibility is to construct a proper terminator to eliminate the impedance mismatch, but that will involve some signal loss, so the little mixer seems like the way to go. I got the impression the OP wanted to feed the line-level sound output from his computer into two amplifiers, his little plastic computer speakers, and the mini-stereo system. Since most modern audio circuits have pretty low impedance (~1K) and most input circuits are rather high impedance (~10K), it seems pretty unlikely that the computer output would have a problem with these two pretty high impedance loads. This is traditionally called "bridging". If he is trying to combine two different outputs into a single input, then I'd agree that a passive "Y-adapter" is likely a poor choice. |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
Hi, Richard. Well, once recently I tried "Y"'ing up the tape output of
my phono preamp so as to make it feed two supposedly high-impedance devices, and when I "A-B"'d the arrangement I could hear noticeable signal degradation. |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
bcrowell wrote ...
Hi, Richard. Well, once recently I tried "Y"'ing up the tape output of my phono preamp so as to make it feed two supposedly high-impedance devices, and when I "A-B"'d the arrangement I could hear noticeable signal degradation. There are single-case examples all over the map because there are no hard standards for consumer equipment. OTOH, I believe you have a better than even chance that a modern, low-impedance source can drive several high-impedance loads without significant side-effects. For your "once" I can cite scores of times I have done the same thing without any problems. But you make a good point that you can't rely on it. |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
Laurence Payne wrote:
[snip] Electrically, this IS a "normal Y-adaptor". We're not talking hi-fi here. As long as you keep the connectors clean I doubt quality will be an issue. Two thoughts: If she's connecting computer sound to a stereo system, does she really need an additional pair of crappy computer speakers? Why? The 3.5mm stereo minijack is possibly the least robust audio connection in general use. (Well OK - maybe the old DIN speaker plug was even crappier :-) When the socket on your soundcard collapses internally, a repair will probably not be practical. I would avoid attaching anything heavier than the standard plug. Thx for your answers guys. Richard and Laurence asked why I thought the pictured piece is not a "normal" Y-adapter. It just seemed that this extra hole sitting there on the head of this thing could affect the flow. Glad to hear no one has noticed such. Does she really need an additional pair of crappy computer speakers? My reasoning here is it may not be a bad idea to keep the ministereo powered down if she's gonna be doing serious stuff for an extended time, yet might still want system sounds at these times, or even audio for things like super-compressed Real audio, etc., where source quality is so woeful it doesn't matter if the speakers are made of Reynolds Wrap. Seems better to give the Panasonic a rest once in a while, although I understand the thing stil draws power when power button is off, dang it. Yeah 3.5mm jacks seem lamentable. I guess for another $10 or so I could go for an M-Audio card with RCA outputs. Would you do that? Thx again all, JG |
Reply |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
FS: Audio Cables & Adapter Cables | Pro Audio | |||
Escort '97 - Can I add Stereo RCA input plugs to my factory stereo? | Car Audio | |||
FS: SCOTT 345 Stereo Receiver (7591s) | Vacuum Tubes | |||
FS/T: FISHER 400 Stereo Receiver | Vacuum Tubes | |||
Why do stereo components lack ground plugs? | Tech |