Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #1   Report Post  
John L Rice
 
Posts: n/a
Default Demand for even higher sampling rates

A recent poll conducted to determine why many have refused to embrace
digital recording, it was revealed that most respondents think that even the
current state of art digital converters are incapable of accurately
capturing all available audible information.

While all respondents agreed that the debate people are currently having on
the validity of 192kHz sampling rates is ridiculous and that anything less
than a 384kHz sampling rate is unacceptable, the respondents were sharply
divided when it came to even higher sampling rates. 52% felt that 384kHz was
sufficient, 37% felt that 768kHz would be significantly better and 11% felt
that 1.536MHz ( or higher ) would be required to capture everything audible
with perfect accuracy.

While such technology currently doesn't exist, or at least is extremely
difficult and/or expensive to obtain, many feel that consumer and marketing
demands will turn this around in the next few years.

( above information reflects data obtained on 04/01/2005 from 100 randomly
selected porpoises and beluga whales )
Reference

--
John L Rice




  #2   Report Post  
David Morgan \(MAMS\)
 
Posts: n/a
Default


"John L Rice" wrote in message ...

( above information reflects data obtained on 04/01/2005 from 100 randomly
selected porpoises and beluga whales )



Good one... you had me going for a minute.

DM


  #3   Report Post  
David Satz
 
Posts: n/a
Default

It is well known that precisely 52,439 opinions add up to a fact. If
the required critical mass of opinion cannot be marshaled, then all
those opinions--no matter how sincere and well-meaning--remain merely
subjective points of view.

A further problem arises when the issue is the issue is that of
doubling the sampling rate for digital audio. A mere 51% agreement
among audiophiles no longer suffices to create an objective fact in
such a case--the degree of consensus also needs to be twice as great,
and for quadrupling the sampling rate, four times.

Without special legislation by Congress to declare that a binary bit
shall henceforth have four potential states rather than only two, I
fear that it could take years to reach so strong a level of agreement.

--best regards

  #4   Report Post  
Mark
 
Posts: n/a
Default

Did you hear that Bush is going to try to overturn the Nyquist theorem?

Mark

  #5   Report Post  
WillStG
 
Posts: n/a
Default


John L Rice wrote:
A recent poll conducted to determine why many have refused to embrace


digital recording, it was revealed that most respondents think that

even the
current state of art digital converters are incapable of accurately
capturing all available audible information.

While all respondents agreed that the debate people are currently

having on
the validity of 192kHz sampling rates is ridiculous and that anything

less
than a 384kHz sampling rate is unacceptable, the respondents were

sharply
divided when it came to even higher sampling rates. 52% felt that

384kHz was
sufficient, 37% felt that 768kHz would be significantly better and

11% felt
that 1.536MHz ( or higher ) would be required to capture everything

audible
with perfect accuracy.

While such technology currently doesn't exist, or at least is

extremely
difficult and/or expensive to obtain, many feel that consumer and

marketing
demands will turn this around in the next few years.

( above information reflects data obtained on 04/01/2005 from 100

randomly
selected porpoises and beluga whales )
Reference


Good joke, but I think it's more a question of what is possible and
available in terms of technology than anything else. With processors
100 times faster than what we have now, technology under utilized at
lower sample rates, with old chips no longer available, sure, I bet
even 192k will be left behind eventually.

I think today's digital consoles will be as obsolete as a MACII/ci
in 10 years, and any facility or Systems Engineer who thinks that they
are saving money by buying a digital console today are going to find
out their digital desks are worth as much as one of those is, certainly
much less than a good Pro analog desk will be in 10 years.

Of course I could be wrong... g

Will Miho
NY Music & TV Audio Guy
Staff Audio / Fox News / M-AES
"The large print giveth and the small print taketh away..." Tom Waits



  #6   Report Post  
David Morgan \(MAMS\)
 
Posts: n/a
Default


"WillStG" wrote in message...

I think today's digital consoles will be as obsolete as a MACII/ci
in 10 years,



H E Y !!!! So it's a little slow....

