AudioBanter.com - View Single Post - "DSD recordings good. PCM recordings bad."

On 23 Jan 2004 22:49:31 GMT, (Mkuller) wrote:

Kalman Rubinson
Why bother dealing with this nonsense! There's no scientific evidence
for anything he purports to prove.

But wait - he's a doctor so he has science on his side, doesn't he?

So did Harold Shipman............

Qualifications are no indicator of the scientific accuracy of an
argument.

Unfortunately a lot of people have experienced discomfort listening to CDs,
especially early ones on early equipment and his theories were as good as any
others back in the 1980s.

Which is where they should have stayed. Basically, he's talking
rubbish which has no basis in reliable and repeatable observations.

Now we know a lot more about jitter and digital
recording, but...maybe he's on to something ;-)

And, maybe he's not. I pick the latter.
--

Stewart Pinkerton | Music is Art - Audio is Engineering