Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
soliciting suggestions for simple live recording gear
My wife and five of her music school chums comprise a [mostly] a
cappella group that performs occasionally in the Hudson Valley NY area. They do not yet consider themselves Professionals, but they're edging toward that. They've done pro bono gigs for local charities and have begun to pick up the occasional club job. One of the members, who used to tag along after rock groups doing sound chores, put together a modest system consisting of six decent Shure wireless mics. They also add a wired mic for a hand drum and sometimes attach a mic'd acoustic guitar. This all feeds a Mackie 1604 mixer that feeds Mackie powered PA speakers and stage monitors. Now they're interested in recording their live performances to augment the studio-recorded demo's they've made the past few years. The criteria: low cost (naturally!), minimum bulk/headache, 2-channels. So, they're looking for something to plug into the faithful Mackie. It seems to me, as a first guess, that an A/D box with a USB interface for a laptop would do the trick. So would a simple, low-cost digital recorder of some sort (direct to CD?). Does anyone have suggestions about (1) the approach I mentioned and (2) specific gear that would meet their requirements? TIA Jason |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
|
#3
|
|||
|
|||
|
#4
|
|||
|
|||
J Warren wrote: Does anyone have suggestions about (1) the approach I mentioned and (2) specific gear that would meet their requirements? For standalone recorders: iRiver iHP-120, Creative Nomad Jukebox 3, Archos Gmini 120. Another alternative is the latest WAV-capable MD recorders from Sony. You'll be limited to 16/44.1 or 16/48 for all of the above solutions. If you want to do 24-bit up to 96 (or 192 KS/s) you might consider our PDAudio system. For laptop solutions being fed from a Line output on a Mackie board: Try an M-Audio Transit (around $70). It'll take a Line or digital optical input and any standard Mac or Windows recording application can record it. Other alternatives are the Audiophile USB or Audiophile Firewire, both also from M-Audio. -- Len Moskowitz PDAudio, Binaural Mics, Cables, DPA, M-Audio Core Sound http://www.stealthmicrophones.com Teaneck, New Jersey USA http://www.core-sound.com Tel: 201-801-0812, FAX: 201-801-0912 |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
J Warren wrote: Does anyone have suggestions about (1) the approach I mentioned and (2) specific gear that would meet their requirements? For standalone recorders: iRiver iHP-120, Creative Nomad Jukebox 3, Archos Gmini 120. Another alternative is the latest WAV-capable MD recorders from Sony. You'll be limited to 16/44.1 or 16/48 for all of the above solutions. If you want to do 24-bit up to 96 (or 192 KS/s) you might consider our PDAudio system. For laptop solutions being fed from a Line output on a Mackie board: Try an M-Audio Transit (around $70). It'll take a Line or digital optical input and any standard Mac or Windows recording application can record it. Other alternatives are the Audiophile USB or Audiophile Firewire, both also from M-Audio. -- Len Moskowitz PDAudio, Binaural Mics, Cables, DPA, M-Audio Core Sound http://www.stealthmicrophones.com Teaneck, New Jersey USA http://www.core-sound.com Tel: 201-801-0812, FAX: 201-801-0912 |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
|
#7
|
|||
|
|||
|
#8
|
|||
|
|||
|
#9
|
|||
|
|||
|
#10
|
|||
|
|||
"J Warren" wrote ...
I wasn't aware that any SONY MD recorder could produce .wav files - I hadn't looked at them because I'd read unflattering reports about their proprietary compression and figured that's all they could do. I'll take another look. They don't "produce .wav files". They all use ATRAC compression. However the more recent vitage is reputed to be unexpectedly good. Depending on what you are recording and what your expectations are, MD recording may per perfectly adequate. A recent review of "pro" and "pro-sumer" DV camcorders revealed that MD is the equal or better of many (most?) of them. (Jay Rose in DV Magazine) |
#11
|
|||
|
|||
"J Warren" wrote ...