;-)



--
David Morgan (MAMS)
http://www.m-a-m-s DOT com
Morgan Audio Media Service
Dallas, Texas (214) 662-9901
_______________________________________
http://www.artisan-recordingstudio.com



  #7   Report Post  
WillStG
 
Posts: n/a
Default


David Morgan (MAMS) wrote:
"WillStG" wrote in message...

I think today's digital consoles will be as obsolete as a

MACII/ci
in 10 years,



H E Y !!!! So it's a little slow....

;-)


Two words David - System 7!

g

Will Miho
NY Music and TV Audio Guy
Staff Audio/ Fox News/ M-AES
"The large print giveth and the small print taketh away..." Tom Waits

  #8   Report Post  
SSJVCmag
 
Posts: n/a
Default

On 4/1/05 2:15 PM, in article d5h3e.463$k66.167@trnddc03, "David Morgan
(MAMS)" wrote:
"John L Rice" wrote in message
...

( above information reflects data obtained on


I HAVe to respond to this sort of audiophilic drabble. The following is long
but VITAl to ANYONE's understanding of the issue. I could say it no better
so I quote:

----------------------------
This is the first 100% virgin wool wide-belt driven transport mechanism in
production. The belt weft induces a trans-harmonic signature which is 180
degrees out of phase with the fundamental 44.1 kHz sampling rate, which
reduces jitter to that of, say, a sleeping Jabba the Hut. As an added bonus,
the wool-lined tray keeps the CD warm during play, greatly reducing stray
magnetic gauss field effects.
--------------------------------


You need to check here for the real poop on this sort of hi-end study...
(DO scroll down to the comments sections)

http://www.audioreview.com/CD+Player...9_1586crx.aspx

http://www.audioreview.com/TurnTable...3_1597crx.aspx


http://www.fmtunerinfo.com/lirpa.html

And

http://www.bstock.com/Lirpa1.htm
(it's thermally self approximating!)

IN LONG CONCLUSION I Quote yet again:

---------------------------------------
50 reviews

Description :
Steam-powered turntable with fire-tube boiler

Review Date January 2, 2003

Overall Rating *4 of 5

Value Rating *4 of 5

Used product for Less than 1 month

Rate this review? *4.64 out of 5

Reviewed by:* redrag, *AudioPhile ,*from*Rochester, NY USA

Price Paid:* $27.00 at Felloffatruck

Product Model Year: Pre 1995

Summary:
In a word, this is one piece of machinery that can only add size to the most
advanced monaural sound system.

I had used the Lirpa April 47 eight-track for years, never realizing their
technology preceded the classic tape industry. (As a side note, I always
thought the April 47 model was the 47th design but it actually honors Dr.
Lirpaıs 47th daughter. But I digress.) I was suspicious of steam technology,
but was pleasantly surprised at its multi-tasking capabilities, especially
the pastrami slicing. Lirpaıs approach of nuclear powering the direct drive
was a surprise eliminating my fears of putting the kettle on boil to get it
started.

Iım told Lirpa Labs makes only one steam turntable every year, each one
different. Well I wish theyıd tried to down size it as mine weighs in at a
hefty 29,921 lbs. Living in Rochester, NY I had to transport it from
Tampoonıs Antique shop and 7-Eleven in Del Ray Beach, CA. I contacted an old
Air Force buddy who arranged for the C5A. The big problem, once I got it to
Buffaloıs airport, was transporting it down the thruway to Rochester (our
airport flies only east to west.) George Pataki offered the National Guard
to dismantle 17 HUMVEES and reconstruct them into a single transport that
straddled the divider with 32 right wheels in the eastbound lane and the
other 32 in the west lanes. The remaining four wheels were added to the rear
on wheelie bars in case we over accelerated. Naturally, the Governor helped
close the thruway for the nine day trip. It would have been quicker had we
not had to dismantle the bridges and remove the final toll booth station.
Overall, the trip was, how shall I say itŠ uneventful.

I apologize for digressing again. Getting it on to the house was easy. I
only had to add one I-beam to our two-story colonial (now a ranch I might
add.) Wiring took a bit of creativity by running a direct line from the
Ginna nuclear plant to jump start it so the single steam cylinder could kick
in.

