|
|
|
|
Comments regarding: Cables, Hearing, Stuff!!
"Bob Marcus" wrote:
Michael Scarpitti wrote:
lcw999 wrote in message
news:9Pn8c.87424$po.663367@attbi_s52...
Over the years these Audio newsgroups have been a beehive of
activity regarding Cables, Amps, CD players...etc.
There is a contingent on some of these groups that tend to have
an Engineering bent toward those that frequent the High-End
audio...basically, it states your "imagination is misleading
you"
There are no detectable differences in cables, etc.
According to William of Occam, nature does not work in a more
complicated way than necessary. Given two explanations, the one that
is simpler is more likely to be true.
As Einstein said, "Everything should be made as simple as possible,
but not
simpler."
The simplest explanation for why
people hear difference between cable is that there are audible
differences between cables.
The simplest explanation for why the sun rises in the east and sets in
the
west is that the sun revolves around the earth. So much for Occam. (Or,
rather, so much for your version of Occam.)
Citing 'psychological factors' is no
explanation at all.
So what is Occam's explanation for why people sometimes hear
differences
between things that are exactly the same?
bob
Or the folks on this wonderful episode of Candid Camera where subjects
gladly
described the major "differences" in the taste of wine which was poured
out of
the same bottle. In this case Candid Camera had a table with several
filled
glasses of wine which were filled from the same bottle but each of
which had a
partially filled open bottle of wine placed next to each glass. I think
the
simplest explantion was expectation effect/ common human percepual bias
mechanisms.
Of course, they only had interviews with a few subjects and it is
possible that
they had to conduct 100 trials to get a small number of "interesting"
responses. But, that doesn't seem likely ...... only 60-minutes or NBC
(remember the pick-up side-gas-tank explosion story where they had to
use
rocket motors to get crash explosions?) would be capable of such gross
offense.
Even so Candid Camera they only had 6 of 25 or so with perceptually
biased
answers it's still likely that the simplest explanation of cable sound
IS human
perceptual bias.
|