I wasn't aware that any SONY MD recorder could produce .wav files - I hadn't looked at them because I'd read unflattering reports about their proprietary compression and figured that's all they could do. I'll take another look. They don't "produce .wav files". They all use ATRAC compression. However the more recent vitage is reputed to be unexpectedly good. Depending on what you are recording and what your expectations are, MD recording may per perfectly adequate. A recent review of "pro" and "pro-sumer" DV camcorders revealed that MD is the equal or better of many (most?) of them. (Jay Rose in DV Magazine) |
#13
|
|||
|
|||
In article ,
says... They don't "produce .wav files". They all use ATRAC compression. However the more recent vitage is reputed to be unexpectedly good. Depending on what you are recording and what your expectations are, MD recording may per perfectly adequate. A recent review of "pro" and "pro-sumer" DV camcorders revealed that MD is the equal or better of many (most?) of them. (Jay Rose in DV Magazine) I couldn't find the Jay Rose article online that you cite (found a lot of other interesting ones, tho :-) ), but I did find an excerpt, apparently from a Sony memo on their introduction of "Hi-MD." It looks as if, in addition to ATRAC, the new format offers "linear PCM." Sounds like .wav files--or close--to me. From the quoted memo: “Hi-MD” uses ATRAC3plus (*4) audio compression technology, which delivers high data compression while maintaining quality of sound. “Hi- MD” also enables linear PCM recordings, resulting in the recording and playback of near CD quality sound. Here's the reference: http://www.minidisc.org/part_Hi-MD_Sony.html I have no idea if "minidisc.org" is legit/reliable/sold-out/etc., but it looks promising. Thanks for the nudge. Jason |
#14
|
|||
|
|||
"J Warren" wrote in message .. . From the quoted memo: "Hi-MD" uses ATRAC3plus (*4) audio compression technology, which delivers high data compression while maintaining quality of sound. "Hi- MD" also enables linear PCM recordings, resulting in the recording and playback of near CD quality sound. One has to wonder why it would only be "NEAR" CD quality if it was in fact 16 bit linear PCM? Lower sample rate maybe? They don't usually consider the analog performance here. TonyP. |
#15
|
|||
|
|||
"J Warren" wrote in message .. . From the quoted memo: "Hi-MD" uses ATRAC3plus (*4) audio compression technology, which delivers high data compression while maintaining quality of sound. "Hi- MD" also enables linear PCM recordings, resulting in the recording and playback of near CD quality sound. One has to wonder why it would only be "NEAR" CD quality if it was in fact 16 bit linear PCM? Lower sample rate maybe? They don't usually consider the analog performance here. TonyP. |
#16
|
|||
|
|||
|
#17
|
|||
|
|||
|
#18
|
|||
|
|||
Mike Rivers wrote:
Like so many things that apply consumer technology, we seem to be in a gap right now. The Jukebox 3 has been discontinued and while there are other ways to accomplish what it does, there are no direct replacements right now. Since recording high quality audio isn't a high priority in the consumer world, I expect that it will be hard to fill this gap. We've heard some good things about the Archos Gmini 120 - you might have a look at that. The iRiver iHP-120 & 140 are another. Being consumer products, again there's no way to know how long they will be available or how long they will be supported. The Sony Hi-MD is another possibility, if an hour and a half of recording time at 16/44.1 is enough. And of course, if you want to record up to 24-bit @ 96 KS/s, there's our PDAudio system. For a digital only system, cost is currently under #500, it's a single hand-holdable unit and fits in a shirt pocket. With an analog front end it's a bit larger and more expensive, much like the JB3 if you added good mic pre/A-to-D. -- Len Moskowitz PDAudio, Binaural Mics, Cables, DPA, M-Audio Core Sound http://www.stealthmicrophones.com Teaneck, New Jersey USA http://www.core-sound.com Tel: 201-801-0812, FAX: 201-801-0912 |