I have experienced one negative. Big Daveıs comment, ³the ants... always the
ants!² Well, I can put up with them. Actually, Iım tired of not being able
to turn it off as thereıs an incessant vibration throughout our whole house.
It has put a constant smile on my wifeıs face but weıre tired of feeding our
dachshunds all this freakinı pastrami. You canıt imagine the weight theyıve
gained.

But I digress again. An unexpected benefit is its well oiled teakwood base
that nicely compliments the tan siding and whatıs left of the brown
shingles. In research, I have learned that the 40 year old grove of teak
trees was just ripe for harvesting.

A word of warning to those considering a LirpaŠ the stylus wear may surprise
you. Unlike the standard diamond styli used by more well known manufacturers
such as the British firm Moorcock and Cordwainer, LTD, the Lirpa steamtable
requires the more costly German Phelge, Boisbaudran und Unterdachel
component. The sound reproduction is well worth the extra money although
replacing the 7 foot stylus after one full revolution can be a bit pricey.
Iıd recommend buying them in bulk direct from Phelge, et al. Then you have
one more reason to build that hanger in the yard for extra storage.

In closing, I canıt say enough for this critical piece of mass that
completes my sound system. With my Lirpa eight track, the Pilkney Windtunnel
stackable 63² speakers, powered by my Arthgardner and Swelkin mini receiver,
I can proudly says I have the loudest system on the block. To pick one
descriptive word is impossible but if I must choose one, it would be, ³Well
done Dr. Lirpa and your fine engineers as well as congratulations on your
47th daughter. All of you have contributed to a monumental step in adding
size to the reproduction of all recorded music but also in adding to the
bulk of equipment on the market. As your logo says, ³If itıs a Lirpa
steamtable, you can use it.²

Strengths:
Re-sale value, deductibilty value, better than nothing

Weaknesses:
Price per pound, environmentally hazardous, limited color selection, faulty
steam safety valve, overheating,

Similar Products Used:
Popeil Pocket Pasta Maker, Earnhardt air bags, Pilkney Windtunnel speakers
--------------------------------------



  #9   Report Post  
playon
 
Posts: n/a
Default

On 1 Apr 2005 12:23:29 -0800, "Mark" wrote:

Did you hear that Bush is going to try to overturn the Nyquist theorem?


Digital regime change?

Al
  #10   Report Post  
John L Rice
 
Posts: n/a
Default


"David Morgan (MAMS)" wrote in message
news:d5h3e.463$k66.167@trnddc03...

"John L Rice" wrote in message
...

( above information reflects data obtained on 04/01/2005 from 100
randomly
selected porpoises and beluga whales )



Good one... you had me going for a minute.

DM



Hehehe. I posted the same thing over on ProSoundWeb too. And I feel a little
bad that a couple people didn't catch on at all! ;-)

--
John L Rice





  #11   Report Post  
David Morgan \(MAMS\)
 
Posts: n/a
Default


"John L Rice" wrote in message ...

"David Morgan (MAMS)" wrote in message
news:d5h3e.463$k66.167@trnddc03...


"John L Rice" wrote in message
...


( above information reflects data obtained on 04/01/2005 from 100
randomly selected porpoises and beluga whales )


Good one... you had me going for a minute.

DM


Hehehe. I posted the same thing over on ProSoundWeb too. And I feel a little
bad that a couple people didn't catch on at all! ;-)

--
John L Rice



Some people don't read the entire post, I've been guilty myself... and you
know what I think of the 'marketing' of digital.

DM


Reply
Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules

Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off


Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
What are they Teaching Michael McKelvy Audio Opinions 199 October 15th 04 07:56 PM
O.T. Grocery clerks strike Michael Mckelvy Audio Opinions 338 November 14th 03 07:32 PM


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 09:53 PM.

Powered by: vBulletin
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright İ2004-2024 AudioBanter.com.
The comments are property of their posters.
 

About Us

"It's about Audio and hi-fi"