View Single Post
  #16   Report Post  
Posted to rec.audio.high-end
willbill willbill is offline
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 58
Default surround sound 5.1 cables: 6 RCA vs toslink vs HDMI

Sonnova wrote:

On Tue, 13 Nov 2007 15:59:48 -0800, willbill wrote
(in article ):


Sonnova wrote:


I have an HD-A2. I use coaxial digital to connect to my Harman-Kardon
AVR-7000. This receiver uses Lexicon surround-sound processing - which is
is why I bit the bullet and paid close to $2000 for it and is excellent.
I've never tried the 6 analog outputs from the player.


the Toshiba HD-A2, that you have,
does *not* have 6 analog outputs!

correct me if i'm wrong.


It might not, I've never actually looked.


fwiw, i thought that it did but then went
out to www.toshiba.com and checked and
discovered that of the 6 current models
only the most expensive of each line
has 6 analog outputs!

so i can't justify one for it's ability
to upscale normal DVD movies

you might consider doing an a/b of inputting
surround audio via coax digital (which you apparently
presently do) vs. toslink optical (also digital)



I've never heard any difference between TOSLINK digital, and Coax digital


odds are that you will find a noticable improvement
with the toslink optical input.



I doubt if there is any difference. In fact, when TOSLINK first appeared,
many audiophiles found just the opposite to be true. I.E., that TOSLINK
sounded distinctly inferior to either coax or glass-fiber, and indeed, some
tests showed that the bandwidth of many early TOSLINK setups was much
narrower than that of either coax or glass-fiber. However, that difference
has been long since addressed. The optical transducers on both ends of modern
TOSLINK connections have been significantly improved.


you might actually try connecting sound
with toslink again with your current AVR

the main key thing that i listen for
is that the sound is less flat

but going back to your HD-A2, do you find the
surround sound of the HD-DVD movies, that you've
so far gotten, to be noticeably superior to that
of ordinary DVD movies?

to my mind, better surround audio is the one real
trump card that they can play with hi def movies.
but so far they don't seem to have done it;
at least not yet. they certainly have plenty
of great source material in the vaults

bill