#19
|
|||
|
|||
Mike Rivers wrote:
Like so many things that apply consumer technology, we seem to be in a gap right now. The Jukebox 3 has been discontinued and while there are other ways to accomplish what it does, there are no direct replacements right now. Since recording high quality audio isn't a high priority in the consumer world, I expect that it will be hard to fill this gap. We've heard some good things about the Archos Gmini 120 - you might have a look at that. The iRiver iHP-120 & 140 are another. Being consumer products, again there's no way to know how long they will be available or how long they will be supported. The Sony Hi-MD is another possibility, if an hour and a half of recording time at 16/44.1 is enough. And of course, if you want to record up to 24-bit @ 96 KS/s, there's our PDAudio system. For a digital only system, cost is currently under #500, it's a single hand-holdable unit and fits in a shirt pocket. With an analog front end it's a bit larger and more expensive, much like the JB3 if you added good mic pre/A-to-D. -- Len Moskowitz PDAudio, Binaural Mics, Cables, DPA, M-Audio Core Sound http://www.stealthmicrophones.com Teaneck, New Jersey USA http://www.core-sound.com Tel: 201-801-0812, FAX: 201-801-0912 |
#20
|
|||
|
|||
Richard Crowley wrote: They don't "produce .wav files". They all use ATRAC compression. This is incorrect. The latest Hi-MD recorders can record linear PCM wav files. -- Len Moskowitz PDAudio, Binaural Mics, Cables, DPA, M-Audio Core Sound http://www.stealthmicrophones.com Teaneck, New Jersey USA http://www.core-sound.com Tel: 201-801-0812, FAX: 201-801-0912 |
#21
|
|||
|
|||
Richard Crowley wrote: They don't "produce .wav files". They all use ATRAC compression. This is incorrect. The latest Hi-MD recorders can record linear PCM wav files. -- Len Moskowitz PDAudio, Binaural Mics, Cables, DPA, M-Audio Core Sound http://www.stealthmicrophones.com Teaneck, New Jersey USA http://www.core-sound.com Tel: 201-801-0812, FAX: 201-801-0912 |
#22
|
|||
|
|||
In article znr1094644062k@trad, says...
In article writes: Did the Hi-MD ever emerge? All I ever hear is reports of it coming. Seems like it would be the talk of the town (this town anyway) if it was actually available. Yes - it's for sale from a number of vendors according to Froogle. I wish somebody I knew had one so I could try it :-( Jason |
#23
|
|||
|
|||
In article znr1094644062k@trad, says...
In article writes: Did the Hi-MD ever emerge? All I ever hear is reports of it coming. Seems like it would be the talk of the town (this town anyway) if it was actually available. Yes - it's for sale from a number of vendors according to Froogle. I wish somebody I knew had one so I could try it :-( Jason |
#24
|
|||
|
|||
|
#26
|
|||
|
|||
|
#27
|
|||
|
|||
|
#28
|
|||
|
|||
In article znr1095075806k@trad, says...
In article writes: I got my mits on one and on the documentation. We're talking about the high resolution Minidisk here, I think? Yes. Hi-MD in PCM mode. So why did you give it back? g Good question - my friend didn't want to let it out of his sight at all to begin with. I guess he knows of my penchant for taking things apart... I did find an authoritative-looking website that has more information: http://www.minidisc.org/hi-md_faq.html#_q93 One shortcoming I see is that, for the moment anyway, one cannot directly upload a PCM file, I.e., without "playing" it and thus suffering multiple d/a and a/d conversions. When connected via USB, the device appears to Windoze as a "USB-attached bulk storage device." You can read and write to it like any other disk. However, after I created a PCM file and transferred it this way, it was NOT a valid .wav file. I think this is going to get fixed; rumor has it that Sony has plans to beef up the PC software in late 2004 to "enhance the upload experience" :-) Jason |
#29
|
|||
|
|||
|
Reply |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
Ferstler on recording | Audio Opinions | |||
Artists cut out the record biz | Pro Audio |